Competing to Be Certain (But Wrong): Market Dynamics and Excessive Confidence in Judgment

In this paper, we investigate how market competition contributes to the expression of overconfidence among those competing for influence. We find evidence that market competition exacerbates the tendency to express excessive confidence. This evidence comes from experiments in which advisors attempt to sell their advice. In the first, advisors must compete with other advice sellers. In the second, advisors and their customers are paired. Advisors are overconfident in both studies and it helps advisors sell their advice. However, competition between advisors in the market further exacerbates overconfidence. In a third study, we demonstrate that the market competition drives overconfidence even when advisors vary in quality. We also investigate the strategic expressions and interpretations of confidence by both sides in the exchange. This paper was accepted by Peter Wakker, decision analysis.

[1]  Dean P. Foster,et al.  Graininess of judgment under uncertainty: An accuracy-informativeness trade-off , 1995 .

[2]  James J. Lindsay,et al.  The Accuracy-Confidence Correlation in the Detection of Deception , 1997, Personality and social psychology review : an official journal of the Society for Personality and Social Psychology, Inc.

[3]  D. Moore,et al.  Use of absolute and comparative performance feedback in absolute and comparative judgments and decisions , 2008 .

[4]  Kevin A. Hassett,et al.  Dow 36,000: The New Strategy for Profiting From the Coming Rise in the Stock Market , 1999 .

[5]  R. N. Kanungo,et al.  Toward a Behavioral Theory of Charismatic Leadership in Organizational Settings , 1987 .

[6]  R. J. House,et al.  Does Leadership Matter? CEO Leadership Attributes and Profitability under Conditions of Perceived Environmental Uncertainty. , 2001 .

[7]  Janet A. Sniezek,et al.  Cueing and Cognitive Conflict in Judge-Advisor Decision Making , 1995 .

[8]  B. Bornstein,et al.  " I know I know it, I know I saw it": The stability of the confidence–accuracy relationship across domains , 1999 .

[9]  Ilan Yaniv,et al.  Overconfidence in interval estimates: What does expertise buy you? , 2008 .

[10]  Jeffrey Pfeffer,et al.  The Ambiguity of Leadership , 1977 .

[11]  Thomas E. Ricks.  Fiasco: The American Military Adventure in Iraq , 2006 .

[12]  Dhananjay K. Gode,et al.  Allocative Efficiency of Markets with Zero-Intelligence Traders: Market as a Partial Substitute for Individual Rationality , 1993, Journal of Political Economy.

[13]  Eric R. Stone,et al.  Intuitive evaluation of likelihood judgment producers: evidence for a confidence heuristic , 2004 .

[14]  Sanford B. Ehrlich,et al.  Small Groups: Key Readings , 2006 .

[15]  Barry M. Staw,et al.  Lend me your wallets: the effect of charismatic leadership on external support for an organization , 2004 .

[16]  R. Selten.  Axiomatic Characterization of the Quadratic Scoring Rule , 1998 .

[17]  Michael Maccoby.  Searching for a Corporate Savior: The Irrational Quest for Charismatic CEOs , 2004 .

[18]  Robert J. MacCoun,et al.  The benefits of knowing what you know (and what you don’t): How calibration affects credibility , 2008 .

[19]  D. A. Kenny,et al.  The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations. , 1986, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[20]  Robert L. Winkler,et al.  Probability Elicitation, Scoring Rules, and Competition Among Forecasters , 2007, Manag. Sci..

[21]  Reid Hastie,et al.  Calibration Trumps Confidence as a Basis for Witness Credibility , 2006, Psychological science.

[22]  Elizabeth A. Olson,et al.  Eyewitness testimony. , 2003, Annual review of psychology.

[23]  Jeffrey C. Kohles,et al.  Romance of Leadership , 2009 .

[24]  Mathew L. A. Hayward,et al.  Explaining the Premiums Paid for Large Acquisitions: Evidence of CEO Hubris , 1997 .

[25]  R. Thaler,et al.  Financial Decision-Making in Markets and Firms: A Behavioral Perspective , 1994 .

[26]  Ulrike Malmendier,et al.  CEO Overconfidence and Corporate Investment , 2002 .

[27]  Joshua Klayman,et al.  Overconfidence in interval estimates. , 2004, Journal of experimental psychology. Learning, memory, and cognition.

[28]  Janet A. Sniezek,et al.  Trust, Confidence, and Expertise in a Judge-Advisor System. , 2001, Organizational behavior and human decision processes.

[29]  Harvey F. Kolodny,et al.  A 1976 THEORY OF CHARISMATIC LEADERSHIP , 2011 .

[30]  D. Moore,et al.  The trouble with overconfidence. , 2008, Psychological review.

[31]  Dean P. Foster,et al.  Precision and Accuracy of Judgmental Estimation , 1997 .

[32]  George A. Akerlof.  The Market for “Lemons”: Quality Uncertainty and the Market Mechanism , 1970 .

[33]  C. Anderson,et al.  Why do dominant personalities attain influence in face-to-face groups? The competence-signaling effects of trait dominance. , 2009, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[34]  Derek J. Koehler,et al.  Heuristics and Biases: The Calibration of Expert Judgment: Heuristics and Biases Beyond the Laboratory , 2002 .

[35]  Henry Mintzberg,et al.  VISIONARY LEADERSHIP AND STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT , 1989 .

[36]  S. Huffmon.  Expert Political Judgment: How Good Is It? How Can We Know? , 2006 .

[37]  C. A. Holt,et al.  5. Industrial Organization: A Survey of Laboratory Research , 1995 .

[38]  James G. Hunt,et al.  Leadership : the cutting edge : a symposium held at Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, October 27-28, 1976 , 1977 .

[39]  John Micklethwait,et al.  The Witch Doctors: Making Sense of the Management Gurus , 1996 .

[40]  Neil Brewer,et al.  The confidence-accuracy relationship in eyewitness identification: effects of lineup instructions, foil similarity, and target-absent base rates. , 2006, Journal of experimental psychology. Applied.

[41]  Philip J. Cook,et al.  The Winner-Take-All Society: Why the Few at the Top Get So Much More Than the Rest of Us , 1996 .

[42]  R. S. Meyers.  Managing With Power: Politics and Influence in Organizations , 1992 .

[43]  Steven E. Daniels,et al.  When Talk Is Not Cheap: Substantive Penance and Expressions of Intent in Rebuilding Cooperation , 2002, Organ. Sci..

[44]  D. Stephen Lindsay,et al.  Accuracy and Confidence in Person Identification: The Relationship Is Strong When Witnessing Conditions Vary Widely , 1998 .

[45]  Dean A. Shepherd,et al.  A Hubris Theory of Entrepreneurship , 2006, Manag. Sci..