Network Modeling Reveals Prevalent Negative Regulatory Relationships between Signaling Sectors in Arabidopsis Immune Signaling

Biological signaling processes may be mediated by complex networks in which network components and network sectors interact with each other in complex ways. Studies of complex networks benefit from approaches in which the roles of individual components are considered in the context of the network. The plant immune signaling network, which controls inducible responses to pathogen attack, is such a complex network. We studied the Arabidopsis immune signaling network upon challenge with a strain of the bacterial pathogen Pseudomonas syringae expressing the effector protein AvrRpt2 (Pto DC3000 AvrRpt2). This bacterial strain feeds multiple inputs into the signaling network, allowing many parts of the network to be activated at once. mRNA profiles for 571 immune response genes of 22 Arabidopsis immunity mutants and wild type were collected 6 hours after inoculation with Pto DC3000 AvrRpt2. The mRNA profiles were analyzed as detailed descriptions of changes in the network state resulting from the genetic perturbations. Regulatory relationships among the genes corresponding to the mutations were inferred by recursively applying a non-linear dimensionality reduction procedure to the mRNA profile data. The resulting static network model accurately predicted 23 of 25 regulatory relationships reported in the literature, suggesting that predictions of novel regulatory relationships are also accurate. The network model revealed two striking features: (i) the components of the network are highly interconnected; and (ii) negative regulatory relationships are common between signaling sectors. Complex regulatory relationships, including a novel negative regulatory relationship between the early microbe-associated molecular pattern-triggered signaling sectors and the salicylic acid sector, were further validated. We propose that prevalent negative regulatory relationships among the signaling sectors make the plant immune signaling network a “sector-switching” network, which effectively balances two apparently conflicting demands, robustness against pathogenic perturbations and moderation of negative impacts of immune responses on plant fitness.

[1]  Riyaz Bhat,et al.  Pre- and Postinvasion Defenses Both Contribute to Nonhost Resistance in Arabidopsis , 2005, Science.

[2]  Jane Glazebrook,et al.  The Arabidopsis NPR1 Gene That Controls Systemic Acquired Resistance Encodes a Novel Protein Containing Ankyrin Repeats , 1997, Cell.

[3]  Jean-Pierre Métraux,et al.  Salicylic Acid Induction–Deficient Mutants of Arabidopsis Express PR-2 and PR-5 and Accumulate High Levels of Camalexin after Pathogen Inoculation , 1999, Plant Cell.

[4]  Ho Bang Kim,et al.  A knock-out mutation in allene oxide synthase results in male sterility and defective wound signal transduction in Arabidopsis due to a block in jasmonic acid biosynthesis. , 2002, The Plant journal : for cell and molecular biology.

[5]  T. Hartung,et al.  Innate immunity in Arabidopsis thaliana: lipopolysaccharides activate nitric oxide synthase (NOS) and induce defense genes. , 2004, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[6]  R. Solano,et al.  JASMONATE-INSENSITIVE1 Encodes a MYC Transcription Factor Essential to Discriminate between Different Jasmonate-Regulated Defense Responses in Arabidopsis , 2004, The Plant Cell Online.

[7]  Jean-Pierre Métraux,et al.  EDS5, an Essential Component of Salicylic Acid–Dependent Signaling for Disease Resistance in Arabidopsis, Is a Member of the MATE Transporter Family Article, publication date, and citation information can be found at www.plantcell.org/cgi/doi/10.1105/tpc.010376. , 2002, The Plant Cell Online.

[8]  Jonathan D. G. Jones,et al.  Bacterial disease resistance in Arabidopsis through flagellin perception , 2004, Nature.

[9]  Jonathan D. G. Jones,et al.  EDS1, an essential component of R gene-mediated disease resistance in Arabidopsis has homology to eukaryotic lipases. , 1999, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[10]  S. He,et al.  The Pseudomonas syringae type III effector tyrosine phosphatase HopAO1 suppresses innate immunity in Arabidopsis thaliana. , 2007, The Plant journal : for cell and molecular biology.

