Improved detection of pulmonary nodules on energy-subtracted chest radiographs with a commercial computer-aided diagnosis software: comparison with human observers

ObjectiveTo retrospectively analyze the performance of a commercial computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) software in the detection of pulmonary nodules in original and energy-subtracted (ES) chest radiographs.MethodsOriginal and ES chest radiographs of 58 patients with 105 pulmonary nodules measuring 5–30 mm and images of 25 control subjects with no nodules were randomized. Five blinded readers evaluated firstly the original postero-anterior images alone and then together with the subtracted radiographs. In a second phase, original and ES images were analyzed by a commercial CAD program. CT was used as reference standard. CAD results were compared to the readers’ findings. True-positive (TP) and false-positive (FP) findings with CAD on subtracted and non-subtracted images were compared.ResultsDepending on the reader’s experience, CAD detected between 11 and 21 nodules missed by readers. Human observers found three to 16 lesions missed by the CAD software. CAD used with ES images produced significantly fewer FPs than with non-subtracted images: 1.75 and 2.14 FPs per image, respectively (p = 0.029). The difference for the TP nodules was not significant (40 nodules on ES images and 34 lesions in non-subtracted radiographs, p = 0.142).ConclusionCAD can improve lesion detection both on energy subtracted and non-subtracted chest images, especially for less experienced readers. The CAD program marked less FPs on energy-subtracted images than on original chest radiographs.

[1]  Douglas C McCrory,et al.  Screening for lung cancer: a review of the current literature. , 2003, Chest.

[2]  Frank Fischbach,et al.  Clinical results of CsI-detector-based dual-exposure dual energy in chest radiography , 2003, European Radiology.

[3]  Kunio Doi,et al.  Computer-aided diagnosis to distinguish benign from malignant solitary pulmonary nodules on radiographs: ROC analysis of radiologists' performance--initial experience. , 2003, Radiology.

[4]  A. Porcel,et al.  Characteristics of missed lung cancer on chest radiographs: a French experience , 2001, European Radiology.

[5]  Shoji Kido,et al.  Detection of simulated pulmonary nodules by single-exposure dual-energy computed radiography of the chest: effect of a computer-aided diagnosis system (Part 2). , 2002, European journal of radiology.

[6]  K. Doi,et al.  Effect of a computer-aided diagnosis scheme on radiologists' performance in detection of lung nodules on radiographs. , 1996, Radiology.

[7]  K. Doi,et al.  Lung cancers missed on chest radiographs: results obtained with a commercial computer-aided detection program. , 2008, Radiology.

[8]  J T Ho,et al.  Comparison of dual-energy and conventional chest radiography for nodule detection. , 1989, Investigative radiology.

[9]  M. Giger,et al.  Potential usefulness of computerized nodule detection in screening programs for lung cancer. , 1992, Investigative radiology.

[10]  M. L. R. D. Christenson,et al.  Guidelines for Management of Small Pulmonary Nodules Detected on CT Scans: A Statement From the Fleischner Society , 2006 .

[11]  Max A. Viergever,et al.  Computer-aided diagnosis in chest radiography: a survey , 2001, IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging.

[12]  Catherine Beigelman-Aubry,et al.  Management of an incidentally discovered pulmonary nodule , 2007, European Radiology.

[13]  B J Flehinger,et al.  Non-small-cell lung cancer: results of the New York screening program. , 1984, Radiology.

[14]  Ehsan Samei,et al.  Recent advances in chest radiography. , 2006, Radiology.

[15]  Elmar Kotter,et al.  Comparison of Radiologist and CAD Performance in the Detection of CT-confirmed Subtle Pulmonary Nodules on Digital Chest Radiographs , 2008, Investigative radiology.

[16]  J W Oestmann,et al.  "Single-exposure" dual energy digital radiography in the detection of pulmonary nodules and calcifications. , 1989, Investigative radiology.

[17]  K. Doi,et al.  Computer-aided diagnosis of pulmonary nodules: results of a large-scale observer test. , 1999, Radiology.

[18]  J. V. van Engelshoven,et al.  Miss rate of lung cancer on the chest radiograph in clinical practice. , 1999, Chest.

[19]  C. Henschke,et al.  Managing the small pulmonary nodule discovered by CT. , 2004, Chest.

[20]  S J Swensen,et al.  A Consensus Statement of the Society of Thoracic Radiology: Screening for Lung Cancer with Helical Computed Tomography , 2001, Journal of thoracic imaging.

[21]  Peter Vock,et al.  Single-exposure dual-energy subtraction chest radiography: Detection of pulmonary nodules and masses in clinical practice , 2007, European Radiology.

[22]  H L Kundel,et al.  Predictive value and threshold detectability of lung tumors. , 1981, Radiology.

[23]  J. V. van Engelshoven,et al.  Detection of lung cancer on the chest radiograph: a study on observer performance. , 2001, European journal of radiology.