Meta‐analysis of genome‐wide association from genomic prediction models

Summary Genome‐wide association (GWA) studies based on GBLUP models are a common practice in animal breeding. However, effect sizes of GWA tests are small, requiring larger sample sizes to enhance power of detection of rare variants. Because of difficulties in increasing sample size in animal populations, one alternative is to implement a meta‐analysis (MA), combining information and results from independent GWA studies. Although this methodology has been used widely in human genetics, implementation in animal breeding has been limited. Thus, we present methods to implement a MA of GWA, describing the proper approach to compute weights derived from multiple genomic evaluations based on animal‐centric GBLUP models. Application to real datasets shows that MA increases power of detection of associations in comparison with population‐level GWA, allowing for population structure and heterogeneity of variance components across populations to be accounted for. Another advantage of MA is that it does not require access to genotype data that is required for a joint analysis. Scripts related to the implementation of this approach, which consider the strength of association as well as the sign, are distributed and thus account for heterogeneity in association phase between QTL and SNPs. Thus, MA of GWA is an attractive alternative to summarizing results from multiple genomic studies, avoiding restrictions with genotype data sharing, definition of fixed effects and different scales of measurement of evaluated traits.

[1]  M. Goddard,et al.  A Validated Genome Wide Association Study to Breed Cattle Adapted to an Environment Altered by Climate Change , 2009, PloS one.

[2]  Peter M. Visscher,et al.  A General Unified Framework to Assess the Sampling Variance of Heritability Estimates Using Pedigree or Marker-Based Relationships , 2014, Genetics.

[3]  J. Steibel,et al.  Genotype imputation accuracy in a F2 pig population using high density and low density SNP panels , 2013, BMC Genetics.

[4]  George A Wells,et al.  The Genome-Wide Association Study—A New Era for Common Polygenic Disorders , 2010, Journal of cardiovascular translational research.

[5]  Y. Benjamini,et al.  Controlling the false discovery rate: a practical and powerful approach to multiple testing , 1995 .

[6]  P. VanRaden,et al.  Invited review: reliability of genomic predictions for North American Holstein bulls. , 2009, Journal of dairy science.

[7]  F. Strozzi,et al.  Meta-Analysis of Two Genome-Wide Association Studies of Bovine Paratuberculosis , 2012, PloS one.

[8]  Jean-Baptiste Cazier,et al.  Meta-analysis of three genome-wide association studies identifies susceptibility loci for colorectal cancer at 1q41, 3q26.2, 12q13.13 and 20q13.33 , 2010, Nature Genetics.

[9]  M. Goddard,et al.  Genomic selection. , 2007, Journal of animal breeding and genetics = Zeitschrift fur Tierzuchtung und Zuchtungsbiologie.

[10]  S. Shackelford,et al.  Use of visible and near-infrared spectroscopy to predict pork longissimus lean color stability. , 2011, Journal of animal science.

[11]  H Geldermann,et al.  Combined analyses of data from quantitative trait loci mapping studies. Chromosome 4 effects on porcine growth and fatness. , 2000, Genetics.

[12]  F. Schenkel,et al.  Meta-analysis of genetic parameter estimates for reproduction, growth and carcass traits of pigs in the tropics , 2013 .

[13]  G. Rohrer,et al.  Genome-wide association of meat quality traits and tenderness in swine. , 2013, Journal of animal science.

[14]  W. G. Cochran The combination of estimates from different experiments. , 1954 .

[15]  R. Bates,et al.  Quantitative trait locus mapping in an F2 Duroc x Pietrain resource population: II. Carcass and meat quality traits. , 2008, Journal of animal science.

[16]  Gustavo de los Campos,et al.  Inferences from Genomic Models in Stratified Populations , 2012, Genetics.

[17]  José Crossa,et al.  Predicting Quantitative Traits With Regression Models for Dense Molecular Markers and Pedigree , 2009, Genetics.

[18]  Ian A. Wood,et al.  A meta-analytic assessment of a Thyroglobulin marker for marbling in beef cattle , 2006, Genetics Selection Evolution.

[19]  Denis Milan,et al.  Design of a High Density SNP Genotyping Assay in the Pig Using SNPs Identified and Characterized by Next Generation Sequencing Technology , 2009, PloS one.

