Craniofacial Superimposition: Historical Review and Current Issues

Methodology of craniofacial superimposition has evolved dramatically since its inception in the early 20th century. Contemporary approaches involve advanced procedures of digitization, use of video cameras, warping algorithms, skull positioning devices and data derived from computed tomography, radiography, and ultrasound technology. Applications have proven most useful in exclusion and casework frequency has declined in some regions in recent years as molecular approaches to identification have become more widely available. Additional research is needed to clarify the probabilities involved and to facilitate comparisons when the technique is employed.

[1]  D. Ubelaker ALES HRDLICKA'S ROLE IN THE HISTORY OF FORENSIC ANTHROPOLOGY , 1999 .

[2]  Carl N Stephan,et al.  Facial approximation: an evaluation of mouth-width determination. , 2003, American journal of physical anthropology.

[3]  P H Buschang,et al.  Midsagittal facial tissue thicknesses of children and adolescents from the Montreal growth study. , 2001, Journal of forensic sciences.

[4]  Sven De Greef,et al.  Three-dimensional cranio-facial reconstruction in forensic identification: latest progress and new tendencies in the 21st century. , 2005, Journal of forensic sciences.

[5]  Carl N Stephan,et al.  Facial approximation: globe projection guideline falsified by exophthalmometry literature. , 2002, Journal of forensic sciences.

[6]  D Austin-Smith,et al.  The reliability of skull/photograph superimposition in individual identification. , 1994, Journal of forensic sciences.

[7]  G. Webster,et al.  Photography as an Aid in Identification: The Plumbago Pit Case , 1955 .

[8]  Oscar Cordón,et al.  An experimental study on the applicability of evolutionary algorithms to craniofacial superimposition in forensic identification , 2009, Inf. Sci..

[9]  Hitoshi Biwasaka,et al.  The applicability of holography in forensic identification: a fusion of the traditional optical technique and digital technique. , 2005, Journal of forensic sciences.

[10]  S. Damas,et al.  Dispersion assessment in the location of facial landmarks on photographs , 2014, International Journal of Legal Medicine.

[11]  Dawnie Wolfe Steadman Approaches to Facial Reproduction and Photographic Superimposition , 2015 .

[12]  G. Macho,et al.  An appraisal of plastic reconstruction of the external nose. , 1986, Journal of forensic sciences.

[13]  Caroline Wilkinson,et al.  Forensic Facial Reconstruction , 2004 .

[14]  C J Nortjé,et al.  A case of skull identification by means of photographic superimposition. , 1986, The Journal of forensic odonto-stomatology.

[15]  P Vanezis,et al.  Application of 3-D computer graphics for facial reconstruction and comparison with sculpting techniques. , 1989, Forensic science international.

[16]  Carl N Stephan,et al.  Facial Soft Tissue Depths in Craniofacial Identification (Part I): An Analytical Review of the Published Adult Data * , 2008, Journal of forensic sciences.

[17]  Ferenc Fazekas,et al.  FACE‐R—A 3D Database of 400 Living Individuals' Full Head CT‐ and Face Scans and Preliminary GMM Analysis for Craniofacial Reconstruction , 2013, Journal of forensic sciences.

[18]  T. D. Stewart,et al.  The points of attachment of the palpebral ligaments: their use in facial reconstructions on the skull. , 1983, Journal of forensic sciences.

[19]  Gian Luca Marella,et al.  A New Experimental Approach to Computer-Aided Face/Skull Identification in Forensic Anthropology , 2006, The American journal of forensic medicine and pathology.

[20]  Carl N Stephan,et al.  The Application of the Central Limit Theorem and the Law of Large Numbers to Facial Soft Tissue Depths: T‐Table Robustness and Trends since 2008 , , 2014, Journal of forensic sciences.

[21]  R. R. Ackermann Three-dimensional imaging in forensic anthropology: a test study using the Macintosh. , 1997, Journal of forensic sciences.

[22]  Brown Ka Developments in cranio-facial superimposition for identification. , 1983 .

[23]  T. Fenton,et al.  Skull‐Photo Superimposition and Border Deaths: Identification Through Exclusion and the Failure to Exclude * , 2008, Journal of forensic sciences.

[24]  G. Macho,et al.  Descriptive morphological features of the nose--an assessment of their importance for plastic reconstruction. , 1989, Journal of forensic sciences.

