Top-seal leakage through faults and fractures: the role of mudrock properties

Abstract Mudrocks are effective top seals for hydrocarbon accumulations because they possess very low permeabilities, high capillary entry pressures, and are often laterally continuous basin-wide. For leakage through the seal to take place, an additional mechanism must provide enhanced permeability in mudrocks. Tectonically induced, dilatant faulting and fracturing in brittle rocks is such a mechanism. The effectiveness of mudrocks as seals may be compromised by a number of other factors, such as tectonic fault displacements in excess of the seal thickness; tensile fracturing under extreme fluid pressure conditions; and leakage via a network of juxtaposed thin leaky beds across sub-seismic faults within the seal. Before hydrocarbon trap integrity analysis, seismic interpretations should honour the fundamental geometry of the trap as closely as possible because top seals can be reliably appraised only when basic geometries are accurately determined. Fluid pressure is a proven risk in many exploration provinces, in terms of mudrock top-seal leakage via opening mode fractures. This natural hydrofracturing can take place if buoyancy pressures, combined with fluid overpressures, exceed the minimum in situ horizontal stress, plus the tensile strenght of the seal, an occurrence that leads to mechanical failure of the seal rock. The rheology of a seal is another important factor as it determines the failure mode, i.e. whether the rocks are ductile and remain sealing after deformation or whether they deform in a brittle manner to create permeable leak paths. Several techniques have been developed to predict rock rheology; these rely on uplift, sonic velocity and clay content data. Burial curves can be used to determine overconsolidation of mudrocks. Sonic velocity data can be used to estimate unconfined compressive strength in mudrocks. The most direct method utilizes relationships between mudrock friction angle, swelling clay content and mudrock surface area to determine ductility. The effect on trap integrity of sub-seismic faults is also quantifiable because advances in structural geological technology now permit predictions of the numbers of sub-seismic faults in a trap. This information, combined with detailed top-seal stratigraphic data, provides the power to screen traps for the risk of top-seal leakage via sub-seismic fault juxtapositions within the seal. A simple strategy incorporating these factors and linking them to other structural and stratigraphic information can contribute to reducing uncertainty about top-seal leakage caused by tectonic deformation.