Supports to Improve Academic Outcomes With Racially and Ethnically Minoritized Youth: A Review of Research

For decades, racially and ethnically minoritized youth have been subject to unequal distributions of access and opportunity in school, leading to inequities in academic outcomes. Educators require knowledge and skills to provide relevant instruction and create a more supportive, effective classroom environment. This systematic review includes 24 qualitative and quantitative studies in which researchers investigated a culturally responsive classroom intervention or practice to promote academic outcomes for racially and ethnically minoritized youth. Within these studies, authors described several approaches to promote academic success: (a) developing authentic partnerships with families, (b) using effective pedagogy with students’ culture infused, and (c) accessing rigorous professional development. In addition, studies were assessed for methodological quality, and qualitative works met design standards more often than the quantitative studies reviewed. Implications include the need for additional research to inform comprehensive support for educators to design effective instructional environments for all students, especially those who have historically encountered systemic barriers in school.

[1]  Ain A. Grooms,et al.  The Retention of Educators of Color Amidst Institutionalized Racism , 2021 .

[2]  J. Banks,et al.  Diversity, Group Identity, and Citizenship Education in a Global Age , 2008, Handbuch Bildungs- und Erziehungssoziologie.

[3]  Benjamin J. Lovett,et al.  Response Validity in Psychoeducational Assessment: a Primer for School Psychologists , 2020, Contemporary School Psychology.

[4]  April Lawrence Teaching as Dialogue: Toward Culturally Responsive Online Pedagogy , 2020 .

[5]  Cixin Wang,et al.  Racial Mismatch among Minoritized Students and White Teachers: Implications and Recommendations for Moving Forward , 2020, Journal of Educational and Psychological Consultation.

[6]  M. Trent,et al.  The Impact of Racism on Child and Adolescent Health , 2019, Pediatrics.

[7]  R. Berry,et al.  A Qualitative Metasynthesis of Culturally Relevant Pedagogy & Culturally Responsive Teaching: Unpacking Mathematics Teaching Practices , 2019 .

[8]  D. Merolla,et al.  Structural racism as the fundamental cause of the academic achievement gap , 2019, Sociology Compass.

[9]  R. Fish Standing Out and Sorting In: Exploring the Role of Racial Composition in Racial Disparities in Special Education , 2019, American Educational Research Journal.

[10]  Jenny Muñiz Culturally Responsive Teaching: A 50-State Survey of Teaching Standards. , 2019 .

[11]  Caitlin Scott,et al.  Closing the Opportunity Gap : How Positive Outlier Districts in California Are Pursuing Equitable Access to Deeper Learning , 2019 .

[12]  Daniel M. Maggin,et al.  Quality Indicators for Reviews of Research in Special Education , 2018 .

[13]  Lindsay M. Fallon,et al.  Direct Training to Improve Educators’ Treatment Integrity: A Systematic Review of Single-Case Design Studies , 2018, School psychology quarterly : the official journal of the Division of School Psychology, American Psychological Association.

[14]  Jim Lindsay,et al.  Evidence-Supported Interventions Associated with Black Students' Education Outcomes: Findings from a Systematic Review of Research. , 2018 .

[15]  Mark Hadfield,et al.  Ensuring Rigor in Qualitative Data Analysis , 2018, International Journal of Qualitative Methods.

[16]  Catherine P. Bradshaw,et al.  Promoting Educators’ Use of Culturally Responsive Practices: A Systematic Review of Inservice Interventions , 2018 .

[17]  Konstantina Peristeris Culturally Sustaining Pedagogies: Teaching and Learning for Justice in a Changing World , 2017 .

[18]  Yanan Fan,et al.  Google Docs as a Tool for Collaborative Writing in the Middle School Classroom , 2017, J. Inf. Technol. Educ. Res..

[19]  J. Zaff,et al.  Factors that Promote High School Graduation: a Review of the Literature , 2017 .

[20]  N. Gordon How State ESSA Accountability Plans Can Shine a Statistically Sound Light on More Students. Evidence Speaks Reports, Vol 2, #17. , 2017 .

[21]  Joy Kreeft Peyton,et al.  Heritage language education: valuing the languages, literacies, and cultural competencies of immigrant youth , 2017 .

[22]  Felice D. Billups,et al.  Evolving an Accelerated School Model through Student Perceptions and Student Outcome Data , 2016 .

[23]  Mark A. Gooden,et al.  Culturally Responsive School Leadership , 2016 .

[24]  Jennifer Cribbs,et al.  The Effects of a Consumer Chemistry Intervention on Urban At‐Risk High School Students’ Performance, Utility Value, and Intentions to Pursue STEM , 2016 .

[25]  Christy M. Byrd Does Culturally Relevant Teaching Work? An Examination From Student Perspectives , 2016 .

[26]  Joann W. L. Yuen,et al.  TeenACE for Science: Using Multimedia Tools and Scaffolds to Support Writing , 2016 .

[27]  M. M. Capraro,et al.  Impact of sustained professional development in STEM on outcome measures in a diverse urban district , 2016 .

[28]  S. Cantrell,et al.  Operationalizing Culturally Responsive Instruction: Preliminary Findings of CRIOP Research , 2016, Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education.

[29]  Cassandra A. Storlie,et al.  Professional School Counselor Perceptions of Systemic Barriers Affecting Latino Students: Implications for Socially Just Preparation and Practice , 2016 .

[30]  Keffrelyn D. Brown Teaching in color: a critical race theory in education analysis of the literature on preservice teachers of color and teacher education in the US , 2014 .

[31]  Django Paris,et al.  What Are We Seeking to Sustain Through Culturally Sustaining Pedagogy? A Loving Critique Forward , 2014 .

