The Influence of Ventilation Measures on the Airborne Risk of Infection in Schools: A Scoping Review

Objectives: To review the risk of airborne infections in schools and evaluate the effect of intervention measures reported in field studies. Background: Schools are part of a country’s critical infrastructure. Good infection prevention measures are essential for reducing the risk of infection in schools as much as possible, since these are places where many individuals spend a great deal of time together every weekday in a small area where airborne pathogens can spread quickly. Appropriate ventilation can reduce the indoor concentration of airborne pathogens and reduce the risk of infection. Methods: A systematic search of the literature was conducted in the databases Embase, MEDLINE, and ScienceDirect using keywords such as school, classroom, ventilation, carbon dioxide (CO2) concentration, SARS-CoV-2, and airborne transmission. The primary endpoint of the studies selected was the risk of airborne infection or CO2 concentration as a surrogate parameter. Studies were grouped according to the study type. Results: We identified 30 studies that met the inclusion criteria, six of them intervention studies. When specific ventilation strategies were lacking in schools being investigated, CO2 concentrations were often above the recommended maximum values. Improving ventilation lowered the CO2 concentration, resulting in a lower risk of airborne infections. Conclusions: The ventilation in many schools is not adequate to guarantee good indoor air quality. Ventilation is an important measure for reducing the risk of airborne infections in schools. The most important effect is to reduce the time of residence of pathogens in the classrooms.

[1]  I. Urbieta,et al.  Assessment of indoor air quality and risk of COVID-19 infection in Spanish secondary school and university classrooms , 2022, Building and Environment.

[2]  L. Mazzarella,et al.  Ventilation strategies to reduce airborne transmission of viruses in classrooms: A systematic review of scientific literature , 2022, Building and Environment.

[3]  L. Morawska,et al.  Increasing ventilation reduces SARS-CoV-2 airborne transmission in schools: A retrospective cohort study in Italy's Marche region , 2022, Frontiers in Public Health.

[4]  B. Amick,et al.  SARS-CoV-2 Incidence in K–12 School Districts with Mask-Required Versus Mask-Optional Policies — Arkansas, August–October 2021 , 2022, MMWR. Morbidity and mortality weekly report.

[5]  D. Mürbe,et al.  Pre-adolescent children exhibit lower aerosol particle volume emissions than adults for breathing, speaking, singing and shouting , 2022, Journal of the Royal Society Interface.

[6]  Antonio J. Aguilar,et al.  Assessment of ventilation rates inside educational buildings in Southwestern Europe: Analysis of implemented strategic measures , 2022, Journal of Building Engineering.

[7]  S. Baumgarte,et al.  Investigation of a Limited but Explosive COVID-19 Outbreak in a German Secondary School , 2022, Viruses.

[8]  Shelly L. Miller,et al.  Room-level ventilation in schools and universities , 2021, Atmospheric Environment: X.

[9]  V. Valero-Amaro,et al.  Ventilation conditions and their influence on thermal comfort in examination classrooms in times of COVID-19. A case study in a Spanish area with Mediterranean climate , 2021, International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health.

[10]  H.-C. Selinka,et al.  Lüftungskonzepte in Schulen zur Prävention einer Übertragung hochinfektiöser Viren (SARS-CoV‑2) über Aerosole in der Raumluft , 2021, Bundesgesundheitsblatt - Gesundheitsforschung - Gesundheitsschutz.

[11]  Alessandro Zivelonghi,et al.  Mitigating aerosol infection risk in school buildings: The role of natural ventilation, volume, occupancy and CO2 monitoring , 2021 .

[12]  J. Frans,et al.  Monitors to improve indoor air carbon dioxide concentrations in the hospital: A randomized crossover trial , 2021, Science of The Total Environment.

[13]  M. Bes-Rastrollo,et al.  Encouraging natural ventilation to improve indoor environmental conditions at schools. Case studies in the north of Spain before and during COVID , 2021, Energy and Buildings.

[14]  L. Morawska,et al.  Respiratory infection risk-based ventilation design method , 2021, Building and Environment.

[15]  Antonio J. Aguilar,et al.  Analysis of Impact of Natural Ventilation Strategies in Ventilation Rates and Indoor Environmental Acoustics Using Sensor Measurement Data in Educational Buildings , 2021, Sensors.

[16]  Zeynep Tufekci,et al.  Airborne transmission of respiratory viruses , 2021, Science.

[17]  Jiannan Cai,et al.  Airborne infection risks of SARS-CoV-2 in U.S. schools and impacts of different intervention strategies , 2021, Sustainable Cities and Society.

[18]  G. de Gennaro,et al.  CO2 concentration monitoring inside educational buildings as a strategic tool to reduce the risk of Sars-CoV-2 airborne transmission , 2021, Environmental Research.