[25]  Hans-Peter Seidel,et al.  Reanimating the dead: reconstruction of expressive faces from skull data , 2003, ACM Trans. Graph..

[26]  P X Iten,et al.  Identification of skulls by video superimposition. , 1987, Journal of forensic sciences.

[27]  Karl Pearson,et al.  THE WILKINSON HEAD OF OLIVER CROMWELL AND ITS RELATIONSHIP TO BUSTS, MASKS AND PAINTED PORTRAITS , 1934 .

[28]  Pascal Desbarats,et al.  Anthropological Facial Approximation in Three Dimensions (AFA3D): Computer‐Assisted Estimation of the Facial Morphology Using Geometric Morphometrics , 2014, Journal of forensic sciences.

[29]  Xanthé Mallett,et al.  Forensic Facial Comparison: Issues of Admissibility in the Development of Novel Analytical Technique , 2013, Journal of forensic sciences.

[30]  Carl N Stephan,et al.  Predicting mouth width from inter-canine width--a 75% rule. , 2003, Journal of forensic sciences.

[31]  T D Koelmeyer Videocamera superimposition and facial reconstruction as an aid to identification , 1982, The American journal of forensic medicine and pathology.

[32]  R. Helmer,et al.  Schädelidentifizierung durch Superprojektion nach dem Verfahren der elektronischen Bildmischung, modifiziert zum Trickbild-Differenz-Verfahren , 1977, Zeitschrift für Rechtsmedizin.

[33]  Seiji Yamamoto,et al.  Application of Superimposition‐Based Personal Identification Using Skull Computed Tomography Images , 2011, Journal of forensic sciences.

[34]  Joanne D. Subtelny,et al.  A longitudinal study of soft tissue facial structures and their profile characteristics, defined in relation to underlying skeletal structures , 1959 .

[35]  John Glaister,et al.  Medico-Legal Aspects of the Ruxton Case , 1938, The Indian Medical Gazette.

[36]  Carl N. Stephan,et al.  Ceiling recognition limits of two-dimensional facial approximations constructed using averages , 2005 .

[37]  Alexandra Lobb,et al.  Medical Jurisprudence and Toxicology , 1939, The Indian Medical Gazette.

[38]  Oscar Cordón,et al.  Forensic identification by computer-aided craniofacial superimposition: A survey , 2011, CSUR.

[39]  R. Benfer,et al.  The death and mortal remains of Francisco Pizarro. , 1989, Journal of forensic sciences.

[40]  Martin Evison Modeling age, obesity, and ethnicity in a computerized 3-D facial reconstruction , 2001 .

[41]  L F Chee,et al.  Skull and photographic superimposition: a new approach using a second party's interpupil distance to extrapolate the magnification factor. , 1989, Journal of forensic sciences.

[42]  Gatot Lao,et al.  Craniofacial identification in forensic medicine , 1999 .

[43]  Douglas H. Ubelaker,et al.  Reconstructing the Shape of the Nose According to the Skull , 2002 .

[44]  Connie L. Parks,et al.  Assessment of presentation methods for ReFace computerized facial approximations. , 2014, Forensic science international.

[45]  C N Stephan,et al.  Anthropological facial 'reconstruction--recognizing the fallacies, 'unembracing' the errors, and realizing method limits. , 2003, Science & justice : journal of the Forensic Science Society.

[46]  Carl N Stephan,et al.  Predicting nose projection and pronasale position in facial approximation: a test of published methods and proposal of new guidelines. , 2003, American journal of physical anthropology.

[47]  J. Rhine,et al.  Thickness of facial tissues in American blacks. , 1980, Journal of forensic sciences.

[48]  D. Ubelaker,et al.  An analysis of forensic anthropology cases submitted to the Smithsonian Institution by the Federal Bureau of Investigation from 1962 to 1994 , 2001 .

[49]  W. His,et al.  Anatomische Forschungen über Johann Sebastian Bach's Gebeine und Antlitz nebst Bemerkungen über dessen Bilder , 1895 .

[50]  C N Stephan,et al.  Recognition by forensic facial approximation: case specific examples and empirical tests. , 2006, Forensic science international.

