Comparison of Bilateral and Unilateral Training for Upper Extremity Hemiparesis in Stroke

Background. Upper extremity hemiparesis is the most common poststroke disability. Longitudinal studies have indicated that 30% to 66% of stroke survivors do not have full arm function 6 months poststroke. One promising treatment approach is bilateral training. To date, no randomized, blinded study of efficacy comparing 2 groups (bilateral training vs unilateral training) using analogous tasks has been performed in chronic stroke survivors with moderate upper extremity impairment. Objective. To compare the effectiveness of bilateral training with unilateral training for individuals with moderate upper limb hemiparesis. The authors hypothesized that bilateral training would be superior to unilateral training in the proximal extremity but not the distal one. Methods. Twenty-four subjects participated in a randomized, single-blind training study. Subjects in the bilateral group (n = 12) practiced bilateral symmetrical activities, whereas the unilateral group (n = 12) performed the same activity with the affected arm only. The activities consisted of reaching-based tasks that were both rhythmic and discrete. The Motor Assessment Scale (MAS), Motor Status Scale (MSS), and muscle strength were used as outcome measures. Assessments were administered at baseline and posttraining by a rater blinded to group assignment. Results. Both groups had significant improvements on the MSS and measures of strength. The bilateral group had significantly greater improvement on the Upper Arm Function scale (a subscale of the MAS-Upper Limb Items). Conclusion. Both bilateral and unilateral training are efficacious for moderately impaired chronic stroke survivors. Bilateral training may be more advantageous for proximal arm function.

[1]  K. Furie,et al.  Heart disease and stroke statistics--2007 update: a report from the American Heart Association Statistics Committee and Stroke Statistics Subcommittee. , 2008, Circulation.

[2]  Jill Whitall,et al.  Exploiting interlimb coupling to improve paretic arm reaching performance in people with chronic stroke. , 2005, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[3]  W. Byblow,et al.  The effect of coordination mode on use-dependent plasticity , 2007, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[4]  W. Byblow,et al.  Disinhibition in the human motor cortex is enhanced by synchronous upper limb movements , 2002, The Journal of physiology.

[5]  J. Whitall,et al.  Bilateral arm training: why and who benefits? , 2008, NeuroRehabilitation.

[6]  P. Bawa,et al.  Bilateral responses of upper limb muscles to transcranial magnetic stimulation in human subjects , 2004, Experimental Brain Research.

[7]  J. Cauraugh,et al.  Two Coupled Motor Recovery Protocols Are Better Than One: Electromyogram-Triggered Neuromuscular Stimulation and Bilateral Movements , 2002, Stroke.

[8]  Hélène Corriveau,et al.  Effectiveness of unilateral and symmetrical bilateral task training for arm during the subacute phase after stroke: a randomized controlled trial , 2005, Clinical rehabilitation.

[9]  James H. Cauraugh,et al.  Coupled bilateral movements and active neuromuscular stimulation: Intralimb transfer evidence during bimanual aiming , 2005, Neuroscience Letters.

[10]  M. Thaut,et al.  Rhythmic auditory-motor facilitation of gait patterns in patients with Parkinson's disease. , 1997, Journal of neurology, neurosurgery, and psychiatry.

[11]  W. Byblow,et al.  Priming the motor system enhances the effects of upper limb therapy in chronic stroke. , 2008, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[12]  Jeffery J. Summers,et al.  Bilateral and unilateral movement training on upper limb function in chronic stroke patients: A TMS study , 2007, Journal of the Neurological Sciences.

[13]  L. Cohen,et al.  Influence of interhemispheric interactions on motor function in chronic stroke , 2004, Annals of neurology.

[14]  J. A. Scott Kelso,et al.  Coordination Dynamics of Large-scale Neural Circuitry Underlying Rhythmic Sensorimotor Behavior , 2009, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[15]  W. Byblow,et al.  Rhythmic Bilateral Movement Training Modulates Corticomotor Excitability and Enhances Upper Limb Motricity Poststroke: A Pilot Study , 2004, Journal of clinical neurophysiology : official publication of the American Electroencephalographic Society.

