An approach to validation of thermomechanical models

Thermomechanical models are being developed to support the design of an Exploratory Studies Facility (ESF) and a potential high-level nuclear waste repository at Yucca Mountain, Nevada. These models are used for preclosure design of underground openings, such as access drifts, emplacement drifts, and waste emplacement boreholes; and in support of postclosure issue resolution relating to waste canister performance, disturbance of the hydrological properties of the host rock, and overall system performance assessment. For both design and performance assessment, the purpose of using models in analyses is to better understand and quantify some phenomenon or process. Therefore, validation is an important process that must be pursued in conjunction with the development and application of models. The Site Characterization Plan (SCP) addressed some general aspects of model validation, but no specific approach has, as yet, been developed for either design or performance assessment models. This paper will discuss a proposed process for thermomechanical model validation and will focus on the use of laboratory and in situ experiments as part of the validation process. The process may be generic enough in nature that it could be applied to the validation of other types of models, for example, models of unsaturated hydrologic flow.