[11]  Y. Bar-Yam,et al.  Attractors and Democratic Dynamics , 2009, Science.

[12]  Yudong D. He,et al.  Functional Discovery via a Compendium of Expression Profiles , 2000, Cell.

[13]  Fumiaki Katagiri,et al.  Topology of the network integrating salicylate and jasmonate signal transduction derived from global expression phenotyping. , 2003, The Plant journal : for cell and molecular biology.

[14]  M. Pagni,et al.  A Downstream Mediator in the Growth Repression Limb of the Jasmonate Pathway[W][OA] , 2007, The Plant Cell Online.

[15]  John C. Walker,et al.  Stomatal Development and Patterning Are Regulated by Environmentally Responsive Mitogen-Activated Protein Kinases in Arabidopsis[W] , 2007, The Plant Cell Online.

[16]  Y. Benjamini,et al.  Controlling the false discovery rate: a practical and powerful approach to multiple testing , 1995 .

[17]  R. Dixon,et al.  Nitric oxide functions as a signal in plant disease resistance , 1998, Nature.

[18]  M. Bolton.  Primary metabolism and plant defense--fuel for the fire. , 2009, Molecular plant-microbe interactions : MPMI.

[19]  A. Bent,et al.  Identification of Pseudomonas syringae pathogens of Arabidopsis and a bacterial locus determining avirulence on both Arabidopsis and soybean. , 1991, The Plant cell.

[20]  David Mackey,et al.  Arabidopsis RIN4 Negatively Regulates Disease Resistance Mediated by RPS2 and RPM1 Downstream or Independent of the NDR1 Signal Modulator and Is Not Required for the Virulence Functions of Bacterial Type III Effectors AvrRpt2 or AvrRpm1 , 2004, The Plant Cell Online.

[21]  J. León,et al.  Enhanced Abscisic Acid-Mediated Responses in nia1nia2noa1-2 Triple Mutant Impaired in NIA/NR- and AtNOA1-Dependent Nitric Oxide Biosynthesis in Arabidopsis1[W] , 2009, Plant Physiology.

[22]  J. Glazebrook.  Contrasting mechanisms of defense against biotrophic and necrotrophic pathogens. , 2005, Annual review of phytopathology.

[23]  Hur-Song Chang,et al.  Quantitative Nature of Arabidopsis Responses during Compatible and Incompatible Interactions with the Bacterial Pathogen Pseudomonas syringae Online version contains Web-only data. Article, publication date, and citation information can be found at www.plantcell.org/cgi/doi/10.1105/tpc.007591. , 2003, The Plant Cell Online.

[24]  She Chen,et al.  A Pseudomonas syringae effector inactivates MAPKs to suppress PAMP-induced immunity in plants. , 2007, Cell host & microbe.

[25]  Nicolai Strizhov,et al.  An Arabidopsis Callose Synthase, GSL5, Is Required for Wound and Papillary Callose Formation Article, publication date, and citation information can be found at www.plantcell.org/cgi/doi/10.1105/tpc.016097. , 2003, The Plant Cell Online.

[26]  C. Lamb,et al.  Genetic Elucidation of Nitric Oxide Signaling in Incompatible Plant-Pathogen Interactions[w] , 2004, Plant Physiology.

[27]  Fumiaki Katagiri,et al.  A high-performance, small-scale microarray for expression profiling of many samples in Arabidopsis-pathogen studies. , 2007, The Plant journal : for cell and molecular biology.

[28]  J. Alfano,et al.  Phytopathogen type III effector weaponry and their plant targets. , 2008, Current opinion in plant biology.

[29]  F. Ausubel,et al.  MAP kinase signalling cascade in Arabidopsis innate immunity , 2002, Nature.

[30]  D. Xie,et al.  COI1: an Arabidopsis gene required for jasmonate-regulated defense and fertility. , 1998, Science.

[31]  Sang Yeol Lee,et al.  Layered basal defenses underlie non-host resistance of Arabidopsis to Pseudomonas syringae pv. phaseolicola. , 2007, The Plant journal : for cell and molecular biology.

