Damage-induced changes in woody plants and their effects on insect herbivore performance: a meta-analysis

We conducted a meta-analysis of 68 studies published between 1982 and 2000 in which the responses of woody plants to natural or simulated herbivore damage and/or insect herbivore performance on control and damaged plants were measured. Cumulative meta-analyses revealed dramatic temporal changes in the magnitude and direction of the plant and herbivore responses reported during the last two decades. Studies conducted in the 1980s reported increase in phenolic concentrations, reduction in nutrient concentrations and negative effect on herbivore performance, consistently with the idea of induced resistance. In contrast, in the early 1990s when the idea that some types of plant damage may result in induced susceptibility was generally accepted, studies reported non-significant results or induced susceptibility, and smaller effects on herbivores. The above changes may reflect paradigm shifts in the theory of induced defenses and/or the differences between study systems used in the early and the more recent studies. Overall, plant growth and carbohydrate concentrations were reduced in damaged plants despite enhanced photosynthetic rates. Damage increased the concentrations of carbon and phenolics, while terpene concentrations tended to decrease after damage; changes in nutrient concentrations after damage varied according to nutrient mobility, inherent plant growth rate, ontogenetic stage and plant type (deciduous/evergreen). Early season damage caused more pronounced changes in plants than late season damage, which is in accordance with the assumption that vigorously growing foliage has a greater capacity to respond to damage. Insect growth rate and female pupal weight decreased on previously damaged plants, while herbivore survival, consumption and male pupal weight were not significantly affected. The magnitude and direction of herbivore responses depended on the type of plant, the type of damage, the time interval between the damage and insect feeding (rapid/delayed induced resistance), and the timing of the damage.

[1]  Ryan D. Csada,et al.  The "File Drawer Problem" of Non-Significant Results: Does It Apply to Biological Research? , 1996 .

[2]  J. R. Evans.  Photosynthesis and nitrogen relationships in leaves of C3 plants , 2004, Oecologia.

[3]  J. Lawton,et al.  Does Foliage Damage Influence Predation on the Insect Herbivores of Birch , 1988 .

[4]  R. Verpoorte,et al.  Induced responses in three alkaloid-containing plant species , 1993, Oecologia.

[5]  J. Koricheva.  Interpreting phenotypic variation in plant allelochemistry: problems with the use of concentrations , 1999, Oecologia.

[6]  E. Christiansen,et al.  Pruning enhances the susceptibility of Picea abies to infection by the bark beetle‐transmitted blue‐stain fungus, Ophiostoma polonicum , 1993 .

[7]  P. Niemelä,et al.  DEFOLIATION OF THE SCOTS PINE AND PERFORMANCE OF DIPRIONID SAWFLIES , 1991 .

[8]  N. Owen‐Smith,et al.  Effects of Severe Defoliation on the Long-Term Resistance to Insect Attack and on Leaf Chemistry in Six Woody Species of the Southern African Savanna , 1991, The American Naturalist.

[9]  C. Mcarthur,et al.  Rethinking the role of many plant phenolics - protection from photodamage not herbivores? , 2002 .

[10]  E. Haukioja,et al.  Nutrient stress: an explanation for plant anti-herbivore responses to defoliation , 1984, Oecologia.

[11]  J. Schultz.  Plant responses induced by herbivores. , 1988, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[12]  C. Canham,et al.  Interspecific and intraspecific variation in tree seedling survival: effects of allocation to roots versus carbohydrate reserves , 1999, Oecologia.

[13]  S. Hanhimäki.  Induced resistance in mountain birch: defence against leaf-chewing insect guild and herbivore competition , 1989, Oecologia.

[14]  S. Larsson,et al.  Effects on growth of simulated and induced shoot pruning by Tomicus piniperda as related to carbohydrate and nitrogen dynamics in Scots pine. , 1985 .

[15]  D. Tallamy,et al.  Phytochemical Induction by Herbivores , 1994 .

