Bispectral index for improving intraoperative awareness and early postoperative recovery in adults.

BACKGROUND The use of clinical signs, or end-tidal anaesthetic gas (ETAG), may not be reliable in measuring the hypnotic component of anaesthesia and may lead to either overdosage or underdosage resulting in adverse effects because of too deep or too light anaesthesia. Intraoperative awareness, whilst uncommon, may lead to serious psychological disturbance, and alternative methods to monitor the depth of anaesthesia may reduce the incidence of serious events. Bispectral index (BIS) is a numerical scale based on electrical activity in the brain. Using a BIS monitor to guide the dose of anaesthetic may have advantages over clinical signs or ETAG. This is an update of a review last published in 2014. OBJECTIVES To assess the effectiveness of BIS to reduce the risk of intraoperative awareness and early recovery times from general anaesthesia in adults undergoing surgery. SEARCH METHODS We searched CENTRAL, MEDLINE, Embase, and Web of Science on 26 March 2019. We searched clinical trial registers and grey literature, and handsearched reference lists of included studies and related reviews. SELECTION CRITERIA We included randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and quasi-RCTs in which BIS was used to guide anaesthesia compared with standard practice which was either clinical signs or end-tidal anaesthetic gas (ETAG) to guide the anaesthetic dose. We included adult participants undergoing any type of surgery under general anaesthesia regardless of whether included participants had a high risk of intraoperative awareness. We included only studies in which investigators aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of BIS for its role in monitoring intraoperative depth of anaesthesia or potential improvements in early recovery times from anaesthesia. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS Two review authors independently assessed studies for inclusion, extracted data, and assessed risk of bias. We assessed the certainty of evidence with GRADE. MAIN RESULTS We included 52 studies with 41,331 participants; two studies were quasi-randomized and the remaining studies were RCTs. All studies included participants undergoing surgery under general anaesthesia. Three studies recruited only participants who were at high risk of intraoperative awareness, whilst two studies specifically recruited an unselected participant group. We analysed the data according to two comparison groups: BIS versus clinical signs; and BIS versus ETAG. Forty-eight studies used clinical signs as a comparison method, which included titration of anaesthesia according to criteria such as blood pressure or heart rate and, six studies used ETAG to guide anaesthesia. Whilst BIS target values differed between studies, all were within a range of values between 40 to 60.BIS versus clinical signsWe found low-certainty evidence that BIS-guided anaesthesia may reduce the risk of intraoperative awareness in a surgical population that were unselected or at high risk of awareness (Peto odds ratio (OR) 0.36, 95% CI 0.21 to 0.60; I2 = 61%; 27 studies; 9765 participants). However, events were rare with only five of 27 studies with reported incidences; we found that incidences of intraoperative awareness when BIS was used were three per 1000 (95% CI 2 to 6 per 1000) compared to nine per 1000 when anaesthesia was guided by clinical signs. Of the five studies with event data, one included participants at high risk of awareness and one included unselected participants, four used a structured questionnaire for assessment, and two used an adjudication process to identify confirmed or definite awareness.Early recovery times were also improved when BIS was used. We found low-certainty evidence that BIS may reduce the time to eye opening by mean difference (MD) 1.78 minutes (95% CI -2.53 to -1.03 minutes; 22 studies; 1494 participants), the time to orientation by MD 3.18 minutes (95% CI -4.03 to -2.33 minutes; 6 studies; 273 participants), and the time to discharge from the postanaesthesia care unit (PACU) by MD 6.86 minutes (95% CI -11.72 to -2 minutes; 13 studies; 930 participants).BIS versus ETAGAgain, events of intraoperative awareness were extremely rare, and we found no evidence of a difference in incidences of intraoperative awareness according to whether anaesthesia was guided by BIS or by ETAG in a surgical population at unselected or at high risk of awareness (Peto OR 1.13, 95% CI 0.56 to 2.26; I2 = 37%; 5 studies; 26,572 participants; low-certainty evidence). Incidences of intraoperative awareness were one per 1000 in both groups. Only three of five studies reported events, two included participants at high risk of awareness and one included unselected participants, all used a structured questionnaire for assessment and an adjudication process to identify confirmed or definite awareness.One large study (9376 participants) reported a reduced time to discharge from the PACU by a median of three minutes less, and we judged the certainty of this evidence to be low. No studies measured or reported the time to eye opening and the time to orientation.Certainty of the evidenceWe used GRADE to downgrade the evidence for all outcomes to low certainty. The incidence of intraoperative awareness is so infrequent such that, despite the inclusion of some large multi-centre studies in analyses, we believed that the effect estimates were imprecise. In addition, analyses included studies that we judged to have limitations owing to some assessments of high or unclear bias and in all studies, it was not possible to blind anaesthetists to the different methods of monitoring depth of anaesthesia.Studies often did not report a clear definition of intraoperative awareness. Time points of measurement differed, and methods used to identify intraoperative awareness also differed and we expected that some assessment tools were more comprehensive than others. AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS Intraoperative awareness is infrequent and, despite identifying a large number of eligible studies, evidence for the effectiveness of using BIS to guide anaesthetic depth is imprecise. We found that BIS-guided anaesthesia compared to clinical signs may reduce the risk of intraoperative awareness and improve early recovery times in people undergoing surgery under general anaesthesia but we found no evidence of a difference between BIS-guided anaesthesia and ETAG-guided anaesthesia. We found six studies awaiting classification and two ongoing studies; inclusion of these studies in future updates may increase the certainty of the evidence.

