Evaluation of Specific Absorption Rate as a Dosimetric Quantity for Electromagnetic Fields Bioeffects

Purpose To evaluate SAR as a dosimetric quantity for EMF bioeffects, and identify ways for increasing the precision in EMF dosimetry and bioactivity assessment. Methods We discuss the interaction of man-made electromagnetic waves with biological matter and calculate the energy transferred to a single free ion within a cell. We analyze the physics and biology of SAR and evaluate the methods of its estimation. We discuss the experimentally observed non-linearity between electromagnetic exposure and biological effect. Results We find that: a) The energy absorbed by living matter during exposure to environmentally accounted EMFs is normally well below the thermal level. b) All existing methods for SAR estimation, especially those based upon tissue conductivity and internal electric field, have serious deficiencies. c) The only method to estimate SAR without large error is by measuring temperature increases within biological tissue, which normally are negligible for environmental EMF intensities, and thus cannot be measured. Conclusions SAR actually refers to thermal effects, while the vast majority of the recorded biological effects from man-made non-ionizing environmental radiation are non-thermal. Even if SAR could be accurately estimated for a whole tissue, organ, or body, the biological/health effect is determined by tiny amounts of energy/power absorbed by specific biomolecules, which cannot be calculated. Moreover, it depends upon field parameters not taken into account in SAR calculation. Thus, SAR should not be used as the primary dosimetric quantity, but used only as a complementary measure, always reporting the estimating method and the corresponding error. Radiation/field intensity along with additional physical parameters (such as frequency, modulation etc) which can be directly and in any case more accurately measured on the surface of biological tissues, should constitute the primary measure for EMF exposures, in spite of similar uncertainty to predict the biological effect due to non-linearity.

[1]  V. Lednev,et al.  Possible mechanism for the influence of weak magnetic fields on biological systems. , 1991, Bioelectromagnetics.

[2]  H. Lai,et al.  Acute low-intensity microwave exposure increases DNA single-strand breaks in rat brain cells. , 1995, Bioelectromagnetics.

[3]  Dimitris J. Panagopoulos,et al.  Mechanism for action of electromagnetic fields on cells. , 2002, Biochemical and biophysical research communications.

[4]  Ferdinando Bersani,et al.  Transient DNA damage induced by high-frequency electromagnetic fields (GSM 1.8 GHz) in the human trophoblast HTR-8/SVneo cell line evaluated with the alkaline comet assay. , 2010, Mutation research.

[5]  O. Fujiwara,et al.  FDTD calculation of whole-body average SAR in adult and child models for frequencies from 30 MHz to 3 GHz , 2006, Physics in medicine and biology.

[6]  Rianne Stam,et al.  Electromagnetic fields and the blood–brain barrier , 2010, Brain Research Reviews.

[7]  J. Herbertz.  Comment on the ICNIRP guidelines for limiting exposure to time-varying electric, magnetic, and electromagnetic fields (up to 300 GHz) , 1998, Health physics.

[8]  R. L. Carpenter,et al.  Evidence For Nonthermal Effects of Microwave Radiation: Abnormal Development of Irradiated Insect Pupae , 1971 .

[9]  Lennart Hardell,et al.  Cell phones and brain tumors: a review including the long-term epidemiologic data. , 2009, Surgical neurology.

[10]  Ashok Agarwal,et al.  Effects of radiofrequency electromagnetic waves (RF-EMW) from cellular phones on human ejaculated semen: an in vitro pilot study. , 2009, Fertility and sterility.

[11]  R. Saunders,et al.  In vitro and in vivo genotoxicity of radiofrequency fields. , 2010, Mutation research.

[12]  Lars Malmgren,et al.  Microwaves from GSM Mobile Telephones Affect 53BP1 and γ-H2AX Foci in Human Lymphocytes from Hypersensitive and Healthy Persons , 2005, Environmental health perspectives.