[32]  Jonathan D. G. Jones,et al.  Arabidopsis gp91phox homologues AtrbohD and AtrbohF are required for accumulation of reactive oxygen intermediates in the plant defense response , 2001, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[33]  Jyoti Shah,et al.  The salicylic acid loop in plant defense. , 2003, Current opinion in plant biology.

[34]  S. Weisberg,et al.  Natural Variation in RPS2-Mediated Resistance among Arabidopsis Accessions: Correlation between Gene Expression Profiles and Phenotypic Responses[W] , 2007, The Plant Cell Online.

[35]  Monica Stein,et al.  Loss of a Callose Synthase Results in Salicylic Acid-Dependent Disease Resistance , 2003, Science.

[36]  P. Repetti,et al.  NDR1, a pathogen-induced component required for Arabidopsis disease resistance. , 1997, Science.

[37]  Michael J. Axtell,et al.  Initiation of RPS2-Specified Disease Resistance in Arabidopsis Is Coupled to the AvrRpt2-Directed Elimination of RIN4 , 2003, Cell.

[38]  H. Kitano.  Systems Biology: A Brief Overview , 2002, Science.

[39]  N. Crawford,et al.  Identification of a Plant Nitric Oxide Synthase Gene Involved in Hormonal Signaling , 2003, Science.

[40]  Xinnian Dong,et al.  NPR1, all things considered. , 2004, Current opinion in plant biology.

[41]  J. Glazebrook,et al.  Arabidopsis CaM Binding Protein CBP60g Contributes to MAMP-Induced SA Accumulation and Is Involved in Disease Resistance against Pseudomonas syringae , 2009, PLoS pathogens.

[42]  K. Shirasu,et al.  Negative Regulation of PAMP-Triggered Immunity by an E3 Ubiquitin Ligase Triplet in Arabidopsis , 2008, Current Biology.

[43]  J. Ecker,et al.  EIN2, a bifunctional transducer of ethylene and stress responses in Arabidopsis. , 1999, Science.

[44]  F. Ausubel,et al.  Activation of defense response pathways by OGs and Flg22 elicitors in Arabidopsis seedlings. , 2008, Molecular plant.

[45]  D F Klessig,et al.  PAD4 Functions Upstream from Salicylic Acid to Control Defense Responses in Arabidopsis , 1998, Plant Cell.

[46]  Xinnian Dong,et al.  Characterization of an Arabidopsis Mutant That Is Nonresponsive to Inducers of Systemic Acquired Resistance. , 1994, The Plant cell.

[47]  Martin J. Mueller,et al.  NPR1 Modulates Cross-Talk between Salicylate- and Jasmonate-Dependent Defense Pathways through a Novel Function in the Cytosol Article, publication date, and citation information can be found at www.plantcell.org/cgi/doi/10.1105/tpc.009159. , 2003, The Plant Cell Online.

[48]  Ken Shirasu,et al.  RAR1 and NDR1 Contribute Quantitatively to Disease Resistance in Arabidopsis, and Their Relative Contributions Are Dependent on the R Gene Assayed Article, publication date, and citation information can be found at www.plantcell.org/cgi/doi/10.1105/tpc.001032. , 2002, The Plant Cell Online.

[49]  Jonathan D. G. Jones,et al.  The Transcriptional Innate Immune Response to flg22. Interplay and Overlap with Avr Gene-Dependent Defense Responses and Bacterial Pathogenesis1[w] , 2004, Plant Physiology.

[50]  D. Klessig,et al.  Uncoupling PR Gene Expression from NPR1 and Bacterial Resistance: Characterization of the Dominant Arabidopsis cpr6-1 Mutant , 1998, Plant Cell.

[51]  E. Weiler,et al.  Allene oxide synthase: a major control point in Arabidopsis thaliana octadecanoid signalling. , 1998, The Plant journal : for cell and molecular biology.