[1]  C. Kim,et al.  The Usefulness of the Bispectral Index during Propofol and Fentanyl Anesthesia for Coronary Bypass Surgery under Cardiopulmonary Bypass , 2003 .

[2]  R. Hetherington,et al.  A SIMPLE STUDY OF AWARENESS AND DREAMING DURING ANAESTHESIA , 1970 .

[3]  K. Leslie,et al.  For Personal Use. Only Reproduce with Permission from the Lancet , 2022 .

[4]  A. Iorio,et al.  Impact of including or excluding both-armed zero-event studies on using standard meta-analysis methods for rare event outcome: a simulation study , 2016, BMJ Open.

[5]  P. White,et al.  The Effect of Cerebral Monitoring on Recovery After General Anesthesia: A Comparison of the Auditory Evoked Potential and Bispectral Index Devices with Standard Clinical Practice , 2003, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[6]  Gordon H Guyatt,et al.  GRADE guidelines: 7. Rating the quality of evidence--inconsistency. , 2011, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[7]  Tony Gin,et al.  BIS-guided Anesthesia Decreases Postoperative Delirium and Cognitive Decline , 2013, Journal of neurosurgical anesthesiology.

[8]  Effect of bispectral index monitoring on extubation time and analgesic consumption in abdominal surgery: a randomised clinical trial. , 2012, Swiss medical weekly.

[9]  Yuanhai Li,et al.  Bispectral Index Monitoring During Anesthesia Promotes Early Postoperative Recovery of Cognitive Function and Reduces Acute Delirium in Elderly Patients with Colon Carcinoma: A Prospective Controlled Study using the Attention Network Test , 2018, Medical science monitor : international medical journal of experimental and clinical research.

[10]  R. Marcus,et al.  Impact of Bispectral Index Monitoring on Fast Tracking of Gynecologic Patients Undergoing Laparoscopic Surgery , 2003, Anesthesiology.

[11]  P. White,et al.  Bispectral index monitoring does not improve early recovery of geriatric outpatients undergoing brief surgical procedures , 2006, Canadian journal of anaesthesia = Journal canadien d'anesthesie.

[12]  M. Witkowska,et al.  Wpływ monitorowania indeksu bispektralnego na dawkowanie środków anestetycznych w docelowej infuzji kontrolowanej do operacji dysków lędźwiowych , 2014 .

[13]  Hyun Sik Chung Awareness and recall during general anesthesia , 2014, Korean journal of anesthesiology.

[14]  M. Struys,et al.  Comparison of Closed-loop Controlled Administration of Propofol Using Bispectral Index as the Controlled Variable versus “Standard Practice” Controlled Administration , 2001, Anesthesiology.

[15]  A. Majid,et al.  Impact of Bispectral Index Monitoring on Propofol Administration in Patients Undergoing Cardiopulmonary Bypass , 2007, Anaesthesia and intensive care.

[16]  Peter S. Sebel,et al.  Can We Monitor Depth of Anesthesia? , 2001 .