[51]  K. S. Reddy,et al.  Identification of dismembered parts: the medicolegal aspects of the Nagaraju case. , 1973, Forensic science.

[52]  Damian Schofield,et al.  Key Parameters of Face Shape Variation in 3D in a Large Sample * , 2010, Journal of forensic sciences.

[53]  Y Lan A study on national differences in identification standards for Chinese skull-image superimposition. , 1995, Forensic science international.

[54]  S Miyasaka,et al.  Computer-assisted skull identification system using video superimposition. , 1997, Forensic science international.

[55]  D. Steadman Hard Evidence: Case Studies in Forensic Anthropology , 2002 .

[56]  B. P. Gatliff,et al.  From skull to visage. , 1979, The Journal of biocommunication.

[57]  S Miyasaka,et al.  The computer-aided facial reconstruction system. , 1995, Forensic science international.

[58]  C N Stephan,et al.  Assessing facial approximation accuracy: how do resemblance ratings of disparate faces compare to recognition tests? , 2006, Forensic science international.

[59]  Ted A. Rathbun,et al.  Human Identification: Case Studies in Forensic Anthropology , 1984 .

[60]  P. Vanezis,et al.  Techniques in facial identification: Computer-aided facial reconstruction using a laser scanner and video superimposition , 2005, International Journal of Legal Medicine.

[61]  Ann H Ross,et al.  Effect of Intentional Cranial Modification on Craniofacial Landmarks: A Three-Dimensional Perspective , 2009, The Journal of craniofacial surgery.

[62]  G Quatrehomme,et al.  A fully three-dimensional method for facial reconstruction based on deformable models. , 1997, Journal of forensic sciences.

[63]  G. J. Srinivasan,et al.  Cranio-facial morphanalysis: a new method for enhancing reliability while identifying skulls by photo superimposition. , 2001, Forensic science international.

[64]  Hélène Coqueugniot,et al.  Facial soft tissue depths in French adults: variability, specificity and estimation. , 2013, Forensic science international.

[65]  S Miyasaka,et al.  Evaluation of anatomical consistency in craniofacial superimposition images. , 1995, Forensic science international.

[66]  Carl N Stephan,et al.  Do resemblance ratings measure the accuracy of facial approximations? , 2002, Journal of forensic sciences.

[67]  R B Dorion Photographic superimposition. , 1983, Journal of forensic sciences.

[68]  K. A. Brown,et al.  The identification of Linda Agostini: the significance of dental evidence in the Albury Pyjama Girl case. , 1982, The American journal of forensic medicine and pathology.

[69]  P. Chandra Sekharan,et al.  Revised Superimposition Technique for Identification of the Individual from the Skull and Photograph, A , 1971 .

[70]  G Quatrehomme,et al.  Facial casting as a method to help identify severely disfigured corpses. , 1996, Journal of forensic sciences.

[71]  Carl N Stephan,et al.  Beyond the Sphere of the English Facial Approximation Literature: Ramifications of German Papers on Western Method Concepts * , 2006, Journal of forensic sciences.

[72]  W A Aulsebrook,et al.  Superimposition and reconstruction in forensic facial identification: a survey. , 1995, Forensic science international.

[73]  P. Claes,et al.  Craniofacial identification: techniques of facial approximation and craniofacial superimposition , 2016 .

[74]  B. P. Gatliff,et al.  Facial sculpture on the skull for identification , 1984, The American journal of forensic medicine and pathology.

[75]  K. Reichs Forensic osteology : advances in the identification of human remains , 1998 .

[76]  C. Susanne Individual age changes of the morphological characteristics , 1977 .

[77]  Hitoshi Biwasaka,et al.  Application of computerised correction method for optical distortion of two-dimensional facial image in superimposition between three-dimensional and two-dimensional facial images. , 2010, Forensic science international.

[78]  T P Sweeney,et al.  Forensic odontology. , 1979, Journal of the Hawaii Dental Association.

[79]  R. Helmer,et al.  Vereinfachte Schädelidentifizierung nach dem Superprojektionsverfahren mit Hilfe einer Video-Anlage , 1977, Zeitschrift für Rechtsmedizin.

[80]  Carl N Stephan,et al.  Facial Soft Tissue Depth Statistics and Enhanced Point Estimators for Craniofacial Identification: The Debut of the Shorth and the 75‐Shormax , 2013, Journal of forensic sciences.

