Case definition and case identification in psychiatric epidemiology: review and assessment

SYNOPSIS Psychiatric epidemiology has advanced considerably since early studies of hospital populations. The direction of this advance has been away from the study of populations of hospital psychiatric patients towards the study of psychiatric disorder in general practice and the community as a whole. Just as the populations under study have different defining characteristics, so have the individuals who comprise them. Psychosis becomes less and less common at greater distances from the hospital patient, and in the community the epidemiologist is faced with large numbers of respondents who present with fewer, minor and non-specific symptoms. In this review, we present evidence to indicate that concepts of case definition and case identification are insufficiently advanced so far, and are still rooted in ideas derived from hospital psychiatry. Foremost among these is an exclusive preoccupation with diagnosis and symptoms. We suggest that this may be inadequate for the study of non-psychotic disturbance in the community, and discuss other models of case definition, encompassing personality and social functioning as well as psychiatric symptomatology.

[1]  A. Clare,et al.  Changing patterns of psychiatric care. , 1981, British medical journal.

[2]  I. Pilowsky.  Personality and depressive illness , 1979, Acta psychiatrica Scandinavica.

[3]  R. Wiggins,et al.  Validity and Uses of a Screening Questionnaire (GHQ) in the Community , 1979, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[4]  E. Acheson.  Clinical practice and epidemiology: two worlds or one? , 1979, British medical journal.

[5]  P. Williams.  Deciding how to treat – the relevance of psychiatric diagnosis , 1979, Psychological Medicine.

[6]  J E Mezzich,et al.  Patterns and issues in multiaxial psychiatric diagnosis , 1979, Psychological Medicine.

[7]  A W Clare,et al.  Design, development and use of a standardized interview to assess social maladjustment and dysfunction in community studies , 1978, Psychological Medicine.

[8]  J. Leff.  Psychiatrists' versus Patients' Concepts of Unpleasant Emotions , 1978, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[9]  M. Shepherd.  Epidemiology and Clinical Psychiatry , 1978, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[10]  P Slater,et al.  The Middlesex Hospital Questionnaire: a validity study. , 1978, The British journal of medical psychology.

[11]  H. Dasberg,et al.  On the validity of the Middlesex Hospital Questionnaire: a comparison of diagnostic self-ratings in psychiatric out-patients, general practice patients, and 'normals' based on the Hebrew version. , 1978, The British journal of medical psychology.

[12]  T J Yager,et al.  The psychiatric status schedule as a measure of dimensions of psychopathology in the general population. , 1978, Archives of general psychiatry.

[13]  E. Robins,et al.  Research diagnostic criteria: rationale and reliability. , 1978, Archives of general psychiatry.

[14]  M. Briscoe.  Sex differences in perception of illness and expressed life satisfaction , 1978, Psychological Medicine.

[15]  R. Wiggins,et al.  The effect of aircraft noise on the mental health of a community sample: a pilot study , 1978, Psychological Medicine.

[16]  J K Wing,et al.  The concept of a ‘case’ in psychiatric population surveys , 1978, Psychological Medicine.

[17]  H. Kedward.  Book Review: The Measurement and Classification of Psychiatric Symptoms , 1978 .

[18]  J. Tanner.  Developments in Psychiatric Research , 1977 .

[19]  D. Fergusson,et al.  The Effect of Mental State on EPI Scores , 1977, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[20]  D. Tuckett.  An Introduction to medical sociology , 1977 .

[21]  I. Levav,et al.  Two shortened versions of the Cornell Medical Index--a new test of their validity. , 1977, International journal of epidemiology.

[22]  J. Wing.  A technique for studying psychiatric morbidity in in-patient and out-patient series and in general population samples , 1977, Psychological Medicine.

[23]  P. Miller,et al.  The concept of prevalence applied to psychiatric disorders and symptoms , 1976, Psychological Medicine.

[24]  C. Climent,et al.  Explanations of bias in psychiatric case-finding instruments. , 1976, Journal of Health and Social Behavior.

[25]  M. Salkind.  Assessment of drugs in general practice. , 1976, British journal of clinical pharmacology.

[26]  R. Forthofer,et al.  The Langner items and acquiescence , 1976 .

[27]  R. Snaith.  Personality and Depressive Illness , 1976, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[28]  J. Pollitt,et al.  The Relationship between Personality and the Symptoms of Depressive Illness , 1975, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[29]  R. Priest,et al.  Book Review: Obstetrics and Gynecology , 1975 .

[30]  E. Robins,et al.  Research diagnostic criteria. , 1975, Psychopharmacology bulletin.

[31]  A. Bedford,et al.  Hierarchy of classes of personal illness , 1975, Psychological Medicine.

[32]  M. Beiser,et al.  Components and correlates of mental well-being. , 1974, Journal of health and social behavior.

[33]  M. Tousignant,et al.  Some considerations concerning the validity and use of the health opinion survey. , 1974, Journal of health and social behavior.

[34]  J. Birtchnell.  Is there a scientifically acceptable alternative to the epidemiological study of familial factors in mental illness? , 1974, Social science & medicine.

[35]  T. Scheff,et al.  The labelling theory of mental illness. , 1974, American sociological review.

[36]  Epidemiological psychiatry , 1973, Psychological Medicine.

[37]  L. H. Seiler.  The 22-item scale used in field studies of mental illness: a question of method, a question of substance, and a question of theory. , 1973, Journal of health and social behavior.

[38]  A. Presly,et al.  Use of a Category System in the Diagnosis of Abnormal Personality , 1973, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[39]  R. Kellner,et al.  A self-rating scale of distress , 1973, Psychological Medicine.

