a critical

This paper proposes a self-contained reference for both policy makers and scholars who want to address the problem of efficiency and effectiveness of Local Public Transport (LPT) in a sound empirical way. Framing economic efficiency studies into a transport planning perspective, it offers a critical discussion of the existing empirical studies, relating them to the main methodological approaches used. The connection between such perspectives and Operations Research studies dealing with scheduling and tactical design of public transport services is also developed. The comprehensive classification of selected relevant dimensions of the empirical literature, namely inputs, outputs, kind of data analyzed, methods adopted and policy relevant questions addressed, and the systematic investigation of their interrelationships allows us to summarize the existing literature and to propose desirable developments and extensions for future studies in the field.

[1]  Paul Schonfeld,et al.  Schedule Coordination in a Multiple Hub Transit Network , 2005 .

[2]  Avishai Ceder,et al.  Urban Transit Scheduling: Framework, Review and Examples , 2002 .

[3]  Staffan Hultén,et al.  The Effects of Competition in Swedish Local Bus Services , 1998 .

[4]  Massimiliano Piacenza,et al.  Regulatory and environmental effects on public transit efficiency: a mixed DEA-SFA approach , 2007 .

[5]  Anna Matas,et al.  Technical characteristics and efficiency of urban bus companies: The case of Spain , 1998 .

[6]  Luca D’Acierno,et al.  The transit network design problem with elastic demand and internalisation of external costs: An application to rail frequency optimisation , 2011 .

[7]  A. U.S.,et al.  Measuring the efficiency of decision making units , 2003 .

[8]  Matthew G. Karlaftis,et al.  Investigating transit production and performance: a programming approach , 2003 .

[9]  Kofi Obeng,et al.  SUBSIDIES AND INEFFICIENCY: STOCHASTIC FRONTIER APPROACH , 1997 .

[10]  J Odeck,et al.  OWNERSHIP, SCALE EFFECTS AND EFFICIENCY OF NORWEGIAN BUS OPERATORS: EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE , 2003 .

[11]  Hollis B. Chenery,et al.  Engineering Production Functions , 1949 .

[12]  Dušan Teodorović,et al.  Performance evaluation of bus routes: A provider and passenger perspective , 2007 .

[13]  Lawrence W. Lan,et al.  A joint measurement of efficiency and effectiveness for non-storable commodities: Integrated data envelopment analysis approaches , 2010, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[14]  Dongjoo Park,et al.  Efficiency analysis of Seoul’s urban bus agencies considering emissions , 2011 .

[15]  M. Kim,et al.  TOTAL FACTOR PRODUCTIVITY IN BUS TRANSPORT , 1985 .

[16]  Graziella Fornengo,et al.  The impact of ownership on the cost of bus service provision: an example from Italy , 2009 .

[17]  Ardeshir J. Dalal,et al.  ESTIMATION OF THE ELASTICITIES OF FACTOR SUBSTITUTION IN URBAN BUS TRANSPORTATION: A COST FUNCTION APPROACH* , 1981 .

[18]  A. Novaes,et al.  RAPID-TRANSIT EFFICIENCY ANALYSIS WITH THE ASSURANCE-REGION DEA METHOD , 2001 .

[19]  David A. Hensher,et al.  The Relationship Between Bus Contract Costs, User Perceived Service Quality and Performance Assessment , 2014 .

[20]  Ginés de Rus,et al.  PRIVATISATION OF URBAN BUS SERVICES IN SPAIN. , 1997 .

[21]  Pål Andreas Pedersen,et al.  Estimating the inefficiency in the Norwegian bus industry from stochastic cost frontier models , 1997 .

[22]  Luigi dell’Olio,et al.  Bus Size and Headways Optimization Model Considering Elastic Demand , 2014 .

[23]  Lawrence W. Lan,et al.  Measuring transport efficiency with adjustment of accidents: case of Taipei bus transit , 2010 .

[24]  Philip A. Viton,et al.  THE QUESTION OF EFFICIENCY IN URBAN BUS TRANSPORTATION , 1986 .

[25]  Pierre Wunsch,et al.  Cost and Productivity of Major Urban Transit Systems in Europe , 1996 .