[17]  M. Ghoneim,et al.  Awareness During Anesthesia: Risk Factors, Causes and Sequelae: A Review of Reported Cases in the Literature , 2009, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[18]  D. Jain,et al.  Comparison of bispectral index and end-tidal anaesthetic concentration monitoring on recovery profile of desflurane in patients undergoing lumbar spine surgery , 2018, Indian journal of anaesthesia.

[19]  Shoyeb Khan,et al.  Effect of bispectral index versus end-tidal anesthetic gas concentration-guided protocol on time to tracheal extubation for halothane-based general anesthesia , 2016, Anesthesia, essays and researches.

[20]  R. Thisted,et al.  BIS Monitoring to Prevent Awareness during General Anesthesia , 2001, Anesthesiology.

[21]  The Entropy Module® and Bispectral Index® as Guidance for Propofol-Remifentanil Anaesthesia in Combination with Regional Anaesthesia Compared with a Standard Clinical Practice Group , 2010, Anaesthesia and intensive care.

[22]  K. Muralidhar,et al.  Bispectral index-guided anaesthesia for off-pump coronary artery bypass grafting. , 2008, Annals of cardiac anaesthesia.

[23]  G. Mashour,et al.  Protocol for the BAG-RECALL clinical trial: a prospective, multi-center, randomized, controlled trial to determine whether a bispectral index-guided protocol is superior to an anesthesia gas-guided protocol in reducing intraoperative awareness with explicit recall in high risk surgical patients , 2009, BMC anesthesiology.

[24]  G. Guyatt,et al.  GRADE guidelines 6. Rating the quality of evidence--imprecision. , 2011, Journal of clinical epidemiology.

[25]  H. Grocott,et al.  The Impact of Bispectral Index Versus End-Tidal Anesthetic Concentration-Guided Anesthesia on Time to Tracheal Extubation in Fast-Track Cardiac Surgery , 2013, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[26]  T. Gruenberger,et al.  Nitrous oxide may not increase the risk of cancer recurrence after colorectal surgery: a follow-up of a randomized controlled trial , 2009, BMC anesthesiology.

[27]  Mary F. Casserly,et al.  5th National Audit Project (NAP5) on accidental awareness during general anaesthesia: summary of main findings and risk factors. , 2014, British journal of anaesthesia.

[28]  P. Sebel,et al.  Preserved Memory Function during Bispectral Index–guided Anesthesia with Sevoflurane for Major Orthopedic Surgery , 2009, Anesthesiology.

[29]  C. Spies,et al.  Monitoring depth of anaesthesia in a randomized trial decreases the rate of postoperative delirium but not postoperative cognitive dysfunction. , 2013, British journal of anaesthesia.

[30]  I. Salehi,et al.  The Ability of Bispectral-Guided Management Compared to Routine Monitoring for Reflecting Awareness Rate in Patients Undergoing Abdominal Surgery , 2014, Iranian Red Crescent medical journal.

[31]  A. Turkistani,et al.  Effect of bispectral index (BIS) monitoring on postoperative recovery and sevoflurane consumption among morbidly obese patients undergoing laparoscopic gastric banding. , 2008, Middle East journal of anaesthesiology.

[32]  Lian Liu,et al.  BIS Monitoring on Intraoperative Awareness: A Meta-analysis , 2018, Current Medical Science.

[33]  A. Rostami,et al.  Studying the effects of BIS Monitoring (Depth of Anesthesia) in early Extubation of Patients Candidated for Non-Emergency CABG , 2017 .

[34]  F. Chung,et al.  Titration of isoflurane using BIS index improves early recovery of elderly patients undergoing orthopedic surgeries , 2002, Canadian journal of anaesthesia = Journal canadien d'anesthesie.

[35]  C. Trepte,et al.  Bispectral index guided titration of sevoflurane in on-pump cardiac surgery reduces plasma sevoflurane concentration and vasopressor requirements: A prospective, controlled, sequential two-arm clinical study , 2014, European journal of anaesthesiology.

[36]  K. Filos,et al.  Anesthesia management for the super obese: is sevoflurane superior to propofol as a sole anesthetic agent? A double-blind randomized controlled trial. , 2015, European review for medical and pharmacological sciences.

[37]  Spencer S. Liu Effects of Bispectral Index Monitoring on Ambulatory Anesthesia: A Meta-analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials and a Cost Analysis , 2004, Anesthesiology.

