Comparison of weight loss among named diet programs in overweight and obese adults: a meta-analysis.

IMPORTANCE Many claims have been made regarding the superiority of one diet or another for inducing weight loss. Which diet is best remains unclear. OBJECTIVE To determine weight loss outcomes for popular diets based on diet class (macronutrient composition) and named diet. DATA SOURCES Search of 6 electronic databases: AMED, CDSR, CENTRAL, CINAHL, EMBASE, and MEDLINE from inception of each database to April 2014. STUDY SELECTION Overweight or obese adults (body mass index ≥25) randomized to a popular self-administered named diet and reporting weight or body mass index data at 3-month follow-up or longer. DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS Two reviewers independently extracted data on populations, interventions, outcomes, risk of bias, and quality of evidence. A Bayesian framework was used to perform a series of random-effects network meta-analyses with meta-regression to estimate the relative effectiveness of diet classes and programs for change in weight and body mass index from baseline. Our analyses adjusted for behavioral support and exercise. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES Weight loss and body mass index at 6- and 12-month follow-up (±3 months for both periods). RESULTS Among 59 eligible articles reporting 48 unique randomized trials (including 7286 individuals) and compared with no diet, the largest weight loss was associated with low-carbohydrate diets (8.73 kg [95% credible interval {CI}, 7.27 to 10.20 kg] at 6-month follow-up and 7.25 kg [95% CI, 5.33 to 9.25 kg] at 12-month follow-up) and low-fat diets (7.99 kg [95% CI, 6.01 to 9.92 kg] at 6-month follow-up and 7.27 kg [95% CI, 5.26 to 9.34 kg] at 12-month follow-up). Weight loss differences between individual diets were minimal. For example, the Atkins diet resulted in a 1.71 kg greater weight loss than the Zone diet at 6-month follow-up. Between 6- and 12-month follow-up, the influence of behavioral support (3.23 kg [95% CI, 2.23 to 4.23 kg] at 6-month follow-up vs 1.08 kg [95% CI, -1.82 to 3.96 kg] at 12-month follow-up) and exercise (0.64 kg [95% CI, -0.35 to 1.66 kg] vs 2.13 kg [95% CI, 0.43 to 3.85 kg], respectively) on weight loss differed. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE Significant weight loss was observed with any low-carbohydrate or low-fat diet. Weight loss differences between individual named diets were small. This supports the practice of recommending any diet that a patient will adhere to in order to lose weight.

[1]  G. Lu,et al.  Assessing Evidence Inconsistency in Mixed Treatment Comparisons , 2006 .

[2]  E. Evans,et al.  A moderate-protein diet produces sustained weight loss and long-term changes in body composition and blood lipids in obese adults. , 2009, The Journal of nutrition.

[3]  S. Daniels,et al.  A randomized trial comparing a very low carbohydrate diet and a calorie-restricted low fat diet on body weight and cardiovascular risk factors in healthy women. , 2003, The Journal of clinical endocrinology and metabolism.

[4]  D. Ryan,et al.  The state of obesity and obesity research. , 2010, JAMA.

[5]  B. Schirmer,et al.  The effect of a low-carbohydrate, high-protein diet on post laparoscopic gastric bypass weight loss: a prospective randomized trial. , 2007, The Journal of surgical research.

[6]  J. Hayano,et al.  Exercise and weight loss reduce blood pressure in men and women with mild hypertension: effects on cardiovascular, metabolic, and hemodynamic functioning. , 2000, Archives of internal medicine.

[7]  B. Appelhans,et al.  A call for an end to the diet debates. , 2013, JAMA.

[8]  Julia A. Ello-Martin,et al.  Dietary energy density in the treatment of obesity: a year-long trial comparing 2 weight-loss diets. , 2007, The American journal of clinical nutrition.

[9]  J. DeLany,et al.  Long-term effects of 2 energy-restricted diets differing in glycemic load on dietary adherence, body composition, and metabolism in CALERIE: a 1-y randomized controlled trial. , 2007, The American journal of clinical nutrition.

[10]  G. Guyatt,et al.  GRADE guidelines: 4. Rating the quality of evidence--study limitations (risk of bias). , 2011, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[11]  R. Wing,et al.  Combining behavioral weight loss treatment and a commercial program: A randomized clinical trial , 2012, Obesity.

