Use of auto-segmentation in the delineation of target volumes and organs at risk in head and neck

Abstract Background: Manual delineation of structures in head and neck cancers is an extremely time-consuming and labor-intensive procedure. With centers worldwide moving towards the use of intensity-modulated radiotherapy and adaptive radiotherapy, there is a need to explore and analyze auto-segmentation (AS) software, in the search for a faster yet accurate method of structure delineation. Material and methods: A search for studies published after 2005 comparing AS and manual delineation in contouring organ at risks (OARs) and target volume for head and neck patients was conducted. The reviewed results were then categorized into arguments proposing and opposing the review title. Results: Ten studies were reviewed and derived results were assessed in terms of delineation time-saving ability and extent of delineation accuracy. The influence of other external factors (observer variability, AS strategies adopted and stage of disease) were also considered. Results were conflicting with some studies demonstrating great potential in replacing manual delineation whereas other studies illustrated otherwise. Six of 10 studies investigated time saving; the largest time saving reported being 59%. However, one study found that additional time of 15.7% was required for AS. Four studies reported AS contours to be between ‘reasonably good’ and ‘better quality’ than the clinically used contours. Remaining studies cited lack of contrast, AS strategy used and the need for physician intervention as limitations in the standardized use of AS. Discussion: The studies demonstrated significant potential of AS as a useful delineation tool in contouring target volumes and OARs in head and neck cancers. However, it is evident that AS cannot totally replace manual delineation in contouring some structures in the head and neck and cannot be used independently without human intervention. It is also emphasized that delineation studies should be conducted locally so as to evaluate the true value of AS in head and neck cancers in a specific center.

[1]  André Wambersie,et al.  The International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements , 2001, Journal of the ICRU.

[2]  H. Menzel,et al.  The International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements , 2011, Journal of the ICRU.

[3]  Laurence Court,et al.  Automatic contouring of brachial plexus using a multi-atlas approach for lung cancer radiation therapy. , 2013, Practical radiation oncology.

[4]  Paolo Zaffino,et al.  Automatic segmentation of head and neck CT images for radiotherapy treatment planning using multiple atlases, statistical appearance models, and geodesic active contours. , 2014, Medical physics.

[5]  Dean F. Sittig,et al.  Prospective randomized double-blind study of atlas-based organ-at-risk autosegmentation-assisted radiation planning in head and neck cancer. , 2014, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[6]  Jean-François Daisne,et al.  Atlas-based automatic segmentation of head and neck organs at risk and nodal target volumes: a clinical validation , 2013, Radiation oncology.

[7]  G. Webster,et al.  Atlas-based Auto-contouring - Balancing Accuracy with Efficiency in OnQ rts ® , 2014 .

[8]  J. Faber,et al.  How sample size influences research outcomes , 2014, Dental press journal of orthodontics.

[9]  Ping Xia,et al.  Dosimetric evaluation of automatic segmentation for adaptive IMRT for head-and-neck cancer. , 2010, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[10]  E. R. van den Heuvel,et al.  3D Variation in delineation of head and neck organs at risk , 2012, Radiation oncology.

[11]  A R Jadad,et al.  Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: is blinding necessary? , 1996, Controlled clinical trials.

[12]  Frederik Wenz,et al.  Performance of an atlas-based autosegmentation software for delineation of target volumes for radiotherapy of breast and anorectal cancer. , 2012, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[13]  A. Lomax,et al.  Systematic evaluation of three different commercial software solutions for automatic segmentation for adaptive therapy in head-and-neck, prostate and pleural cancer , 2012, Radiation oncology.

[14]  Quynh-Thu Le,et al.  New developments in radiation therapy for head and neck cancer: intensity-modulated radiation therapy and hypoxia targeting. , 2008, Seminars in oncology.

[15]  C. Njeh,et al.  Tumor delineation: The weakest link in the search for accuracy in radiotherapy , 2008, Journal of medical physics.

[16]  Martin Lundmark,et al.  Clinical evaluation of multi-atlas based segmentation of lymph node regions in head and neck and prostate cancer patients , 2013, Radiation oncology.

[17]  Xiao Han,et al.  Clinical validation of atlas-based auto-segmentation of multiple target volumes and normal tissue (swallowing/mastication) structures in the head and neck. , 2011, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[18]  Nicholas Slevin,et al.  Evaluation of an automatic segmentation algorithm for definition of head and neck organs at risk , 2014, Radiation oncology.