[52]  V. Joardar,et al.  The Arabidopsis thaliana JASMONATE INSENSITIVE 1 gene is required for suppression of salicylic acid-dependent defenses during infection by Pseudomonas syringae. , 2006, Molecular plant-microbe interactions : MPMI.

[53]  Murray Grant,et al.  Salicylic acid in plant defence--the players and protagonists. , 2007, Current opinion in plant biology.

[54]  Jonathan D. G. Jones,et al.  Pathological hormone imbalances. , 2007, Current opinion in plant biology.

[55]  M. Zottini,et al.  Salicylic acid activates nitric oxide synthesis in Arabidopsis. , 2007, Journal of experimental botany.

[56]  Yidong Liu,et al.  Phosphorylation of 1-Aminocyclopropane-1-Carboxylic Acid Synthase by MPK6, a Stress-Responsive Mitogen-Activated Protein Kinase, Induces Ethylene Biosynthesis in Arabidopsisw⃞ , 2004, The Plant Cell Online.

[57]  Hongwei Guo,et al.  ETHYLENE INSENSITIVE3 and ETHYLENE INSENSITIVE3-LIKE1 Repress SALICYLIC ACID INDUCTION DEFICIENT2 Expression to Negatively Regulate Plant Innate Immunity in Arabidopsis[W][OA] , 2009, The Plant Cell Online.

[58]  Edda Klipp,et al.  Systems Biology , 1994 .

[59]  J. Glazebrook,et al.  Local Context Finder (LCF) reveals multidimensional relationships among mRNA expression profiles of Arabidopsis responding to pathogen infection , 2003, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[60]  S T Roweis,et al.  Nonlinear dimensionality reduction by locally linear embedding. , 2000, Science.

[61]  L. C. van Loon,et al.  Ethylene as a modulator of disease resistance in plants. , 2006, Trends in plant science.

[62]  Jonathan D. G. Jones,et al.  Plant pathogens and integrated defence responses to infection , 2001, Nature.

[63]  D F Klessig,et al.  The cpr5 mutant of Arabidopsis expresses both NPR1-dependent and NPR1-independent resistance. , 1997, The Plant cell.

[64]  F. Ausubel,et al.  The A. Thaliana Disease Resistance Gene Rps2 Encodes a Protein Containing a Nucleotide-binding Site and Leucine-rich Repeats , 2022 .

[65]  F. Ausubel,et al.  Arabidopsis thaliana PAD4 encodes a lipase-like gene that is important for salicylic acid signaling. , 1999, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[66]  Yan Xiong,et al.  Dual control of nuclear EIN3 by bifurcate MAPK cascades in C2H4 signalling , 2008, Nature.

[67]  J. Ecker,et al.  Activation of the Ethylene Gas Response Pathway in Arabidopsis by the Nuclear Protein ETHYLENE-INSENSITIVE3 and Related Proteins , 1997, Cell.

[68]  R. Liechti,et al.  Arabidopsis Jasmonate Signaling Pathway , 2006, Science's STKE.

[69]  J. Glazebrook,et al.  Interplay between MAMP-triggered and SA-mediated defense responses. , 2008, The Plant journal : for cell and molecular biology.

[70]  M. Kreitman,et al.  Fitness costs of R-gene-mediated resistance in Arabidopsis thaliana , 2003, Nature.

[71]  Jonathan D. G. Jones,et al.  The plant immune system , 2006, Nature.

[72]  T. Boller,et al.  Sensitivity of Different Ecotypes and Mutants ofArabidopsis thaliana toward the Bacterial Elicitor Flagellin Correlates with the Presence of Receptor-binding Sites* , 2001, The Journal of Biological Chemistry.

[73]  A. Cabral,et al.  Arabidopsis SENESCENCE-ASSOCIATED GENE101 Stabilizes and Signals within an ENHANCED DISEASE SUSCEPTIBILITY1 Complex in Plant Innate Immunityw⃞ , 2005, The Plant Cell Online.

[74]  T. Boller,et al.  FLS2: an LRR receptor-like kinase involved in the perception of the bacterial elicitor flagellin in Arabidopsis. , 2000, Molecular cell.