[81]  John G Clement,et al.  Lateral facial soft-tissue prediction model: analysis using Fourier shape descriptors and traditional cephalometric methods. , 2003, American journal of physical anthropology.

[82]  R E Barsley,et al.  In vivo facial tissue depth measurements for children and adults. , 2000, Journal of forensic sciences.

[83]  Paul T. Jayaprakash,et al.  Skull-Photo Superimposition: A Remedy to the Problem of Unidentified Dead in Malaysia , 2010 .

[84]  J J McKenna,et al.  A method of matching skulls with photographic portraits using landmarks and measurements of the dentition. , 1984, Journal of forensic sciences.

[85]  Y Lan Development and Current Status of Skull-Image Superimposition - Methodology and Instrumentation. , 1992, Forensic science review.

[86]  Stephen P Nawrocki,et al.  Variation in midfacial tissue thickness of African-American children. , 2002, Journal of forensic sciences.

[87]  K. Taylor Forensic Art and Illustration , 2000 .

[88]  Robert M. George,et al.  The Lateral Craniographic Method of Facial Reconstruction , 1987 .

[89]  Oscar Cordón,et al.  A cooperative coevolutionary approach dealing with the skull–face overlay uncertainty in forensic identification by craniofacial superimposition , 2012, Soft Comput..

[90]  Oscar Cordón,et al.  Modeling the Skull–Face Overlay Uncertainty Using Fuzzy Sets , 2011, IEEE Transactions on Fuzzy Systems.

[91]  G. D. Dalitz,et al.  Video Superimposition of Skulls and Photographic Portraits—A New Aid to Identification , 1986 .

[92]  D. Ubelaker A History of Smithsonian-FBI Collaboration in Forensic Anthropology, Especially in Regard to Facial Imagery , 2000 .

[93]  Adolf H. Schultz Relation of the external nose to the bony nose and nasal cartilages in whites and negroes , 1918 .

[94]  P R Sutton,et al.  Bizygomatic diameter: the thickness of the soft tissues over the zygions. , 1969, American journal of physical anthropology.

[95]  David Glassman Methods of Superimposition , 2000 .

[96]  R Evenhouse,et al.  Computer-aided forensic facial reconstruction , 1991, Other Conferences.

[97]  Alice M. Brues,et al.  Identification of Skeletal Remains , 1958 .

[98]  Connie L. Parks,et al.  Preliminary assessment of facial soft tissue thickness utilizing three-dimensional computed tomography models of living individuals. , 2014, Forensic science international.

[99]  G M Gordon,et al.  An investigation into the accuracy and reliability of skull-photo superimposition in a South African sample. , 2012, Forensic science international.

[100]  J A Perper,et al.  Face imaging reconstructive morphography. A new method for physiognomic reconstruction. , 1988, The American journal of forensic medicine and pathology.

[101]  E R Dumont,et al.  Mid-facial tissue depths of white children: an aid in facial feature reconstruction. , 1986, Journal of forensic sciences.

[102]  Douglas H. Ubelaker,et al.  Computer-Assisted Photographic Superimposition , 1992 .

[103]  S. Saunders,et al.  Midline facial tissue thicknesses of subadults from a longitudinal radiographic study. , 1999, Journal of forensic sciences.

[104]  C N Stephan,et al.  Building faces from dry skulls: are they recognized above chance rates? , 2001, Journal of forensic sciences.

[105]  Carl N Stephan,et al.  Does sexual dimorphism in facial soft tissue depths justify sex distinction in craniofacial identification? , 2005, Journal of forensic sciences.

[106]  L. S. Lieberman,et al.  In vivo measurements of facial tissue thicknesses in American caucasoid children. , 1985, Journal of forensic sciences.

[107]  R P Helmer,et al.  Identification of the cadaver remains of Josef Mengele. , 1987, Journal of forensic sciences.

[108]  Carl N Stephan,et al.  Facial Soft Tissue Thicknesses in Australian Adult Cadavers * , 2006, Journal of forensic sciences.

[109]  Developments in cranio-facial superimposition for identification. , 1983, The Journal of forensic odonto-stomatology.

[110]  Use of Craniofacial Superimposition in Historic Investigation , 2014, Journal of forensic sciences.