[13]  Bruce V. King,et al.  Mobile Phone Radiation Induces Reactive Oxygen Species Production and DNA Damage in Human Spermatozoa In Vitro , 2009, PloS one.

[14]  W. R. Adey,et al.  Sensitivity of calcium binding in cerebral tissue to weak environmental electric fields oscillating at low frequency. , 1976, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[15]  O. Johansson.  Disturbance of the immune system by electromagnetic fields-A potentially underlying cause for cellular damage and tissue repair reduction which could lead to disease and impairment. , 2009, Pathophysiology : the official journal of the International Society for Pathophysiology.

[16]  George Louis Carlo,et al.  Wireless phones and health : scientific progress , 1998 .

[17]  Guidelines Icnirp.  Guidelines for limiting exposure to time-varying electric, magnetic, and electromagnetic fields (up to 300 GHz) , 1998 .

[18]  M. T. Marron,et al.  Effects of electromagnetic fields on molecules and cells. , 1995, International review of cytology.

[19]  G L Carlo,et al.  Scientific progress - wireless phones and brain cancer: current state of the science. , 2000, MedGenMed : Medscape general medicine.

[20]  Devra Lee Davis,et al.  Exposure Limits: The underestimation of absorbed cell phone radiation, especially in children , 2012, Electromagnetic biology and medicine.

[21]  Edward J Calabrese,et al.  Hormesis: the dose-response revolution. , 2003, Annual review of pharmacology and toxicology.

[22]  H. Hinrikus,et al.  Effect of 7, 14 and 21 Hz modulated 450 MHz microwave radiation on human electroencephalographic rhythms , 2008, International journal of radiation biology.

[23]  Kenneth R. Foster,et al.  Thermal Properties of Tissue Equivalent Phantom Materials , 1984, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering.

[24]  H. Dertinger,et al.  Stochastic resonance as a possible mechanism of amplification of weak electric signals in living cells. , 1994, Bioelectromagnetics.

[25]  W. Friedland,et al.  Non-linear response of cells to signals leads to revised characteristics of bystander effects inferred from their modelling , 2012, International journal of radiation biology.

[26]  Giuseppina Raciti,et al.  Reactive oxygen species levels and DNA fragmentation on astrocytes in primary culture after acute exposure to low intensity microwave electromagnetic field , 2010, Neuroscience Letters.

[27]  J E Moulder,et al.  Cell phones and cancer: what is the evidence for a connection? , 1999, Radiation research.

[28]  J M Simard,et al.  The patch clamp technique. , 1995, Neurosurgery.

[29]  Dimitris J. Panagopoulos,et al.  MOBILE TELEPHONY RADIATION EFFECTS ON LIVING ORGANISMS , 2008 .

[30]  D Krause,et al.  Role of modulation on the effect of microwaves on ornithine decarboxylase activity in L929 cells. , 1997, Bioelectromagnetics.

[31]  Elizabeth Corcoran,et al.  Tacky Lasers are the Tiniest yet , 1992 .

[32]  W. R. Adey,et al.  EFFECTS OF MODULATED VHF FIELDS ON THE CENTRAL NERVOUS SYSTEM * , 1975, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[33]  H. Lai,et al.  Melatonin and a spin-trap compound block radiofrequency electromagnetic radiation-induced DNA strand breaks in rat brain cells. , 1997, Bioelectromagnetics.

[34]  Dimitris J. Panagopoulos.  Effect of Microwave Exposure on the Ovarian Development of Drosophila melanogaster , 2012, Cell Biochemistry and Biophysics.

[35]  E. A. Navarro,et al.  The Microwave Syndrome: A Preliminary Study in Spain , 2003 .

[36]  P. Kosted.  The biological effects of electromagnetic fields , 1995 .

[37]  P. Raskmark,et al.  Changes in cell proliferation due to environmental non-ionizing radiation: 2. Microwave radiation , 1998 .

[38]  Niels Kuster,et al.  Age-dependent tissue-specific exposure of cell phone users , 2010, Physics in medicine and biology.

