Pathways to scale up early childhood programs: A scoping review of Reach Up and Care for Child Development

Evidence-based early childhood development (ECD) programs that strengthen nurturing parenting skills and promote early stimulation, such as Reach Up (RU) and Care for Child Development (CCD), are critical investments for interrupting cycles of intergenerational poverty; however, the implementation impact of these programs varies greatly globally. Analyzing systematically the evidence on the implementation pathways based on contexts (i.e., external and internal influences on intervention implementation), implementation strategies (i.e., mechanisms used to promote program initiation, design, and delivery with existing systems), and implementation outcomes (i.e., related to the implementation goals) can increase the likelihood of implementation success. Our scoping review aimed to identify implementation pathways of RU and CCD programs in low- and middle-income countries. A search in English, Spanish, and Portuguese of grey literature and five databases of peer reviewed literature; from inception through July 16, 2022, yielded 2,267 publications. Using predetermined eligibility criteria, 75 records yielded implementation details for 33 programs across 23 low- and middle-income countries. Two reviewers independently extracted program data on context, implementation strategies, and implementation outcomes following a program theory. A thematic analysis identified 37 implementation strategies across six “building blocks of implementation”: program emergence, intersectoriality, intervention characteristics, workforce, training, and monitoring systems. Implementation pathways across building blocks are highly influenced by contextual factors, such as infrastructure, social norms, and the target population’s demand and interest, which may shape different implementation outcomes. Six ‘building blocks’ shaping implementation pathways of CCD and RU in LMICs were identified. The careful consideration of context and use of intentional evidence-based planning can enable the successful implementation of ECD nurturing care interventions. We recommend the use of the ECD Implementation Checklist for Enabling Program Scale Up to guide decision-making regarding context and implementation strategies to support implementation outcomes and subsequent ECD program success.

[1]  F. Aboud,et al.  Implementation of UNICEF and WHO's care for child development package: Lessons from a global review and key informant interviews , 2023, Frontiers in Public Health.

[2]  G. Buccini,et al.  Single Mothers in Poverty in Brazil: Repercussions on Quality of Life and Anxiety for Pregnant and Postpartum Women , 2022, Journal of Poverty.

[3]  R. Pérez‐Escamilla,et al.  Socio-demographic, maternal, and infant characteristics associated with early childhood development delays among children of young mothers in Brasília, Brazil , 2022, PloS one.

[4]  R. Pérez‐Escamilla,et al.  Prioritizing nurturing care at the municipal and district level with the Brazilian Early Childhood Friendly Municipal Index (IMAPI) , 2022, Maternal & child nutrition.

[5]  J. Jenkins,et al.  Teaching home-visitors to support responsive caregiving: A cluster randomized controlled trial of an online professional development program in Brazil , 2022, Journal of global health.

[6]  Tanya Lalwani,et al.  A pilot to promote early child development within health systems in Mozambique: a qualitative evaluation , 2021, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[7]  S. El Arifeen,et al.  Effects of integrated psychosocial stimulation (PS) and unconditional cash transfer (UCT) on children's development in rural Bangladesh: A cluster randomized controlled trial. , 2021, Social science & medicine.

[8]  H. Baker-Henningham,et al.  Qualitative Evaluation of a Scalable Early Childhood Parenting Programme in Rural Colombia. , 2021, Child: care, health and development.

[9]  R. Pérez‐Escamilla,et al.  Sociodemographic inequities in nurturing care for early childhood development across Brazilian municipalities , 2021, Maternal & child nutrition.

[10]  R. Pérez‐Escamilla,et al.  Nurturing care indicators for the Brazilian Early Childhood Friendly Municipal Index (IMAPI) , 2021, Maternal & child nutrition.

[11]  Christopher J. Miller,et al.  The FRAME-IS: a framework for documenting modifications to implementation strategies in healthcare , 2021, Implementation Science.

[12]  Elizabeth L. Prado,et al.  The principles of Nurturing Care promote human capital and mitigate adversities from preconception through adolescence , 2021, BMJ Global Health.