[12]  Lisa Hartling,et al.  Risk of bias versus quality assessment of randomised controlled trials: cross sectional study , 2009, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[13]  Effects of hypocaloric diet, low-intensity resistance exercise with slow movement, or both on aortic hemodynamics and muscle mass in obese postmenopausal women , 2013, Menopause.

[14]  M. Egger,et al.  The hazards of scoring the quality of clinical trials for meta-analysis. , 1999, JAMA.

[15]  D L Sackett,et al.  Users' Guides to the Medical Literature: XIX. Applying clinical trial results B. Guidelines for determining whether a drug is exerting (more than) a class effect. , 1999, JAMA.

[16]  W. Kraemer,et al.  Effects of dietary carbohydrate restriction versus low-fat diet on flow-mediated dilation. , 2009, Metabolism: clinical and experimental.

[17]  Ethan M Balk,et al.  Influence of Reported Study Design Characteristics on Intervention Effect Estimates From Randomized, Controlled Trials , 2012, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[18]  C. Rock,et al.  Effect of a free prepared meal and incentivized weight loss program on weight loss and weight loss maintenance in obese and overweight women: a randomized controlled trial. , 2010, JAMA.

[19]  Comparison of the Atkins, Zone, Ornish, and LEARN Diets for Change in Weight and Related Risk Factors Among Overweight Premenopausal Women: The A TO Z Weight Loss Study: A Randomized Trial , 2007 .

[20]  Kristian Thorlund,et al.  How to use an article reporting a multiple treatment comparison meta-analysis. , 2012, JAMA.

[21]  C. Apovian,et al.  Consuming a hypocaloric high fat low carbohydrate diet for 12 weeks lowers C-reactive protein, and raises serum adiponectin and high density lipoprotein-cholesterol in obese subjects. , 2013, Metabolism: clinical and experimental.

[22]  D. Almirall,et al.  Effects of two weight-loss diets on health-related quality of life , 2009, Quality of Life Research.

[23]  James M Robins,et al.  Randomized Trials Analyzed as Observational Studies , 2013, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[24]  S. Aldana,et al.  The Effects of an Intensive Lifestyle Modification Program on Carotid Artery Intima-Media Thickness: A Randomized Trial , 2007, American journal of health promotion : AJHP.

[25]  D. Rader,et al.  A randomized trial of a low-carbohydrate diet for obesity. , 2003, The New England journal of medicine.

[26]  F. Hu,et al.  Weight-loss diets modify glucose-dependent insulinotropic polypeptide receptor rs2287019 genotype effects on changes in body weight, fasting glucose, and insulin resistance: the Preventing Overweight Using Novel Dietary Strategies trial. , 2012, The American journal of clinical nutrition.

[27]  J. King,et al.  Popular diets: a scientific review. , 2001, Obesity research.

[28]  Robert F Kushner,et al.  2013 AHA/ACC/TOS guideline for the management of overweight and obesity in adults: a report of the American College of Cardiology/American Heart Association Task Force on Practice Guidelines and The Obesity Society. , 2014, Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

[29]  C. Ebbeling,et al.  Effects of a low-glycemic load vs low-fat diet in obese young adults: a randomized trial. , 2007, JAMA.

[30]  G. Brinkworth,et al.  Long-term effects of a very low-carbohydrate diet and a low-fat diet on mood and cognitive function. , 2009, Archives of internal medicine.

[31]  J. Blundell,et al.  Weight, Protein, Fat, and Timing of Preloads Affect Food Intake , 1997, Physiology & Behavior.

[32]  Howard Balshem,et al.  GRADE guidelines: 3. Rating the quality of evidence. , 2011, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[33]  G. Brinkworth,et al.  Effects of a Low Carbohydrate Weight Loss Diet on Exercise Capacity and Tolerance in Obese Subjects , 2009, Obesity.

[34]  R. Boileau,et al.  Dietary protein and exercise have additive effects on body composition during weight loss in adult women. , 2005, The Journal of nutrition.

[35]  R. Wing,et al.  Lifestyle Intervention in Overweight Individuals With a Family History of Diabetes , 1998, Diabetes Care.