[40]  Boris OGUIBENINE.  Familiar Faces , 1972 .

[41]  R. Cooperstock.  Sex differences in the use of mood-modifying drugs: an explanatory model. , 1971, Journal of health and social behavior.

[42]  M. Eastwood.  Screening for psychiatric disorder , 1971, Psychological Medicine.

[43]  J. Tower.  Social work in general practice. , 1970, Lancet.

[44]  R. Lanyon,et al.  Development and validation of a psychological screening inventory. , 1970, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[45]  D. Phillips,et al.  Response biases in field studies of mental illness. , 1970, American sociological review.

[46]  D. Goldberg,et al.  Psychiatric Illness in General Practice: A Detailed Study Using a New Method of Case Identification* , 1970, British medical journal.

[47]  B. Dohrenwend,et al.  Psychiatric symptoms in community, clinic, and mental hospital groups. , 1970, The American journal of psychiatry.

[48]  Garai Je.  Sex differences in mental health. , 1970 .

[49]  M Shepherd,et al.  A standardized psychiatric interview for use in community surveys. , 1970, British journal of preventive & social medicine.

[50]  E. Hare,et al.  Eysenck Personality Inventory Scores of Patients with Depressive Illness , 1969, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[51]  R. Kendell,et al.  Eysenck Personality Inventory Scores of Patients with Depressive Illnesses , 1968, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[52]  D. Levinson,et al.  Becoming a patient. , 1967, Archives of general psychiatry.

[53]  R. A. Rorie.  PSYCHIATRIC ILLNESS IN GENERAL PRACTICE , 1967, The Ulster Medical Journal.

[54]  S Crown,et al.  A Short Clinical Diagnostic Self-rating Scale for Psychoneurotic Patients , 1966, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[55]  B. Dohrenwend.  Social status and psychological disorder: an issue of substance and an issue of method. , 1966, American sociological review.

[56]  S. Cobb,et al.  Health behavior, illness behavior, and sick role behavior. I. Health and illness behavior. , 1966, Archives of environmental health.

[57]  F. H. Kanfer,et al.  BEHAVIORAL ANALYSIS: AN ALTERNATIVE TO DIAGNOSTIC CLASSIFICATION. , 1965, Archives of general psychiatry.

[58]  A. Coppen,et al.  Effect of a Depressive Illness on M.P.I. Scores , 1965, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[59]  Bruce P. Dohrewend,et al.  THE PROBLEM OF VALIDITY IN FIELD STUDIES OF PSYCHOLOGICAL DISORDER. , 1965 .

[60]  Mervyn Susser,et al.  Mental Health and Environment , 1964, Mental Health.

[61]  T. Szasz,et al.  The Myth of Mental Illness , 1963, Mental Health.

[62]  R. Blum.  Case identification in psychiatric epidemiology: methods and problems. , 1962, The Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly.

[63]  D. Mechanic,et al.  The concept of illness behavior. , 1962, Journal of chronic diseases.

[64]  P. Sainsbury,et al.  The reliability of psychiatric assessment: an analysis. , 1961, The Journal of mental science.

[65]  G. Foulds.  The manual of the Maudsley personality inventory , 1960 .

[66]  K. Keniston,et al.  Yeasayers and naysayers: agreeing response set as a personality variable. , 1960, Journal of abnormal and social psychology.

[67]  L. Ozarin.  SYMPOSIUM ON PREVENTIVE AND SOCIAL PSYCHIATRY , 1959 .

[68]  Bernard S. Phillips,et al.  An Analysis of the Validity of Health Questionnaires , 1958 .

[69]  M. Kuhn,et al.  Family, Socialization and Interaction Process , 1957, Pediatrics.

[70]  R. Bales,et al.  Family, socialization and interaction process , 1956 .

[71]  J. E. Finesinger,et al.  A normative social adjustment scale. , 1955, The American journal of psychiatry.

[72]  L. J. Webb,et al.  Sex differences in mental health. , 1979, The Journal of psychology.

[73]  H. Murphy.  The meaning of symptom-check-list scores in mental health surveys: a testing of multiple hypotheses. , 1978, Social science & medicine.

[74]  David J. P. Barker,et al.  Epidemiology in medical practice , 1976 .

[75]  R. Kendell,et al.  The role of diagnosis in psychiatry. , 1975 .

[76]  M. Tousignant,et al.  Psychiatric patients and the "untreated" cases of epidemiological surveys: a comparative analysis of the self-concept. , 1975, Social science & medicine.

[77]  D. Goldberg.  The detection of psychiatric illness by questionnaire : a technique for the identification and assessment of non-psychotic psychiatric illness , 1972 .

[78]  J. Feighner,et al.  Diagnostic criteria for use in psychiatric research. , 1972, Archives of general psychiatry.

[79]  Cyril M. Franks,et al.  Behavior therapy: Appraisal and status. , 1969 .

[80]  D. Mechanic,et al.  Medical Sociology: A Selective View. , 1969 .

[81]  Thomas J. Scheff,et al.  Being mentally ill : a sociological theory , 1966 .

[82]  B. Dohrenwend,et al.  The problem of validity in field studies of psychological disorder. , 1965, International journal of psychiatry.

[83]  T. Langner.  A twenty-two item screening score of psychiatric symptoms indicating impairment. , 1962, Journal of health and human behavior.

[84]  A. L. Edwards.  Social desirability and personality test construction. , 1959 .

[85]  S. L. Morrison.  Epidemiology of mental disorders. , 1958, Royal Society of Health journal.

[86]  Russell Fraser,et al.  The incidence of neurosis among factory workers , 1947 .