Skill assessment of urological laparoscopic surgeons: can criterion levels of surgical performance be determined using the pelvic box trainer?

OBJECTIVES To correlate between surgeons' experience in urological laparoscopy and their performance of a set of laparoscopic tasks performed on a box trainer in the laparoscopic laboratory. METHODS 44 urologists participated in this study. A self-administrated questionnaire enquired about their experience in laparoscopy and they were divided to 4 categories: no experience, minimal experience, basic and advanced laparoscopists. Tests consisted of 4 tasks: passage of a ligature, intracorporeal knotting, intracorporeal suturing, and cutting a carton circle out of a square. All tests were supervised and time was recorded for each of the tasks. Histograms were plotted showing the mean time for performance of each task in each experience group. The Kruskal-Wallis analysis of variance was used to assess statistical significance. RESULTS Seven participants had no previous experience in laparoscopy and 14 had minimal experience. 15 had basic experience and 8 were advanced laparoscopists. No difference in performance was found between the no experience and minimal experience group and they were united and defined as beginners. A significant difference in performance was noted between the beginners, basic and advanced groups, especially when comparing beginners to advanced. Criterion level values of surgical performance drawn from this data were highly discriminative with sensitivity of 71-85% and specificity of 74.2%-88%. CONCLUSIONS We were able to differentiate between various levels of laparoscopic skills among the participating urologists. Values drawn from such studies could be the basis of criterion level values for technical laparoscopic performance during training programs and before granting laparoscopic privileges to urologists.

[1]  G. Fried,et al.  Development of a model for training and evaluation of laparoscopic skills. , 1998, American journal of surgery.

[2]  A. Hawasli,et al.  Laparoscopic training in residency program. , 1996, Journal of laparoendoscopic surgery.

[3]  C. Abbou,et al.  A simplified 5-step model for training laparoscopic urethrovesical anastomosis. , 2003, The Journal of urology.

[4]  Daniel B. Jones,et al.  Evaluating surgical competency with the American Board of Surgery In-Training Examination, skill testing, and intraoperative assessment. , 2000, Surgery.

[5]  J. Kaouk,et al.  Laparoscopic reconstructive urology. , 2003, The Journal of urology.

[6]  B. Guillonneau,et al.  Laparoscopic radical prostatectomy: the Montsouris experience. , 2000, The Journal of urology.

[7]  Louis R Kavoussi,et al.  Laparoscopic Nephrectomy: Initial Case Report. , 1991, The Journal of urology.

[8]  J. Rosser,et al.  Skill acquisition and assessment for laparoscopic surgery. , 1997, Archives of surgery.

[9]  C D Smith,et al.  Assessing laparoscopic manipulative skills. , 2001, American journal of surgery.

[10]  J. Sackier,et al.  A method of objectively evaluating improvements in laparoscopic skills , 1998, Surgical Endoscopy.

[11]  W. Melvin,et al.  Laparoscopic skills enhancement. , 1996, American journal of surgery.

[12]  B. Guillonneau,et al.  Laparoscopic radical prostatectomy. , 2002, The Journal of urology.

[13]  D. Fowler.  Laparoscopic Adrenalectomy: There Can Be No Doubt , 2003, Annals of Surgical Oncology.

[14]  R. Rege,et al.  Laparoscopic skills training. , 2001, American journal of surgery.

[15]  J. Lingeman,et al.  Training postgraduate urologists in laparoscopic surgery: the current challenge. , 2002, The Journal of urology.

[16]  P. Schellhammer,et al.  Laparoscopic radical prostatectomy: decreasing the learning curve using a mentor initiated approach. , 2003, The Journal of urology.

[17]  Vadim Sherman,et al.  Using simulators to assess laparoscopic competence: ready for widespread use? , 2004, Surgery.

[18]  B. Guillonneau,et al.  Proposal for a ‘European Scoring System for Laparoscopic Operations in Urology’ , 2001, European Urology.

[19]  C. Abbou,et al.  Cadaveric versus Porcine Models in Urological Laparoscopic Training , 2003, Urologia Internationalis.

[20]  C. Roehrborn,et al.  Laparoscopic Nephrectomy Is Cost Effective Compared With Open Nephrectomy in a Large County Hospital , 2003, JSLS : Journal of the Society of Laparoendoscopic Surgeons.

[21]  R. Clayman,et al.  Surgical treatment of renal neoplasia: evolving toward a laparoscopic standard of care. , 2003, Urology.

[22]  J. Rassweiler,et al.  Technical evolution of laparoscopic radical prostatectomy after 450 cases. , 2003, Journal of endourology.

[23]  G. Fried,et al.  The effect of practice on performance in a laparoscopic simulator , 1998, Surgical Endoscopy.

[24]  D. Scott,et al.  The impact of intense laparoscopic skills training on the operative performance of urology residents. , 2001, The Journal of urology.

[25]  C. Abbou,et al.  Laparoscopic Radical Prostatectomy , 2001, European Urology.