[16]  R. Karban,et al.  Effects of an early-season folivorous moth on the success of a later-season species, mediated by a change in the quality of the shared host, Lupinus arboreus Sims , 1986, Oecologia.

[17]  Julia Koricheva,et al.  META-ANALYSIS OF SOURCES OF VARIATION IN FITNESS COSTS OF PLANT ANTIHERBIVORE DEFENSES , 2002 .

[18]  J. Lawton,et al.  Rapidly Induced Defenses and Talking Trees: The Devil's Advocate Position , 1985, The American Naturalist.

[19]  J. Bryant.  CHAPTER 12 – Environmental Constraint Of Constitutive and Long-Term Inducible Defenses in Woody Plants , 1988 .

[20]  V. Kitunen,et al.  Responses of Pinus sylvestris branches to simulated herbivory are modified by tree sink/source dynamics and by external resources , 1999 .

[21]  T. Kuhn.  The structure of scientific revolutions, 3rd ed. , 1996 .

[22]  G. T. Brooks.  Penetration and Distribution of Insecticides , 1976 .

[23]  L. E. Eddleman,et al.  The response of western juniper (Juniperusoccidentalis) to reductions in above-and below-ground tissue , 1991 .

[24]  K. Raffa,et al.  Compound effects of induced plant responses on insect herbivores and parasitoids: implications for tritrophic interactions , 2000 .

[25]  R. Dixon,et al.  Evidence for Chewing Insect-Specific Molecular Events Distinct from a General Wound Response in Leaves , 1997, Plant physiology.

[26]  J. Bryant.  Feltleaf Willow‐Snowshoe Hare Interactions: Plant Carbon/Nutrient Balance and Floodplain Succession , 1987 .

[27]  E. Vapaavuori,et al.  Combined Effects of Partial Defoliation and Nutrient Availability on Cloned Betula pendula Saplings II. CHANGES IN NET PHOTOSYNTHESIS AND RELATED BIOCHEMICAL PROPERTIES , 1993 .

[28]  E. Kruger,et al.  Influences of atmospheric CO2 enrichment on the responses of sugar maple and trembling aspen to defoliation , 1998 .

[29]  P. Lyytikäinen.  Comparison of the effects of artificial and natural defoliation on the growth of diprionid sawflies on Scots pine foliage , 1992 .

[30]  M. Berenbaum.  The chemistry of defense: theory and practice. , 1995, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[31]  E. Haukioja,et al.  INDUCED LONG-TERM RESISTANCE OF BIRCH FOLIAGE AGAINST DEFOLIATORS: DEFENSIVE OR INCIDENTAL? , 1985 .

[32]  R. Marquis,et al.  INDUCED DEFENSE IN WHITE OAK: EFFECTS ON HERBIVORES AND CONSEQUENCES FOR THE PLANT , 1997 .

[33]  D. Reavey.  Do birch-feeding caterpillars make the right feeding choices? , 1991, Oecologia.

[34]  E. Haukioja,et al.  Long-term inducible resistance in birch foliage: triggering cues and efficacy on a defoliator , 1985, Oecologia.

[35]  G. Wheeler,et al.  Caterpillars' compensatory feeding response to diluted nutrients leads to toxic allelochemical dose , 1992 .

[36]  M. Dearing.  Effects of Acomastylis rossii tannins on a mammalian herbivore, the North American pika, Ochotona princeps , 1996, Oecologia.

[37]  W. Hamilton,et al.  Low Nutritive Quality as Defense Against Herbivores , 1980 .

[38]  J. Senn,et al.  Consequences of herbivory in the mountain birch (Betula pubescens ssp tortuosa): importance of the functional organization of the tree , 1990, Oecologia.

[39]  G. Cooper-Driver,et al.  Role of Phenolics in Plant Evolution. , 1999 .

[40]  P. Reich,et al.  Growth, nutrition and gas exchange of Pinus resinosa following artificial defoliation , 2004, Trees.