[38]  A. G. Messina,et al.  Anaesthetic interventions for prevention of awareness during surgery. , 2016, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[39]  Zhen Zhao,et al.  Bispectral index monitoring prevent awareness during total intravenous anesthesia: a prospective, randomized, double-blinded, multi-center controlled trial. , 2011, Chinese medical journal.

[40]  Peter S. Sebel,et al.  Bispectral Index Monitoring Allows Faster Emergence and Improved Recovery from Propofol, Alfentanil, and Nitrous Oxide Anesthesia , 1997 .

[41]  G. Mashour,et al.  Protocol for the "Michigan Awareness Control Study": A prospective, randomized, controlled trial comparing electronic alerts based on bispectral index monitoring or minimum alveolar concentration for the prevention of intraoperative awareness , 2009, BMC anesthesiology.

[42]  Seongtae Jeong,et al.  The Effect of Bispectral Index Monitoring on Anesthetic Use and Recovery in Long Duration Sevoflurane Anesthesia , 2002 .

[43]  A. Apan,et al.  Effect of bispectral index monitoring on sevoflurane consumption , 2003, European journal of anaesthesiology.

[44]  W. Bernardo,et al.  Benefício da anestesia geral com monitoração do índice bispectral em comparação com o monitoramento guiado apenas por parâmetros clínicos. Revisão sistemática e metanálise , 2017 .

[45]  H. Asadi,et al.  FACILITATE IN ELDERLY WAKING AFTER SURGERY WITH DEPTH OF ANESTHESIA MONITORING , 2014 .

[46]  A. Zbinden,et al.  Different benefit of bispectal index (BIS™) in desflurane and propofol anesthesia , 2003, Acta anaesthesiologica Scandinavica.

[47]  M. Antonelli,et al.  Minimum alveolar concentration threshold of sevoflurane for postoperative dream recall. , 2015, Minerva Anestesiologica.

[48]  Karen B. Domino,et al.  The Incidence of Awareness During Anesthesia: A Multicenter United States Study , 2004, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[49]  Paul F. White,et al.  Titration of Volatile Anesthetics Using Bispectral Index Facilitates Recovery after Ambulatory Anesthesia , 1997, Anesthesiology.

[50]  S. Omar,et al.  Bispectral Index Monitoring Tailors Clinical Anesthetic Delivery and Reduces Anesthetic Drug Consumption , 2009 .

[51]  M. Fischler,et al.  Does Monitoring Bispectral Index or Spectral Entropy Reduce Sevoflurane Use? , 2006, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[52]  Hong Ma,et al.  Does the Use of Electroencephalographic Bispectral Index or Auditory Evoked Potential Index Monitoring Facilitate Recovery after Desflurane Anesthesia in the Ambulatory Setting? , 2004, Anesthesiology.

[53]  Gordon H Guyatt,et al.  GrADe : what is “ quality of evidence ” and why is it important to clinicians ? rATING quALITY of evIDeNCe AND STreNGTH of reCommeNDATIoNS , 2022 .

[54]  George A. Mashour,et al.  Prevention of Intraoperative Awareness with Explicit Recall in an Unselected Surgical Population: A Randomized Comparative Effectiveness Trial , 2012, Anesthesiology.

[55]  M. Lazarides,et al.  Influence of bispectral index monitoring on decision making during cardiac anesthesia. , 2005, Journal of clinical anesthesia.

[56]  Özlem Korkmaz Dilmen,et al.  The Effect of BIS Usage on Anaesthetic Agent Consumption, Haemodynamics and Recovery Time in Supratentorial Mass Surgery. , 2014, Turkish journal of anaesthesiology and reanimation.

[57]  Min-Hsien Chiang,et al.  Bispectral Index and non-Bispectral Index anesthetic protocols on postoperative recovery outcomes. , 2018, Minerva anestesiologica.

[58]  A. Yli-Hankala,et al.  Sevoflurane Titration Using Bispectral Index Decreases Postoperative Vomiting in Phase II Recovery After Ambulatory Surgery , 2001, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[59]  M. Todd,et al.  EEGs, EEG processing, and the bispectral index. , 1998, Anesthesiology.

