Assessing telemedicine: a systematic review of the literature.

BACKGROUND To clarify the current status of telemedicine, we carried out a systematic review of the literature. We identified controlled assessment studies of telemedicine that reported patient outcomes, administrative changes or economic assessments and assessed the quality of that literature. METHODS We carried out a systematic electronic search for articles published from 1966 to early 2000 using the MEDLINE (1966-April 2000), HEALTHSTAR (1975-January 2000), EMBASE (1988-February 2000) and CINALH (1982-January 2000) databases. In addition, the HSTAT database (Health Services/Technology Assessment Text, US National Library of Medicine), the Database of Abstracts of Reviews of Effectiveness (DARE, NHS Centre for Reviews and Dissemination, United Kingdom), the NHS Economic Evaluation Database and the Cochrane Controlled Trials Register were searched. We consulted experts in the field and did a manual search of the reference lists of review articles. RESULTS A total of 1124 studies were identified. Based on a review of the abstracts, 133 full-text articles were obtained for closer inspection. Of these, 50 were deemed to represent assessment studies fulfilling the inclusion criteria of the review. Thirty-four of the articles assessed at least some clinical outcomes; the remaining 16 were mainly economic analyses. Most of the available literature referred only to pilot projects and short-term outcomes, and most of the studies were of low quality. Relatively convincing evidence of effectiveness was found only for teleradiology, teleneurosurgery, telepsychiatry, transmission of echocardiographic images, and the use of electronic referrals enabling e-mail consultations and video conferencing between primary and secondary health care providers. Economic analyses suggested that teleradiology, especially transmission of CT images, can be cost-saving. INTERPRETATION Evidence regarding the effectiveness or cost-effectiveness of telemedicine is still limited. Based on current scientific evidence, only a few telemedicine applications can be recommended for broader use.

[1]  M Hoare,et al.  The use of a computerized image transfer system linking a regional neuroradiology centre to its district hospitals. , 1991, Clinical radiology.

[2]  D. Eedy,et al.  Diagnostic accuracy and clinical management by realtime teledermatology. Results from the Northern Ireland arms of the UK Multicentre Teledermatology Trial , 1998, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[3]  Cost issues surrounding the use of computerized telemedicine for obstetric ultrasonography , 1998, Ultrasound in obstetrics & gynecology : the official journal of the International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.

[4]  K. J. Lehmann,et al.  Concept and applicability of the KAMEDIN teleradiology system in view of a cost-benefit analysis , 1997, Der Radiologe.

[5]  R Wootton,et al.  Telemedicine: a cautious welcome , 1996, BMJ.

[6]  A Allen,et al.  A cost measurement study for a tele-oncology practice , 1998, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[7]  N A Blackwell,et al.  Telemedicine ophthalmology consultation in remote Queensland , 1997, The Medical journal of Australia.

[8]  W. Poon,et al.  The impact of teleradiology on the inter-hospital transfer of neurosurgical patients. , 1997, British journal of neurosurgery.

[9]  Jarmo Reponen,et al.  A model for the assessment of telemedicine and a plan for testing of the model within five specialities , 1997 .

[10]  A. Jovell,et al.  [Evaluation of scientific evidence]. , 1995, Medicina clinica.

[11]  T. Bergmo,et al.  An economic analysis of teleradiology versus a visiting radiologist service , 1996, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[12]  Mark C. Rendina,et al.  The Effect of a Neonatal Telecardiology System on Respiratory Therapy in Very Low Birthweight Infants , 1998, MedInfo.

[13]  B. Zelickson,et al.  Teledermatology in the nursing home. , 1997, Archives of dermatology.

[14]  John E. Stollerman,et al.  A telecommunications system for monitoring and counseling patients with hypertension. Impact on medication adherence and blood pressure control. , 1996, American journal of hypertension.

[15]  Crump Wj,et al.  Communication in integrated practice networks: using interactive video technology to build the medical office without walls. , 1997 .

[16]  J. Piette,et al.  Do automated calls with nurse follow-up improve self-care and glycemic control among vulnerable patients with diabetes? , 2000, The American journal of medicine.

[17]  D. Perednia.  Telemedicine system evaluation, transaction models, and multicentered research. , 1996, Journal of AHIMA.

[18]  Fakultät für Klinische,et al.  Einsatzmöglichkeiten des KAMEDIN-Teleradiologiesystems unter besonderer Berücksichtigung einer Wirtschaftlichkeitsanalyse , 1997 .

[19]  P Wallace,et al.  Virtual outreach: a telemedicine pilot study using a cluster-randomized controlled design , 1999, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[20]  P E Mazmanian,et al.  The case of Powhatan Correctional Center/Virginia Department of Corrections and Virginia Commonwealth University/Medical College of Virginia. , 1997, Telemedicine journal : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[21]  T. Bergmo,et al.  An economic analysis of teleconsultation in otorhinolaryngology , 1997, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[22]  W. Hundt,et al.  Cost-benefit study of different application scenarios in teleradiology , 1997, Der Radiologe.

[23]  A. Albisser,et al.  Diabetes intervention in the information age. , 1996, Medical informatics = Medecine et informatique.

[24]  S. Speedie,et al.  The relative cost of outpatient telemedicine services. , 1999, Telemedicine journal : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[25]  M E McConnell,et al.  Interactive telecardiology for the evaluation of heart murmurs in children. , 1999, Telemedicine journal : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[26]  E V Dunn,et al.  A clinical evaluation of four alternative telemedicine systems. , 1977, Behavioral science.