[36]  G. Brinkworth,et al.  Metabolic effects of weight loss on a very-low-carbohydrate diet compared with an isocaloric high-carbohydrate diet in abdominally obese subjects. , 2008, Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

[37]  M. Noakes,et al.  Psychological benefits of a high-protein, low-carbohydrate diet in obese women with polycystic ovary syndrome—A pilot study , 2007, Appetite.

[38]  K. Resch.  [Dietary Intervention Randomized Controlled Trial (DIRECT) group: weight loss with a low-carbohydrate, Mediterranean, or low-fat diet]. , 2008, Forschende Komplementarmedizin.

[39]  Stanley Heshka,et al.  Weight loss with self-help compared with a structured commercial program: a randomized trial. , 2003, JAMA.

[40]  E. Gracely,et al.  A low-carbohydrate as compared with a low-fat diet in severe obesity. , 2003, The New England journal of medicine.

[41]  Adrian P Mander,et al.  Primary care referral to a commercial provider for weight loss treatment versus standard care: a randomised controlled trial , 2011, The Lancet.

[42]  C C Curioni,et al.  Long-term weight loss after diet and exercise: a systematic review , 2005, International Journal of Obesity.

[43]  W. Satz,et al.  The Effects of a Commercially Available Weight Loss Program among Obese Patients with Type 2 Diabetes: A Randomized Study , 2009, Postgraduate medicine.

[44]  Thomas Wadden,et al.  Systematic Review: An Evaluation of Major Commercial Weight Loss Programs in the United States , 2005, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[45]  M. Livingstone,et al.  Randomised controlled trial of four commercial weight loss programmes in the UK: initial findings from the BBC “diet trials” , 2006, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[46]  Deborah F Tate,et al.  A self-regulation program for maintenance of weight loss. , 2006, The New England journal of medicine.

[47]  P. Freedson,et al.  Improved psychological well-being, quality of life, and health practices in moderately overweight women participating in a 12-week structured weight loss program. , 1998, Obesity research.

[48]  J. Sterne,et al.  The Cochrane Collaboration’s tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials , 2011, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[49]  K. J. Smith,et al.  Comparison of high-fat and high-protein diets with a high-carbohydrate diet in insulin-resistant obese women , 2004, Diabetologia.

[50]  K. Macleod,et al.  Short‐term effects of severe dietary carbohydrate‐restriction advice in Type 2 diabetes—a randomized controlled trial , 2006, Diabetic medicine : a journal of the British Diabetic Association.

[51]  M. Noakes,et al.  Effects of energy-restricted diets containing increased protein on weight loss, resting energy expenditure, and the thermic effect of feeding in type 2 diabetes. , 2002, Diabetes care.

[52]  William Caplan,et al.  Weight-loss outcomes: a systematic review and meta-analysis of weight-loss clinical trials with a minimum 1-year follow-up. , 2007, Journal of the American Dietetic Association.

[53]  J. Wylie-Rosett,et al.  Comparative Study of the Effects of a 1-Year Dietary Intervention of a Low-Carbohydrate Diet Versus a Low-Fat Diet on Weight and Glycemic Control in Type 2 Diabetes , 2009, Diabetes Care.

[54]  W. Kraemer,et al.  Carbohydrate Restriction has a More Favorable Impact on the Metabolic Syndrome than a Low Fat Diet , 2009, Lipids.

[55]  E. Evans,et al.  Moderate carbohydrate, moderate protein weight loss diet reduces cardiovascular disease risk compared to high carbohydrate, low protein diet in obese adults: A randomized clinical trial , 2008, Nutrition & metabolism.

[56]  Peymane Adab,et al.  Comparison of range of commercial or primary care led weight reduction programmes with minimal intervention control for weight loss in obesity: Lighten Up randomised controlled trial , 2011, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[57]  A. Stopeck,et al.  Changes in Body Weight and Metabolic Indexes in Overweight Breast Cancer Survivors Enrolled in a Randomized Trial of Low-Fat vs. Reduced Carbohydrate Diets , 2010, Nutrition and cancer.

[58]  M. Noakes,et al.  Effect of a high-protein, energy-restricted diet on body composition, glycemic control, and lipid concentrations in overweight and obese hyperinsulinemic men and women. , 2003, The American journal of clinical nutrition.