[60]  J. Bruhn,et al.  Narcotrend or Bispectral Index Monitoring During Desflurane-Remifentanil Anesthesia: A Comparison with a Standard Practice Protocol , 2005, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[61]  K. Leslie,et al.  Recovery from Bispectral Index-guided Anaesthesia in a Large Randomized Controlled Trial of Patients at High Risk of Awareness , 2005, Anaesthesia and intensive care.

[62]  Yodying Punjasawadwong,et al.  Bispectral index for improving anaesthetic delivery and postoperative recovery. , 2014, The Cochrane database of systematic reviews.

[63]  I. Kissin A Concept for Assessing Interactions of General Anesthetics , 1997, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[64]  M. Nemati,et al.  Comparative Efficacy of Bispectral Index Monitoring and Clinical Assessment in The Recovery of Patients Undergoing Open Renal Surgery: A Randomized, Double-Blind Study , 2016 .

[65]  Z. Bigat,et al.  Does Using the Bispectral Index (BIS) During Craniotomy Affect the Quality of Recovery? , 2006, Journal of neurosurgical anesthesiology.

[66]  Hannah R Rothstein,et al.  A basic introduction to fixed‐effect and random‐effects models for meta‐analysis , 2010, Research synthesis methods.

[67]  Aliya Ahmed,et al.  Effects of bispectral index monitoring on isoflurane consumption and recovery profiles for anesthesia in an elderly asian population , 2012, Journal of anaesthesiology, clinical pharmacology.

[68]  I. Rampil A Primer for EEG Signal Processing in Anesthesia , 1998, Anesthesiology.

[69]  G. Mashour,et al.  Prevention of intraoperative awareness in a high-risk surgical population. , 2011, The New England journal of medicine.

[70]  Sevoflurane requirements during ambulatory surgery: a clinical study of bispectral index and auditory evoked potential guided anaesthesia , 2002 .

[71]  Sephalie Y. Patel,et al.  Epidural anesthesia and cancer outcomes in bladder cancer patients: is it the technique or the medication? A matched-cohort analysis from a tertiary referral center , 2018, BMC Anesthesiology.

[72]  X. Wang,et al.  Bispectral index for monitoring anesthetic depth in patients with severe burns receiving target-controlled infusion of remifentanil and propofol. , 2015, Genetics and molecular research : GMR.

[73]  Jonathan J Deeks,et al.  Much ado about nothing: a comparison of the performance of meta‐analytical methods with rare events , 2007, Statistics in medicine.

[74]  Adam C. Searleman,et al.  Anesthesia awareness and the bispectral index. , 2008, The New England journal of medicine.

[75]  [Influence of bispectral index monitoring on fentanyl requirements during total intravenous anesthesia for major gynecological surgery]. , 2001, Revista espanola de anestesiologia y reanimacion.

[76]  J. Bruhn,et al.  Bispectral index and A-line AAI index as guidance for desflurane-remifentanil anaesthesia compared with a standard practice group: a multicentre study. , 2005, British journal of anaesthesia.

[77]  G. Puri,et al.  Bispectral index monitoring in patients undergoing cardiac surgery under cardiopulmonary bypass , 2003, European journal of anaesthesiology.

[78]  Observation of anesthesia depth in severe burn patients with target controlled infusion of propofol and remifentanil by bispectral index , 2012 .

[79]  S. Kreuer,et al.  Narcotrend Monitoring Allows Faster Emergence and a Reduction of Drug Consumption in Propofol–Remifentanil Anesthesia , 2003, Anesthesiology.

[80]  Wei Zhang,et al.  Narcotrend and bispectral index for monitoring intraoperative anesthetic depth in patients with severe burns , 2016 .

[81]  S. Rangalakshmi,et al.  MONITORING DEPTH OF ANAESTHESIA USING PRST SCORE AND BISPECTRAL INDEX , 2015 .

[82]  Technology assessment and the "learning contamination" bias. , 1994, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[83]  L. P. Malver,et al.  Impact of Bispectral Index for monitoring propofol remifentanil anaesthesia. A randomised clinical trial , 2013, Acta anaesthesiologica Scandinavica.

[84]  C. Arndt,et al.  Bispectral index to guide induction of anesthesia: a randomized controlled study , 2018, BMC Anesthesiology.

[85]  E. Minchole,et al.  Bispectral Index Monitoring Reduces the Dosage of Propofol and Adverse Events in Sedation for Endobronchial Ultrasound , 2016, Respiration.