Relational contracting methods are a natural evolution from the many versions of project delivery that have been developed over the past two decades aimed at increasing the amount of integration and collaboration among mega-project stakeholders. Alliancing was born in the 1990’s in North Sea oilfields and imported down under to Australia and New Zealand where it has used to deliver over 300 complex projects. The litigious environment present in the North American construction sector led project owners to implement partnering programs to enhance the quality of relationships on projects of all sizes delivered using the full spectrum of delivery methods. Integrated Project Delivery (IPD) made its appearance in 2002, employing nonbinding partnering program objectives into multi-party relational contracts. While developed separately, alliancing and IPD share the same objective: an environment where decisions are made on a “best-for-project” basis and all stakeholders share the both the pain and the gain associated with ultimate project performance. This paper chronicles the evolution of project delivery methods, as well as their successes and failures. The paper finds that each approach has been tailored to maximize collaboration within each culture’s legal and business environment. It also finds that alliancing appears to offer the most advantages and has a welldocumented record of success. Lastly, the paper recommends that the commercial building project IPD currently used in North America needs to be revised to increase its potential on complex megaprojects.
[2]
J. Barlow,et al.
Innovation and learning in complex offshore construction projects
,
2000
.
[3]
Craig L. Simoneau.
Alternative contracting methods in the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
,
1992
.
[4]
Peter E.D. Love,et al.
Risk/Reward Compensation Model for Civil Engineering Infrastructure Alliance Projects
,
2011
.
[5]
Douglas D. Gransberg,et al.
Effective Tools for Projects Delivered by Construction Manager–General Contractor Method
,
2012
.
[6]
Pertti Lahdenperä,et al.
Making sense of the multi-party contractual arrangements of project partnering, project alliancing and integrated project delivery
,
2012
.
[7]
Colin Duffield,et al.
In pursuit of additional value: A benchmarking study into alliancing in the Australian Public Sector
,
2009
.
[8]
Yi Min Xie,et al.
Overview of alliancing research and practice in the construction industry
,
2012
.