Structural foundations of optogenetics: Determinants of channelrhodopsin ion selectivity

Significance Channelrhodopsins are membrane proteins that enable cellular regulation of transmembrane ion conductance through light-gated pores; these proteins have found application in optogenetics. This paper tests the hypothesis that selectivity of channelrhodopsins is determined by surface potential of the pore region: Cations are conducted by a negatively charged pore, and chloride ions are conducted by a pore that has neutral and positively charged residues. In confirming this hypothesis and applying the resulting principles, we engineer improved chloride-conducting channels with higher chloride selectivity and conductivity. We also provide insights into the distinct mechanisms underlying inhibition mediated by higher-efficiency chloride channels compared with ion pumps. Finally, we demonstrate initial utility of light-gated microbial opsin-based chloride channels in controlling behavior of freely moving animals. The structure-guided design of chloride-conducting channelrhodopsins has illuminated mechanisms underlying ion selectivity of this remarkable family of light-activated ion channels. The first generation of chloride-conducting channelrhodopsins, guided in part by development of a structure-informed electrostatic model for pore selectivity, included both the introduction of amino acids with positively charged side chains into the ion conduction pathway and the removal of residues hypothesized to support negatively charged binding sites for cations. Engineered channels indeed became chloride selective, reversing near −65 mV and enabling a new kind of optogenetic inhibition; however, these first-generation chloride-conducting channels displayed small photocurrents and were not tested for optogenetic inhibition of behavior. Here we report the validation and further development of the channelrhodopsin pore model via crystal structure-guided engineering of next-generation light-activated chloride channels (iC++) and a bistable variant (SwiChR++) with net photocurrents increased more than 15-fold under physiological conditions, reversal potential further decreased by another ∼15 mV, inhibition of spiking faithfully tracking chloride gradients and intrinsic cell properties, strong expression in vivo, and the initial microbial opsin channel-inhibitor–based control of freely moving behavior. We further show that inhibition by light-gated chloride channels is mediated mainly by shunting effects, which exert optogenetic control much more efficiently than the hyperpolarization induced by light-activated chloride pumps. The design and functional features of these next-generation chloride-conducting channelrhodopsins provide both chronic and acute timescale tools for reversible optogenetic inhibition, confirm fundamental predictions of the ion selectivity model, and further elucidate electrostatic and steric structure–function relationships of the light-gated pore.