Superiority of Dobutamine over Dopamine for Augmentation of Cardiac Output in Patients with Chronic Low Output Cardiac Failure

Dobutamine is a newly developed catecholamine reported to have minimal direct vascular effects relative to its inotropic activity and to have less chronotropic and arrhythmogenic properties than other catecholamines used in the treatment of low output states. In this study, the acute hemodynamic effects of dobutamine were compared to those of dopamine in 13 patients with chronic low output cardiac failure. At dosages adjusted to achieve similar increments in cardiac output, dobutamine reduced left yen tricular filling pressure (LVFP) from 25 ± 2 mm Hg (SEM) to 17 ± 2 mm Hg, while dopamine increased LVFP to 30 ± 3 mm Hg and in six patients caused arterial 02 saturation to fall below 90%. This poor response to dopamine was probably the result of its vasoconstrictive effects and illustrates the potential advantages of using a cardioselective agent such as dobutamine when the desired goal of therapy is to improve ventricular function by direct inotropic stimulation.