Association Between Adherence and Glycemic Control in Pediatric Type 1 Diabetes: A Meta-analysis

CONTEXT: Although adherence has been identified in practice guidelines for youth with type 1 diabetes to promote optimal glycemic control, there has been no systematic integration of studies investigating the adherence-glycemic control link. This recommendation partly stemmed from the Diabetes Control and Complications Trial (DCCT); however, this trial did not comprehensively measure adherence and had only 195 adolescents. OBJECTIVE: Our goal was to determine the magnitude of the adherence-glycemic control link in pediatric type 1 diabetes and evaluate its correlates. METHODS: Our data sources were PubMed (1950–2008), Scopus (1950–2008), and references from reviews in pediatric type 1 diabetes. Studies that included youth under age 19 with type 1 diabetes and a reported association between adherence and glycemic control were eligible for inclusion. Articles were not included if they contained youth with type 2 diabetes, had study samples that overlapped with other studies, or the results came from intervention studies. Of the eligible 26 studies, 21 had sufficient statistical data. Two authors independently extracted information by using a standardized protocol. Agreement between coders was high. RESULTS: The mean effect size across 21 studies, including 2492 youth with type 1 diabetes, was −0.28 (95% confidence interval: −0.32 to −0.24). As adherence increases, A1c values decrease. No sample or disease characteristics were correlates of the adherence-glycemic control link. Pre-DCCT studies had a mean effect size of −0.32 (8 studies; 1169 participants) compared with −0.25 in post-DCCT studies (13 studies; 1323 participants). CONCLUSIONS: This meta-analysis supports the adherence-glycemic control link in pediatric type 1 diabetes. The weaker post-DCCT association suggests that the approach to intensive diabetes management has shortcomings. We conclude that this is because of a mismatch between what scientists and clinicians know is the best way to manage pediatric type 1 diabetes and the capabilities of youth and their families.

[1]  M. Phillip,et al.  Use of Insulin Pump Therapy in the Pediatric Age-Group , 2007, Diabetes Care.

[2]  P. Hougaard,et al.  Persistent differences among centers over 3 years in glycemic control and hypoglycemia in a study of 3,805 children and adolescents with type 1 diabetes from the Hvidøre Study Group. , 2001, Diabetes care.

[3]  Jorie M. Butler,et al.  Role of Parental Monitoring in Understanding the Benefits of Parental Acceptance on Adolescent Adherence and Metabolic Control of Type 1 Diabetes , 2008 .

[4]  S. Johnson,et al.  Adherence-health status relationships in childhood diabetes. , 1990, Health psychology : official journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association.

[5]  J. Dora,et al.  Standards of Medical Care in Diabetes—2008 , 2008, Diabetes Care.

[6]  J. Naglieri,et al.  Deviation from Developmentally Appropriate Self-Care Autonomy: Association with diabetes outcomes , 1996, Diabetes Care.

[7]  Y. Jang,et al.  Standards of Medical Care in Diabetes-2010 by the American Diabetes Association: Prevention and Management of Cardiovascular Disease , 2010 .

[8]  W. Tamborlane,et al.  Optimal control of type 1 diabetes mellitus in youth receiving intensive treatment. , 2006, The Journal of pediatrics.

[9]  L. Greening,et al.  Child routines and youths' adherence to treatment for type 1 diabetes. , 2006, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[10]  B. Anderson,et al.  Diabetes problem solving by youths with type 1 diabetes and their caregivers: measurement, validation, and longitudinal associations with glycemic control. , 2008, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[11]  S Shapiro,et al.  Meta-analysis/Shmeta-analysis. , 1994, American journal of epidemiology.

[12]  S. Genuth,et al.  The effect of intensive treatment of diabetes on the development and progression of long-term complications in insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. , 1993, The New England journal of medicine.

[13]  C. Holmes,et al.  Sociodemographic Risk Factors to Disease Control in Children with Diabetes , 1997 .

[14]  J. Silverstein,et al.  Assessing daily management in childhood diabetes. , 1986, Health psychology : official journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association.

[15]  F. Kaufman,et al.  Association Between Diabetes Control and Visits to a Multidisciplinary Pediatric Diabetes Clinic , 1999, Pediatrics.