[26]  Henry-Jean Gathon Indicators Of Partial Productivity And Technical Efficiency In The European Urban Transit Sector , 1989 .

[27]  Ming-Miin Yu,et al.  The joint determination of efficiency in multi-mode bus transit , 2004 .

[28]  Jean-Marc Rousseau,et al.  Chapter 5 Models in urban and air transportation , 1994, Operations research and the public sector.

[29]  Hiroyuki Iseki,et al.  Effects of contracting on cost efficiency in US fixed-route bus transit service , 2010 .

[30]  Antonio Mauttone,et al.  A multi-objective metaheuristic approach for the Transit Network Design Problem , 2009, Public Transp..

[31]  Avishai Ceder,et al.  Public Transit Planning and Operation , 2007 .

[32]  Kofi Obeng,et al.  Indirect production function and the output effect of public transit subsidies , 2011 .

[33]  Jonathan Cowie,et al.  Acquisition, efficiency and scale economies: An analysis of the British bus industry , 2002 .

[34]  Kenneth Button,et al.  Economic efficiency gains from urban public transport regulatory reform: Two case studies of changes in Europe , 1999 .

[35]  C. Pestana Barros Estimating the efficiency of the Portuguese bus industry , 2005 .

[36]  Abraham Charnes,et al.  Measuring the efficiency of decision making units , 1978 .

[37]  Chakkaphant Nanutsathit Economies of Scale In Bus Transport , 1980 .

[38]  K. Obeng Bus transit technical efficiency using latent class stochastic indirect production frontier , 2013 .

[39]  James Odeck,et al.  The effect of mergers on efficiency and productivity of public transport services , 2008 .

[40]  C. Lovell,et al.  Stochastic Frontier Analysis: Frontmatter , 2000 .

[41]  Jonathan Cowie,et al.  Organisation form, scale effects and efficiency in the British bus industry , 1999 .

[42]  W. Y. Szeto,et al.  Review on Urban Transportation Network Design Problems , 2013 .

[43]  Carlo Scarpa,et al.  Do competition and ownership matter? Evidence from local public transport in Europe , 2010 .

[44]  D J Harmatuck Cost Functions and Efficiency Estimates of Midwest Bus Transit Systems , 2005 .

[45]  Cinzia Daraio,et al.  Evaluating the effectiveness of public transport operations: A critical review and some policy indicators , 2014 .

[46]  Yaser E. Hawas,et al.  Evaluating and Enhancing the Operational Performance of Public Bus Systems Using GIS-based Data Envelopment Analysis , 2012 .

[47]  Yasmin A. Rios-Solis,et al.  Synchronization of bus timetabling , 2012 .

[48]  Yves Croissant,et al.  Reducing urban public transport costs by tendering lots: a panel data estimation , 2013 .

[49]  Fang Zhao,et al.  Optimization of transit route network, vehicle headways and timetables for large-scale transit networks , 2008, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[50]  M. Farsi,et al.  Cost Efficiency in Regional Bus Companies: An Application of Alternative Stochastic Frontier Models , 2006 .

[51]  Yuval Hadas,et al.  Public-transit frequency setting using minimum-cost approach with stochastic demand and travel time , 2012 .

[52]  Yousef Shafahi,et al.  A practical model for transfer optimization in a transit network: Model formulations and solutions , 2010 .

[53]  Yanhong Li,et al.  Expected value model for optimizing the multiple bus headways , 2013, Appl. Math. Comput..

[54]  Christian von Hirschhausen,et al.  A Nonparametric Efficiency Analysis of German Public Transport Companies , 2010 .

[55]  James L. Perry,et al.  COMPARATIVE PERFORMANCE IN URBAN BUS TRANSIT: ASSESSING PRIVATIZATION STRATEGIES , 1986 .

[56]  Léopold Simar,et al.  Advanced Robust and Nonparametric Methods in Efficiency Analysis: Methodology and Applications , 2007 .

[57]  W. Y. Szeto,et al.  Transit route and frequency design: Bi-level modeling and hybrid artificial bee colony algorithm approach , 2014 .

[58]  Kofi Obeng,et al.  Sources of productivity change: a Malmquist total factor productivity approach , 2005 .

