In his paper ‘Some Remarks about the Senses’ H.P. Grice argues that our distinction among perceptual modalities requires that the modalities must be characterized in terms of the introspectable character of experience. I first show that Grice's argument provides support for the claim that perceptual experiences have qualia, namely, mental qualitative properties of experience which are what it is like to be conscious of perceived properties such as colour. I then defend intentionalism about experience, which rejects qualia, by showing that we need not appeal to differences in qualia in order to distinguish the senses. Rather I claim that we can appeal to, among other factors, differences in the physical properties of physical objects which experience represents.
[1]
R Sorabji,et al.
Aristotle on decmarcating the five senses.
,
1970,
The Philosophical review.
[2]
C. Coady.
The Senses of Martians
,
1974
.
[3]
Ned Block,et al.
Are Absent Qualia Impossible
,
1980
.
[4]
Clyde L. Hardin,et al.
Color for Philosophers: Unweaving the Rainbow
,
1988
.
[5]
M. Leon.
Characterising the Senses
,
1988
.
[6]
Categorising the Senses
,
1990
.
[7]
Fred I. Dretske.
Reply to Lopes
,
2000
.
[8]
Dominic McIver Lopes,et al.
What Is It Like to See with Your Ears? The Representational Theory of Mind
,
2000
.
[9]
Peter W. Ross.
The Location Problem for Color Subjectivism
,
2001,
Consciousness and Cognition.