Research Paper: The Risks of Multimedia Methods: Effects of Actor's Race and Gender on Preferences for Health States

OBJECTIVE While the use of multimedia methods in medical education and decision support can facilitate learning, it also has certain hazards. One potential hazard is the inadvertent triggering of racial and gender bias by the appearance of actors or patients in presentations. The authors hypothesized that race and gender affect preferences. To explore this issue they studied the effects of actors' race and gender on preference ratings for health states that include symptoms of schizophrenia. DESIGN A convenience sample of patients with schizophrenia, family members of patients, and health professionals was used. Participants were randomly assigned to rate two health states, one portrayed by either a man of mixed race (Hispanic-black) or a white man and the second portrayed by either a white woman or a white man. MEASUREMENTS Visual analog scale (VAS) and standard gamble ratings of health state preferences for health states that include symptoms of mild and moderate schizophrenia. RESULTS Studies of the effects of the race of the actor (n = 114) revealed that racial mismatch between the actor and the participant affected the participant's preferences for health states. Ratings were lower when racial groups differed (mean difference, 0.098 for visual analog scale ratings and 0.053 lower in standard gamble, P = 0.006 for interactions between the race of the subject and the actor). In studies of the effects of a female actress on ratings (n = 117), we found no evidence of a corresponding interaction between the gender of the actor and the study participant. Rather, an interaction between actor's gender and method of assessment was observed. Standard gamble ratings (difference between means, 0.151), but not visual analog scale ratings (difference, 0.005), were markedly higher when the state was portrayed by the actress (P = 0.003 for interactions between actor's gender and method of preference assessment). Differential effects on standard gamble ratings suggest that an actor's gender may influence the willingness of viewers to gamble to gain health benefits (or risk attitude). CONCLUSIONS Educators and researchers considering the use of multimedia methods for decision support need to be aware of the potential for the race and gender of patients or actors to influence preferences for health states and thus, potentially, medical decisions.

[1]  C. Sugar,et al.  Comparison of preferences for health outcomes in schizophrenia among stakeholder groups. , 2000, Journal of psychiatric research.

[2]  A. J. Schultz,et al.  Videotape Increases Parent Knowledge About Poliovirus Vaccines and Choices of Polio Vaccination Schedules , 1998, Pediatrics.

[3]  N. Press,et al.  The effects of ethnicity, education and an informational video on pregnant women's knowledge and decisions about a prenatal diagnostic screening test. , 1996, Patient education and counseling.

[4]  M. Munetz,et al.  Documenting informed consent for treatment with neuroleptics: an alternative to the consent form. , 1996, Psychiatric services.

[5]  M E Gagliano,et al.  A literature review on the efficacy of video in patient education. , 1988, Journal of medical education.

[6]  H. Moldofsky,et al.  Videotape educational program for people with asthma. , 1979, Canadian Medical Association journal.

[7]  L. Kasten,et al.  Patient assertiveness and physician decision-making among older breast cancer patients. , 1999, Social science & medicine.

[8]  S. Bochner,et al.  The effectiveness of same-sex versus opposite-sex role models in advertisements to reduce alcohol consumption in teenagers. , 1994, Addictive behaviors.

[9]  J. Williams,et al.  Informed consent for antipsychotic medication. , 1999, Canadian family physician Medecin de famille canadien.

[10]  Lisa M. Schwartz,et al.  Misunderstandings about the effects of race and sex on physicians' referrals for cardiac catheterization. , 1999, The New England journal of medicine.

[11]  David A. Welton,et al.  Culturally Sensitive AIDS Educational Videos for African American Audiences: Effects of Source, Message, Receiver, and Context , 1998, American journal of community psychology.

[12]  L. O'donnell,et al.  Video-based sexually transmitted disease patient education: its impact on condom acquisition. , 1995, American journal of public health.

[13]  B. Duncan.  Differential social perception and attribution of intergroup violence: Testing the lower limits of stereotyping of Blacks. , 1976 .

[14]  H A Feldman,et al.  Physician variability and uncertainty in the management of breast cancer. Results from a factorial experiment. , 1998, Medical care.

[15]  J. Mckinlay,et al.  Non-medical influences on medical decision-making. , 1996, Social science & medicine.

[16]  L. Kasten,et al.  Patient, physician and presentational influences on clinical decision making for breast cancer: results from a factorial experiment. , 1997, Journal of evaluation in clinical practice.

[17]  R. Kane,et al.  Methodology for measuring health-state preferences--II: Scaling methods. , 1989, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[18]  J. Darley,et al.  A hypothesis-confirming bias in labeling effects. , 1983 .

[19]  S. Kalichman,et al.  Context framing to enhance HIV-antibody-testing messages targeted to African American women. , 1995, Health psychology : official journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association.

[20]  S. Holzapfel.  Documenting informed consent for antipsychotic medication. , 1999, Canadian family physician Medecin de famille canadien.

[21]  M K Goldstein,et al.  Developing and Testing a Multimedia Presentation of a Health-state Description , 1994, Medical decision making : an international journal of the Society for Medical Decision Making.

[22]  S. Chokron,et al.  Race, sex, and physicians' referrals for cardiac catheterization. , 1999, The New England journal of medicine.

[23]  M. Barry,et al.  Patient Reactions to a Program Designed to Facilitate Patient Participation in Treatment Decisions for Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia , 1995, Medical care.

[24]  B. Spilker,et al.  Quality of life and pharmacoeconomics in clinical trials , 1996 .

[25]  L. Lenert,et al.  The Effect of Search Procedures on Utility Elicitations , 1998, Medical decision making : an international journal of the Society for Medical Decision Making.

[26]  R. Tibshirani,et al.  The Measurement of Patients' Values in Medicine , 1982, Medical decision making : an international journal of the Society for Medical Decision Making.

[27]  J Weston,et al.  Evaluating the benefits of a patient information video during the informed consent process. , 1997, Patient education and counseling.

[28]  R. Bagby,et al.  Criminal sentence recommendations in a simulated rape trial: Examining juror prejudice in Canada , 1995 .

[29]  S. Hobfoll,et al.  Effect of physical attractiveness on therapists' initial judgments of a person's self-concept. , 1978, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology.

[30]  A. Mulley,et al.  Developing shared decision-making programs to improve the quality of health care. , 1992, QRB. Quality review bulletin.

[31]  M K Goldstein,et al.  Measurement of the validity of utility elicitations performed by computerized interview. , 1997, Medical care.

[32]  F. Davidoff.  Race, sex, and physicians' referrals for cardiac catheterization. , 1999, The New England journal of medicine.

[33]  L. Kasten,et al.  Nonmedical influences on medical decision making: an experimental technique using videotapes, factorial design, and survey sampling. , 1997, Health services research.

[34]  K A Schulman,et al.  The effect of race and sex on physicians' recommendations for cardiac catheterization. , 1999, The New England journal of medicine.

[35]  J. Morrow,et al.  Instructional design strategies for developing an interactive video educational program for pregnant teens: a pilot study. , 1984, Patient education and counseling.

[36]  J. Ernst,et al.  The effects of applicant's health status and qualifications on simulated hiring decisions. , 1990, International journal of obesity.