[19]  G. Sharp,et al.  Vision 20/20: perspectives on automated image segmentation for radiotherapy. , 2014, Medical physics.

[20]  Radhe Mohan,et al.  Performance evaluation of automatic anatomy segmentation algorithm on repeat or four-dimensional computed tomography images using deformable image registration method. , 2008, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[21]  Rajat J Kudchadker,et al.  Dosimetric effects of weight loss or gain during volumetric modulated arc therapy and intensity-modulated radiation therapy for prostate cancer. , 2013, Medical dosimetry : official journal of the American Association of Medical Dosimetrists.

[22]  Mischa S. Hoogeman,et al.  Atlas Based Auto-segmentation of CT Images: Clinical Evaluation of using Auto-contouring in High-dose, High-precision Radiotherapy of Cancer in the Head and Neck , 2008 .

[23]  Daniel Rueckert,et al.  Multi-atlas based segmentation of brain images: Atlas selection and its effect on accuracy , 2009, NeuroImage.

[24]  M A Deeley,et al.  Erratum: Evaluation of multiple-atlas-based strategies for segmentation of the thyroid gland in head and neck CT images for IMRT , 2012, Physics in medicine and biology.

[25]  G A Whitfield,et al.  Interobserver variation in clinical target volume and organs at risk segmentation in post-parotidectomy radiotherapy: can segmentation protocols help? , 2012, The British journal of radiology.

[26]  Vincenzo Valentini,et al.  Automatic delineation for replanning in nasopharynx radiotherapy: What is the agreement among experts to be considered as benchmark? , 2013, Acta oncologica.

[27]  R. Reznek,et al.  Role of the radiologist in radiotherapy planning , 2009 .

[28]  Maarten L P Dirkx,et al.  Does atlas-based autosegmentation of neck levels require subsequent manual contour editing to avoid risk of severe target underdosage? A dosimetric analysis. , 2011, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[29]  Stefan Klein,et al.  Automatic segmentation of the prostate in 3D MR images by atlas matching using localized mutual information. , 2008, Medical physics.

[30]  M. V. van Herk,et al.  Irradiation of paranasal sinus tumors, a delineation and dose comparison study. , 2002, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[31]  Y. Mao,et al.  Recommendation for a contouring method and atlas of organs at risk in nasopharyngeal carcinoma patients receiving intensity-modulated radiotherapy. , 2014, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[32]  Iddo Wernick,et al.  Atlas-based segmentation improves consistency and decreases time required for contouring postoperative endometrial cancer nodal volumes. , 2011, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[33]  Vincenzo Valentini,et al.  Recommendations on how to establish evidence from auto-segmentation software in radiotherapy. , 2014, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[34]  Joshua D. Lawson,et al.  Evaluation of automatic atlas-based lymph node segmentation for head-and-neck cancer. , 2010, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[35]  Vladimir Pekar,et al.  Auto-segmentation of normal and target structures in head and neck CT images: a feature-driven model-based approach. , 2011, Medical physics.

[36]  J. Piper,et al.  Timesavings for Contour Generation in Head and Neck IMRT: Multi-institutional Experience with an Atlas-based Segmentation Method , 2008 .

[37]  Grégoire Malandain,et al.  Evaluation of an atlas-based automatic segmentation software for the delineation of brain organs at risk in a radiation therapy clinical context. , 2008, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[38]  Jan-Jakob Sonke,et al.  Deformable image registration for adaptive radiation therapy of head and neck cancer: accuracy and precision in the presence of tumor changes. , 2014, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[39]  Jonathan Sykes,et al.  Reflections on the current status of commercial automated segmentation systems in clinical practice , 2014, Journal of medical radiation sciences.

[40]  Lei Dong,et al.  Reduce in variation and improve efficiency of target volume delineation by a computer-assisted system using a deformable image registration approach. , 2007, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[41]  Carsten Brink,et al.  Multi-institutional quantitative evaluation and clinical validation of Smart Probabilistic Image Contouring Engine (SPICE) autosegmentation of target structures and normal tissues on computer tomography images in the head and neck, thorax, liver, and male pelvis areas. , 2013, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[42]  Peter Balter,et al.  Auto-segmentation of low-risk clinical target volume for head and neck radiation therapy. , 2014, Practical radiation oncology.