Are there independent lexical and nonlexical routes in word processing? An evaluation of the dual-route theory of reading

Abstract One of the most popular and influential theories of word processing, dual-route theory, proposes that there are two functionally independent means of processing words, one involving access to lexical knowledge and the other involving nonlexical grapheme-to-phoneme conversion. Three topics germane to this theory are the processing of nonwords, spelling regularity effects, and the manner in which reading may be impaired following selective damage to either route. This paper evaluates evidence on these topics, and in each case the claims of the theory for an independent nonlexical processing route are called into question. This conclusion is further supported by a discussion of the linguistic constraints that limit any nonlexical grapheme—phoneme conversion process. Some alternative approaches to visual word processing, which share the assumption that lexical knowledge can guide the assembly of phonological information, are discussed. It is argued that these approaches should direct future research.

[1]  E. B. Huey The Psychology And Pedagogy Of Reading , 1908 .

[2]  J. Bruner,et al.  Familiarity of Letter Sequences and Tachistoscopic Identification , 1954 .

[3]  Jerome S. Bruner,et al.  A Note on the Informativeness of Parts of Words , 1958 .

[4]  E. Gibson,et al.  The role of grapheme-phoneme correspondence in the perception of words. , 1962, The American journal of psychology.

[5]  R. Venezky The Structure of English Orthography , 1965 .

[6]  J. Marshall,et al.  Syntactic and semantic errors in paralexia , 1966 .

[7]  H. Kucera,et al.  Computational analysis of present-day American English , 1967 .

[8]  Kenneth S. Goodman,et al.  The psycholinguistic nature of the reading process , 1968 .

[9]  Noam Chomsky,et al.  The Sound Pattern of English , 1968 .

[10]  G. M. Reicher Perceptual recognition as a function of meaninfulness of stimulus material. , 1969, Journal of experimental psychology.

[11]  Herbert A. Simon,et al.  The Sciences of the Artificial , 1970 .

[12]  John J. L. Morton,et al.  Interaction of information in word recognition. , 1969 .

[13]  Carol L. Chomsky,et al.  Reading, Writing, and Phonology , 1970 .

[14]  D. D. Wheeler Processes in word recognition , 1970 .

[15]  E. Gibson,et al.  Utilization of spelling patterns by deaf and hearing subjects , 1971 .

[16]  H. Rubenstein,et al.  Evidence for phonemic recoding in visual word recognition , 1971 .

[17]  Philip B. Gough,et al.  One Second of Reading. , 1972 .

[18]  J. Baron,et al.  An analysis of the word-superiority effect☆ , 1973 .

[19]  J. Marshall,et al.  Patterns of paralexia: A psycholinguistic approach , 1973 .

[20]  K. Forster,et al.  Lexical Access and Naming Time. , 1973 .

[21]  D. Rumelhart,et al.  Process of recognizing tachistoscopically presented words. , 1974, Psychological review.

[22]  R. Schvaneveldt,et al.  Functions of graphemic and phonemic codes in visual word-recognition , 1974, Memory & cognition.

[23]  E. Warrington Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology the Selective Impairment of Semantic Memory the Selective Impairment of Semantic Memory , 2022 .

[24]  T. Shallice,et al.  Word Recognition in a Phonemic Dyslexic Patient , 1975, The Quarterly journal of experimental psychology.

[25]  M. Mason Reading Ability and Letter Search Time: Effects of Orthographic Structure Defined by Single-Letter Positional Frequency. , 1975 .

[26]  C. T. James The Role of Semantic Information in Lexical Decisions. , 1975 .

[27]  E. Rosch,et al.  Family resemblances: Studies in the internal structure of categories , 1975, Cognitive Psychology.

[28]  G. McConkie,et al.  The span of the effective stimulus during a fixation in reading , 1975 .

[29]  K. T. Spoehr,et al.  The role of orthographic and phonotactic rules in perceiving letter patterns. , 1975, Journal of experimental psychology. Human perception and performance.

[30]  J. L. Mcclelland Preliminary letter identification in the perception of words and nonwords. , 1976, Journal of experimental psychology. Human perception and performance.

[31]  H. Hawkins,et al.  Flexible coding in word recognition. , 1976, Journal of experimental psychology. Human perception and performance.

[32]  J. Baron,et al.  Use of orthographic and word-specific knowledge in reading words aloud. , 1976 .

[33]  J. Frederiksen,et al.  Spelling and sound: Approaches to the internal lexicon. , 1976 .

[34]  E. Saffran,et al.  Reading without Phonology: Evidence from Aphasia , 1977 .