[20]  Juan P. Steibel,et al.  Rapid screening for phenotype-genotype associations by linear transformations of genomic evaluations , 2014, BMC Bioinformatics.

[21]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  Meta-analysis methods for genome-wide association studies and beyond , 2013, Nature Reviews Genetics.

[22]  Yun Li,et al.  METAL: fast and efficient meta-analysis of genomewide association scans , 2010, Bioinform..

[23]  Chengqing Wu,et al.  A Comparison of Association Methods Correcting for Population Stratification in Case–Control Studies , 2011, Annals of human genetics.

[24]  C. Óvilo,et al.  Quantitative trait locus mapping for meat quality traits in an Iberian x Landrace F2 pig population. , 2002, Journal of animal science.

[25]  U. Peters,et al.  The use of imputed values in the meta‐analysis of genome‐wide association studies , 2011, Genetic epidemiology.

[26]  Zhiwu Zhang,et al.  Mixed linear model approach adapted for genome-wide association studies , 2010, Nature Genetics.

[27]  D Rabinowitz,et al.  A transmission disequilibrium test for quantitative trait loci. , 1997, Human heredity.

[28]  R. Fernando,et al.  Deregressing estimated breeding values and weighting information for genomic regression analyses , 2009, Genetics Selection Evolution.

[29]  J. Bastiaansen,et al.  Meta-analysis of results from quantitative trait loci mapping studies on pig chromosome 4. , 2011, Animal genetics.

[30]  J. Dekkers,et al.  Joint analysis of two breed cross populations in pigs to improve detection and characterization of quantitative trait loci. , 2005, Journal of animal science.

[31]  R Core Team,et al.  R: A language and environment for statistical computing. , 2014 .

[32]  Accuracy of Estimation of Genomic Breeding Values in Pigs Using Low-Density Genotypes and Imputation , 2014, G3: Genes, Genomes, Genetics.

[33]  G. Tseng,et al.  Comprehensive literature review and statistical considerations for GWAS meta-analysis , 2012, Nucleic acids research.

[34]  H. Piepho,et al.  Comparison of Weighting in Two‐Stage Analysis of Plant Breeding Trials , 2009 .

[35]  I Misztal,et al.  Hot topic: a unified approach to utilize phenotypic, full pedigree, and genomic information for genetic evaluation of Holstein final score. , 2010, Journal of dairy science.

[36]  J. Steibel,et al.  Methods of tagSNP selection and other variables affecting imputation accuracy in swine , 2013, BMC Genetics.

[37]  A. Reverter,et al.  Joint analysis of multiple cDNA microarray studies via multivariate mixed models applied to genetic improvement of beef cattle. , 2004, Journal of animal science.

[38]  E. Lander,et al.  Genetic dissection of complex traits: guidelines for interpreting and reporting linkage results , 1995, Nature Genetics.

[39]  M. Daly,et al.  Genome-wide association studies for common diseases and complex traits , 2005, Nature Reviews Genetics.

[40]  B. Gutiérrez-Gil,et al.  GWA Analysis for Milk Production Traits in Dairy Sheep and Genetic Support for a QTN Influencing Milk Protein Percentage in the LALBA Gene , 2012, PloS one.

[41]  G. L. Bennett,et al.  Genome-wide association study of growth in crossbred beef cattle. , 2010, Journal of animal science.

[42]  D. Garrick,et al.  Technical note: Derivation of equivalent computing algorithms for genomic predictions and reliabilities of animal merit. , 2009, Journal of dairy science.

[43]  I Misztal,et al.  Computing procedures for genetic evaluation including phenotypic, full pedigree, and genomic information. , 2009, Journal of dairy science.

[44]  Larry V. Hedges,et al.  A random effects model for effect sizes , 1983 .

[45]  C. Óvilo,et al.  Quantitative trait locus mapping for meat quality traits in an Iberian × Landrace F2 pig population1 , 2002 .

[46]  W. G. Hill,et al.  Genome partitioning of genetic variation for height from 11,214 sibling pairs. , 2007, American journal of human genetics.

[47]  J. B. Morgan,et al.  PORK CHAIN QUALITY AUDIT SURVEY: QUANTIFICATION OF PORK QUALITY CHARACTERISTICS , 1996 .

[48]  G. Glass Primary, Secondary, and Meta-Analysis of Research1 , 1976 .