[32]  Amanda L. Sullivan,et al.  Disproportionality in Special Education: Effects of Individual and School Variables on Disability Risk , 2013 .

[33]  D. Stewart Racially Minoritized Students at U.S. Four-Year Institutions. , 2013 .

[34]  H. Milner Losing the Color-Blind Mind in the Urban Classroom , 2012 .

[35]  Gloria D. Campbell-Whatley,et al.  Infusing Culturally Responsive Instruction to Improve Mathematics Performance of Latino Students with Specific Learning Disabilities , 2012 .

[36]  Laurie H. Rubel,et al.  Reinscribing urban: teaching high school mathematics in low income, urban communities of color , 2011, Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education.

[37]  Peter C. Olson Weaker Readers as Experts: Preferential Instruction and the Fluency Improvement of Lower Performing Student Tutors. , 2011 .

[38]  Donna M. Sobel,et al.  Deepening culturally responsive understandings within a teacher preparation program: it’s a process , 2011 .

[39]  María E. Fránquiz,et al.  Newcomers developing English literacy through historical thinking and digitized primary sources , 2011 .

[40]  D. Sampson,et al.  Cultural Vibrancy: Exploring the Preferences of African American Children Toward Culturally Relevant and Non-Culturally Relevant Lessons , 2011 .

[41]  James Morgan,et al.  Professional Learning Communities as a Leadership Strategy to Drive Math Success in an Urban High School Serving Diverse, Low-Income Students: A Case Study , 2011 .

[42]  Alberto J. Rodriguez Exposing the impact of opp(reg)ressive policies on teacher development and on student learning , 2010 .

[43]  Evelyn Y. Young Challenges to Conceptualizing and Actualizing Culturally Relevant Pedagogy: How Viable Is the Theory in Classroom Practice? , 2010 .

[44]  Bree Picower,et al.  The unexamined Whiteness of teaching: how White teachers maintain and enact dominant racial ideologies , 2009 .

[45]  Bryan M. J. Brayboy,et al.  Culturally Responsive Schooling for Indigenous Youth: A Review of the Literature , 2008 .

[46]  Holly H. Robbins,et al.  Operationalizing Culturally Relevant Pedagogy: A Synthesis of Classroom-Based Research , 2008 .

[47]  A. Harden,et al.  Methods for the thematic synthesis of qualitative research in systematic reviews , 2008, BMC medical research methodology.

[48]  J. Boaler,et al.  Creating Mathematical Futures through an Equitable Teaching Approach: The Case of Railside School , 2008, Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education.

[49]  Alfinio Flores,et al.  Examining Disparities in Mathematics Education: Achievement Gap or Opportunity Gap? , 2007 .

[50]  S. Ross,et al.  Achievement and Climate Outcomes for the Knowledge is Power Program in an Inner-City Middle School , 2007 .

[51]  Hsiu-Fang Hsieh,et al.  Three Approaches to Qualitative Content Analysis , 2005, Qualitative health research.

[52]  Craig K. Enders,et al.  An instructional intervention's impact on the science and literacy achievement of culturally and linguistically diverse elementary students , 2005 .

[53]  Alfredo J. Artiles,et al.  Addressing the Disproportionate Representation of Culturally and Linguistically Diverse Students in Special Education through Culturally Responsive Educational Systems , 2005 .

[54]  Vincent E. Mumford,et al.  Urban School Failure and Disproportionality in a Post-Brown Era , 2005 .

[55]  Okhee Lee,et al.  Improving science inquiry with elementary students of diverse backgrounds , 2005 .

[56]  Robert T. Jiménez,et al.  Qualitative Studies in Special Education , 2005 .

[57]  D. Gillborn Education policy as an act of white supremacy: whiteness, critical race theory and education reform , 2005 .

[58]  Noel Enyedy,et al.  Inquiry in Interaction: How Local Adaptations of Curricula Shape Classroom Communities , 2004 .

[59]  S. Ross,et al.  Using School Reform Models to Improve Reading Achievement: A Longitudinal Study of Direct Instruction and Success For All in an Urban District , 2004 .

[60]  Sharon Vaughn,et al.  Alternative approaches to the definition and identification of learning disabilities: Some questions and answers , 2004, Annals of dyslexia.

[61]  Tonya R. Moon,et al.  Curricular Modifications, Family Outreach, and a Mentoring Program: Impacts on Achievement and Gifted Identification in High-Risk Primary Students , 2001 .

[62]  Julie A. Bianchini,et al.  Where knowledge construction, equity, and context intersect: Student learning of science in small groups , 1997 .

[63]  E. Gutstein,et al.  Culturally Relevant Mathematics Teaching in a Mexican American Context , 1997 .

[64]  J. Banks Educating Citizens in a Multicultural Society. Multicultural Education Series. , 1997 .

[65]  Jim Cummins,et al.  Multicultural Education and Technology: Promise and Pitfalls , 1996 .

[66]  Gloria J. Ladson-Billings,et al.  Toward a Theory of Culturally Relevant Pedagogy , 1995 .

[67]  Gloria J. Ladson-Billings,et al.  Toward a Critical Race Theory of Education , 1995, Teachers College Record: The Voice of Scholarship in Education.

[68]  J. Banks,et al.  Equity pedagogy: An essential component of multicultural education , 1995 .

[69]  L. Delpit Other People's Children: Cultural Conflict in the Classroom , 1995 .

[70]  Cheryl Becker,et al.  What is Literacy? , 1989 .

[71]  L. Delpit The Silenced Dialogue: Power and Pedagogy in Educating Other People's Children , 1988 .

[72]  J. Banks Teaching Ethnic Studies: Concepts and Strategies. 43rd Yearbook. , 1973 .