[59]  Subal C. Kumbhakar,et al.  Productivity growth in passenger-bus transportation: A heteroskedastic error component model with unbalanced panel data , 1996 .

[60]  Gisle Solvoll,et al.  THE COSTS OF BUS OPERATIONS IN NORWAY. , 1995 .

[61]  Jin-Kao Hao,et al.  Transit Network Re-timetabling and Vehicle Scheduling , 2008, MCO.

[62]  Ludo Waltman,et al.  A smart local moving algorithm for large-scale modularity-based community detection , 2013, The European Physical Journal B.

[63]  Philip A. Viton,et al.  Changes in multi-mode bus transit efficiency, 1988–1992 , 1998 .

[64]  Magnus Söderberg,et al.  A Broad Performance Benchmark Based on Citizens’ Preferences: The Case of Swedish Public Transportation , 2009 .

[65]  Isabel María García Sánchez Technical and Scale Efficiency in Spanish Urban Transport: Estimating with Data Envelopment Analysis , 2009, Adv. Oper. Res..

[66]  Oswaldo Lima Neto,et al.  Efficiency Analysis of Public Transport Systems: Lessons for Institutional Planning , 2008 .

[67]  Johan Holmgren,et al.  The efficiency of public transport operations - An evaluation using stochastic frontier analysis , 2013 .

[68]  Aparajita Mukherjee,et al.  Utilization of passenger transport subsidy in Kolkata: A case study of Calcutta State Transport Corporation , 2013 .

[69]  Matthew G. Karlaftis,et al.  A DEA approach for evaluating the efficiency and effectiveness of urban transit systems , 2004, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[70]  J. Nolan,et al.  Identifying and measuring public policy goals: ISTEA and the US bus transit industry , 2002 .

[71]  Matthew G. Karlaftis,et al.  Subsidy and public transit performance: A factor analytic approach , 1997 .

[72]  Piet Rietveld,et al.  Does competitive tendering improve customer satisfaction with public transport? A case study for the Netherlands , 2013 .

[73]  Boulevard Lavoisier Transit Network Timetabling and Vehicle Assignment for Regulating Authorities , 2010 .

[74]  L. R. Christensen,et al.  Economies of Density versus Economies of Scale: Why Trunk and Local Service Airline Costs Differ , 1984 .

[75]  Léopold Simar,et al.  Explaining inefficiency in nonparametric production models: the state of the art , 2014, Ann. Oper. Res..

[76]  W. Y. Szeto,et al.  A simultaneous bus route design and frequency setting problem for Tin Shui Wai, Hong Kong , 2011, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[77]  Fabian Cevallos,et al.  Minimizing Transfer Times in Public Transit Network with Genetic Algorithm , 2006 .

[78]  James Nolan,et al.  DETERMINANTS OF PRODUCTIVE EFFICIENCY IN URBAN TRANSIT , 1996 .

[79]  Matthew G. Karlaftis,et al.  The Effect of Privatization on Public Transit Costs , 1999 .

[80]  Ming-Miin Yu,et al.  Measuring the Cost Effectiveness of Multimode Bus Transit in the Presence of Accident Risks , 2006 .

[81]  Léopold Simar,et al.  How to measure the impact of environmental factors in a nonparametric production model , 2012, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[82]  Jin-Kao Hao,et al.  Transit network design and scheduling: A global review , 2008 .

[83]  Ryan Yeung,et al.  What is paratransit worth , 2010 .

[84]  Brian W. Sloboda,et al.  Performance Measurement of U.S. Transit Systems, 1982-2001 , 2008 .

[85]  Matthew G. Karlaftis,et al.  Estimating DEA confidence intervals with statistical panel data analysis , 2012 .

[86]  Massimiliano Piacenza,et al.  Regulatory Contracts and Cost Efficiency: Stochastic Frontier Evidence from the Italian Local Public Transport , 2006 .

[87]  Matthew G. Karlaftis,et al.  Ownership and competition in European transit: assessing efficiency , 2010 .

[88]  Kristiaan Kerstens,et al.  Decomposing Technical Efficiency and Effectiveness of French Urban Transport , 1999 .

