Outpatient psychotherapy for borderline personality disorder: randomized trial of schema-focused therapy vs transference-focused psychotherapy.

CONTEXT Borderline personality disorder is a severe and chronic psychiatric condition, prevalent throughout health care settings. Only limited effects of current treatments have been documented. OBJECTIVE To compare the effectiveness of schema-focused therapy (SFT) and psychodynamically based transference-focused psychotherapy (TFP) in patients with borderline personality disorder. DESIGN A multicenter, randomized, 2-group design. SETTING Four general community mental health centers. PARTICIPANTS Eighty-eight patients with a Borderline Personality Disorder Severity Index, fourth version, score greater than a predetermined cutoff score. INTERVENTION Three years of either SFT or TFP with sessions twice a week. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES Borderline Personality Disorder Severity Index, fourth version, score; quality of life; general psychopathologic dysfunction; and measures of SFT/TFP personality concepts. Patient assessments were made before randomization and then every 3 months for 3 years. RESULTS Data on 44 SFT patients and 42 TFP patients were available. The sociodemographic and clinical characteristics of the groups were similar at baseline. Survival analyses revealed a higher dropout risk for TFP patients than for SFT patients (P = .01). Using an intention-to-treat approach, statistically and clinically significant improvements were found for both treatments on all measures after 1-, 2-, and 3-year treatment periods. After 3 years of treatment, survival analyses demonstrated that significantly more SFT patients recovered (relative risk = 2.18; P = .04) or showed reliable clinical improvement (relative risk = 2.33; P = .009) on the Borderline Personality Disorder Severity Index, fourth version. Robust analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) showed that they also improved more in general psychopathologic dysfunction and measures of SFT/TFP personality concepts (P<.001). Finally, SFT patients showed greater increases in quality of life than TFP patients (robust ANCOVAs, P=.03 and P<.001). CONCLUSIONS Three years of SFT or TFP proved to be effective in reducing borderline personality disorder-specific and general psychopathologic dysfunction and measures of SFT/TFP concepts and in improving quality of life; SFT is more effective than TFP for all measures.

[1]  Niels G. Waller,et al.  Exploring personality through test construction: Development of the multidimensional personality questionnaire , 2008 .

[2]  H. Nordahl,et al.  Schema therapy for patients with borderline personality disorder: a single case series. , 2005, Journal of behavior therapy and experimental psychiatry.

[3]  M. Nader,et al.  PET imaging of dopamine D2 receptors in monkey models of cocaine abuse: genetic predisposition versus environmental modulation. , 2005, The American journal of psychiatry.

[4]  J. Oldham.  Guideline Watch: Practice Guideline for the Treatment of Patients With Borderline Personality Disorder , 2005 .

[5]  P. Antoine.  Schema Therapy — A practioner's guide , 2005 .

[6]  H. Van den Bergh,et al.  Stability and discriminative power of the Young Schema-Questionnaire in a Dutch clinical versus non-clinical population. , 2005, Journal of behavior therapy and experimental psychiatry.

[7]  T. Joiner,et al.  The schema questionnaire: Investigation of psychometric properties and the hierarchical structure of a measure of maladaptive schemas , 1995, Cognitive Therapy and Research.

[8]  Mark Zimmerman,et al.  Assessment Instruments and Standardized Evaluation. , 2005 .

[9]  E. Ziegel.  Introduction to Robust Estimation and Hypothesis Testing (2nd ed.) , 2005 .

[10]  A. Arntz,et al.  Beliefs in personality disorders: a test with the personality disorder belief questionnaire. , 2004, Behaviour research and therapy.

[11]  A. Beck,et al.  An open clinical trial of cognitive therapy for borderline personality disorder. , 2004, Journal of personality disorders.

[12]  S. Yen,et al.  Combined dialectical behavior therapy and fluoxetine in the treatment of borderline personality disorder. , 2004, The Journal of clinical psychiatry.

[13]  Arnoud Arntz,et al.  Short-interval test-retest interrater reliability of the Dutch version of the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV personality disorders (SCID-II). , 2003, Journal of personality disorders.

[14]  M. Weishaar,et al.  Schema Therapy: A Practitioner's Guide , 2003 .

[15]  W. van den Brink,et al.  Dialectical behaviour therapy for women with borderline personality disorder , 2003, British Journal of Psychiatry.

[16]  A. Arntz,et al.  Reliability and validity of the borderline personality disorder severity index. , 2003, Journal of personality disorders.

[17]  J. Hennen,et al.  The longitudinal course of borderline psychopathology: 6-year prospective follow-up of the phenomenology of borderline personality disorder. , 2003, The American journal of psychiatry.

[18]  O. Kernberg,et al.  A Primer of Transference-Focused Psychotherapy for the Borderline Patient , 2002 .

[19]  K. Sagduyu,et al.  Neuropsychopharmacology: The Fifth Generation of Progress , 2002 .

[20]  M. Schuckit.  98 VULNERABILITY FACTORS FOR ALCOHOLISM , 2002 .

[21]  P. Fonagy,et al.  Treatment of borderline personality disorder with psychoanalytically oriented partial hospitalization: an 18-month follow-up. , 2006, The American journal of psychiatry.

[22]  M. Lenzenweger,et al.  The Inventory of Personality Organization: psychometric properties, factorial composition, and criterion relations with affect, aggressive dyscontrol, psychosis proneness, and self-domains in a nonclinical sample. , 2001, Psychological assessment.