[27]  J. Finley,et al.  Paediatric echocardiography by telemedicine-nine years' experience , 1997, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[28]  S. Perry.  Report from the Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical Research. , 1997, International journal of technology assessment in health care.

[29]  Didier Martin.  Prise en charge des urgences neurochirurgicales , 1996 .

[30]  Peter Cukor,et al.  Telepsychiatry at Forty: What Have We Learned? , 1997, Harvard review of psychiatry.

[31]  Richard Wootton,et al.  TELEMEDICINE: THE CURRENT STATE OF THE ART , 1997 .

[32]  C. Muller,et al.  Cost Factors in Urban Telemedicine , 1977, Medical care.

[33]  M C Davis,et al.  Teleradiology in rural imaging centres , 1997, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[34]  W J Crump,et al.  Communication in integrated practice networks: using interactive video technology to build the medical office without walls. , 1997, Texas medicine.

[35]  K M Kessler,et al.  A cost-effectiveness strategy for transtelephonic arrhythmia monitoring. , 1995, The American journal of cardiology.

[36]  J. Grigsby,et al.  Effects and Effectiveness of Telemedicine , 1995, Health care financing review.

[37]  J C Maroon,et al.  Utilization and cost savings of a wide-area computer network for neurosurgical consultation. , 1997, Telemedicine journal : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[38]  W. Cordell,et al.  Dobutamine stress tele-echocardiography for evaluation of emergency department patients with chest pain. , 1997, Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

[39]  J. Cairns,et al.  A framework for the economic evaluation of telemedicine , 1997, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[40]  Telemedicine: fad or future? , 1995, The Lancet.

[41]  K. Harno,et al.  Telemedicine in managing demand for secondary-care services , 1999, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[42]  P. Trott,et al.  Cost evaluation of a telepsychiatry service in northern Queensland , 1998, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[43]  R S Weinstein,et al.  Cost minimization analysis of telepathology. , 1999, American journal of clinical pathology.

[44]  W H Grant,et al.  A Teleradiology Case Conference System , 1995, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[45]  S. Mavrogeni,et al.  Transmission of electrocardiograms from a moving ambulance , 1998, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[46]  A Allen.  A review of cost effectiveness research. , 1998, Telemedicine today.

[47]  Perednia Da.  Telemedicine system evaluation, transaction models, and multicentered research. , 1996 .

[48]  H. Laing,et al.  A cyberclinic in rheumatology. , 1999, Journal of the Royal College of Physicians of London.

[49]  K. Sparks,et al.  Alternatives for cardiac rehabilitation patients unable to return to a hospital-based program. , 1993, Heart & lung : the journal of critical care.

[50]  S K Mun,et al.  A telemedicine consultative service for the evaluation of patients with urolithiasis. , 1998, Urology.

[51]  D. Hailey,et al.  Evaluation of a telepsychiatry pilot project , 1999, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[52]  J. Sisk,et al.  A proposed framework for economic evaluation of telemedicine. , 1998, Telemedicine journal : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[53]  B. Vialettes,et al.  Evaluation multicentrique du système télématique nutri-expert auprès de patients diabétiques , 1995 .

[54]  Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München,et al.  Nutzwert- und Wirtschaftlichkeitsanalyse verschiedener Teleradiologieszenarien , 1997 .

[55]  P. Taylor,et al.  A survey of research in telemedicine. 1: Telemedicine systems , 1998, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[56]  P. Taylor,et al.  A survey of research in telemedicine. 2: Telemedicine services , 1998, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[57]  M. Kienzle,et al.  Telemedicine to Iowa's correctional facilities: initial clinical experience and assessment of program costs. , 1999, Telemedicine journal : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[58]  R. Shih,et al.  Telemedicine in the emergency department: a randomized controlled trial , 1999, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[59]  James Wallace,et al.  The Effect of a Teledermatology Program on Rural Referral Patterns to Dermatologists and the Management of Skin Disease , 1998, MedInfo.

[60]  R M Brecht,et al.  The University of Texas Medical Branch--Texas Department of Criminal Justice Telemedicine Project: findings from the first year of operation. , 1996, Telemedicine journal : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[61]  A. Juutinen,et al.  The application of teleophthalmology in examining patients with glaucoma: a pilot study. , 1999, Journal of glaucoma.

[62]  Marilyn J. Field,et al.  Committee on Evaluating Clinical Applications of Telemedicine , 1996 .

[63]  M S Eljamel,et al.  The use of a computer-based image link system to assist inter-hospital referrals. , 1992, British journal of neurosurgery.

[64]  J. Piette,et al.  The effect of automated calls with telephone nurse follow-up on patient-centered outcomes of diabetes care: a randomized, controlled trial. , 2000, Medical care.

[65]  A. Dessl,et al.  A cost analysis of an emergency computerized tomography teleradiology system , 1997, Journal of telemedicine and telecare.

[66]  I. Kristiansen,et al.  Radiology services for remote communities: cost minimisation study of telemedicine , 1996, BMJ.

[67]  D. Eedy,et al.  Multicentre randomised control trial comparing real time teledermatology with conventional outpatient dermatological care: societal cost-benefit analysis , 2000, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[68]  E Cordonnier,et al.  Influence of the teleradiology technology (N-ISDN and ATM) on the inter-hospital management of neurosurgical patients. , 1999, Medical informatics and the Internet in medicine.

[69]  S. Downs,et al.  Effect of telemedicine on health outcomes in 87 infants requiring neonatal intensive care. , 1998, Telemedicine journal : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.