[35]  Charles A. Perfetti,et al.  Discourse Comprehension and Sources of Individual Differences. , 1977 .

[36]  James F. Juola,et al.  Isolating visual units in the perception of words and nonwords , 1977 .

[37]  Max Coltheart,et al.  Access to the internal lexicon , 1977 .

[38]  M. Just,et al.  Cognitive processes in comprehension , 1977 .

[39]  A. J. Marcel,et al.  Aphasia, Dyslexia and the Phonological Coding of Written Words , 1977 .

[40]  W. Kintsch,et al.  Memory and cognition , 1977 .

[41]  Geoffrey E. Hinton Relaxation and its role in vision , 1977 .

[42]  Keith E. Stanovich,et al.  Experiments on the spelling-to-sound regularity effect in word recognition , 1978 .

[43]  M. Mason The role of spatial redundancy in grapheme recognition: perception or inference? , 1978, Journal of experimental psychology. Human perception and performance.

[44]  Dominic W. Massaro,et al.  Toward a Psychology of Reading , 1978 .

[45]  G A Bruder,et al.  Role of visual familiarity in the word-superiority effects obtained with the simultaneous-matching task. , 1978, Journal of experimental psychology. Human perception and performance.

[46]  H. McGurk,et al.  Visual influences on speech perception processes , 1978, Perception & psychophysics.

[47]  Derek Besner,et al.  Phonological recoding and lexical access , 1978 .

[48]  Kathryn T. Spoehr,et al.  Phonological encoding in visual word recognition , 1978 .

[49]  Elizabeth B.-N. Sanders,et al.  The effects of graphemic, phonetic, and semantic relationships on access to lexical structures , 1978 .

[50]  Phonemic Dyslexia: Errors of Meaning and the Meaning of Errors , 1978, The Quarterly journal of experimental psychology.

[51]  J F Juola,et al.  The development of visual information processing skills related to reading. , 1978, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[52]  T. Carr,et al.  Perceptual flexibility in word recognition: strategies affect orthographic computation but not lexical access. , 1978, Journal of experimental psychology. Human perception and performance.

[53]  M. Coltheart Lexical access in simple reading tasks , 1978 .

[54]  J Dérouesné,et al.  Phonological alexia: three dissociations. , 1979 .

[55]  E. Rosch,et al.  Cognition and Categorization , 1980 .

[56]  Tim Shallice,et al.  Case study approach in neuropsychological research , 1979 .

[57]  Lee Brooks,et al.  A Comparison of Explicit and Implicit Knowledge of an Alphabet , 1979 .

[58]  R. Glushko The Organization and Activation of Orthographic Knowledge in Reading Aloud. , 1979 .

[59]  Jonathan Baron,et al.  Orthographic and Word-Specific Mechanisms in Children's Reading of Words. , 1979 .

[60]  T Shallice,et al.  Semantic access dyslexia. , 1979, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[61]  M. Schwartz,et al.  Dissociations of language function in dementia: A case study , 1979, Brain and Language.

[62]  Derek Besner,et al.  Phonological Encoding in the Lexical Decision Task , 1979 .

[63]  Paul A. Kolers,et al.  Processing of visible language , 1979 .

[64]  John Morton,et al.  Facilitation in Word Recognition: Experiments Causing Change in the Logogen Model , 1979 .

[65]  J Dérouesné,et al.  Phonological processing in reading: data from alexia. , 1979 .

[66]  Michael I. Posner,et al.  Human Visual Cognition , 1979 .

[67]  K. Stanovich TOWARD AN INTERACTIVE-COMPENSATORY MODEL OF INDIVIDUAL DIFFERENCES IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF READING FLUENCY , 1980 .

[68]  Fernando G. Diaz,et al.  A Neurologist's View , 1980 .

[69]  C. A. Becker Semantic context effects in visual word recognition: An analysis of semantic strategies , 1980, Memory & cognition.

[70]  G. Underwood Strategies of information processing , 1980 .

[71]  T Shallice,et al.  Modality specific word comprehension deficits in deep dyslexia. , 1980, Journal of neurology, neurosurgery, and psychiatry.

[72]  M A Just,et al.  A theory of reading: from eye fixations to comprehension. , 1980, Psychological review.

[73]  W. Cooper,et al.  Sentence Processing: Psycholinguistic Studies Presented to Merrill Garrett. , 1980 .

[74]  J F Juola,et al.  Whole-word units are used before orthographic knowledge in perceptual development. , 1980, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[75]  James L. McClelland,et al.  Experimental tests of a hierarchical model of word identification , 1980 .

