Does the institutional diversity of editorial boards increase journal quality? The case economics field

In academic communication, editors exert a significant influence on a journal’s mission and content. We examined how the composition of editorial board members, in particular diversity in terms of institution, is related to journal quality. Our sample comprised 6916 editors who were affiliated with 246 economics journals. Using Stirling Index of Diversity, we provided a single numeric index (DI) to measure the diversity of institutions which is composed of variety, balance, and disparity. Then we related it to journal quality, as reflected in three widely used indices in economics: the five-year impact factor, the association of business schools’ (ABS) journal quality guide, and the eigenfactors. The results show that academic journals in the field of economics are heavily dominated by US institutions, but in terms of geographic distribution, there are more institutions in Europe than in North America. Surprisingly, we found that the diversity of editorial board members in terms of institution is negatively related to ABS ranking, but unrelated to the five-year impact factor and the eigenfactors. While when we removed the US journals from the sample, there was a significant positive impact between institutional diversity and the five-year impact factor. Our study extends the scarce knowledge on the composition of editorial teams and their relevance to journal quality by study the correlation between the institutional diversity index and three different journal quality indices. The implication of this study is that more effort is needed to increase the diversity in the composition of editorial teams in order to ensure transparency and promote equity.

[1]  Vincent Larivière,et al.  Gender and international diversity improves equity in peer review , 2018, bioRxiv.

[2]  Lucio Barabesi,et al.  Interlocking editorship. A network analysis of the links between economic journals , 2008, Scientometrics.

[3]  Rick Vogel,et al.  Editorial governance and journal impact: a study of management and business journals , 2017, Scientometrics.

[4]  O. C. Herfindahl.  Concentration in the steel industry , 1950 .

[5]  Ann Marie Ryan,et al.  How Are We Doing? An Examination of Gender Representation in Industrial and Organizational (I-O) Psychology , 2018, Industrial and Organizational Psychology.

[6]  Maja Jokić,et al.  Do the international editorial board members of Croatian social sciences and humanities journals contribute to their visibility , 2015 .

[7]  Manuel Goyanes,et al.  Editorial boards in communication sciences journals: Plurality or standardization? , 2020, International Communication Gazette.

[8]  Carmen Robinson,et al.  Practicing what we preach. , 2002, American journal of critical care : an official publication, American Association of Critical-Care Nurses.

[9]  B. Frey,et al.  Do Rankings Reflect Research Quality? , 2008, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[10]  Ismael Rafols,et al.  Indicators of the interdisciplinarity of journals: Diversity, centrality, and citations , 2010, J. Informetrics.

[11]  M. Jones,et al.  Editorial boards of accounting journals: gender diversity and internationalisation , 2017 .

[12]  Jing Chen,et al.  The Impact of Cluster Diversity on Economic Performance in U.S. Metropolitan Statistical Areas , 2020 .

[13]  K. McCann.  The diversity–stability debate , 2000, Nature.

[14]  Ben Wooliscroft,et al.  What does it take to get published in a top marketing journal from Australasia , 2005 .

[15]  Marton Demeter,et al.  Changing Center and Stagnant Periphery in Communication and Media Studies: National Diversity of Major International Journals in the Field of Communication from 2013 to 2017 , 2018 .

[16]  E. Giménez-Toledo,et al.  The Editorial Boards of Spanish Scholarly Journals: What Are They Like? What Should They Be Like? , 2009 .

[17]  Isabel Metz,et al.  Practicing what We Preach , 2012, Management International Review.

[18]  Alan L. Porter,et al.  Science overlay maps: A new tool for research policy and library management , 2009, J. Assoc. Inf. Sci. Technol..

[19]  Mary Stegmaier,et al.  Getting on the Board: The Presence of Women in Political Science Journal Editorial Positions , 2011, PS: Political Science & Politics.

[20]  Daniel A. Levinthal,et al.  ABSORPTIVE CAPACITY: A NEW PERSPECTIVE ON LEARNING AND INNOVATION , 1990 .

[21]  G. Kaufman,et al.  Rankings of Finance Departments by Faculty Representation on Editorial Boards of Professional Journals: A Note , 1984 .

[22]  Loet Leydesdorff,et al.  Interdisciplinarity as Diversity in Citation Patterns among Journals: Rao-Stirling Diversity, Relative Variety, and the Gini coefficient , 2018, J. Informetrics.

[23]  C. Harvey,et al.  Journal rankings and the ABS Journal Quality Guide , 2009 .

