Interpreting Ecological Diversity Indices Applied to Terminal Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism Data: Insights from Simulated Microbial Communities

ABSTRACT Ecological diversity indices are frequently applied to molecular profiling methods, such as terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism (T-RFLP), in order to compare diversity among microbial communities. We performed simulations to determine whether diversity indices calculated from T-RFLP profiles could reflect the true diversity of the underlying communities despite potential analytical artifacts. These include multiple taxa generating the same terminal restriction fragment (TRF) and rare TRFs being excluded by a relative abundance (fluorescence) threshold. True community diversity was simulated using the lognormal species abundance distribution. Simulated T-RFLP profiles were generated by assigning each species a TRF size based on an empirical or modeled TRF size distribution. With a typical threshold (1%), the only consistently useful relationship was between Smith and Wilson evenness applied to T-RFLP data (TRF-Evar) and true Shannon diversity (H′), with correlations between 0.71 and 0.81. TRF-H′ and true H′ were well correlated in the simulations using the lowest number of species, but this correlation declined substantially in simulations using greater numbers of species, to the point where TRF-H′ cannot be considered a useful statistic. The relationships between TRF diversity indices and true indices were sensitive to the relative abundance threshold, with greatly improved correlations observed using a 0.1% threshold, which was investigated for comparative purposes but is not possible to consistently achieve with current technology. In general, the use of diversity indices on T-RFLP data provides inaccurate estimates of true diversity in microbial communities (with the possible exception of TRF-Evar). We suggest that, where significant differences in T-RFLP diversity indices were found in previous work, these should be reinterpreted as a reflection of differences in community composition rather than a true difference in community diversity.

[1]  Benjamin Smith,et al.  A consumer's guide to evenness indices , 1996 .

[2]  K. Walsh,et al.  Using ecological diversity measures with bacterial communities. , 2003, FEMS microbiology ecology.

[3]  E. Paul,et al.  Terminal Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism Data Analysis for Quantitative Comparison of Microbial Communities , 2003, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[4]  Lawrence O. Ticknor,et al.  Empirical and Theoretical Bacterial Diversity in Four Arizona Soils , 2002, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[5]  A. Kent,et al.  Microbial communities and their interactions in soil and rhizosphere ecosystems. , 2002, Annual review of microbiology.

[6]  Josh D. Neufeld,et al.  Unexpectedly High Bacterial Diversity in Arctic Tundra Relative to Boreal Forest Soils, Revealed by Serial Analysis of Ribosomal Sequence Tags , 2005, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[7]  Thomas P. Curtis,et al.  Estimating prokaryotic diversity and its limits , 2002, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[8]  C. Moyer,et al.  Fidelity of Select Restriction Endonucleases in Determining Microbial Diversity by Terminal-Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism , 2003, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[9]  C. Kaplan,et al.  Variation between observed and true Terminal Restriction Fragment length is dependent on true TRF length and purine content. , 2003, Journal of microbiological methods.

[10]  Lionel Ranjard,et al.  Sampling strategy in molecular microbial ecology: influence of soil sample size on DNA fingerprinting analysis of fungal and bacterial communities. , 2003, Environmental microbiology.

[11]  J. Schimel,et al.  Comparison of subsurface and surface soil bacterial communities in california grassland as assessed by terminal restriction fragment length polymorphisms of PCR-amplified 16S rRNA genes , 2003, Microbial Ecology.

[12]  C. Blackwood,et al.  Evaluating the physical capture method of terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism for comparison of soil microbial communities , 2007 .

[13]  F. Gillet,et al.  Statistical analysis of denaturing gel electrophoresis (DGE) fingerprinting patterns. , 2002, Environmental microbiology.

[14]  F. W. Preston.  The Commonness, And Rarity, of Species , 1948 .