[16]  E. Taub,et al.  Improved motor recovery after stroke and massive cortical reorganization following Constraint-Induced Movement therapy. , 2003, Physical medicine and rehabilitation clinics of North America.

[17]  M. Thaut,et al.  Auditory rhythmicity enhances movement and speech motor control in patients with Parkinson's disease. , 2001, Functional neurology.

[18]  William D. Bandy,et al.  Therapeutic exercise for physical therapist assistants , 2008 .

[19]  J. H. van der Lee,et al.  Forced use of the upper extremity in chronic stroke patients: results from a single-blind randomized clinical trial. , 1999, Stroke.

[20]  E. Taub,et al.  Constraint-Induced Movement Therapy: a new family of techniques with broad application to physical rehabilitation--a clinical review. , 1999, Journal of rehabilitation research and development.

[21]  P. Thompson,et al.  Cortical outflow to proximal arm muscles in man. , 1990, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[22]  J. M. Brault,et al.  Rhythmic auditory stimulation in gait training for Parkinson's disease patients , 1996, Movement disorders : official journal of the Movement Disorder Society.

[23]  T. Matyas,et al.  Can simultaneous bilateral movement involve the undamaged hemisphere in reconstruction of neural networks damaged by stroke? , 2000, Disability and rehabilitation.

[24]  T. Matyas,et al.  Bilateral Training Does Not Facilitate Performance of Copying Tasks in Poststroke Hemiplegia , 2006, Neurorehabilitation and neural repair.

[25]  C. Winstein,et al.  The co-ordination of bimanual rapid aiming movements following stroke , 2005, Clinical rehabilitation.

[26]  M. Thaut,et al.  Rhythmic facilitation of gait training in hemiparetic stroke rehabilitation , 1997, Journal of the Neurological Sciences.

[27]  M. Thaut,et al.  Kinematic optimization of spatiotemporal patterns in paretic arm training with stroke patients , 2002, Neuropsychologia.

[28]  M. Levin,et al.  Improvement of Arm Movement Patterns and Endpoint Control Depends on Type of Feedback During Practice in Stroke Survivors , 2007, Neurorehabilitation and neural repair.

[29]  Sandra B. Davis,et al.  Bilateral Arm Training With Rhythmic Auditory Cueing in Chronic Stroke: Not Always Efficacious , 2008, Neurorehabilitation and neural repair.

[30]  S. Schaal,et al.  Rhythmic arm movement is not discrete , 2004, Nature Neuroscience.

[31]  A. Luft,et al.  Repetitive bilateral arm training and motor cortex activation in chronic stroke: a randomized controlled trial. , 2004, JAMA.

[32]  Jennifer A Stevens,et al.  Beneficial effects of postural intervention on prehensile action for an individual with ataxia resulting from brainstem stroke. , 2005, NeuroRehabilitation.

[33]  Jill Whitall,et al.  Hand dominance and side of stroke affect rehabilitation in chronic stroke , 2005, Clinical rehabilitation.

[34]  N. Byl,et al.  Effectiveness of Sensory and Motor Rehabilitation of the Upper Limb Following the Principles of Neuroplasticity: Patients Stable Poststroke , 2003, Neurorehabilitation and neural repair.

[35]  A. Gentile,et al.  Rehabilitation of reaching after stroke: task-related training versus progressive resistive exercise. , 2004, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[36]  J. P. Miller,et al.  Effect of constraint-induced movement therapy on upper extremity function 3 to 9 months after stroke: the EXCITE randomized clinical trial. , 2006, JAMA.

[37]  J Whitall,et al.  Temporal and spatial control following bilateral versus unilateral training. , 2008, Human movement science.

[38]  N. Hogan,et al.  Assessing the Motor Status Score: A Scale for the Evaluation of Upper Limb Motor Outcomes in Patients after Stroke , 2002, Neurorehabilitation and neural repair.