[19]  L. Morawska,et al.  Ventilation procedures to minimize the airborne transmission of viruses in classrooms , 2021, Building and Environment.

[20]  P. Griffin,et al.  Assessing school-based policy actions for COVID-19: An agent-based analysis of incremental infection risk , 2021, Computers in Biology and Medicine.

[21]  C. Drenzek,et al.  Mask Use and Ventilation Improvements to Reduce COVID-19 Incidence in Elementary Schools — Georgia, November 16–December 11, 2020 , 2021, MMWR. Morbidity and mortality weekly report.

[22]  Eun Kyung Kim,et al.  Natural ventilation strategy and related issues to prevent coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) airborne transmission in a school building , 2021, Science of The Total Environment.

[23]  Michael J. Birnkrant,et al.  A systematic approach to estimating the effectiveness of multi-scale IAQ strategies for reducing the risk of airborne infection of SARS-CoV-2 , 2021, Building and Environment.

[24]  R. Iannaccone,et al.  From spontaneous to strategic natural window ventilation: Improving indoor air quality in Swiss schools. , 2021, International journal of hygiene and environmental health.

[25]  B. Cabañas,et al.  Assessment of CO2 and aerosol (PM2.5, PM10, UFP) concentrations during the reopening of schools in the COVID-19 pandemic: The case of a metropolitan area in Central-Southern Spain , 2021, Environmental Research.

[26]  M. Lachmann,et al.  The Experience of 2 Independent Schools With In‐Person Learning During the COVID‐19 Pandemic , 2021, The Journal of school health.

[27]  C. Tambani,et al.  High energy efficiency ventilation to limit COVID-19 contagion in school environments , 2021, Energy and Buildings.

[28]  J. J. Sendra,et al.  Effects of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Indoor Air Quality and Thermal Comfort of Primary Schools in Winter in a Mediterranean Climate , 2021, Sustainability.

[29]  U. Janoske,et al.  Transmission and reduction of aerosols in classrooms using air purifier systems , 2021, Physics of fluids.

[30]  Jasmine Y Nakayama,et al.  Clusters of SARS-CoV-2 Infection Among Elementary School Educators and Students in One School District — Georgia, December 2020–January 2021 , 2021, MMWR. Morbidity and mortality weekly report.

[31]  Qiaoling Lu,et al.  An outbreak of pulmonary tuberculosis and a follow-up investigation of latent tuberculosis in a high school in an eastern city in China, 2016–2019 , 2021, PloS one.

[32]  D. Mürbe,et al.  Aerosol emission of adolescents voices during speaking, singing and shouting , 2021, PloS one.

[33]  Q. Bi,et al.  SARS-CoV-2 setting-specific transmission rates: a systematic review and meta-analysis. , 2021, Clinical infectious diseases : an official publication of the Infectious Diseases Society of America.

[34]  Zachary Wallace,et al.  COVID-19 Cases and Transmission in 17 K–12 Schools — Wood County, Wisconsin, August 31–November 29, 2020 , 2021, MMWR. Morbidity and mortality weekly report.

[35]  E. Kelvin,et al.  Estimating aerosol transmission risk of SARS-CoV-2 in New York City public schools during reopening , 2021, Environmental Research.

[36]  P. Linden,et al.  Seasonal variation in airborne infection risk in schools due to changes in ventilation inferred from monitored carbon dioxide , 2021, Indoor air.

[37]  OUP accepted manuscript , 2021, International Journal Of Epidemiology.

[38]  J. Zemitis,et al.  The Study of Co2 Concentration in A Classroom During The Covid-19 Safety Measures , 2021, E3S Web of Conferences.

[39]  V. Saliba,et al.  SARS-CoV-2 infection and transmission in educational settings: a prospective, cross-sectional analysis of infection clusters and outbreaks in England , 2020, The Lancet Infectious Diseases.

[40]  Naglaa A. Megahed,et al.  Indoor Air Quality: Rethinking rules of building design strategies in post-pandemic architecture , 2020, Environmental Research.

[41]  J. Soland,et al.  Projecting the Potential Impact of COVID-19 School Closures on Academic Achievement , 2020, Educational Researcher.

[42]  J. Curtius,et al.  Testing mobile air purifiers in a school classroom: Reducing the airborne transmission risk for SARS-CoV-2 , 2020, medRxiv.

[43]  R. Viner,et al.  Susceptibility to SARS-CoV-2 Infection Among Children and Adolescents Compared With Adults: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. , 2020, JAMA pediatrics.

[44]  J. L. Jimenez,et al.  Exhaled CO2 as COVID-19 infection risk proxy for different indoor environments and activities , 2020, medRxiv.