[89]  Hani S. Mahmassani,et al.  Optimal Allocation of Service Frequencies over Transit Network Routes and Time Periods , 2013 .

[90]  Georgios K. D. Saharidis,et al.  Minimizing waiting times at transitional nodes for public bus transportation in Greece , 2014, Oper. Res..

[91]  Anita Schöbel,et al.  Integrating line planning, timetabling, and vehicle scheduling: a customer-oriented heuristic , 2009, Public Transp..

[92]  Leonard Merewitz On measuring the efficiency of public enterprises: Bus operating companies in the San Francisco Bay area , 1977 .

[93]  Maria Boile,et al.  ESTIMATING TECHNICAL AND SCALE INEFFICIENCIES OF PUBLIC TRANSIT SYSTEMS , 2001 .

[94]  Marc Ivaldi,et al.  Incentive Regulatory Policies: The Case of Public Transit Systems in France , 2002 .

[95]  B. Starr McMullen,et al.  Accounting for emissions in the measurement of transit agency efficiency: A directional distance function approach , 2007 .

[96]  David R. Miller Differences among Cities, Differences among Firms, and Costs of Urban Bus Transport , 1970 .

[97]  Daniel Albalate,et al.  What shapes local public transportation in Europe? Economics, Mobility, Institutions, and Geography , 2010 .

[98]  Vicente Pina,et al.  Analysis of the efficiency of local government services delivery. An application to urban public transport , 2001 .

[99]  James Odeck,et al.  The performance of subsidized urban and rural public bus operators: Empirical evidence from Norway , 2004 .

[100]  Luigi dell’Olio,et al.  Optimizing bus-size and headway in transit networks , 2012 .

[101]  Kuo-Ping Chang,et al.  The relative efficiency of public versus private municipal bus firms: An application of data envelopment analysis , 1992 .

[102]  Chungwon Lee,et al.  Efficiency analysis on bus companies in Seoul city using a network DEA model , 2013 .

[103]  Massimo Filippini,et al.  Unobserved Heterogeneity and Efficiency Measurement in Public Transport , 2012 .

[104]  K. Obeng,et al.  RE-EXAMINATION OF INEFFICIENCIES IN URBAN TRANSIT SYSTEMS: A STOCHASTIC FRONTIER APPROACH , 1995 .

[105]  Sonali Tandon,et al.  Improving the Efficiency of Metropolitan Area Transit by Joint DEA of Its Multiple Providers , 2009 .

[106]  C. Cambini,et al.  Restructuring Public Transit Systems: Evidence on Cost Properties from Medium and Large-Sized Companies , 2007 .

[107]  Anne Yvrande-Billon,et al.  Ownership, Contractual Practices and Technical Efficiency: The Case of Urban Public Transport in France , 2007 .

[108]  Giuseppe Bruno,et al.  Models for the schedule optimization problem at a public transit terminal , 2009, OR Spectr..

[109]  Matthew G. Karlaftis,et al.  Efficiency Measurement in Public Transport: Are Findings Specification Sensitive? , 2012 .

[110]  K. Kerstens Technical efficiency measurement and explanation of French urban transit companies , 1996 .

[111]  James Odeck,et al.  Congestion, ownership, region of operation, and scale: Their impact on bus operator performance in Norway , 2006 .

[112]  Pascal Forget,et al.  Efficiency evaluation in public road transport: a stochastic frontier analysis , 2013 .

[113]  Zhiyuan Liu,et al.  Robust optimization model of bus transit network design with stochastic travel time , 2013 .

[114]  Dag Morten Dalen,et al.  Yardsticks on the road: Regulatory contracts and cost efficiency in the Norwegian bus industry , 2003 .

[115]  Lawrence W. Lan,et al.  Route-based data envelopment analysis models , 2012 .

[116]  Matthias Walter Some Determinants of Cost Efficiency in German Public Transport , 2011 .

[117]  Boujelbene Younes,et al.  Public Road Transport Efficiency: A Stochastic Frontier Analysis , 2013 .

[118]  José M. P. Paixão,et al.  Vehicle Scheduling for Public Mass Transit — An Overview , 1995 .