[41]  S. Leather,et al.  Insect induced resistance in Lodgepole pine: effects on two pine feeding insects , 1997 .

[42]  K. Gerhardt.  Leaf defoliation of tropical dry forest tree seedlings – implications for survival and growth , 1998, Trees.

[43]  J. Myers.  CHAPTER 11 – The Induced Defense Hypothesis: Does It Apply to the Population Dynamics of Insects? , 1988 .

[44]  K. Clancy,et al.  Rapid Herbivore Growth Enhances Enemy Attack: Sublethal Plant Defenses Remain a Paradox , 1987 .

[45]  R. Bergström,et al.  Winter browsing by moose on two birch species: impact on food resources , 1989 .

[46]  T. Young,et al.  Thorns as induced defenses: experimental evidence , 1991, Oecologia.

[47]  Thomas P. Clausen,et al.  Chemical model for short-term induction in quaking aspen (Populus tremuloides) foliage against herbivores , 1989, Journal of Chemical Ecology.

[48]  Markku Keinänen,et al.  HERBIVORE RESISTANCE IN BETULA PENDULA: EFFECT OF FERTILIZATION, DEFOLIATION, AND PLANT GENOTYPE , 2000 .

[49]  F. Chapin,et al.  Delayed Inducible Resistance in Mountain Birch in Response to Fertilization and Shade , 1996 .

[50]  E. Haukioja,et al.  Low nutritive quality as defence against herbivores: induced responses in birch , 1984, Oecologia.

[51]  R. Bergström,et al.  Interactions between Browsing Moose and Two Species of Birch in Sweden , 1985 .

[52]  P. Karlsson,et al.  Effects of defoliation on radial stem growth and photosynthesis in the mountain birch (Betula pubescens ssp. tortuosa). , 1992 .

[53]  P. Lyytikäinen.  The influence of damage level in Pinus sylvestris foliage on the performance of diprionid sawflies , 1992 .

[54]  F. Slansky,et al.  THE NUTRITIONAL ECOLOGY OF IMMATURE INSECTS , 1981 .

[55]  M. Walls,et al.  Changes in Leaf Gas Exchange Properties of Cloned Betula pendula Saplings after Partial Defoliation , 1992 .

[56]  Rapid wound-induced resistance in white birch (Betula pubescens) foliage to the geometrid Epirrita autumnata: a comparison of trees and moths within and outside the outbreak range of the moth , 2004, Oecologia.

[57]  Michael D Greenfield,et al.  Wound-Induced Proteinase Inhibitor in Plant Leaves: A Possible Defense Mechanism against Insects , 1972, Science.

[58]  K. Danell,et al.  Does Browsing Modify the Quality of Birch Foliage for Epirrita autumnata Larvae , 1987 .

[59]  Richard Karban,et al.  Induced Responses to Herbivory , 1997 .

[60]  G. Lovett,et al.  Carbon and nitrogen assimilation in red oaks (Quercus rubra L.) subject to defoliation and nitrogen stress. , 1993, Tree physiology.

[61]  P. Reymond,et al.  Differential Gene Expression in Response to Mechanical Wounding and Insect Feeding in Arabidopsis , 2000, Plant Cell.

[62]  K. Huss-Danell,et al.  Feeding by insects and hares on birches earlier affected by moose browsing , 1985 .

[63]  M. Walls,et al.  Herbivore-induced resistance in Betula pendula: the role of plant vascular architecture , 1996, Oecologia.

[64]  E. Haukioja,et al.  Delayed inducible resistance against a leaf-chewing insect in four deciduous tree species , 1987, Oecologia.

[65]  Dean C. Adams,et al.  RESAMPLING TESTS FOR META‐ANALYSIS OF ECOLOGICAL DATA , 1997 .

[66]  J. Hjältén,et al.  The Effect of Pruning on Willow Growth and Sawfly Population Densities , 1996 .

[67]  F. Heyden,et al.  Regrowth and tannin production in woody and succulent karoo shrubs in response to simulated browsing , 1993, Oecologia.