[15]  Peter Ricke,et al.  Application of a Newly Developed ARB Software-Integrated Tool for In Silico Terminal Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism Analysis Reveals the Dominance of a Novel pmoA Cluster in a Forest Soil , 2005, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[16]  P. Sassone-Corsi,et al.  Computational Improvements Reveal Great Bacterial Diversity and High Metal Toxicity in Soil , 2022 .

[17]  Lawrence O. Ticknor,et al.  Phylogenetic Specificity and Reproducibility and New Method for Analysis of Terminal Restriction Fragment Profiles of 16S rRNA Genes from Bacterial Communities , 2001, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[18]  M. Roberts,et al.  Physiological and molecular characterisation of microbial communities associated with different water-stable aggregate size classes , 2005 .

[19]  N. Fierer,et al.  Influence of Drying–Rewetting Frequency on Soil Bacterial Community Structure , 2002, Microbial Ecology.

[20]  Yaniv Bernstein,et al.  New Threshold and Confidence Estimates for Terminal Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism Analysis of Complex Bacterial Communities , 2006, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[21]  L. Jost.  Entropy and diversity , 2006 .

[22]  A. Magurran,et al.  Measuring Biological Diversity , 2004 .

[23]  A. Solow,et al.  Measuring biological diversity , 2006, Environmental and Ecological Statistics.

[24]  R. B. Jackson,et al.  The diversity and biogeography of soil bacterial communities. , 2006, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[25]  Robert K. Colwell,et al.  Quantifying biodiversity: procedures and pitfalls in the measurement and comparison of species richness , 2001 .

[26]  V. Torsvik,et al.  High diversity in DNA of soil bacteria , 1990, Applied and environmental microbiology.

[27]  G. Muyzer,et al.  Optimization of Terminal-Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism Analysis for Complex Marine Bacterioplankton Communities and Comparison with Denaturing Gradient Gel Electrophoresis , 1999, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[28]  S. Zechmeister-Boltenstern,et al.  Comparison of Diversities and Compositions of Bacterial Populations Inhabiting Natural Forest Soils , 2004, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[29]  R. Conrad,et al.  Impact of flooding on soil bacterial communities associated with poplar (Populus sp.) trees. , 2005, FEMS microbiology ecology.

[30]  D. Dykhuizen.  Santa Rosalia revisited: Why are there so many species of bacteria? , 2004, Antonie van Leeuwenhoek.

[31]  J. P. Grime,et al.  Biodiversity and Ecosystem Functioning: Current Knowledge and Future Challenges , 2001, Science.

[32]  T. Marsh,et al.  Section 3 update: The Analysis of Microbial Communities with Terminal Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism (T-RFLP) , 2004 .

[33]  K. Schleifer,et al.  ARB: a software environment for sequence data. , 2004, Nucleic acids research.

[34]  C. Kuske,et al.  Assessment of Microbial Diversity in Four Southwestern United States Soils by 16S rRNA Gene Terminal Restriction Fragment Analysis , 2000, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[35]  Jérôme Harmand,et al.  Denaturing gradient electrophoresis (DGE) and single-strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) molecular fingerprintings revisited by simulation and used as a tool to measure microbial diversity. , 2006, Environmental microbiology.

[36]  J. Kelly,et al.  Elevated Atmospheric CO2 Alters Soil Microbial Communities Associated with Trembling Aspen (Populus tremuloides) Roots , 2005, Microbial Ecology.

[37]  Martin Hartmann,et al.  Community Structure Analyses Are More Sensitive to Differences in Soil Bacterial Communities than Anonymous Diversity Indices , 2006, Applied and Environmental Microbiology.

[38]  C. Pedrós-Alió,et al.  Marine microbial diversity: can it be determined? , 2006, Trends in microbiology.

[39]  E. Angert,et al.  Assessment of biases associated with profiling simple, model communities using terminal-restriction fragment length polymorphism-based analyses. , 2006, Journal of microbiological methods.

[40]  B. Schmid,et al.  Influence of plant diversity and elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide levels on belowground bacterial diversity , 2006, BMC Microbiology.