Critique of dose response in carcinogenesis

A few landmarks in the development of dose response in toxicology are presented, with an explanation of why dose should only be considered on a logarithmic scale. Examples are shown, illustrating that the current practice of labeling dose-response curves for carcinogenesis as supralinear, linear or sublinear, is meaningless unless the dose-response scales are defined. Since many reports labeling such curves as supralinear, linear, or sublinear are carried out with dose on a linear scale, the scientific significance of the shape of the curve is obscured. Examples of dose-response curves for carcinogenesis from 2-acetylaminofluorene, N-nitrosodiethylamine, aflatoxins, and radium are shown. In addition, more than 500 National Toxicology Program Technical Reports (NTP-TR) on carcinogenicity were examined; from this database, three groups of studies were selected. The first group consisted of those studies in which the lowest dose produced no tumors and the study had a positive dose response. The second group consisted of those studies with three or more doses, with a positive dose response producing tumors, but in which there were no tumors in the control group. The third group of more than 50 studies was from NTP-TR-00 to NTP-TR-52 that had only two data points with a positive dose response. These studies were all evaluated on the Rozman et al. scale, since it conforms to the laws of nature and allows evaluation of all doses. It was observed that virtually all of these NTP-TR carcinogenicity studies show a linear response when dose is on this logarithmic scale; a clear threshold for carcinogenicity is typical for nearly all of these chemicals. An exponential dose-response curve was a better fit for a few, but experimental error could account for this deviation from linearity. It is pointed out that there is strong experimental evidence that the mere presence of DNA adducts does not necessarily lead to tumor production. Hormesis probably applies to carcino-genesis and proof of this will require abandoning the no threshold concept. Experiments showing that cumulative dose is a better metric than daily dose may require reevaluating almost all carcinogenicity studies.

[1]  A. Hill.  The Combinations of Haemoglobin with Oxygen and with Carbon Monoxide. I. , 1913, The Biochemical journal.

[2]  J. Gaddum,et al.  Lognormal Distributions , 1945, Nature.

[3]  J. Gaddum.  Bioassays and mathematics. , 1953, Pharmacological reviews.

[4]  G. Wogan,et al.  Carcinogenic effects of low dietary levels of aflatoxin B1 in rats. , 1974, Food and cosmetics toxicology.

[5]  V. Burse,et al.  Induction of liver tumor in Sherman strain female rats by polychlorinated biphenyl aroclor 1260. , 1975, Journal of the National Cancer Institute.

[6]  C. Wade,et al.  Results of a two-year chronic toxicity and oncogenicity study of 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin in rats. , 1978, Toxicology and applied pharmacology.

[7]  A. Pegg,et al.  Formation and subsequent removal of O6-methylguanine from deoxyribonucleic acid in rat liver and kidney after small doses of dimethylnitrosamine. , 1978, The Biochemical journal.

[8]  R. Kodell,et al.  Dose and time responses models for the incidence of bladder and liver neoplasms in mice fed 2-acetylaminofluorene continuously. , 1980, Journal of environmental pathology and toxicology.

[9]  D. Gaylor,et al.  Journal Abstracts , 1979, Journal of environmental pathology and toxicology.

[10]  W F Boron,et al.  Intracellular pH. , 1981, Physiological reviews.

[11]  M. Beers,et al.  The Merck Manual of Diagnosis and Therapy , 1982 .

[12]  L. Stoloff.  Aflatoxin as a cause of primary liver-cell cancer in the United States: a probability study. , 1983, Nutrition and cancer.

[13]  H. Greim,et al.  Pathology of chronic polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB) feeding in rats. , 1984, Toxicology and applied pharmacology.

[14]  E A Crouch,et al.  Dose-response relationships for carcinogens: a review. , 1987, Environmental health perspectives.

[15]  F. Beland,et al.  Comparison between DNA adduct formation and tumorigenesis in livers and bladders of mice chronically fed 2-acetylaminofluorene. , 1991, Carcinogenesis.

[16]  P Grasso,et al.  Effects on 4080 rats of chronic ingestion of N-nitrosodiethylamine or N-nitrosodimethylamine: a detailed dose-response study. , 1991, Cancer research.

[17]  K. Kitchin,et al.  Dose-response relationship for rat liver DNA damage caused by 49 rodent carcinogens. , 1994, Toxicology.

[18]  M. Hollinger,et al.  CRC handbook of toxicology , 1995 .

[19]  H. Greim,et al.  A toxicologist's view of cancer risk assessment. , 1996, Drug metabolism reviews.

[20]  T. Lange,et al.  Dissimilarity in aflatoxin dose-response relationships between DNA adduct formation and development of preneoplastic foci in rat liver. , 1997, Chemico-biological interactions.