[39]  Kjell Hansson Mild,et al.  Epidemiological evidence for an association between use of wireless phones and tumor diseases. , 2009, Pathophysiology : the official journal of the International Society for Pathophysiology.

[40]  H. Lai,et al.  Biological effects from exposure to electromagnetic radiation emitted by cell tower base stations and other antenna arrays , 2010 .

[41]  W. R. Adey,et al.  Low frequency amplitude modulated microwave fields change calcium efflux rates from synaptosomes. , 1982, Bioelectromagnetics.

[42]  Dimitris J. Panagopoulos,et al.  A mechanism for action of oscillating electric fields on cells. , 2000, Biochemical and biophysical research communications.

[43]  A. Ahlbom.  Guidelines for limiting exposure to time-varying electric, magnetic, and electromagnetic fields (up to 300 GHz) , 1998 .

[44]  Kjell Hansson Mild,et al.  Long-term use of cellular phones and brain tumours: increased risk associated with use for ⩾10 years , 2007, Occupational and Environmental Medicine.

[45]  R. Mitchel,et al.  Low Doses of Radiation are Protective in vitro and in vivo: Evolutionary Origins , 2006, Dose-response : a publication of International Hormesis Society.

[46]  Ashok Agarwal,et al.  Effect of cell phone usage on semen analysis in men attending infertility clinic: an observational study. , 2008, Fertility and sterility.

[47]  C K Chou,et al.  Auditory response to pulsed radiofrequency energy , 2003, Bioelectromagnetics.

[48]  J. Hendry,et al.  Radiobiology for the Radiologist , 1979, British Journal of Cancer.

[49]  Rosario D'Agata,et al.  Effects of the exposure to mobile phones on male reproduction: a review of the literature. , 2012, Journal of andrology.

[50]  K. N. Dudkin,et al.  [Adaptive effects of hypoxic preconditioning in brain neurons]. , 2001, Rossiiskii fiziologicheskii zhurnal imeni I.M. Sechenova.

[51]  P Raskmark,et al.  The effects of radiofrequency fields on cell proliferation are non-thermal. , 1999, Bioelectrochemistry and bioenergetics.

[52]  Alvin C. Harper,et al.  Mobile Telephones: Networks, Applications, and Performance , 2008 .

[53]  L. Szabó,et al.  Effects of modulated and continuous microwave irradiation on the morphology and cell surface negative charge of 3T3 fibroblasts. , 1991, Scanning microscopy.

[54]  Dimitris J. Panagopoulos,et al.  The identification of an intensity ‘window’ on the bioeffects of mobile telephony radiation , 2010, International journal of radiation biology.

[55]  R. Gilchrist,et al.  Radiofrequency Electromagnetic Fields, Properties, Quantities and Units, Biophysical Interaction, and Measurements , 1984 .

[56]  H. Lai,et al.  Single- and double-strand DNA breaks in rat brain cells after acute exposure to radiofrequency electromagnetic radiation. , 1996, International journal of radiation biology.

[57]  W. R. Adey,et al.  Ionic factors in release of 45Ca2+ from chicken cerebral tissue by electromagnetic fields. , 1978, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[58]  L. Dombrovska,et al.  Experimental study of the effects of radiofrequency electromagnetic fields on animals with soft tissue wounds. , 1996, The Science of the total environment.

[59]  R. Cortvrindt,et al.  Continuous exposure to bisphenol A during in vitro follicular development induces meiotic abnormalities. , 2008, Mutation research.

[60]  R. W. Lau,et al.  The dielectric properties of biological tissues: III. Parametric models for the dielectric spectrum of tissues. , 1996, Physics in medicine and biology.

[61]  Jukka Juutilainen,et al.  Proliferation, Oxidative Stress and Cell Death in Cells Exposed to 872 MHz Radiofrequency Radiation and Oxidants , 2008, Radiation research.