[16]  J. Skyler,et al.  Developmental and Behavioral Aspects of Diabetes Management in Youngsters , 1990 .

[17]  Peter P. Morgan,et al.  Compliance in Health Care , 1979 .

[18]  Sylvie Naar-King,et al.  The role of parental monitoring in adolescent health outcomes: impact on regimen adherence in youth with type 1 diabetes. , 2007, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[19]  Margaret Grey,et al.  Depression in type 1 diabetes in children: natural history and correlates. , 2002, Journal of psychosomatic research.

[20]  Philip Hougaard,et al.  Comparison of Metabolic Control in a Cross-Sectional Study of 2,873 Children and Adolescents With IDDM from 18 Countries , 1997, Diabetes Care.

[21]  Dennis Drotar,et al.  The relationship between parent-reported social support and adherence to medical treatment in families of adolescents with type 1 diabetes. , 2006, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[22]  Sabine Landau,et al.  Psychological interventions to improve glycaemic control in patients with type 1 diabetes: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials , 2006, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[23]  B. Anderson,et al.  Care of children and adolescents with type 1 diabetes: a statement of the American Diabetes Association. , 2005, Diabetes care.

[24]  Diabetes Control.  Effect of intensive diabetes treatment on the development and progression of long-term complications in adolescents with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus: Diabetes Control and Complications Trial. Diabetes Control and Complications Trial Research Group. , 1994, The Journal of pediatrics.

[25]  K. Williams,et al.  Temperament characteristics and clinical outcomes in young children with diabetes mellitus. , 1990, Journal of child psychology and psychiatry, and allied disciplines.

[26]  L. Laffel,et al.  The Impact of Physiological, Therapeutic and Psychosocial Variables on Glycemic Control in Youth with Type 1 Diabetes Mellitus , 2004, Journal of pediatric endocrinology & metabolism : JPEM.

[27]  N. White,et al.  Adolescents with diabetes from single-parent, blended, and intact families: Health-related and family functioning. , 1999 .

[28]  S. Henggeler,et al.  Family system variables and the health status of adolescents with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. , 1989, Health psychology : official journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association.

[29]  A. Connell,et al.  Family conflict, adherence, and glycaemic control in youth with short duration Type 1 diabetes , 2002, Diabetic medicine : a journal of the British Diabetic Association.

[30]  A. La Greca,et al.  Parenting styles, regimen adherence, and glycemic control in 4- to 10-year-old children with diabetes. , 2001, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[31]  T. Skinner,et al.  Behavioral Interventions for Adolescents With Type 1 Diabetes , 2000 .

[32]  F. Ovalle,et al.  Continuous Glucose Monitoring and Intensive Treatment of Type 1 Diabetes , 2009 .

[33]  B. Anderson,et al.  Temporal trends in the treatment of pediatric type 1 diabetes and impact on acute outcomes. , 2007, The Journal of pediatrics.

[34]  E. Dubow,et al.  Contribution of Coping to Medical Adjustment and Treatment Responsibility among Children and Adolescents with Diabetes , 1994, Journal of developmental and behavioral pediatrics : JDBP.

[35]  S. Johnson,et al.  A longitudinal analysis of adherence and health status in childhood diabetes. , 1992, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[36]  B. Buckingham,et al.  Self-care behaviors in insulin-dependent diabetes: evaluative tools and their associations with glycemic control. , 1996, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[37]  T. Wysocki,et al.  Associations of paternal involvement in disease management with maternal and family outcomes in families with children with chronic illness. , 2006, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[38]  C. Donaldson,et al.  Predictors of treatment adherence in young children with type 1 diabetes. , 2007, Journal of advanced nursing.

[39]  H. Dorchy,et al.  Glycated Hemoglobin and Related Factors in Diabetic Children and Adolescents Under 18 Years of Age: a Belgian Experience , 1997, Diabetes Care.

[40]  The Relationship of Glycemic Exposure (HbA1c) to the Risk of Development and Progression of Retinopathy in the Diabetes Control and Complications Trial , 1995, Diabetes.