[24]  J. P. Forrester,et al.  An Assessment of Public Administration Journals: The Perspective of Editors and Editorial Board Members , 1994 .

[25]  Geoffrey M. Hodgson,et al.  The Editors and Authors of Economics Journals: A Case of Institutional Oligopoly? , 1999 .

[26]  Vincent Larivière,et al.  Author-Reviewer Homophily in Peer Review , 2018 .

[27]  Hee Sun Park,et al.  Where and what do they publish? Editors’ and editorial board members’ affiliated institutions and the citation counts of their endogenous publications in the field of communication , 2019, Scientometrics.

[28]  John Flowerdew,et al.  Attitudes of Journal Editors to Nonnative Speaker Contributions , 2001 .

[29]  A. Stirling.  A general framework for analysing diversity in science, technology and society , 2007, Journal of The Royal Society Interface.

[30]  Thomas E. Nisonger,et al.  The relationship between international editorial board composition and citation measures in political science, business, and genetics journals , 2002, Scientometrics.

[31]  Louis E. Boone,et al.  Rating Marketing Faculties on the Basis of Editorial Review Board Memberships , 1988 .

[32]  Jianping Li,et al.  Journal editorship index for assessing the scholarly impact of academic institutions: An empirical analysis in the field of economics , 2018, J. Informetrics.

[33]  P. Pagel,et al.  Bibliometric analysis of anaesthesia journal editorial board members: correlation between journal impact factor and the median h-index of its board members. , 2011, British journal of anaesthesia.

[34]  E. Lauf,et al.  National diversity of major international journals in the field of communication , 2005 .

[35]  Jean D. Gibbons,et al.  Rankings of Economics Faculties and Representation on Editorial Boards of Top Journals , 1991 .

[36]  Andreas Andrikopoulos,et al.  Editorial board interlocks in financial economics , 2015 .

[37]  N. A. Mazov,et al.  Bibliometric Indicators of Scientific Journals and Editorial Board Members (Based on the Example of Russian Journals on Earth Sciences) , 2018, Scientific and Technical Information Processing.

[38]  Christopher B. Murray,et al.  Structural diversity in binary nanoparticle superlattices , 2006, Nature.

[39]  M. Alvesson,et al.  Habitat and Habitus: Boxed-in versus Box-Breaking Research , 2014 .

[40]  M. Husain,et al.  Neurocomputational mechanisms underlying subjective valuation of effort costs , 2017, PLoS biology.

[41]  Tibor Braun,et al.  Citation patterns of editorial gatekeepers in international chemistry journals , 2005, Scientometrics.

[42]  Cecelia M. Brown.  Communication in the sciences , 2010, Annu. Rev. Inf. Sci. Technol..

[43]  Yvonne Benschop,et al.  Guest Editorial: Unpacking Diversity, Grasping Inequality: Rethinking Difference Through Critical Perspectives , 2010 .

[44]  N. Bontis,et al.  A citation-based ranking of the business ethics scholarly journals , 2009 .

[45]  Gary Richard Schoener,et al.  Practicing What We Preach , 1999 .

[46]  Stuart A. Kauffman,et al.  The origins of order , 1993 .

[47]  Alice H. Eagly,et al.  Women as leaders: Leadership style versus leaders’ values and attitudes , 2013 .

[48]  Bill Harley,et al.  Variety, Novelty, and Perceptions of Scholarship in Research on Management and Organizations: An Appeal for Ambidextrous Scholarship , 2014 .

[49]  Begoña Granadino,et al.  The representation of nationalities on the editorial boards of international journals and the promotion of the scientific output of the same countries , 2010, Scientometrics.

[50]  Pablo E. Allen,et al.  A persistent lack of international representation on editorial boards in environmental biology , 2017, bioRxiv.

[51]  Andrew Stirling,et al.  Social-ecological resilience and socio-technical transitions: critical issues for sustainability governance , 2008 .

[52]  Pier Paolo Saviotti,et al.  Variety and the evolution of refinery processing , 2005 .

[53]  Rebecca Toppe Shortridge,et al.  A pragmatic model to estimate journal quality in accounting , 2009 .

[54]  Robin L. Wakefield.  Networks of accounting research: A citation-based structural and network analysis , 2008 .

[55]  John R. Hollenbeck,et al.  Successful Authors and Effective Reviewers , 2009 .

[56]  Arthur G. Bedeian,et al.  Scientific Achievement and Editorial Board Membership , 2009 .