[23]  Kenneth N. Levy,et al.  The development of a psychodynamic treatment for patients with borderline personality disorder: a preliminary study of behavioral change. , 2001, Journal of personality disorders.

[24]  G. Gabbard.  Empirical evidence and psychotherapy: a growing scientific base. , 2001, The American journal of psychiatry.

[25]  A. R. Lang,et al.  Expectations of alcohol-induced positive affect: a cross-cultural comparison. , 2000, Journal of studies on alcohol.

[26]  R. V. Van Heertum,et al.  Increased baseline occupancy of D2 receptors by dopamine in schizophrenia. , 2000, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[27]  P. Fonagy,et al.  Effectiveness of partial hospitalization in the treatment of borderline personality disorder: a randomized controlled trial. , 1999, The American journal of psychiatry.

[28]  H Schmidt,et al.  Dialectical behavior therapy for patients with borderline personality disorder and drug-dependence. , 1999, The American journal on addictions.

[29]  J. C. Perry,et al.  Effectiveness of psychotherapy for personality disorders. , 1999, The American journal of psychiatry.

[30]  H. Begleiter,et al.  What is inherited in the predisposition toward alcoholism? A proposed model. , 1999, Alcoholism, clinical and experimental research.

[31]  A. Arntz,et al.  Do personality disorders exist? On the validity of the concept and its cognitive-behavioral formulation and treatment. , 1999, Behaviour research and therapy.

[32]  O. Kernberg,et al.  Psychotherapy for Borderline Personality , 1998 .

[33]  N. Volkow,et al.  Association between decline in brain dopamine activity with age and cognitive and motor impairment in healthy individuals. , 1998, The American journal of psychiatry.

[34]  Dan J Stein,et al.  Cognitive Therapy of Borderline Personality Disorder , 1998, Journal of Cognitive Psychotherapy.

[35]  S. Saxena,et al.  The World Health Organization Quality of Life Assessment (WHOQOL): development and general psychometric properties. , 1998, Social science & medicine.

[36]  R. Wilcox.  ANCOVA based on comparing a robust measure of location at empirically determined design points , 1997 .

[37]  R. Wilcox.  Introduction to Robust Estimation and Hypothesis Testing , 1997 .

[38]  M. First,et al.  Structured clinical interview for DSM-IV axis II personality disorders : SCID-II , 1997 .

[39]  M. First,et al.  Structured clinical interview for DSM-IV axis I disorders : SCID-I : clinical version : scoresheet , 1997 .

[40]  M. First,et al.  Structured clinical interview for DSM-IV axis I disorders : SCID-I: clinical version : administration booklet , 1996 .

[41]  H. Schouten,et al.  Adaptive biased urn randomization in small strata when blinding is impossible. , 1995, Biometrics.

[42]  E. Marziali,et al.  A controlled trial of short-term group treatment for borderline personality disorder , 1995 .

[43]  R. Spitzer.  Dsm-IV Casebook: A Learning Companion to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition , 1994 .

[44]  M. Zimmerman.  Diagnosing personality disorders. A review of issues and research methods. , 1994, Archives of general psychiatry.

[45]  M. Linehan,et al.  Naturalistic follow-up of a behavioral treatment for chronically parasuicidal borderline patients. , 1993, Archives of general psychiatry.

[46]  F. Yeomans,et al.  Studying the treatment contract in intensive psychotherapy with borderline patients. , 1993, Psychiatry.

[47]  M. Steinberg.  Structured clinical interview for DSM-IV dissociative disorders (SCID-D). , 1993 .

[48]  N. Draijer,et al.  The validation of the Dissociative Experiences Scale against the criterion of the SCID-D, using receiver operating characteristics (ROC) analysis. , 1993 .

[49]  J. Paris.  The treatment of borderline personality disorder in light of the research on its long term outcome. , 1993, Canadian journal of psychiatry. Revue canadienne de psychiatrie.

[50]  F. Yeomans,et al.  Treating The Borderline Patient: A Contract-based Approach , 1992 .

[51]  W. J. Lyddon.  Cognitive Therapy for Personality Disorders: A Schema-Focused Approach , 1992, Journal of Cognitive Psychotherapy.

[52]  D. D. Davis,et al.  Cognitive therapy of personality disorders. , 1990, Progress in behavior modification.

[53]  M. Vichnar,et al.  [Borderline personality disorder]. , 1992, Ceskoslovenska pediatrie.

[54]  M. Linehan,et al.  Cognitive-behavioral treatment of chronically parasuicidal borderline patients. , 1991, Archives of general psychiatry.

[55]  N. Jacobson,et al.  Clinical significance: a statistical approach to defining meaningful change in psychotherapy research. , 1991, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[56]  A. Williams.  EuroQol : a new facility for the measurement of health-related quality of life , 1990 .

[57]  G. Andrews,et al.  The determination of defense style by questionnaire. , 1989, Archives of general psychiatry.

[58]  I. L. Zimmerman,et al.  Clinical Interpretation of the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale , 1975 .

[59]  L. Covi,et al.  SCL-90: an outpatient psychiatric rating scale--preliminary report. , 1973, Psychopharmacology bulletin.

[60]  G. N. Braucht,et al.  Self-concept and psychiatric symptomatology. , 1971, Journal of clinical psychology.

[61]  D. J. Lee.  Society and the Adolescent Self-Image , 1969 .