[68]  Päivi Lyytikäinen-Saarenmaa.  Effects of natural and artificial defoliations on sawfly performance and foliar chemistry of Scots pine saplings , 1994 .

[69]  K. Ruohomäki,et al.  Consequences of defoliation on phenological interaction between Epirrita autumnata and its host plant, Mountain Birch , 1997 .

[70]  E. Zvereva,et al.  Pollution suppresses delayed inducible resistance in boreal willow Salix borealis. , 2000 .

[71]  V. Ossipov,et al.  Delayed induced changes in the biochemical composition of host plant leaves during an insect outbreak , 1998, Oecologia.

[72]  E. Haukioja,et al.  How to study induced plant resistance? , 1985, Oecologia.

[73]  A. Honěk,et al.  Intraspecific variation in body size and fecundity in insects: a general relationship , 1993 .

[74]  M. Litvak,et al.  Patterns of induced and constitutive monoterpene production in conifer needles in relation to insect herbivory , 1998, Oecologia.

[75]  S. McNaughton.  Compensatory plant growth as a response to herbivory , 1983 .

[76]  J. Landsberg.  Dieback of rural eucalypts: Response of foliar dietary quality and herbivory to defoliation , 1990 .

[77]  R. Rosenthal.  The file drawer problem and tolerance for null results , 1979 .

[78]  S. Faeth.  Indirect Interactions Between Temporally Separated Herbivores Mediated by the Host Plant , 1986 .

[79]  F. S. Chapin,et al.  The Mineral Nutrition of Wild Plants , 1980 .

[80]  M. Walls,et al.  Combined Effects of Partial Defoliation and Nutrient Availability on Cloned Betula pendula Saplings I CHANGES IN GROWTH, PARTITIONING AND NITROGEN UPTAKE , 1993 .

[81]  J. Trumble,et al.  Plant compensation for arthropod herbivory , 1993 .

[82]  Craig Loehle,et al.  Tree life history strategies: the role of defenses , 1988 .

[83]  H. T. Valentine,et al.  Nutritional changes in host foliage during and after defoliation, and their relation to the weight of gypsy moth pupae , 1983, Oecologia.

[84]  A. Palmer,et al.  Detecting Publication Bias in Meta‐analyses: A Case Study of Fluctuating Asymmetry and Sexual Selection , 1999, The American Naturalist.

[85]  J. Roland,et al.  Improved insect performance from host‐plant defoliation: winter moth on oak and apple , 1987 .

[86]  J. Bryant,et al.  Long-term and short-term induction in quaking aspen: related phenomena? , 1991 .

[87]  T C Chalmers,et al.  Cumulative meta-analysis of therapeutic trials for myocardial infarction. , 1992, The New England journal of medicine.

[88]  S. Faeth.  Do defoliation and subsequent phytochemical responses reduce future herbivory on oak trees? , 1992, Journal of Chemical Ecology.

[89]  D. Herms,et al.  The Dilemma of Plants: To Grow or Defend , 1992, The Quarterly Review of Biology.

[90]  F. Macdowall,et al.  Utilization of carbon and nitrogen reserves of alfalfa roots in supporting N2-fixation and shoot regrowth , 1990, Plant and Soil.

[91]  L. Hedges,et al.  Meta-analysis: Combining the results of independent experiments , 1993 .

[92]  F. Stuart Chapin,et al.  Carbon/nutrient balance of boreal plants in relation to vertebrate herbivory , 1983 .

[93]  E. Haukioja,et al.  Why does a branch suffer more after branch-wide than after tree-wide defoliation ? , 1994 .

[94]  R. Ruess.  The interaction of defoliation and nutrient uptake in Sporobolus kentrophyllus, a short-grass species from the serengeti plains , 1988, Oecologia.

[95]  K. C. Spencer,et al.  Chemical Mediation of Coevolution , 1990 .

