Modern treatises on the origin of the theory of mineral nutrition of plants and the Law of the Minimum usually refer to books published by Justus von Liebig in 1840 and 1855. These works are believed to be original reports of Liebig's own research. Occasionally, however, scholars of early agronomic literature have stated that these books by Liebig contain doctrines on mineral plant nutrition and nutrient deficiencies that had been published earlier by Liebig's countryman and colleague Carl Sprengel (1787-1859). To examine such statements, we studied the relevant literature. This study showed that the agronomist and chemist Carl Sprengel conducted pioneering research in agricultural chemistry during the first half of the 19th century. His early artides and books mark the beginning of a new epoch in agronomy. He published in 1826 an article in which the humus theory was refuted, and in 1828 another, extended journal article on soil chemistry and mineral nutrition of plants that contained in essence the Law of the Minimum. Sprengel's doctrines are presented again in the books published by Liebig in 1840 and 1855. To avoid a dispute on priorities and impacts and to recognize and commemorate the achievements of both pioneering scientists, the Association of German Agricultural Experimental and Research Stations has created the Sprengel-Liebig Medal. We propose that the international community of agronomists acts similarly by recognizing Sprengel as a cofounder of agricultural chemistry and that the Law of the Minimum henceforth be called the Sprengel-Liebig Law of the Minimum.
[1]
W. Böhm.
Biographisches Handbuch zur Geschichte des Pflanzenbaus
,
1997
.
[2]
W. J. Whittington.
John Lawes of Rothamsted. Pioneer of Science, Farming and Industry , by G. V. Dyke. 234 pp. Harpenden: Hoos Press (1993). £20.00 (hardback). ISBN 0 9521306 0 2.
,
1994,
The Journal of Agricultural Science.
[3]
P. Mcdonald,et al.
Early soil science and trends in the early literature.
,
1994
.
[4]
P. Mcdonald.
The literature of soil science.
,
1994
.
[5]
C. A. Black,et al.
Soil Fertility Evaluation and Control
,
1993
.
[6]
Uschi Schling-Brodersen.
Liebig's Role in the Establishment of Agricultural Chemistry
,
1992
.
[7]
P. Munday.
Liebig's Metamorphosis: From Organic Chemistry to the Chemistry of Agriculture.
,
1991,
Ambix.
[8]
M. Finlay.
The Rehabilitation of an Agricultural Chemist: Justus Von Liebig and the Seventh Edition.
,
1991,
Ambix.
[9]
D. Schroeder.
Carl Sprengel – 150 Jahre „Bodenkunde”︁–
,
1987
.
[10]
F. G. Viets.
A Perspective on Two Centuries of Progress in Soil Fertility and Plant Nutrition 1
,
1977
.
[11]
F. Rintelen.
Geschichtlicher Überblick über die Entwicklung der Augenheilkunde
,
1969
.
[12]
A. B. Charles.
A Source Book Of Agricultural Chemistry
,
1944
.
[13]
E. W. Russell,et al.
Soil Conditions and Plant Growth.
,
1917
.