Management Utopia or User Dystopia? A Critical Analysis of a University Administration System

Enterprise Systems (ES) have been introduced into many large organizations and are found across many sectors including Higher Education which is experiencing unprecedented levels of competition, government regulation and growth in student numbers. These systems based on ‘ideal’ models of business and organisational ‘best practice’ promise vast improvement in efficiency and effectiveness according to what might be seen as utopian visions of management. In reality they can result in a more dystopian reality. This empirical study takes a critical theoretical approach to an ES implementation in a UK university which procured and installed a large scale ES, SITS (Student Information Technology System). The study uses an inductive approach using interviews, document analysis and data from high level strategic meetings. This is analysed using a critical theoretical framework. Conclusions are that SITS has effected a significant de-skilling of academics resulting in the rise of a new managerialism within the HE sector.

[1]  M. Alvesson,et al.  Making Sense of Management: A Critical Introduction , 1997 .

[2]  Christopher Grey,et al.  Critical Management Studies: Towards a More Mature Politics , 2005 .

[3]  Ojelanki K. Ngwenyama,et al.  Communication Richness in Electronic Mail: Critical Social Theory and the Contextuality of Meaning , 1997, MIS Q..

[4]  Kathy McGrath,et al.  Doing critical research in information systems: a case of theory and practice not informing each other * , 2005, Inf. Syst. J..

[5]  David E. Avison,et al.  Emancipatory Research Themes in Information Systems Development: Human, Organizational and Social Aspects , 1993, Human, Organizational, and Social Dimensions of Information Systems Development.

[6]  Teresa Waring,et al.  Communicating the complexity of computer‐integrated operations: An innovative use of process modelling in a North East hospital Trust , 2002 .

[7]  Elisabeth J. Umble,et al.  Enterprise resource planning: Implementation procedures and critical success factors , 2003, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[8]  Kees Boersma,et al.  Developing a cultural perspective on ERP , 2005, Bus. Process. Manag. J..

[9]  Toni M. Somers,et al.  The impact of critical success factors across the stages of enterprise resource planning implementations , 2001, Proceedings of the 34th Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences.

[10]  J. Herf.  Introduction to Critical Theory , 1982, Telos.

[11]  Hong Woo.  Critical success factors for implementing ERP: the case of a Chinese electronics manufacturer , 2007 .

[12]  James Cornford,et al.  ERP systems and the university as a "unique" organisation , 2004, Inf. Technol. People.

[13]  T. Davenport.  Putting the enterprise into the enterprise system. , 1998, Harvard business review.

[14]  Alan Fowler,et al.  A Framework for Stakeholder Integration in Higher Education Information Systems Projects , 2003, Technol. Anal. Strateg. Manag..

[15]  J. Law.  A Sociology of monsters: Essays on power, technology, and domination , 1991 .

[16]  Stewart Clegg,et al.  Handbook of organization studies , 1997 .

[17]  David Wainwright,et al.  Issues and challenges in the use of template analysis: twocomparative case studies from the field , 2008 .

[18]  Thomaz Wood,et al.  Reductionism and complex thinking during ERP implementations , 2001, Bus. Process. Manag. J..

[19]  Chris Westrup,et al.  Management Fashions and Information Systems , 2005 .

[20]  M. Markus,et al.  The Enterprise System Experience— From Adoption to Success , 2000 .

[21]  Rosío Alvarez,et al.  Examining technology, structure and identity during an Enterprise System implementation , 2008, Inf. Syst. J..

[22]  C. Cassell,et al.  Essential guide to qualitative methods in organizational research , 2004 .

[23]  John Mingers,et al.  Technical, Practical and Critical OR: Past, Present and Future? , 1992 .

[24]  V. Fournier,et al.  At the Critical Moment: Conditions and Prospects for Critical Management Studies , 2000 .

[25]  David W. Wainwright,et al.  The application and adaptation of a diffusion of innovation framework for information systems research in NHS general medical practice , 2007, J. Inf. Technol..

[26]  Damian Hodgson,et al.  Making Projects Critical: an Introduction , 2006 .

[27]  M. Lorentzon.  Doing Qualitative Research , 1993 .

[28]  Matthew B. Miles,et al.  Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook , 1994 .

[29]  Prasad Bingi,et al.  Critical Issues Affecting an ERP Implementation , 1999, Inf. Syst. Manag..

[30]  M. Crotty.  The Foundations of Social Research: Meaning and Perspective in the Research Process , 1998 .