[96]  J. Bryant,et al.  Slight tissue wounding fails to induce consistent chemical defense in three willow (Salix spp.) clones , 1995, Oecologia.

[97]  A. Tolvanen,et al.  Effects of reproduction and artificial herbivory on vegetative growth and resource levels in deciduous and evergreen dwarf shrubs , 1997 .

[98]  K. Raffa,et al.  Comparison of insect, fungal, and mechanically induced defoliation of larch: effects on plant productivity and subsequent host susceptibility , 1992, Oecologia.

[99]  R. Kobe.  Carbohydrate allocation to storage as a basis of interspecific variation in sapling survivorship and growth , 1997 .

[100]  M. Dicke.  Are herbivore‐induced plant volatiles reliable indicators of herbivore identity to foraging carnivorous arthropods? , 1999 .

[101]  I. Baldwin,et al.  Herbivory simulations in ecological research. , 1990, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[102]  P. Feeny,et al.  Plant apparency and chemical defense , 1976 .

[103]  C. Canham,et al.  Effects of the frequency, timing, and intensity of simulated browsing on growth and mortality of tree seedlings , 1994 .

[104]  Christopher B. Field,et al.  photosynthesis--nitrogen relationship in wild plants , 1986 .

[105]  Thomas P. Clausen,et al.  Effects of Mineral Nutrition on Delayed Inducible Resistance in Alaska Paper Birch , 1993 .

[106]  T. Vuorisalo,et al.  Induced Accumulation of Foliage Phenols in Mountain Birch: Branch Response to Defoliation? , 1988, The American Naturalist.

[107]  R. Croteau,et al.  Defense mechanisms of conifers : differences in constitutive and wound-induced monoterpene biosynthesis among species. , 1991, Plant physiology.

[108]  K. McPherson,et al.  The role of carbohydrate reserves in the growth, resilience, and persistence of cabbage palm seedlings (Sabal palmetto) , 1998, Oecologia.

[109]  P. Lyytikäinen-Saarenmaa.  THE RESPONSES OF SCOTS PINE, PINUS SYLVESTRIS, TO NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL DEFOLIATION STRESS , 1999 .

[110]  M. McClure.  Competition between exotic species.scale insects on hemlock , 1980 .

[111]  S. Hurlbert.  Pseudoreplication and the Design of Ecological Field Experiments , 1984 .

[112]  K. Ruohomäki,et al.  Consumption of apical buds as a mechanism of alleviating host plant resistance for Epirrita autumnata larvae , 1997 .

[113]  M. Jennions,et al.  Relationships fade with time: a meta-analysis of temporal trends in publication in ecology and evolution , 2002, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences.

[114]  J. Cornelissen.  Growth, morphology and leaf characteristics after simulated herbivory in Chinese subtropical evergreen saplings , 1993, Ecological Research.

[115]  K. Percy,et al.  Changes in needle morphology, anatomy, and mineral content during the recovery of protected balsam fir trees initially defoliated by the spruce budworm , 1984 .

[116]  R. Bennett,et al.  Secondary metabolites in plant defence mechanisms. , 1994, The New phytologist.

[117]  Nonstructural carbohydrate allocation following different frequencies of simulated browsing in three semi-arid shrubs , 1995, Oecologia.

[118]  E. Meijden,et al.  Defence and regrowth, alternative plant strategies in the struggle against herbivores , 1988 .

[119]  David B. Pillemer,et al.  Summing Up: The Science of Reviewing Research , 1984 .

[120]  M. Elgar,et al.  Heritabilities and paradigm shifts , 1997, Nature.

[121]  Jessica Gurevitch,et al.  STATISTICAL ISSUES IN ECOLOGICAL META‐ANALYSES , 1999 .

[122]  R. Hollingworth.  The Biochemical and Physiological Basis of Selective Toxicity , 1976 .

[123]  K. Danell,et al.  The Impact of Herbivory and Competition on the Phenolic Concentration and Palatability of Juvenile Birches , 1994 .