[76]  M. Snowling,et al.  The development of grapheme-phoneme correspondence in normal and dyslexic readers. , 1980, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[77]  K E Stanovich,et al.  Lexical access and the spelling-to-sound regularity effect , 1980, Memory & cognition.

[78]  Mark D. Jackson,et al.  Further evidence for a relationship between memory access and reading ability , 1980 .

[79]  G. Claxton Cognitive psychology: New directions , 1980 .

[80]  U. Frith Cognitive Processes in Spelling , 1980 .

[81]  L. Henderson Critical Notice: Information Processing Approaches to Acquired Dyslexia , 1981 .

[82]  Laurie Beth Feldman,et al.  VISUAL WORD RECOGNITION IN SERBO-CROATIAN IS NECESSARILY PHONOLOGICAL , 1981 .

[83]  Derek Besner,et al.  This and THAP — Constraints on the Pronunciation of New, Written Words , 1981 .

[84]  Charles A. Perfetti,et al.  Interactive Processes in Reading , 1981 .

[85]  G. Humphreys,et al.  The Use of Abstract Graphemic Information in Lexical Access , 1981 .

[86]  Randolph G. Bias,et al.  Phonological recoding and reading. , 1981 .

[87]  D. Allport,et al.  Components of the Mental Lexicon , 1981 .

[88]  K. Forster Priming and the Effects of Sentence and Lexical Contexts on Naming Time: Evidence for Autonomous Lexical Processing* , 1981 .

[89]  Janice Kay,et al.  One Process, Not Two, in Reading Aloud: Lexical Analogies Do the Work of Non-Lexical Rules , 1981 .

[90]  G Chastain,et al.  Phonological and orthographic factors in the word-superiority effect , 1981, Memory & cognition.

[91]  E K Warrington,et al.  Concrete word dyslexia. , 1981, British journal of psychology.

[92]  Randolph G. Bias,et al.  Word recognition inside out and outside in , 1981 .

[93]  M. Coltheart Disorders of reading and their implications for models of normal reading. , 1981 .

[94]  K E Patterson,et al.  Neuropsychological approaches to the study of reading. , 1981, British journal of psychology.

[95]  J. Marshall,et al.  Lexical access: A perspective from pathology , 1981, Cognition.

[96]  James L. McClelland,et al.  An interactive activation model of context effects in letter perception: I. An account of basic findings. , 1981 .

[97]  L Pring,et al.  Phonological codes and functional spelling units: Reality and implications , 1981, Perception & psychophysics.

[98]  James L. McClelland,et al.  An interactive activation model of context effects in letter perception: Part 2. The contextual enhancement effect and some tests and extensions of the model. , 1982, Psychological review.

[99]  A. Parkin Phonological recoding in lexical decision: Effects of spelling-to-sound regularity depend on how regularity is defined , 1982, Memory & cognition.

[100]  Randi C. Martin,et al.  The Pseudohomophone Effect: The Role of Visual Similarity in Non-Word Decisions , 1982, The Quarterly journal of experimental psychology. A, Human experimental psychology.

[101]  R W Schvaneveldt,et al.  An activation--verification model for letter and word recognition: the word-superiority effect. , 1982, Psychological review.

[102]  L. Henderson Orthography and Word Recognition in Reading , 1982 .

[103]  M Taft,et al.  An alternative to grapheme-phoneme conversion rules? , 1982, Memory & cognition.

[104]  S. Andrews Phonological recoding: Is the regularity effect consistent? , 1982 .

[105]  G W Humphreys,et al.  Automatic phonological priming in visual word recognition , 1982, Memory & cognition.

[106]  Alfonso Caramazza,et al.  Lexical decision for open- and closed-class words: Failure to replicate differential frequency sensitivity , 1982, Brain and Language.

[107]  M Coltheart,et al.  The psycholinguistic analysis of acquired dyslexias: some illustrations. , 1982, Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences.

[108]  Geoffrey Underwood,et al.  Word shape, orthographic regularity, and contextual interactions in a reading task , 1982, Cognition.

[109]  Gerard Deloche,et al.  Surface dyslexia: A case report and some theoretical implications to reading models , 1982, Brain and Language.

[110]  P. Briggs,et al.  Phonological coding in good and poor readers. , 1982, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[111]  Klaus Poeck,et al.  What do we mean by “aphasic syndromes?” A neurologist's view , 1983, Brain and Language.

[112]  Rosaleen A. McCarthy,et al.  Reading without Semantics , 1983 .

[113]  P. Reitsma,et al.  Printed word learning in beginning readers , 1983 .

[114]  John A. Sloboda,et al.  The Acquisition of Symbolic Skills , 1983 .

[115]  K. Stanovich,et al.  On priming by a sentence context. , 1983, Journal of experimental psychology. General.

