Do Highlights Affect Comprehension?: Lessons from a User Study

A largely unquestioned assumption in social reading is that publicly shared annotations improve reading outcomes. In this study, we explore the specific assumption that relevant and irrelevant passive highlighting affects comprehension. Participants were divided by cognitive style based on their degree of Field Dependence-Independence [20]. We found that irrelevant highlights had significant negative effects on reading comprehension for Field Independents (FIs), but not Field Dependents (FDs). This is a surprising result because FDs typically rely on external cues to structure and help process information, whereas FIs use internal cues. This suggests that highlighting cues information but does not structure it.

[1]  L. Goldberger,et al.  Field Dependence and Short-Term Memory , 1979, Perceptual and motor skills.

[2]  James M. Royer.  The Sentence Verification Technique: A Practical Procedure for Testing Comprehension. , 1987 .

[3]  D R Goodenough,et al.  Cognitive styles: essence and origins. Field dependence and field independence. , 1981, Psychological issues.

[4]  V. Shipman,et al.  Cognitive Styles: Some Conceptual, Methodological, and Applied Issues , 1985 .

[5]  Raylene Reese,et al.  How users read on the web , 2013 .

[6]  R. Fowler,et al.  Effectiveness of highlighting for retention of text material. , 1974 .

[7]  H. A. Witkin.  A Manual for the embedded figures tests , 1971 .

[8]  Sherrie L. Nist,et al.  The Role of Underlining and Annotating in Remembering Textual Information. , 1987 .

[9]  R. F. Lorch,et al.  Effects of Typographical Cues on Reading and Recall of Text , 1995 .

[10]  Ed H. Chi,et al.  Visual Foraging of Highlighted Text: An Eye-Tracking Study , 2007, HCI.

[11]  Walter Kintsch,et al.  Comprehension: A Paradigm for Cognition , 1998 .

[12]  R. Kozma,et al.  Individuality in learning. , 1978 .

[13]  H. A. Witkin.  Psychological differentiation; studies of development , 1974 .

[14]  Catherine C. Marshall,et al.  Annotation: from paper books to the digital library , 1997, DL '97.

[15]  S. A. Karp,et al.  Psychological Differentiation: Studies of Development , 1963 .

[16]  D. Goodenough.  The role of individual differences in field dependence as a factor in learning and memory. , 1975, Psychological bulletin.

[17]  Kathryn F. Cochran,et al.  An information processing view of field dependence‐independence∗ , 1989 .

[18]  R. F. Lorch,et al.  Text-signaling devices and their effects on reading and memory processes , 1989 .

[19]  H. V. Restorff.  Über die Wirkung von Bereichsbildungen im Spurenfeld , 1933 .

[20]  Lynna J. Ausburn,et al.  Cognitive styles: Some information and implications for instructional design , 1978 .

[21]  S. A. Karp,et al.  Differentiation: Studies of development. , 1962 .

[22]  David S. Kreiner,et al.  The effects of pre‐existing inappropriate highlighting on reading comprehension , 1997 .

[23]  Herman A. Witkin,et al.  PSYCHOLOGICAL DIFFERENTIATION: CURRENT STATUS , 1977 .