[59]  T. Dudley,et al.  Effect of a low-carbohydrate, ketogenic diet program compared to a low-fat diet on fasting lipoprotein subclasses. , 2006, International journal of cardiology.

[60]  K. Fox,et al.  Comparison of the effects of four commercially available weight-loss programmes on lipid-based cardiovascular risk factors , 2009, Public Health Nutrition.

[61]  W. Yancy,et al.  A Low-Carbohydrate, Ketogenic Diet versus a Low-Fat Diet To Treat Obesity and Hyperlipidemia , 2004, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[62]  J. Griffith,et al.  Comparison of the Atkins, Ornish, Weight Watchers, and Zone diets for weight loss and heart disease risk reduction: a randomized trial. , 2005, JAMA.

[63]  L. Darga,et al.  Combining weight-loss counseling with the weight watchers plan for obese breast cancer survivors. , 2002, Obesity research.

[64]  T. Wadden,et al.  A randomized controlled trial of a commercial internet weight loss program. , 2004, Obesity research.

[65]  M. Stampfer,et al.  Weight loss with a low-carbohydrate, Mediterranean, or low-fat diet. , 2008, The New England journal of medicine.

[66]  G. Brinkworth,et al.  Long-term effects of a high-protein, low-carbohydrate diet on weight control and cardiovascular risk markers in obese hyperinsulinemic subjects , 2004, International Journal of Obesity.

[67]  N. Laird,et al.  Meta-analysis in clinical trials. , 1986, Controlled clinical trials.

[68]  M. Noakes,et al.  Effect of a high-protein, energy-restricted diet on weight loss and energy expenditure after weight stabilization in hyperinsulinemic subjects , 2003, International Journal of Obesity.

[69]  M. Gladis,et al.  Dieting and the development of eating disorders in obese women: results of a randomized controlled trial. , 2004, The American journal of clinical nutrition.

[70]  J. Foreyt,et al.  Nondieting versus dieting treatment for overweight binge-eating women. , 1998, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[71]  T. Wadden,et al.  Weight and Metabolic Outcomes After 2 Years on a Low-Carbohydrate Versus Low-Fat Diet , 2010, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[72]  Screening for obesity in adults: recommendations and rationale. , 2004, American family physician.

[73]  Reneé H Moore,et al.  Effects of a Low‐intensity Intervention That Prescribed a Low‐carbohydrate vs. a Low‐fat Diet in Obese, Diabetic Participants , 2010, Obesity.

[74]  G. Brinkworth,et al.  Long-term effects of advice to consume a high-protein, low-fat diet, rather than a conventional weight-loss diet, in obese adults with Type 2 diabetes: one-year follow-up of a randomised trial , 2004, Diabetologia.

[75]  C. Rock,et al.  Randomized Trial of a Multifaceted Commercial Weight Loss Program , 2007, Obesity.

[76]  F. Greenway,et al.  Self-help weight loss versus a structured commercial program after 26 weeks: a randomized controlled study. , 2000, The American journal of medicine.

[77]  S. Daniels,et al.  The role of energy expenditure in the differential weight loss in obese women on low-fat and low-carbohydrate diets. , 2005, The Journal of clinical endocrinology and metabolism.

[78]  E. Gracely,et al.  The Effects of Low-Carbohydrate versus Conventional Weight Loss Diets in Severely Obese Adults: One-Year Follow-up of a Randomized Trial , 2004, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[79]  R. Boileau,et al.  A reduced ratio of dietary carbohydrate to protein improves body composition and blood lipid profiles during weight loss in adult women. , 2003, The Journal of nutrition.

[80]  M. Noakes,et al.  Effect of a high-protein, high-monounsaturated fat weight loss diet on glycemic control and lipid levels in type 2 diabetes. , 2002, Diabetes care.

[81]  Elroy J. Aguiar,et al.  A 12-Week Commercial Web-Based Weight-Loss Program for Overweight and Obese Adults: Randomized Controlled Trial Comparing Basic Versus Enhanced Features , 2012, Journal of medical Internet research.

[82]  W. Yancy,et al.  The effect of a low-carbohydrate, ketogenic diet versus a low-glycemic index diet on glycemic control in type 2 diabetes mellitus , 2008, Nutrition & metabolism.