[41]  H. Szajewska,et al.  Continuous subcutaneous insulin infusion vs. multiple daily injections in children with type 1 diabetes: a systematic review and meta‐analysis of randomized control trials , 2009, Pediatric diabetes.

[42]  B. Anderson,et al.  Parental involvement in diabetes management tasks: relationships to blood glucose monitoring adherence and metabolic control in young adolescents with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. , 1997, The Journal of pediatrics.

[43]  S. Schroeder.  Shattuck Lecture. We can do better--improving the health of the American people. , 2007, The New England journal of medicine.

[44]  N. Tubiana-Rufi,et al.  Is the relationship between adherence behaviours and glycaemic control bi‐directional at adolescence? A longitudinal cohort study , 2005, Diabetic medicine : a journal of the British Diabetic Association.

[45]  W. Tamborlane,et al.  Continuous subcutaneous insulin infusion (CSII) in children with type 1 diabetes. , 2006, Diabetes research and clinical practice.

[46]  Norman Fleischer,et al.  The effect of intensive treatment of diabetes on the development and progression of long-term complications in insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. The Diabetes Control and Complications Trial Research Group. , 1993 .

[47]  Mark W. Lipsey,et al.  Practical Meta-Analysis , 2000 .

[48]  Victoria A. Miller,et al.  Decision-making competence and adherence to treatment in adolescents with diabetes. , 2006, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[49]  N. White,et al.  Disparity in Glycemic Control and Adherence Between African-American and Caucasian Youths With Diabetes: Family and community contexts , 1997, Diabetes Care.

[50]  W. Tamborlane,et al.  Impaired insulin action in puberty. A contributing factor to poor glycemic control in adolescents with diabetes. , 1986, The New England journal of medicine.

[51]  J. Weissberg-Benchell,et al.  Insulin pump therapy: a meta-analysis. , 2003, Diabetes care.

[52]  F. Leturcq,et al.  Improvement of Diabetic Control and Acceptability of a Three-Injection Insulin Regimen in Diabetic Adolescents: A multicenter controlled study , 1993, Diabetes Care.

[53]  C. Davis,et al.  Brief Report : Parenting Styles , Regimen Adherence , and Glycemic Control in 4to 10-Year-Old Children With Diabetes , 2001 .

[54]  B. Zinman,et al.  Effect of Glycemic Exposure on the Risk of Microvascular Complications in the Diabetes Control and Complications Trial—Revisited , 2008, Diabetes.

[55]  Victoria A. Miller,et al.  Discrepancies between mother and adolescent perceptions of diabetes-related decision-making autonomy and their relationship to diabetes-related conflict and adherence to treatment. , 2003, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[56]  C. Berg,et al.  Children's appraisals of maternal involvement in coping with diabetes: enhancing our understanding of adherence, metabolic control, and quality of life across adolescence. , 2005, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[57]  E. Storch,et al.  The relation between family factors and metabolic control: the role of diabetes adherence. , 2006, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[58]  T. Templin,et al.  Gender differences in adherence and metabolic control in urban youth with poorly controlled type 1 diabetes: the mediating role of mental health symptoms. , 2006, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[59]  Russell E Glasgow,et al.  Adherence to IDDM Regimens: Relationship to Psychosocial Variables and Metabolic Control , 1983, Diabetes Care.

[60]  E. Cohen,et al.  We Can Do Better — Improving the Health of the American People , 2008 .

[61]  Xiao-Hua Zhou,et al.  Statistical Methods for Meta‐Analysis , 2008 .

[62]  S. Genuth,et al.  Insights from the diabetes control and complications trial/epidemiology of diabetes interventions and complications study on the use of intensive glycemic treatment to reduce the risk of complications of type 1 diabetes. , 2006, Endocrine practice : official journal of the American College of Endocrinology and the American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists.

[63]  M. Kovács,et al.  Major Depressive Disorder in Youths With IDDM: A controlled prospective study of course and outcome , 1997, Diabetes Care.

[64]  E. Northam,et al.  Interventions to promote optimal health outcomes in children with Type 1 diabetes—are they effective? , 2006, Diabetic medicine : a journal of the British Diabetic Association.