[21]  E. Calabrese,et al.  Can the concept of hormesis Be generalized to carcinogenesis? , 1998, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP.

[22]  M. C. Newman,et al.  The individual tolerance concept is not the sole explanation for the probit dose‐effect model , 2000 .

[23]  The individual tolerance concept is not the sole explanation for the probit dose‐effect model , 2000 .

[24]  G M Williams,et al.  Mechanistic Basis for Nonlinearities and Thresholds in Rat Liver Carcinogenesis by the DNA-Reactive Carcinogens 2-Acetylaminofluorene and Diethylnitrosamine , 2000, Toxicologic pathology.

[25]  T. Tsukamoto,et al.  Lack of a Dose‐response Relationship for Carcinogenicity in the Rat Liver with Low Doses of 2‐Amino‐3,8‐dimethylimidazo[4,5‐f]quinoxaline or N‐Nitrosodiethylamine , 2002, Japanese journal of cancer research : Gann.

[26]  W. Waddell.  Thresholds of carcinogenicity of flavors. , 2002, Toxicological sciences : an official journal of the Society of Toxicology.

[27]  Thresholds of carcinogenicity in the ED01 study. , 2003, Toxicological sciences : an official journal of the Society of Toxicology.

[28]  W. Waddell.  Thresholds in Chemical Carcinogenesis: What Are Animal Experiments Telling Us? , 2003, Toxicologic pathology.

[29]  Hiroyuki Tsuda,et al.  Value of GST-P Positive Preneoplastic Hepatic Foci in Dose-Response Studies of Hepatocarcinogenesis: Evidence for Practical Thresholds with Both Genotoxic and Nongenotoxic Carcinogens. A Review of Recent Work , 2003, Toxicologic pathology.

[30]  W. Waddell.  Threshold for carcinogenicity of N-nitrosodiethylamine for esophageal tumors in rats. , 2003, Food and chemical toxicology : an international journal published for the British Industrial Biological Research Association.

[31]  W. Waddell.  Comparison of human exposures to selected chemicals with thresholds from NTP carcinogenicity studies in rodents , 2003, Human & experimental toxicology.

[32]  J. Swenberg,et al.  Molecular dosimetry of N7-(2-hydroxypropyl)guanine in tissues of F344 rats after inhalation exposure to propylene oxide. , 2003, Carcinogenesis.

[33]  Thresholds of Carcinogenicity in the ED 01 Study , 2003 .

[34]  Reply to Gaylor , 2003 .

[35]  Thresholds in carcinogenicity in ED01 study. , 2003, Toxicological sciences : an official journal of the Society of Toxicology.

[36]  S. Peña-Llopis,et al.  Fish tolerance to organophosphate-induced oxidative stress is dependent on the glutathione metabolism and enhanced by N-acetylcysteine. , 2003, Aquatic toxicology.

[37]  William J. Waddell,et al.  Dose-Response Curves in Chemical Carcinogenesis , 2004, Nonlinearity in biology, toxicology, medicine.

[38]  P. Carmichael,et al.  Correlation of tumors with DNA adducts from methyl eugenol and tamoxifen in rats. , 2004, Toxicological sciences : an official journal of the Society of Toxicology.

[39]  W. Waddell.  Comparisons of thresholds for carcinogenicity on linear and logarithmic dosage scales , 2005, Human & experimental toxicology.

[40]  D. Gardner.  Toxicology of the Lung , 2005 .

[41]  S. Fukushima,et al.  Hormesis and dose-response-mediated mechanisms in carcinogenesis: evidence for a threshold in carcinogenicity of non-genotoxic carcinogens. , 2005, Carcinogenesis.

[42]  D. Pinson,et al.  Chronic toxicity and carcinogenicity of 1,2,3,4,6,7,8-heptachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin displays a distinct dose/time toxicity threshold (c x t = k) and a life-prolonging subthreshold effect. , 2005, Food and chemical toxicology : an international journal published for the British Industrial Biological Research Association.

[43]  Should hormesis be the default model in risk assessment? , 2005, Human & experimental toxicology.

[44]  S. Fukushima,et al.  Concordance of thresholds for carcinogenicity of N-nitrosodiethylamine , 2006, Archives of Toxicology.

[45]  K. Rozman.  Hormesis and risk assessment , 2005, Human & experimental toxicology.

[46]  Dose thresholds should exist for chemical carcinogens. , 2005, Toxicological sciences : an official journal of the Society of Toxicology.

[47]  Influences of Dynamics, Kinetics, and Exposure on Toxicity in the Lung , 2005 .

[48]  Saralees Nadarajah,et al.  Letter to the editor , 2007, Int. Trans. Oper. Res..