The Court Helps Those Who Help Themselves … The Legal Status of Migrant Work-Seekers under Community Law in the Light of the Collins Judgment

This article considers the rights to free movement and equal treatment enjoyed by migrant work-seekers, in their capacity as Union citizens, in the light of the judgment of the European Court of Justice in Collins. The Court's approach now focuses upon the right of such lawfully resident Community nationals to challenge discriminatory restrictions on subsistence benefits under Article 39 EC as reinterpreted in light of Article 12 EC; and the potential for the Member States nevertheless to justify such restrictions by reference to their legitimate desire to ensure a ‘real link’ between economically inactive migrants and the domestic welfare systems. The article further addresses the impact of the Collins ruling upon legislative choices made by the Community's political institutions about the mutual allocation between Member States of financial responsibilities for economically inactive persons (including migrant work-seekers), in particular, as contained in Directive 2004/38 on free movement for Union citizens and their family members, and Regulations 1408/71 and 883/2004 on the co-ordination of national social security systems.