[124]  E. Haukioja.  Induction of Defenses in Trees , 1991 .

[125]  F. Chapin,et al.  Defensive Responses of Trees in Relation to Their Carbon/Nutrient Balance , 1988 .

[126]  G. Kudo.  Herbivory pattern and induced responses to simulated herbivory inQuercus mongolica var.grosseserrata , 1996, Ecological Research.

[127]  R. Karban,et al.  Induced Plant Responses to Herbivory , 1989 .

[128]  P. Reich,et al.  The effect of defoliation intensity and history on photosynthesis, growth and carbon reserves of two conifers with contrasting leaf lifespans and growth habits , 1999 .

[129]  D. Herms,et al.  Defensive Strategies of Woody Plants Against Different Insect-Feeding Guilds in Relation to Plant Ecological Strategies and Intimacy of Association with Insects , 1988 .

[130]  D. Quiring,et al.  WHY DOES EARLY-SEASON HERBIVORY AFFECT SUBSEQUENT BUDBURST? , 1999 .

[131]  A. Agrawal,et al.  Why Induced Defenses May Be Favored Over Constitutive Strategies in Plants , 2000 .

[132]  S. Strauss.  Direct, Indirect, and Cumulative Effects of Three Native Herbivores on a Shared Host Plant , 1991 .

[133]  J. Myers,et al.  Lack of short or long term inducible defenses in the red alder - western tent caterpillar system , 1987 .

[134]  W. J. Mattson,et al.  Mechanisms of woody plant defenses against insects: search for pattern, held in Orleans, France, on 26-29 August 1986. , 1988 .

[135]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  Evolution of treatment effects over time: empirical insight from recursive cumulative metaanalyses. , 2001, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[136]  F. Chapin,et al.  Lack of induced chemical defense in juvenile Alaskan woody plants in response to simulated browsing , 1985, Oecologia.

[137]  T. Tammaru,et al.  Realized fecundity in Epirrita autumnata (Lepidoptera: Geometridae): relation to body size and consequences to population dynamics , 1996 .

[138]  Robert J. Marquis,et al.  A Bite is a Bite is a Bite? Constraints on Response to Folivory in Piper Arieianum (Piperaceae) , 1992 .

[139]  K. Raffa,et al.  Effects of elicitation treatment and genotypic variation on induced resistance in Populus: impacts on gypsy moth (Lepidoptera: Lymantriidae) development and feeding behavior , 1999, Oecologia.

[140]  J. Schultz,et al.  Fertilization Mitigates Chemical Induction and Herbivore Responses Within Damaged Oak Trees , 1995 .

[141]  S. Leather,et al.  Insect‐induced chemical changes in young lodgepole pine (Pinus contorta): the effect of previous defoliation on oviposition, growth and survival of the pine beauty moth, Panolis flammea , 1987 .

[142]  G. M. Puttick,et al.  Phenolics, nutrition and insect herbivory in some garrigue and maquis plant species , 1989, Oecologia.

[143]  M. Wagner.  Induced Defenses in Ponderosa Pine Against Defoliating Insects , 1988 .

[144]  M. Wagner,et al.  Defoliation increases nutritional quality and allelochemics of pine seedlings , 1985, Oecologia.

[145]  P. Kaitaniemi,et al.  Effects of cumulative defoliations on growth, reproduction, and insect resistance in mountain birch , 1999 .

[146]  J. Schultz,et al.  Oak Leaf Quality Declines in Response to Defoliation by Gypsy Moth Larvae , 1982, Science.

[147]  R. Schultz,et al.  Artificial defoliation effect on Populus growth, biomass production, and total nonstructural carbohydrate concentration , 1996 .

[148]  J. Sullivan,et al.  THE IMPACT OF HERBIVORY ON PLANTS IN DIFFERENT RESOURCE CONDITIONS: A META-ANALYSIS , 2001 .

[149]  F. Stuart Chapin,et al.  Resource Availability and Plant Antiherbivore Defense , 1985, Science.