Comparison of the ellipsis-based theory of non-constituent coordination with its alternatives

In this paper, I compare the ellipsis-based theory of non-constituent coordination proposed in Yatabe (2001) with three of its alternatives, namely the theory that has been widely accepted within the context of Categorial Grammar, Mouret’s HPSG-based theory, and the theory proposed by Bachrach and Katzir in the framework of the Minimalist Program. It is found (i) that the CG-based theory of non-constituent coordination cannot deal with medial RNR, i.e. a subset of right-node raising constructions in which either all or a part of the right-node-raised material is realized at a location other than the right edge of the final conjunct, (ii) that Mouret’s theory encounters similar difficulties when applied to RNR, and (iii) that Bachrach and Katzir’s theory cannot be applied to left-node raising in English, has difficulty capturing the semantic inertness of medial RNR, and overgenerates in several ways. The ellipsis-based theory, on the other hand, appears to be consistent with all the observations.

[1]  Anne Abeillé,et al.  On the Rule of Right-Node-Raising in French , 2011 .

[2]  François Mouret,et al.  A phrase structure approach to argument cluster coordination , 2006, Proceedings of the International Conference on Head-Driven Phrase Structure Grammar.

[3]  Chris Wilder,et al.  Right Node Raising and the LCA , 2000 .

[4]  Robert Levine,et al.  Linearization and its discontents , 2011, Proceedings of the International Conference on Head-Driven Phrase Structure Grammar.

[5]  Richard Hudson,et al.  Coordination and grammatical relations , 1988, Journal of Linguistics.

[6]  Asaf Bachrach,et al.  Right-Node Raising and Delayed Spellout∗† , 2006 .

[7]  Asaf Bachrach,et al.  Spelling out QR , 2007 .

[8]  Ivan A. Sag,et al.  Coordinate ellipsis and apparent non-constituent coordination , 2004, Proceedings of the International Conference on Head-Driven Phrase Structure Grammar.

[9]  Berthold Crysmann,et al.  An Asymmetric Theory of Peripheral Sharing in HPSG : Conjunction Reduction and Coordination of Unlikes , 2008 .

[10]  Shûichi Yatabe.  syntax and semantics of left-node raising in Japanese , 2001, Proceedings of the International Conference on Head-Driven Phrase Structure Grammar.

[11]  Mark Steedman,et al.  The syntactic process , 2004, Language, speech, and communication.

[12]  Anne Abeillé,et al.  Quelques contraintes sur les coordinations elliptiques en français , 2008 .

[13]  Shûichi Yatabe,et al.  A comprehensive theory of coordination of unlikes , 2004, Proceedings of the International Conference on Head-Driven Phrase Structure Grammar.

[14]  Joseph Sabbagh,et al.  Right Node Raising , 2014, Lang. Linguistics Compass.

[15]  Shûichi Yatabe,et al.  A linearization-based theory of summative agreement in peripheral-node raising constructions , 2003, Proceedings of the International Conference on Head-Driven Phrase Structure Grammar.