[49]  I Olkin,et al.  Simple Pooling versus Combining in Meta-Analysis , 2001, Evaluation & the health professions.

[50]  S. Shackelford,et al.  Chilling rate effects on pork loin tenderness in commercial processing plants. , 2012, Journal of animal science.

[51]  L. Hedges,et al.  Fixed- and random-effects models in meta-analysis. , 1998 .

[52]  Eleazar Eskin,et al.  Rapid and Accurate Multiple Testing Correction and Power Estimation for Millions of Correlated Markers , 2009, PLoS genetics.

[53]  R. Fernando,et al.  Genome-wide association mapping including phenotypes from relatives without genotypes in a single-step (ssGWAS) for 6-week body weight in broiler chickens , 2014, Front. Genet..

[54]  Alain Charcosset,et al.  MetaQTL: a package of new computational methods for the meta-analysis of QTL mapping experiments , 2007, BMC Bioinformatics.

[55]  Julio Sánchez-Meca,et al.  Weighting by Inverse Variance or by Sample Size in Random-Effects Meta-Analysis , 2010 .

[56]  Yurii S. Aulchenko,et al.  BIOINFORMATICS APPLICATIONS NOTE doi:10.1093/bioinformatics/btm108 Genetics and population analysis GenABEL: an R library for genome-wide association analysis , 2022 .

[57]  M. Heo,et al.  Meta-analysis of linkage data under worst-case conditions: a demonstration using the human OB region. , 1998, Genetics.

[58]  Reedik Mägi,et al.  GWAMA: software for genome-wide association meta-analysis , 2010, BMC Bioinformatics.

[59]  M. Goddard,et al.  Genome-wide association studies for feedlot and growth traits in cattle. , 2011, Journal of animal science.

[60]  M. Goddard,et al.  Prediction of total genetic value using genome-wide dense marker maps. , 2001, Genetics.

[61]  Ashis Kumar Chakraborty,et al.  On multivariate folded normal distribution , 2013, Sankhya B.

[62]  H. Kang,et al.  Variance component model to account for sample structure in genome-wide association studies , 2010, Nature Genetics.

[63]  M. Goddard,et al.  A Multi-Trait, Meta-analysis for Detecting Pleiotropic Polymorphisms for Stature, Fatness and Reproduction in Beef Cattle , 2014, PLoS genetics.

[64]  Alkes L. Price,et al.  New approaches to population stratification in genome-wide association studies , 2010, Nature Reviews Genetics.

[65]  Daniel T Blumstein,et al.  Fear in animals: a meta-analysis and review of risk assessment , 2005, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[66]  J. Steibel,et al.  Estimation of linkage disequilibrium in four US pig breeds , 2012, BMC Genomics.

[67]  B. J. Hayes,et al.  Genomic selection: Genomic selection , 2007 .

[68]  Daniel L. Koller,et al.  Genome-Wide Association of Bipolar Disorder Suggests an Enrichment of Replicable Associations in Regions near Genes , 2011, PLoS genetics.

[69]  Jianxin Shi,et al.  Optimal methods for meta‐analysis of genome‐wide association studies , 2011, Genetic epidemiology.

[70]  Rehan Qayyum,et al.  A Meta-Analysis and Genome-Wide Association Study of Platelet Count and Mean Platelet Volume in African Americans , 2012, PLoS genetics.

[71]  G. Abecasis,et al.  Joint analysis is more efficient than replication-based analysis for two-stage genome-wide association studies , 2006, Nature Genetics.

[72]  Kent A Weigel,et al.  Nonparametric Methods for Incorporating Genomic Information Into Genetic Evaluations: An Application to Mortality in Broilers , 2008, Genetics.

[73]  W. Muir,et al.  Genome-wide association mapping including phenotypes from relatives without genotypes. , 2012, Genetics research.

[74]  Bin Fan,et al.  Genome-Wide Association Study Identifies Loci for Body Composition and Structural Soundness Traits in Pigs , 2011, PloS one.

[75]  Xiao-Hua Zhou,et al.  Statistical Methods for Meta‐Analysis , 2008 .

[76]  Eleazar Eskin,et al.  Interpreting Meta-Analyses of Genome-Wide Association Studies , 2012, PLoS genetics.