Theoretical analysis of the dose dependence of the oxygen enhancement ratio and its relevance for clinical applications

BackgroundThe increased resistance of hypoxic cells to ionizing radiation is usually believed to be the primary reason for treatment failure in tumors with oxygen-deficient areas. This oxygen effect can be expressed quantitatively by the oxygen enhancement ratio (OER). Here we investigate theoretically the dependence of the OER on the applied local dose for different types of ionizing irradiation and discuss its importance for clinical applications in radiotherapy for two scenarios: small dose variations during hypoxia-based dose painting and larger dose changes introduced by altered fractionation schemes.MethodsUsing the widespread Alper-Howard-Flanders and standard linear-quadratic (LQ) models, OER calculations are performed for T1 human kidney and V79 Chinese hamster cells for various dose levels and various hypoxic oxygen partial pressures (pO2) between 0.01 and 20 mmHg as present in clinical situations in vivo. Our work comprises the analysis for both low linear energy transfer (LET) treatment with photons or protons and high-LET treatment with heavy ions. A detailed analysis of experimental data from the literature with respect to the dose dependence of the oxygen effect is performed, revealing controversial opinions whether the OER increases, decreases or stays constant with dose.ResultsThe behavior of the OER with dose per fraction depends primarily on the ratios of the LQ parameters alpha and beta under hypoxic and aerobic conditions, which themselves depend on LET, pO2 and the cell or tissue type. According to our calculations, the OER variations with dose in vivo for low-LET treatments are moderate, with changes in the OER up to 11% for dose painting (1 or 3 Gy per fraction compared to 2 Gy) and up to 22% in hyper-/hypofractionation (0.5 or 20 Gy per fraction compared to 2 Gy) for oxygen tensions between 0.2 and 20 mmHg typically measured clinically in hypoxic tumors. For extremely hypoxic cells (0.01 mmHg), the dose dependence of the OER becomes more pronounced (up to 36%). For high LET, OER variations up to 4% for the whole range of oxygen tensions between 0.01 and 20 mmHg were found, which were much smaller than for low LET.ConclusionsThe formalism presented in this paper can be used for various tissue and radiation types to estimate OER variations with dose and help to decide in clinical practice whether some dose changes in dose painting or in fractionation can bring more benefit in terms of the OER in the treatment of a specific hypoxic tumor.

[1]  U Oelfke,et al.  A phenomenological model for the relative biological effectiveness in therapeutic proton beams. , 2004, Physics in medicine and biology.

[2]  B. Vojnovic,et al.  The irradiation of V79 mammalian cells by protons with energies below 2 MeV. Part I: Experimental arrangement and measurements of cell survival. , 1989, International journal of radiation biology.

[3]  P. Vaupel,et al.  Hypoxia in cancer: significance and impact on clinical outcome , 2007, Cancer and Metastasis Reviews.

[4]  E. Hall,et al.  Radiobiology for the radiologist , 1973 .

[5]  J. Lyman,et al.  In vivo cell survival and volume response characteristics of rat rhabdomyosarcoma tumors irradiated in the extended peak region of carbon- and neon-ion beams. , 1980, Radiation research.

[6]  J. Lyman,et al.  Survival of oxygenated and hypoxic tumor cells in the extended-peak regions of heavy charged-particle beams. , 1982, Radiation research.

[7]  J. Lyman,et al.  Inactivation of human kidney cells by high-energy monoenergetic heavy-ion beams. , 1979, Radiation research.

[8]  J. Fowler,et al.  Radiosensitization of Chinese hamster cells by oxygen and misonidazole at low X-ray doses. , 1986, International journal of radiation biology and related studies in physics, chemistry, and medicine.

[9]  David J. Carlson,et al.  Effects of oxygen on intrinsic radiation sensitivity: A test of the relationship between aerobic and hypoxic linear-quadratic (LQ) model parametersa). , 2006, Medical physics.

[10]  Daniela Thorwarth,et al.  Implementation of hypoxia imaging into treatment planning and delivery. , 2010, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[11]  David J. Carlson,et al.  Comparison of in vitro and in vivo a/ ratios for prostate cancer , 2004 .

[12]  S. Curtis.  Letter: The OER of mixed high- and low-LET radiation. , 1976, Radiation research.

[13]  M. Dewhirst,et al.  Tumor hypoxia adversely affects the prognosis of carcinoma of the head and neck. , 1997, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[14]  R. A. Cox,et al.  OER and RBE for negative pion beams of different peak widths. , 1979, The British journal of radiology.

[15]  Daniela Thorwarth,et al.  Modelling and simulation of [18F]fluoromisonidazole dynamics based on histology-derived microvessel maps , 2011, Physics in medicine and biology.

[16]  A. Begg,et al.  Resistance of hypoxic cells to ionizing radiation is influenced by homologous recombination status. , 2006, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[17]  E. Hall.  The effect of hypoxia on the repair of sublethal radiation damage in cultured mammalian cells. , 1972, Radiation research.

[18]  C. J. Gillespie,et al.  The inactivation of Chinese hamster cells by x rays: the effects of chemical modifiers on single- and double-events. , 1975, Radiation research.

