Reductionism in Cultural Ecology: The Amazon Case [and Comments and Reply]

Cultural ecologists attempting to trace the influence of ecological scarcities on cultural development are often criticized for reductionism. In the Amazon case, critics of ecological theories have argued that resource scarcity is of minor importance as a determinant of cultural features because native communities appear to enjoy abundant land and fully nutritious diets. This paper presents data and arguments suggesting that much of this "resource abundance" is the anthropologist's artifact and does not accurately reflect native perceptions of their environment and of competition from their neighbors. Furthermore, "reductionism" is a universal feature of scientific explanation and is even to be found in antiecological eclectic and structural explanations. Although cultural ecologists can improve their explanations by combining theoretical approaches and developing multivariate models, some degree of reductionism is unavoidable wherever explanation is a goal.

[1]  D. Bohm,et al.  Causality and Chance in Modern Physics , 1963 .

[2]  G. Mesher,et al.  royal Incest: a reply to Sturtevant , 1981 .

[3]  R. Redfield,et al.  The primitive world and its transformations , 1953 .

[4]  C. Spath.  Getting to the Meat of the Problem: Some Comments on Protein as a Limiting Factor in Amazonia , 1981 .

[5]  E. Mayr.  Cause and effect in biology. , 1961, Science.

[6]  G. Orians.  Natural Selection and Ecological Theory , 1962, The American Naturalist.

[7]  S. George,et al.  Assessment of the World Food Situation-Present and Future , 1975, Food and nutrition.

[8]  D. Mclaren,et al.  The great protein fiasco. , 1974, Lancet.

[9]  Terence S. Turner.  5. THE GÊ AND BORORO SOCIETIES AS DIALECTICAL SYSTEMS: A GENERAL MODEL , 1979 .

[10]  J. Bennett,et al.  Anticipation, adaptation, and the concept of culture in anthropology. , 1976, Science.

[11]  B. Meggers.  Environmental Limitation on the Development of Culture1 , 1954 .

[12]  Mary W. Helms,et al.  Beyond the Myths of Culture: Essays in Cultural Materialism. , 1981 .

[13]  S. A. Barnett,et al.  The natural regulation of animal numbers , 1955 .

[14]  G. Sarton.  The Relation of Nature to Man in Aboriginal America , 1927, Nature.

[15]  Andrew McLaughlin,et al.  Contemporary Schools of Metascience , 1969, Telos.

[16]  Allen Johnson,et al.  Nutritional criteria in machiguenga food production decisions: A linear-programming analysis , 1982 .

[17]  R. I. M. Dunbar.  Sex, Evolution, and Behavior, 2nd Edition, Martin Daly, Margo Wilson. Willard Grant Press, Boston (1983), xiv, +402. Price £15.75 (paperback) , 1984 .

[18]  A. Wallace,et al.  Slash-and-burn Agriculture: A Closer Look at its Implications for Settlement Patterns , 1960 .

[19]  N. Chagnon,et al.  Protein deficiency and tribal warfare in Amazonia: new data. , 1979, Science.

[20]  J. M. Smith,et al.  Optimization Theory in Evolution , 1978 .

[21]  M. Ravenel,et al.  Science and the Modern World , 1926 .

[22]  P. Pellett.  Nutritional problems of the Arab world , 1976 .

[23]  Paul W. Diener,et al.  Meat, markets, and mechanical materialism: The great protein fiasco in anthropology , 1980 .

[24]  M. Chibnik.  Ch. (4) The statistical behavior approach: the choice between wage labor and cash cropping in rural Belize. , 1980 .

[25]  M. Harris.  Cows, Pigs, Wars, and Witches: The Riddles of Culture , 1974 .

[26]  C. Behrens.  Time allocation and meat procurement among the Shipibo Indians of eastern Peru , 1981 .

[27]  S. Beckerman.  The Abundance of Protein in Amazonia: A Reply to Gross , 1979 .

[28]  D. Hegsted.  Protein-calorie malnutrition. , 1978, American scientist.

[29]  Daniel R. Gross,et al.  Protein Capture and Cultural Development in the Amazon Basin1 , 1975 .

[30]  E. Ross,et al.  On Food Taboos and Amazon Cultural Ecology , 1979, Current Anthropology.

[31]  M. Harris,et al.  崩れゆくアメリカ = America now : the anthropology of a changing culture , 1981 .

[32]  N. Scrimshaw,et al.  The requirements of human nutrition. , 1976, Scientific American.

[33]  R. Murphy.  Headhunter's Heritage: Social and Economic Change among the Mundurucú Indians , 1960 .

[34]  P. V. Sukhatme.  Protein Gap , 1974, Nature.

[35]  W. Wimsatt.  Reductionism, Levels of Organization, and the Mind-Body Problem , 1976 .

[36]  H. Brookfield,et al.  Intensification and disintensification in Pacific agriculture: a theoretical approach , 1972 .

[37]  E. Berlin,et al.  An assessment of the nutritional and health status of an aguaruna jivaro community, amazonas, Peru , 1977 .

[38]  R. Levins.  Evolution in Changing Environments , 1968 .

[39]  Robinson Crusoe and Friday: Strength and Weakness of the Big Man Paradigm , 1973 .

[40]  A. Kroeber,et al.  Cultural and natural areas of native North America , 1939 .

[41]  D. C. Phillips.  Holistic Thought in Social Science , 1976 .

[42]  Ellen B. Basso,et al.  Food Taboos, Diet, and Hunting Strategy: The Adaptation to Animals in Amazon Cultural Ecology [and Comments and Reply] , 1978, Current Anthropology.

[43]  W. Newcomb.  A Re‐examination of the Causes of Plains Warfare , 1950 .

[44]  Napoleon A. Chagnon,et al.  Evolutionary biology and human social behavior: An anthropological perspective , 1979 .