[13]  R. Pérez‐Escamilla,et al.  Scaling up of Brazil's Criança Feliz early childhood development program: an implementation science analysis , 2021, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[14]  P. Winch,et al.  A holistic approach to promoting early child development: a cluster randomised trial of a group-based, multicomponent intervention in rural Bangladesh , 2021, BMJ Global Health.

[15]  H. Baker-Henningham,et al.  Adapting an Evidence-Based, Early Childhood Parenting Programme for Integration into Government Primary Health Care Services in Rural Bangladesh , 2021, Frontiers in Public Health.

[16]  F. Aboud,et al.  Group-based parenting interventions to promote child development in rural Kenya: a multi-arm, cluster-randomised community effectiveness trial , 2020, The Lancet. Global health.

[17]  C. Sudfeld,et al.  Effects of a community health worker delivered intervention on maternal depressive symptoms in rural Tanzania , 2020, Health policy and planning.

[18]  Micah D J Peters,et al.  Updated methodological guidance for the conduct of scoping reviews , 2020, JBI evidence synthesis.

[19]  P. Winch,et al.  Adaptation and Integration of Psychosocial Stimulation, Maternal Mental Health and Nutritional Interventions for Pregnant and Lactating Women in Rural Bangladesh , 2020, International journal of environmental research and public health.

[20]  B. Kirkwood,et al.  Observed feeding behaviours and effects on child weight and length at 12 months of age: Findings from the SPRING cluster-randomized controlled trial in rural India , 2020, PloS one.

[21]  Laura B. Rawlings,et al.  Lay-worker Delivered Home Visiting Promotes Early Childhood Development and Reduces Violence in Rwanda: A Randomized Pilot , 2020 .

[22]  James M Radner,et al.  Human resources and curricula content for early child development implementation: multicountry mixed methods evaluation , 2020, BMJ Open.

[23]  Laura B. Rawlings,et al.  Integrating social protection and early childhood development: open trial of a family home-visiting intervention, Sugira Muryango , 2020 .

[24]  J. Fisher,et al.  Protocol for an economic evaluation alongside a cluster randomised controlled trial: cost-effectiveness of Learning Clubs, a multicomponent intervention to improve women’s health and infant’s health and development in Vietnam , 2019, BMJ Open.

[25]  G. Aarons,et al.  The Value Equation: Three complementary propositions for reconciling fidelity and adaptation in evidence-based practice implementation , 2019, BMC Health Services Research.

[26]  Laura B. Rawlings,et al.  Promoting parent-child relationships and preventing violence via home-visiting: a pre-post cluster randomised trial among Rwandan families linked to social protection programmes , 2019, BMC Public Health.

[27]  C. Stewart,et al.  Effects of nutritional supplementation and home visiting on growth and development in young children in Madagascar: a cluster-randomised controlled trial. , 2019, The Lancet. Global health.

[28]  M. Black,et al.  Grow Smart: An Integrated Nutrition and Early Child Development Intervention Among Infants Improves Expressive Language and Reduces Anemia and Iron Deficiency in Rural India (FS08-03-19). , 2019, Current Developments in Nutrition.

[29]  C. Sudfeld,et al.  Effect of a community health worker delivered health, nutrition and responsive stimulation package and conditional cash transfers on child development and growth in rural Tanzania: protocol for a cluster-randomized trial , 2019, BMC Public Health.

[30]  B. Daelmans,et al.  Reaching the dream of optimal development for every child, everywhere: what do we know about ‘how to’? , 2019, Archives of Disease in Childhood.

[31]  B. Daelmans,et al.  Scaling early child development: what are the barriers and enablers? , 2019, Archives of Disease in Childhood.

[32]  J. Lawn,et al.  Rating early child development outcome measurement tools for routine health programme use , 2019, Archives of Disease in Childhood.

[33]  James M Radner,et al.  Contextual design choices and partnerships for scaling early child development programmes , 2019, Archives of Disease in Childhood.

[34]  J. Lawn,et al.  Accountability for funds for Nurturing Care: what can we measure? , 2019, Archives of Disease in Childhood.

[35]  F. Tofail,et al.  Effects of adding psychosocial stimulation for children of lactating mothers using an unconditional cash transfer platform on neurocognitive behavior of children in rural Bangladesh: protocol for a cluster randomized controlled trial , 2019, BMC Psychology.