[119]  Philip A. Viton,et al.  TECHNICAL EFFICIENCY IN MULTI-MODE BUS TRANSIT: A PRODUCTION FRONTIER ANALYSIS , 1997 .

[120]  Ming-Miin Yu,et al.  Measuring the efficiency and return to scale status of multi-mode bus transit – evidence from Taiwan's bus system , 2008 .

[121]  Bruno De Borger Cost and Productivity in Regional Bus Transportation: The Belgian Case , 1984 .

[122]  Seung-Young Kho,et al.  Analysis of the efficiency of Seoul Arterial Bus routes and its determinant factors , 2011 .

[123]  Massimo Filippini,et al.  INEFFICIENCY IN A REGULATED INDUSTRY , 1992 .

[124]  Martin Williams FIRM SIZE AND OPERATING COSTS IN URBAN BUS TRANSPORTATION , 1979 .

[125]  Yoshinori Takahashi,et al.  Ten years after bus deregulation in Japan: An analysis of institutional changes and cost efficiency , 2013 .

[126]  Kumares C. Sinha,et al.  THE STRUCTURE OF PUBLIC TRANSIT COSTS IN THE PRESENCE OF MULTIPLE SERIAL CORRELATION , 1999 .

[127]  Peter Nijkamp,et al.  Efficiency of urban public transit: A meta analysis , 2005 .

[128]  Walter Ukovich,et al.  Scheduling multimodal transportation systems , 2004, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[129]  Luigi dell’Olio,et al.  Design of a Tabu Search Algorithm for Assigning Optimal Bus Sizes and Frequencies in Urban Transport Services , 2012 .

[130]  P. Viton A TRANSLOG COST FUNCTION FOR URBAN BUS TRANSIT , 1981 .

[131]  Carlos Pestana Barros,et al.  Productivity changes in Portuguese bus companies , 2010 .

[132]  Ratnesh R. Saxena,et al.  Measuring efficiencies in Indian public road transit: a data envelopment analysis approach , 2010 .

[133]  Héctor Martínez,et al.  Frequency optimization in public transportation systems: Formulation and metaheuristic approach , 2014, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[134]  Wang Chiang,et al.  Cost structure and technological change of local public transport: the Kaohsiung City Bus case , 2005 .

[135]  Ning Zhang,et al.  Environmental efficiency analysis of transportation system in China:A non-radial DEA approach , 2013 .

[136]  Kristiaan Kerstens,et al.  Public transit performance: What does one learn from frontier studies? , 2002 .

[137]  Attah K. Boame THE TECHNICAL EFFICIENCY OF CANADIAN URBAN TRANSIT SYSTEMS , 2004 .

[138]  Torben Holvad,et al.  Measuring inefficiency in the Norwegian bus industry using multi-directional efficiency analysis , 2004 .

[139]  Dimitrios A Tsamboulas,et al.  Assessing Performance under Regulatory Evolution: A European Transit System Perspective , 2006 .

[140]  P. W. Wilson,et al.  Estimation and inference in two-stage, semi-parametric models of production processes , 2007 .

[141]  Elisabetta Ottoz,et al.  Diversification strategies and scope economies: evidence from a sample of Italian regional bus transport providers , 2008 .

[142]  Bin Yu,et al.  Genetic Algorithm for Bus Frequency Optimization , 2010 .

[143]  Massimo Filippini,et al.  Is Scale and Cost Inefficiency in the Swiss Bus Industry a Regulatory Problem? Evidence from a Frontier Cost Approach , 1994 .

[144]  Wei Zhou,et al.  Scheduling Combination and Headway Optimization of Bus Rapid Transit , 2008 .

[145]  Matthew G. Karlaftis,et al.  COST STRUCTURES OF PUBLIC TRANSIT SYSTEMS: A PANEL DATA ANALYSIS , 2002 .

[146]  David A. Hensher,et al.  Productivity measurement in the urban bus sector , 1995 .

[147]  Massimo Filippini,et al.  Economies of scale and scope in local public transportation , 2007 .

[148]  Ming-Miin Yu,et al.  Measuring the performance of multimode bus transit: A mixed structure network DEA model , 2009 .

[149]  Jennifer Duthie,et al.  Incorporating equity into the transit frequency-setting problem , 2012 .

