INTRODUCTION................................................................................. 1044 I. BOUMEDIENE AND ITS METHODOLOGY: WHAT CONSTITUTIONAL THEORY HAS TO DO WITH JURISDICTION-STRIPPING............................................................ 1053 A. The Opinion ....................................................................... 1053 B. Boumediene’s Potential Methodological Significance ........................................................................ 1056 II. ALLOCATION OF JURISDICTION BETWEEN STATE AND FEDERAL COURTS........................................................................ 1063 A. Withdrawal of Both Federal District Court and Supreme Court Jurisdiction .............................................. 1065 1. The Traditional View................................................... 1065 2. Professor Amar’s Neo-Federalist Rejoinder ............. 1069 3. Deciding in the Face of Historical Uncertainty ......... 1072 4. Supplementing Text-Based Originalism: Congressional Motives Reconsidered........................ 1074 5. Beyond Motive: Broader Limitations on the Total Stripping of Federal Jurisdiction................................ 1083 B. Withdrawal of Supreme Court Jurisdiction .................... 1087 1. Background Principles ................................................ 1087 2. Jurisdiction-Stripping and Supervisory Powers........ 1089 C. Stripping of District Court Jurisdiction ........................... 1093 III. WITHDRAWAL OF ALL JUDICIAL JURISDICTION .................... 1095 A. Sources of Limits on Congressional Power .................... 1098 B. Remedies and “the Battaglia Principle”.......................... 1101 1. Battaglia v. General Motors Corp. ............................ 1102 2. What Battaglia Forbids and Permits.......................... 1102 C. Constitutionally Necessary Remedies .............................. 1104
[1]
M. C. Sullivan,et al.
Administrative Law
,
2006
.
[2]
Vicki C. Jackson.
Suing the Federal Government: Sovereignty, Immunity, and Judicial Independence
,
2003
.
[3]
S. N. Greenberg.
Who Says It's a Crime?: Chevron Deference to Agency Interpretations of Regulatory Statutes that Create Criminal Liability
,
1996
.
[4]
Gary Lawson.
THE RISE AND RISE OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE STATE
,
1994
.
[5]
J. Resnik.
Rereading "The Federal Courts": Revising the Domain of Federal Courts Jurisprudence at the End of the Twentieth Century
,
1994
.
[6]
Neal T. Buethe.
United States Magistrates Hearing Civil Cases: The Constitutionality of Rendering Final Judgments after Northern Pipeline Construction Co. v. Marathon Pipe Line Co.
,
1984
.
[7]
Martin H. Redish,et al.
Congressional Power to Control the Jurisdiction of Lower Federal Courts: A Critical Review and a New Synthesis
,
1975
.