[45]  U. Buchholz,et al.  Surveillance of COVID-19 school outbreaks, Germany, March to August 2020 , 2020, Euro surveillance : bulletin Europeen sur les maladies transmissibles = European communicable disease bulletin.

[46]  Bin Zhao,et al.  Association of the infection probability of COVID-19 with ventilation rates in confined spaces , 2020, Building Simulation.

[47]  D. Mumovic,et al.  Ventilation rates in naturally ventilated primary schools in the UK; Contextual, Occupant and Building-related (COB) factors , 2020, Building and Environment.

[48]  C. Stein-Zamir,et al.  A large COVID-19 outbreak in a high school 10 days after schools’ reopening, Israel, May 2020 , 2020, Euro surveillance : bulletin Europeen sur les maladies transmissibles = European communicable disease bulletin.

[49]  Yuri Bruinen de Bruin,et al.  Indoor air pollution, physical and comfort parameters related to schoolchildren's health: Data from the European SINPHONIE study. , 2020, The Science of the total environment.

[50]  G Aernout Somsen,et al.  Small droplet aerosols in poorly ventilated spaces and SARS-CoV-2 transmission , 2020, The Lancet Respiratory Medicine.

[51]  M. Agha,et al.  The socio-economic implications of the coronavirus pandemic (COVID-19): A review , 2020, International Journal of Surgery.

[52]  B. Liu,et al.  Aerosol and Surface Distribution of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 in Hospital Wards, Wuhan, China, 2020 , 2020, Emerging infectious diseases.

[53]  L. Morawska,et al.  Airborne transmission of SARS-CoV-2: The world should face the reality , 2020, Environment International.

[54]  Dylan H. Morris,et al.  Aerosol and Surface Stability of SARS-CoV-2 as Compared with SARS-CoV-1 , 2020, The New England journal of medicine.

[55]  P. Azimi,et al.  Estimating the nationwide transmission risk of measles in US schools and impacts of vaccination and supplemental infection control strategies , 2020, BMC Infectious Diseases.

[56]  K. K. Coleman,et al.  Airborne Influenza A Virus Exposure in an Elementary School , 2020, Scientific Reports.

[57]  R. Jou,et al.  Effect of ventilation improvement during a tuberculosis outbreak in underventilated university buildings , 2019, Indoor air.

[58]  A. Wexler,et al.  Aerosol emission and superemission during human speech increase with voice loudness , 2019, Scientific Reports.

[59]  P V Nielsen,et al.  Short‐range airborne transmission of expiratory droplets between two people , 2017, Indoor air.

[60]  S M Almeida,et al.  Assessment of ventilation and indoor air pollutants in nursery and elementary schools in France. , 2016, Indoor air.

[61]  P Wargocki,et al.  Use of visual CO2 feedback as a retrofit solution for improving classroom air quality. , 2015, Indoor air.

[62]  B. Brunekreef,et al.  A ventilation intervention study in classrooms to improve indoor air quality: the FRESH study , 2013, Environmental Health.

[63]  S. Almeida,et al.  Winter Ventilation Rates at Primary Schools: Comparison Between Portugal and Finland , 2013, Journal of toxicology and environmental health. Part A.

[64]  Derek Clements-Croome,et al.  Ventilation rates in schools and pupils' performance , 2012 .

[65]  U. Haverinen-Shaughnessy,et al.  Association between substandard classroom ventilation rates and students' academic achievement. , 2011, Indoor air.

[66]  A M J Ragas,et al.  Comparing the effectiveness of interventions to improve ventilation behavior in primary schools. , 2008, Indoor air.

[67]  Derek Clements-Croome,et al.  Ventilation rates in schools , 2008 .

[68]  Gesundheitliche Bewertung von Kohlendioxid in der Innenraumluft , 2008, Bundesgesundheitsblatt - Gesundheitsforschung - Gesundheitsschutz.

[69]  C. Liao,et al.  Modelling control measures to reduce the impact of pandemic influenza among schoolchildren , 2007, Epidemiology and Infection.

[70]  D Faulkner,et al.  Associations between classroom CO2 concentrations and student attendance in Washington and Idaho. , 2004, Indoor air.

[71]  D. Milton,et al.  Risk of indoor airborne infection transmission estimated from carbon dioxide concentration. , 2003, Indoor air.

[72]  P A Scheff,et al.  Indoor air quality in a middle school, Part I: Use of CO2 as a tracer for effective ventilation. , 2000, Applied occupational and environmental hygiene.

[73]  G Murphy,et al.  Airborne spread of measles in a suburban elementary school. , 1978, American journal of epidemiology.