[75]  T. Boller,et al.  A single locus determines sensitivity to bacterial flagellin in Arabidopsis thaliana. , 1999, The Plant journal : for cell and molecular biology.

[76]  R. Doerge,et al.  Natural Variation among Arabidopsis thaliana Accessions for Transcriptome Response to Exogenous Salicylic Acid[W][OA] , 2007, The Plant Cell Online.

[77]  F. Katagiri,et al.  The Arabidopsis Thaliana-Pseudomonas Syringae Interaction , 2002, The arabidopsis book.

[78]  E. Holub,et al.  Identification of three putative signal transduction genes involved in R gene-specified disease resistance in Arabidopsis. , 1999, Genetics.

[79]  J. Ecker,et al.  Genetic analysis of ethylene signal transduction in Arabidopsis thaliana: five novel mutant loci integrated into a stress response pathway. , 1995, Genetics.

[80]  Frederick M. Ausubel,et al.  Isochorismate synthase is required to synthesize salicylic acid for plant defence , 2001, Nature.

[81]  K. Shinozaki,et al.  The Mitogen-Activated Protein Kinase Cascade MKK3–MPK6 Is an Important Part of the Jasmonate Signal Transduction Pathway in Arabidopsis[W][OA] , 2007, The Plant Cell Online.

[82]  Hiroyuki Toh,et al.  Inference of a genetic network by a combined approach of cluster analysis and graphical Gaussian modeling , 2002, Bioinform..

[83]  J. Giraudat,et al.  RPS2 of Arabidopsis thaliana: a leucine-rich repeat class of plant disease resistance genes. , 1994, Science.

[84]  Xiaoyan Tang,et al.  RAR1, a central player in plant immunity, is targeted by Pseudomonas syringae effector AvrB , 2006, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[85]  J. Ecker,et al.  Arabidopsis RIN4 Is a Target of the Type III Virulence Effector AvrRpt2 and Modulates RPS2-Mediated Resistance , 2003, Cell.

[86]  Lihuang Zhu,et al.  Activation of a COI1-dependent pathway in Arabidopsis by Pseudomonas syringae type III effectors and coronatine. , 2004, The Plant journal : for cell and molecular biology.

[87]  J. Micol,et al.  The JAZ family of repressors is the missing link in jasmonate signalling , 2007, Nature.

[88]  N. Crawford,et al.  Identification of the Arabidopsis CHL3 gene as the nitrate reductase structural gene NIA2. , 1991, The Plant cell.

[89]  Bryan C Thines,et al.  JAZ repressor proteins are targets of the SCFCOI1 complex during jasmonate signalling , 2007, Nature.

[90]  Frederick M. Ausubel,et al.  Glucosinolate Metabolites Required for an Arabidopsis Innate Immune Response , 2009, Science.

[91]  J. Hancock,et al.  ABA-induced NO generation and stomatal closure in Arabidopsis are dependent on H2O2 synthesis. , 2006, The Plant journal : for cell and molecular biology.

[92]  C. Pieterse,et al.  Jasmonates - Signals in Plant-Microbe Interactions , 2004, Journal of Plant Growth Regulation.

[93]  Fumiaki Katagiri,et al.  The genetic network controlling the Arabidopsis transcriptional response to Pseudomonas syringae pv. maculicola: roles of major regulators and the phytotoxin coronatine. , 2008, Molecular plant-microbe interactions : MPMI.

[94]  Jonathan D. G. Jones,et al.  Six Arabidopsis thaliana homologues of the human respiratory burst oxidase (gp91phox). , 1998, The Plant journal : for cell and molecular biology.

[95]  J. Glazebrook,et al.  Network Properties of Robust Immunity in Plants , 2009, PLoS genetics.

[96]  Paul A Clemons,et al.  The Connectivity Map: Using Gene-Expression Signatures to Connect Small Molecules, Genes, and Disease , 2006, Science.

[97]  S. He,et al.  Interplay of the Arabidopsis nonhost resistance gene NHO1 with bacterial virulence , 2003, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.