[39]  W. Rymer,et al.  Robot-assisted reaching exercise promotes arm movement recovery in chronic hemiparetic stroke: a randomized controlled pilot study , 2006, Journal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation.

[40]  Jack Crosbie,et al.  Scapulohumeral rhythm and associated spinal motion. , 2008, Clinical biomechanics.

[41]  Jill Whitall,et al.  Fine motor control in adults with and without chronic hemiparesis: baseline comparison to nondisabled adults and effects of bilateral arm training. , 2004, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[42]  C B Walter,et al.  Bilateral facilitation of motor control in chronic hemiplegia. , 2002, Acta psychologica.

[43]  F. Su,et al.  Effect of bilateral reaching on affected arm motor control in stroke – with and without loading on unaffected arm , 2006, Disability and rehabilitation.

[44]  J. Poole,et al.  Motor assessment scale for stroke patients: concurrent validity and interrater reliability. , 1988, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[45]  M. Levin,et al.  Short-Term Effects of Practice With Trunk Restraint on Reaching Movements in Patients With Chronic Stroke: A Controlled Trial , 2004, Stroke.

[46]  N. Hogan,et al.  Effects of robotic therapy on motor impairment and recovery in chronic stroke. , 2003, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[47]  J. Mehrholz,et al.  Computerized Arm Training Improves the Motor Control of the Severely Affected Arm After Stroke: A Single-Blinded Randomized Trial in Two Centers , 2005, Stroke.

[48]  M H Thaut,et al.  Rhythmic Auditor y Stimulation Improves Gait More Than NDT/Bobath Training in Near-Ambulatory Patients Early Poststroke: A Single-Blind, Randomized Trial , 2007, Neurorehabilitation and neural repair.

[49]  Ching-yi Wu,et al.  Effects of Constraint-Induced Therapy Versus Bilateral Arm Training on Motor Performance, Daily Functions, and Quality of Life in Stroke Survivors , 2009, Neurorehabilitation and neural repair.

[50]  N. Hogan,et al.  Robotic therapy for chronic motor impairments after stroke: Follow-up results. , 2004, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[51]  S. Hesse,et al.  Robot-assisted arm trainer for the passive and active practice of bilateral forearm and wrist movements in hemiparetic subjects. , 2003, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[52]  G. Kwakkel,et al.  Probability of regaining dexterity in the flaccid upper limb: impact of severity of paresis and time since onset in acute stroke. , 2003, Stroke.

[53]  Hurt,et al.  Rhythmic Auditory Stimulation in Gait Training for Patients with Traumatic Brain Injury. , 1998, Journal of music therapy.

[54]  W. Byblow,et al.  Neurophysiological and behavioural adaptations to a bilateral training intervention in individuals following stroke , 2004, Clinical rehabilitation.

[55]  J. Carr,et al.  Investigation of a new motor assessment scale for stroke patients. , 1985, Physical therapy.

[56]  J. Whitall,et al.  Repetitive Bilateral Arm Training With Rhythmic Auditory Cueing Improves Motor Function in Chronic Hemiparetic Stroke , 2000, Stroke.

[57]  K. Furie,et al.  Heart disease and stroke statistics--2008 update: a report from the American Heart Association Statistics Committee and Stroke Statistics Subcommittee. , 2007, Circulation.

[58]  James H. Cauraugh,et al.  Chronic stroke motor recovery: duration of active neuromuscular stimulation , 2003, Journal of the Neurological Sciences.

[59]  H. Kautiainen,et al.  Effect of isometric upper-extremity exercises on the activation of core stabilizing muscles. , 2008, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[60]  H. Krebs,et al.  Mechanical Arm Trainer for the Treatment of the Severely Affected Arm After a Stroke: A Single-Blinded Randomized Trial in Two Centers , 2008, American journal of physical medicine & rehabilitation.