[31]  B. Latour.  Technology is Society Made Durable , 1990 .

[32]  Chrisanthi Avgerou.  Doing critical research in information systems: some further thoughts , 2005, Inf. Syst. J..

[33]  Ben Light,et al.  A Critical Success Factors Model for Enterprise Resource Planning Implementation , 1999, ECIS.

[34]  M. Alvesson,et al.  On the Idea of Emancipation in Management and Organization Studies , 1992 .

[35]  Zahir Irani,et al.  Integrating ERP using EAI: a model for post hoc evaluation , 2005, Eur. J. Inf. Syst..

[36]  Enid Mumford,et al.  Effective Systems Design and Requirements Analysis , 1995 .

[37]  Zhenyu Huang,et al.  ERP implementation issues in advanced and developing countries , 2001, Bus. Process. Manag. J..

[38]  B. Macfarlane.  The Disengaged Academic: the Retreat from Citizenship , 2005 .

[39]  Christine Räisänen,et al.  Technologizing Discourse to Standardize Projects in Multi-Project Organizations: Hegemony by Consensus? , 2004 .

[40]  Rudy Hirschheim,et al.  Four paradigms of information systems development , 1989, CACM.

[41]  Ray J. Paul,et al.  The Labyrinths of Information: Challenging the Wisdom of Systems , 2005, Eur. J. Inf. Syst..

[42]  Angappa Gunasekaran,et al.  Enterprise information systems project implementation:: A case study of ERP in Rolls-Royce , 2004 .

[43]  Wanda J. Orlikowski,et al.  Technology and Institutions: What Can Research on Information Technology and Research on Organizations Learn from Each Other? , 2001, MIS Q..

[44]  A. Adam.  Whatever happened to information systems ethics? Caught between the devil and the deep blue sea , 2004 .

[45]  David W. Wainwright,et al.  Three domains for implementing integrated information systems: redressing the balance between technology, strategic and organisational analysis , 2004, Int. J. Inf. Manag..

[46]  Ziaul Huq,et al.  Realigning Top Management's Strategic Change Actions for ERP Implementation: How Specializing on Just Cultural and Environmental Contextual Factors Could Improve Success , 2007 .

[47]  Amany R. Elbanna,et al.  Implementing an integrated system in a socially dis-integrated enterprise: A critical view of ERP enabled integration , 2007, Inf. Technol. People.

[48]  Rudy Hirschheim,et al.  Realizing Emancipatory Principles in Information Systems Development: The Case for ETHICS , 1994, MIS Q..

[49]  Rachel McLean,et al.  International Journal of Information Management the Panoptic Gaze: Analysing the Interaction between Enterprise Resource Planning Technology and Organisational Culture , 2022 .

[50]  M. Lynne Markus,et al.  Learning from adopters' experiences with ERP: problems encountered and success achieved , 2000, J. Inf. Technol..

[51]  Nigel King,et al.  Using templates in the thematic analysis of text , 2004 .

[52]  Hugh Willmott,et al.  Studying Management Critically , 2003 .

[53]  BILL DOOLIN,et al.  Information technology as disciplinary technology: being critical in interpretive research on information systems , 1998, J. Inf. Technol..

[54]  Neil A. M. Maiden,et al.  The implementation of enterprise resource planning packages in different organisational and national cultures , 2001, Inf. Syst..

[55]  Eileen M. Trauth,et al.  Choosing Critical IS Research , 2005 .

[56]  CAROLE BROOKE,et al.  What does it mean to be ‘critical’ in IS research? , 2002, J. Inf. Technol..

[57]  D. Silverman.  Doing Qualitative Research , 2009 .

[58]  Ziaul Huq,et al.  BPR through ERP: Avoiding change management pitfalls , 2006 .

[59]  Christian Vogt,et al.  Intractable ERP: a comprehensive analysis of failed enterprise-resource-planning projects , 2002, SOEN.

[60]  Ronald Batenburg,et al.  Sticking to standards; technical and other isomorphic pressures in deploying ERP-systems , 2006, Inf. Manag..

[61]  Abdullah S. Al-Mudimigh,et al.  Enterprise resource planning: A taxonomy of critical factors , 2003, Eur. J. Oper. Res..

[62]  Lorraine Warren,et al.  The use of critical systems thinking in designing a system for a university information systems support service , 1999, Inf. Syst. J..

[63]  Edgar A. Whitley,et al.  On the interpretative flexibility of hosted ERP systems , 2005, J. Strateg. Inf. Syst..