[19]  J P Logue,et al.  Tumour oxygenation levels correlate with dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging parameters in carcinoma of the cervix. , 2000, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[20]  J P Freyer,et al.  Oxygen enhancement ratio as a function of dose and cell cycle phase for radiation-resistant and sensitive CHO cells. , 1991, Radiation research.

[21]  D. Hristov,et al.  Adapting radiotherapy to hypoxic tumours , 2006, Physics in medicine and biology.

[22]  L. Skarsgard,et al.  Dose dependence of the oxygen enhancement ratio (OER) in radiation inactivation of Chinese hamster V79-171 cells. , 1991, Radiation Research.

[23]  Jan J Wilkens,et al.  Modelling of the oxygen enhancement ratio for ion beam radiation therapy , 2011, Physics in medicine and biology.

[24]  T. Kanai,et al.  Inactivation of Aerobic and Hypoxic Cells from Three Different Cell Lines by Accelerated 3He-, 12C- and 20Ne-Ion Beams , 2000, Radiation research.

[25]  David J Brenner,et al.  The linear-quadratic model is an appropriate methodology for determining isoeffective doses at large doses per fraction. , 2008, Seminars in radiation oncology.

[26]  P. Vaupel,et al.  Hypoxia and Radiation Response in Human Tumors. , 1996, Seminars in radiation oncology.

[27]  R. A. Cox,et al.  A heavy particle comparative study. Part III: OER and RBE. , 1978, The British journal of radiology.

[28]  Jian Z. Wang,et al.  Comparison of in vitro and in vivo alpha/beta ratios for prostate cancer. , 2004, Physics in medicine and biology.

[29]  Dag Rune Olsen,et al.  Strategies for biologic image-guided dose escalation: a review. , 2009, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[30]  P. Keall,et al.  Hypofractionation results in reduced tumor cell kill compared to conventional fractionation for tumors with regions of hypoxia. , 2011, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[31]  K. Prise,et al.  The irradiation of V79 mammalian cells by protons with energies below 2 MeV. Part II. Measurement of oxygen enhancement ratios and DNA damage. , 1990, International journal of radiation biology.

[32]  Vladimir A Semenenko,et al.  Effects of oxygen on intrinsic radiation sensitivity: A test of the relationship between aerobic and hypoxic linear-quadratic (LQ) model parameters. , 2006, Medical physics.

[33]  Georgios S Stamatakos,et al.  A spatio-temporal simulation model of the response of solid tumours to radiotherapy in vivo: parametric validation concerning oxygen enhancement ratio and cell cycle duration. , 2004, Physics in medicine and biology.

[34]  TIKVAH ALPER,et al.  Role of Oxygen in Modifying the Radiosensitivity of E. Coli B. , 1956, Nature.

[35]  R. Shridhar,et al.  Characteristic 8 keV X Rays Possess Radiobiological Properties of Higher-LET Radiation , 2010, Radiation research.

[36]  A. Maggi,et al.  Relationships between cell killing, mutation induction and DNA damage in X-irradiated V79 cells: the influence of oxygen and DMSO. , 1991, International journal of radiation biology.

[37]  T L Phillips,et al.  Oxygen in human tumors: correlations between methods of measurement and response to therapy. Summary of a workshop held November 19-20, 1992, at the National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, Maryland. , 1993, Radiation research.

[38]  A. Kellerer,et al.  A generalized formulation of dual radiation action. , 2012, Radiation research.

[39]  P. Vaupel,et al.  Tumor hypoxia: definitions and current clinical, biologic, and molecular aspects. , 2001, Journal of the National Cancer Institute.

[40]  R K Sachs,et al.  The link between low-LET dose-response relations and the underlying kinetics of damage production/repair/misrepair. , 1997, International journal of radiation biology.

[41]  L. Verhey,et al.  Relative biological effectiveness of a high energy modulated proton beam using a spontaneous murine tumor in vivo. , 1980, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[42]  H. Lyng,et al.  Hypoxia-induced treatment failure in advanced squamous cell carcinoma of the uterine cervix is primarily due to hypoxia-induced radiation resistance rather than hypoxia-induced metastasis , 2000, British Journal of Cancer.

[43]  X. Li,et al.  Dose escalation to combat hypoxia in prostate cancer: a radiobiological study on clinical data. , 2006, The British journal of radiology.

[44]  Steven F Petit,et al.  Intra-voxel heterogeneity influences the dose prescription for dose-painting with radiotherapy: a modelling study , 2009, Physics in medicine and biology.

[45]  B. Wouters,et al.  Cells at intermediate oxygen levels can be more important than the "hypoxic fraction" in determining tumor response to fractionated radiotherapy. , 1997, Radiation research.

[46]  E. Malaise,et al.  Measurement of RBE, OER, and recovery of potentially lethal damage of a 645 MeV helium ion beam using EMT6 cells. , 1977, Radiation research.

[47]  Harald Paganetti,et al.  Relative biological effectiveness (RBE) values for proton beam therapy. , 2002, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.