[150]  Matthew G. Karlaftis,et al.  Transit Route Network Design Problem: Review , 2009 .

[151]  Bruce W. Lamar,et al.  MEASURING TRANSIT PERFORMANCE USING DATA ENVELOPMENT ANALYSIS , 1992 .

[152]  Giovanni Fraquelli,et al.  Regulating Public Transit Networks: How Do Urban-Intercity Diversification and Speed-Up Measures Affect Firms' Cost Performance? , 2004 .

[153]  Jiazhen Huo,et al.  Undesirable factors in integer-valued DEA: Evaluating the operational efficiencies of city bus systems considering safety records , 2012, Decis. Support Syst..

[154]  Marc Ivaldi,et al.  Stochastic Frontiers and Asymmetric Information Models , 2002 .

[155]  J S Wabe,et al.  THE SHORT AND LONG-RUN COST OF BUS TRANSPORT IN URBAN AREAS , 1975 .

[156]  Kenichi Shoji,et al.  The effect of governmental subsidies and the contractual model on the publicly-owned bus sector in Japan , 2010 .

[157]  Kristiaan Kerstens,et al.  Transit Costs and Cost Efficiency: Bootstrapping Non-Parametric Frontiers , 2008 .

[158]  M. Karlaftis,et al.  OPERATING SUBSIDIES AND PERFORMANCE IN PUBLIC TRANSIT: AN EMPIRICAL STUDY , 1998 .

[159]  Nils Fearnley,et al.  Norwegian experiences with tendered buss services , 2006 .

[160]  Ming-Miin Yu,et al.  Productivity Change and the Effects of the Enhancement of the Mass Transportation Programme on the Bus Transit System in Taiwan , 2008 .

[161]  Shou-Ren Hu,et al.  Optimizing Headways for Mass Rapid Transit Services , 2014 .

[162]  Johan Holmgren,et al.  Putting our money to good use: Can we attract more passengers without increasing subsidies? , 2010 .

[163]  Léopold Simar,et al.  Directional distances and their robust versions: Computational and testing issues , 2013, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[164]  Lourdes Torres,et al.  Public–private efficiency in the delivery of services of general economic interest: The case of urban transport , 2006 .

[165]  Steven I-Jy Chien,et al.  Joint Optimization of Bus Size, Headway, and Slack Time for Efficient Timed Transfer , 2011 .

[166]  David A. Hensher,et al.  Productive efficiency and ownership of urban bus services , 1987 .

[167]  James Odeck,et al.  Evaluating efficiency in the Norwegian bus industry using data envelopment analysis , 2001 .

[168]  Baozhen Yao,et al.  Parallel genetic algorithm in bus route headway optimization , 2011, Appl. Soft Comput..

[169]  Allan Larsen,et al.  The Simultaneous Vehicle Scheduling and Passenger Service Problem , 2013, Transp. Sci..

[170]  G. Battese,et al.  A model for technical inefficiency effects in a stochastic frontier production function for panel data , 1995 .

[171]  M. Filippini,et al.  The influence of ownership on the cost of bus service provision in Switzerland - an empirical illustration , 2003 .

[172]  A. Zellner An Efficient Method of Estimating Seemingly Unrelated Regressions and Tests for Aggregation Bias , 1962 .

[173]  James Nolan,et al.  Measuring efficiency in the public sector using nonparametric frontier estimators: a study of transit agencies in the USA , 2001 .

[174]  Kofi Obeng,et al.  Total factor productivity decomposition, input price inefficiencies, and public transit systems , 2002 .

[175]  Andres Monzon,et al.  Analysis of the Technical Efficiency of Urban Bus Services in Spain Based on SBM Models , 2012 .

[176]  Christian Liebchen,et al.  Periodic Timetable Optimization in Public Transport , 2006, OR.

[177]  M. Diana,et al.  Measuring the satisfaction of multimodal travelers for local transit services in different urban contexts , 2012 .

[178]  Kofi Obeng,et al.  TYPE OF MANAGEMENT AND SUBSIDY-INDUCED ALLOCATIVE DISTORTIONS IN URBAN TRANSIT FIRMS: A TIME-SERIES APPROACH , 1997 .