[36]  F. Aboud,et al.  Testing means to scale early childhood development interventions in rural Kenya: the Msingi Bora cluster randomized controlled trial study design and protocol , 2019, BMC Public Health.

[37]  H. Baker-Henningham,et al.  Integrating an early childhood development programme into Bangladeshi primary health-care services: an open-label, cluster-randomised controlled trial. , 2019, The Lancet. Global health.

[38]  B. Kirkwood,et al.  Impact of adversity on early childhood growth & development in rural India: Findings from the early life stress sub-study of the SPRING cluster randomised controlled trial (SPRING-ELS) , 2019, PloS one.

[39]  Laura B. Rawlings,et al.  Promoting Early Childhood Development Through Combining Cash Transfers and Parenting Programs , 2018 .

[40]  J. McGowan,et al.  PRISMA Extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR): Checklist and Explanation , 2018, Annals of Internal Medicine.

[41]  S. Luchters,et al.  Addressing multiple modifiable risks through structured community-based Learning Clubs to improve maternal and infant health and infant development in rural Vietnam: protocol for a parallel group cluster randomised controlled trial , 2018, BMJ Open.

[42]  K. Maleta,et al.  The care, stimulation and nutrition of children from 0-2 in Malawi—Perspectives from caregivers; "Who’s holding the baby?" , 2018, PloS one.

[43]  K. Maleta,et al.  Care for Child Development in rural Malawi: a model feasibility and pilot study , 2018, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[44]  F. Aboud,et al.  Reporting guidelines for implementation research on nurturing care interventions designed to promote early childhood development , 2018, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[45]  P. Stansbery.  Translation of evidence to practice to promote early childhood development programs , 2018, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[46]  S. Walker,et al.  Implementation of Reach Up early childhood parenting program: acceptability, appropriateness, and feasibility in Brazil and Zimbabwe , 2018, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[47]  A. Yousafzai,et al.  Integration of parenting and nutrition interventions in a community health program in Pakistan: an implementation evaluation , 2018, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[48]  C. Meghir,et al.  Impacts 2 years after a scalable early childhood development intervention to increase psychosocial stimulation in the home: A follow-up of a cluster randomised controlled trial in Colombia , 2018, PLoS medicine.

[49]  S. Walker,et al.  The Reach Up Early Childhood parenting program: origins, content and implementation , 2018 .

[50]  D. McCoy,et al.  Integrating Early Child Development and Violence Prevention Programs: A Systematic Review. , 2018, New directions for child and adolescent development.

[51]  T. Haines,et al.  The effectiveness of research implementation strategies for promoting evidence-informed policy and management decisions in healthcare: a systematic review , 2017, Implementation Science.

[52]  M. Maxwell,et al.  The influence of contextual factors on healthcare quality improvement initiatives: what works, for whom and in what setting? Protocol for a realist review , 2017, Systematic Reviews.

[53]  Z. Bhutta,et al.  Promoting Early Child Development With Interventions in Health and Nutrition: A Systematic Review , 2017, Pediatrics.

[54]  J. Obradović,et al.  Maternal care mediates the effects of nutrition and responsive stimulation interventions on young children's growth , 2017, Child: care, health and development.

[55]  Elizabeth Murray,et al.  Standards for Reporting Implementation Studies (StaRI) Statement , 2017, British Medical Journal.

[56]  Chunling Lu,et al.  Early childhood development coming of age: science through the life course , 2017, The Lancet.

[57]  Chunling Lu,et al.  Investing in the foundation of sustainable development: pathways to scale up for early childhood development , 2017, The Lancet.

[58]  J. Leckman,et al.  Nurturing care: promoting early childhood development , 2017, The Lancet.

[59]  Z. Bhutta,et al.  Early childhood development: the foundation of sustainable development , 2017, The Lancet.

[60]  Amy Reid,et al.  A framework for scaling up health interventions: lessons from large-scale improvement initiatives in Africa , 2015, Implementation Science.

[61]  S. Gillespie,et al.  Scaling Up Impact on Nutrition: What Will It Take? , 2015, Advances in nutrition.

