Investigation of the Safety Effects of Knee Bolster Air Bag Deployment in Similar Real-World Crash Comparisons

Objective: The lower extremity is the most frequently injured body region and knee–thigh–hip (KTH) injuries account for half of these injuries. Knee bolster air bags (KBABs) have been incorporated in some vehicles to serve as an additional restraint for the occupant's knees and reduce KTH injuries. To investigate the safety benefits of KBABs, similar frontal crashes with opposing KBAB deployment were selected from the Crash Injury Research and Engineering Network (CIREN) database. Methods: An 8-point similarity scoring algorithm was used to quantify crash and occupant similarity and select case comparisons. A total of 183 cases without a KBAB were scored for similarity to 9 KBAB cases. These similarity scores were used to select 31 final case comparisons. The effect of KBAB deployment on occupant injury patterns was investigated with a particular focus on KTH injuries. Results: Over half of the occupants exposed to a KBAB sustained no KTH injuries and a reduction in femur fractures was observed in KBAB occupants (P = .036). However, increases in proximal tibia/fibula and foot/ankle fractures were observed in KBAB occupants (P = .022 and .002, respectively). Mildly significant decreases in pelvic fractures and Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS) 2+ head injuries were observed in the KBAB occupants, supporting the notion that KBABs reduce forward occupant excursion (P = .094 and .055, respectively). Investigation of each case comparison yielded further insight into the reasons for injury pattern differences between cases with opposing KBAB deployment. In addition to KBAB deployment status, differences in occupant factors (age, height, and weight) and crash factors (delta V and belt use) between the cases for a particular comparison could explain variation in injury patterns. Conclusions: The current study presents a preliminary in-depth qualitative and quantitative assessment of KBAB safety benefits. However, further investigation is recommended to provide conclusive evidence of KBAB effectiveness.

[1]  Gerald McGwin,et al.  Restraint use and lower extremity fractures in frontal motor vehicle collisions. , 2004, The Journal of trauma.

[2]  Matthew P Reed,et al.  Effects of hip posture on the frontal impact tolerance of the human hip joint. , 2003, Stapp car crash journal.

[3]  Joel D Stitzel,et al.  Investigating injury mechanism and occupant bmi for malleolar fractures in frontal motor vehicle collisions - biomed 2010. , 2010, Biomedical sciences instrumentation.

[4]  Soongu Hong,et al.  A Study on Invisible Knee Airbag Cushion Folding Design Using Doe (Design of Experimental) Method , 2007 .

[5]  Erle Stanley Gardner,et al.  The Bigger They Come , 1984 .

[6]  Tsuyoshi Yasuki,et al.  A Study of Knee Joint Kinematics and Mechanics using a Human FE Model. , 2005, Stapp car crash journal.

[7]  Carol A C Flannagan,et al.  Injury risk curves for the skeletal knee-thigh-hip complex for knee-impact loading. , 2010, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[8]  Yan Fu,et al.  A genetic algorithm for optimal design of an inflatable knee bolster , 2004 .

[9]  Matthew P Reed,et al.  The tolerance of the human hip to dynamic knee loading. , 2002, Stapp car crash journal.

[10]  Jonathan D Rupp,et al.  Injuries to the hip joint in frontal motor-vehicle crashes: biomechanical and real-world perspectives. , 2004, The Orthopedic clinics of North America.

[11]  Shashi Kuppa,et al.  An overview of knee-thigh-hip injuries in frontal crashes in the United States , 2003 .

[12]  L A Spaine,et al.  'The bigger they come ...': the relationship between body mass index and severity of ankle fractures. , 1996, Injury.

[13]  Stephen W Rouhana,et al.  Impact response and biomechanical analysis of the knee-thigh-hip complex in frontal impacts with a full human body finite element model. , 2008, Stapp car crash journal.

[14]  Rolf H. Eppinger,et al.  LOWER EXTREMITY INJURIES AND ASSOCIATED INJURY CRITERIA , 2001 .

[15]  Xavier Trosseille,et al.  Evaluation of the risk of injury caused by a knee airbag in out-of-position , 2009 .

[16]  J R Stewart,et al.  A new method for predicting crashworthiness. , 1997, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[17]  Kathryn L. Loftis,et al.  Development of a Method to Compare Real-World Crashes to Vehicle Crash Tests , 2010 .

[18]  Kristy B Arbogast,et al.  BioTab—A New Method for Analyzing and Documenting Injury Causation in Motor-Vehicle Crashes , 2011, Traffic injury prevention.

[19]  Joel D Stitzel,et al.  Categorical similarity comparison of ciren and nass. , 2008, Biomedical sciences instrumentation.

[20]  John D. States,et al.  Adult Occupant Injuries of the Lower Limb , 1986 .

[21]  G. Murray Mackay,et al.  Comparisons of Car Crashes in Three Countries , 1969 .

[22]  James K. Conlee,et al.  Blow-Molded Plastic Active Knee Bolsters , 2004 .

[23]  Kathryn L. Loftis,et al.  A similarity scoring technique to analyse comparisons of real-world crashes to crash tests: initial results from a 12-point system , 2013 .

[24]  Matthew P Reed,et al.  Characterization of knee-thigh-hip response in frontal impacts using biomechanical testing and computational simulations. , 2008, Stapp car crash journal.

[25]  P. Atkinson,et al.  Knee injuries in motor vehicle collisions: a study of the National Accident Sampling System database for the years 1979-1995. , 2000, Accident; analysis and prevention.

[26]  Joseph A Kufera,et al.  Psychosocial and physical factors associated with lower extremity injury. , 2002, Annual proceedings. Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine.

[27]  Craig S. Poster,et al.  The interaction of 'occupant factors' on the lower extremity fractures in frontal collision of motor vehicle crashes based on a level I trauma center. , 2007, The Journal of trauma.

[28]  Joel D Stitzel,et al.  Investigating the effects of side airbag deployment in real-world crashes using crash comparison techniques. , 2011, Annals of advances in automotive medicine. Association for the Advancement of Automotive Medicine. Annual Scientific Conference.

[29]  F. S. Gayzik,et al.  Development of a Full Body CAD Dataset for Computational Modeling: A Multi-modality Approach , 2011, Annals of Biomedical Engineering.

[30]  Steffen Sohr,et al.  Benefit of Adaptive Occupant Restraint Systems with Focus on the New US-NCAP Rating Requirements , 2009 .

[31]  A. Tencer,et al.  Factors affecting pelvic and thoracic forces in near-side impact crashes: a study of US-NCAP, NASS, and CIREN data. , 2005, Accident; analysis and prevention.