[62]  J. Lagendijk,et al.  Calculation of SAR and temperature rise in a high-resolution vascularized model of the human eye and orbit when exposed to a dipole antenna at 900, 1500 and 1800 MHz , 2007, Physics in medicine and biology.

[63]  D. D. de Pomerai,et al.  A small temperature rise may contribute towards the apparent induction by microwaves of heat‐shock gene expression in the nematode Caenorhabditis Elegans , 2006, Bioelectromagnetics.

[64]  Dr. Hermann Dertinger,et al.  Molecular Radiation Biology , 1970, Heidelberg Science Library.

[65]  Dimitris J. Panagopoulos,et al.  Bioeffects of mobile telephony radiation in relation to its intensity or distance from the antenna , 2010, International journal of radiation biology.

[66]  M A Stuchly,et al.  A novel equivalent circuit model for gap-connected cells. , 1998, Physics in medicine and biology.

[67]  N. Singh,et al.  Electromagnetic fields and DNA damage. , 2009, Pathophysiology : the official journal of the International Society for Pathophysiology.

[68]  R. Adair.  Biological effects on the cellular level of electric field pulses. , 1991, Health Physics.

[69]  R. W. Lau,et al.  The dielectric properties of biological tissues: II. Measurements in the frequency range 10 Hz to 20 GHz. , 1996, Physics in medicine and biology.

[70]  J. Elder,et al.  Induction of calcium-ion efflux from brain tissue by radiofrequency radiation: effect of sample number and modulation frequency on the power-density window. , 1980, Bioelectromagnetics.

[71]  George L. Carlo,et al.  Wireless phones and health II : state of the science , 2001 .

[72]  Dimitris J. Panagopoulos,et al.  Cell death induced by GSM 900-MHz and DCS 1800-MHz mobile telephony radiation. , 2007, Mutation research.

[73]  G. Thuröczy,,et al.  Simultaneous Response of Brain Electrical Activity (EEG) and Cerebral Circulation (REG) to Microwave Exposure in Rats , 1994, Reviews on environmental health.

[74]  S. Alekseev,et al.  Bursting responses of Lymnea neurons to microwave radiation. , 1992, Bioelectromagnetics.

[75]  D. Averbeck.  Non-targeted effects as a paradigm breaking evidence. , 2010, Mutation research.

[76]  H. P. Schwan,et al.  Interactions between electromagnetic fields and cells , 1985 .

[77]  K. Foster,et al.  Dielectric properties of tissues and biological materials: a critical review. , 1989, Critical reviews in biomedical engineering.

[78]  P. Lindop.  Biological Effects of Radiation , 1957, Nature.

[79]  M. Multigner,et al.  In vivo measurements of electrical conductivity of porcine organs at low frequency: New method of measurement , 2012, Bioelectromagnetics.

[80]  Bertil R. R. Persson,et al.  Blood-Brain Barrier Permeability and Nerve Cell Damage in Rat Brain 14 and 28 Days After Exposure to Microwaves from GSM Mobile Phones , 2008, Electromagnetic biology and medicine.

[81]  Dieter Haemmerich,et al.  Measurement of temperature-dependent specific heat of biological tissues , 2005, Physiological measurement.

[82]  L. S. Kinney,et al.  Multiple power-density windows and their possible origin. , 1989, Bioelectromagnetics.

[83]  A. Liboff,et al.  Kinetics of channelized membrane ions in magnetic fields. , 1988, Bioelectromagnetics.

[84]  Olle Johansson,et al.  Electrohypersensitivity: State-of-the-art of a Functional Impairment the Biological Effects of Weak Electromagnetic Fields , 2022 .

[85]  C Gabriel,et al.  Changes in the dielectric properties of rat tissue as a function of age at microwave frequencies. , 2001, Physics in medicine and biology.

[86]  M. Geffard,et al.  Antibody responses of mice exposed to low-power microwaves under combined, pulse-and-amplitude modulation. , 1991, Bioelectromagnetics.