[116]  M. Coltheart,et al.  Surface dyslexia. , 1983, The Quarterly journal of experimental psychology. A, Human experimental psychology.

[117]  L. Katz,et al.  Relation between pronunciation and recognition of printed words in deep and shallow orthographies. , 1983, Journal of experimental psychology. Learning, memory, and cognition.

[118]  Jonathan Baron,et al.  Phonological recording and use of spelling-sound rules in reading of sentences , 1983 .

[119]  M. Rosson From SOFA to LOUCH: Lexical contributions to pseudoword pronunciation , 1983, Memory & cognition.

[120]  G. Simpson,et al.  Encoding and contextual components of word recognition in good and poor readers. , 1983, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[121]  E. Funnell Phonological processes in reading: new evidence from acquired dyslexia. , 1983 .

[122]  D. Besner,et al.  Suedohomofoan effects in visual word recognition: evidence for phonological processing. , 1983, Canadian journal of psychology.

[123]  Derek Besner,et al.  Basic decoding components in reading: Two dissociable feature extraction processes. , 1983 .

[124]  G Underwood,et al.  Orthographic vs. phonological irregularity in lexical decision , 1983, Memory & cognition.

[125]  K. Rayner,et al.  Eye Movements in Reading: Perceptual and Language Processes , 1985 .

[126]  D. Balota,et al.  A word’s meaning affects the decision in lexical decision , 1984, Memory & cognition.

[127]  Mark S. Seidenberg,et al.  When does irregular spelling or pronunciation influence word recognition , 1984 .

[128]  M Taft,et al.  Evidence for an abstract lexical representation of word structure , 1984, Memory & cognition.

[129]  P. H. Seymour,et al.  Developmental dyslexia: a cognitive experimental analysis of phonological, morphemic, and visual impairments , 1984 .

[130]  P Reitsma,et al.  Sound priming in beginning readers. , 1984, Child development.

[131]  G. Waters,et al.  Children’s and adults’ use of spelling-sound information in three reading tasks , 1984, Memory & cognition.

[132]  Alfonso Caramazza,et al.  The logic of neuropsychological research and the problem of patient classification in aphasia , 1984, Brain and Language.

[133]  M. Gernsbacher Resolving 20 years of inconsistent interactions between lexical familiarity and orthography, concreteness, and polysemy. , 1984, Journal of experimental psychology. General.

[134]  Mark S. Seidenberg,et al.  Acquisition and use of spelling-sound correspondences in reading , 1984 .

[135]  A. Parkin Redefining the regularity effect , 1984, Memory & cognition.

[136]  Mark S. Seidenberg,et al.  Pre- and postlexical loci of contextual effects on word recognition , 1984, Memory & cognition.

[137]  G Chastain,et al.  Phonological access to the mental lexicon in a target discrimination task. , 1984, The Journal of general psychology.

[138]  D. Balota,et al.  Are lexical decisions a good measure of lexical access? The role of word frequency in the neglected decision stage. , 1984, Journal of experimental psychology. Human perception and performance.

[139]  Don C. Mitchell,et al.  The process of reading : a cognitive analysis of fluent reading and learning to read , 1984 .

[140]  S. Lupker Semantic Priming without Association: A Second Look. , 1984 .

[141]  R Treiman,et al.  Individual differences among children in spelling and reading styles. , 1984, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[142]  Mark S. Seidenberg,et al.  Spelling-sound effects in reading: Time-course and decision criteria , 1985, Memory & cognition.

[143]  Mark S. Seidenberg The time course of phonological code activation in two writing systems , 1985, Cognition.

[144]  Mark S. Seidenberg Constraining models of word recognition , 1985, Cognition.

[145]  D. Balota,et al.  The locus of word-frequency effects in the pronunciation task: Lexical access and/or production? ☆ , 1985 .

[146]  Dennis Norris,et al.  Race models and analogy theories: A dead heat? Reply to Seidenberg , 1985, Cognition.

[147]  G. E. MacKinnon,et al.  Reading Research Advances in Theory and Practice , 1985 .

[148]  M. Rosson The interaction of pronunciation rules and lexical representations in reading aloud , 1985, Memory & cognition.

[149]  A. Ellis Progress in the psychology of language , 1985 .

[150]  J. Kay,et al.  The Nature of Phonological Processing in Oral Reading: Evidence from Surface Dyslexia , 1985, The Quarterly journal of experimental psychology. A, Human experimental psychology.

[151]  James L. McClelland,et al.  Parallel distributed processing: explorations in the microstructure of cognition, vol. 1: foundations , 1986 .