[62]  Z. Bhutta,et al.  Parenting Skills and Emotional Availability: An RCT , 2015, Pediatrics.

[63]  E. Fitzsimons,et al.  Estimating the Production Function for Human Capital: Results from a Randomized Control Trial in Colombia , 2015, SSRN Electronic Journal.

[64]  Z. Bhutta,et al.  Effect of integrated responsive stimulation and nutrition interventions in the Lady Health Worker programme in Pakistan on child development, growth, and health outcomes: a cluster-randomised factorial effectiveness trial , 2014, The Lancet.

[65]  Costas Meghir,et al.  Using the infrastructure of a conditional cash transfer program to deliver a scalable integrated early child development program in Colombia: cluster randomized controlled trial , 2014, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[66]  J. Heckman,et al.  Labor market returns to an early childhood stimulation intervention in Jamaica , 2014, Science.

[67]  J. Wyatt,et al.  Better reporting of interventions: template for intervention description and replication (TIDieR) checklist and guide , 2014, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[68]  Z. Bhutta,et al.  Cost effectiveness of responsive stimulation and nutrition interventions on early child development outcomes in Pakistan , 2014, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[69]  B. Kirkwood,et al.  Understanding care and feeding practices: building blocks for a sustainable intervention in India and Pakistan , 2014, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[70]  B. Kirkwood,et al.  Integrating maternal psychosocial well‐being into a child‐development intervention: the five‐pillars approach , 2014, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[71]  K. Maleta,et al.  A job analysis of community health workers in the context of integrated nutrition and early child development , 2014, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[72]  F. Aboud,et al.  Review of implementation processes for integrated nutrition and psychosocial stimulation interventions , 2014, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[73]  N. Balakrishna,et al.  Integrating nutrition and early child‐development interventions among infants and preschoolers in rural India , 2014, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[74]  S. Walker,et al.  Effects of integrated child development and nutrition interventions on child development and nutritional status , 2014, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[75]  Enola K Proctor,et al.  Implementation strategies: recommendations for specifying and reporting , 2013, Implementation Science.

[76]  Margaret Chan.  Linking child survival and child development for health, equity, and sustainable development , 2013, The Lancet.

[77]  Geoffrey M. Curran,et al.  Effectiveness-implementation Hybrid Designs: Combining Elements of Clinical Effectiveness and Implementation Research to Enhance Public Health Impact , 2012, Medical care.

[78]  T. Ahmed,et al.  Effects of a community-based approach of food and psychosocial stimulation on growth and development of severely malnourished children in Bangladesh: a randomised trial , 2012, European Journal of Clinical Nutrition.

[79]  P. Engle,et al.  Strategies for reducing inequalities and improving developmental outcomes for young children in low-income and middle-income countries , 2011, The Lancet.

[80]  C. Nelson,et al.  Inequality in early childhood: risk and protective factors for early child development , 2011, The Lancet.

[81]  A. Lake.  Early childhood development—global action is overdue , 2011, The Lancet.

[82]  Alicia C. Bunger,et al.  Outcomes for Implementation Research: Conceptual Distinctions, Measurement Challenges, and Research Agenda , 2010, Administration and Policy in Mental Health and Mental Health Services Research.

[83]  K. Devers,et al.  Qualitative data analysis for health services research: developing taxonomy, themes, and theory. , 2007, Health services research.

[84]  F. Jiang,et al.  “Care for Development” Intervention in Rural China: A Prospective Follow-up Study , 2007, Journal of developmental and behavioral pediatrics : JDBP.

[85]  F. Khatun,et al.  Psychosocial stimulation improves the development of undernourished children in rural Bangladesh. , 2006, The Journal of nutrition.

[86]  I. Ertem,et al.  Promoting Child Development at Sick-Child Visits: A Controlled Trial , 2006, Pediatrics.

[87]  S. Walker,et al.  Feasibility of integrating early stimulation into primary care for undernourished Jamaican children: cluster randomised controlled trial , 2004, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[88]  S. Walker,et al.  Effects of early childhood supplementation with and without stimulation on later development in stunted Jamaican children. , 1997, The American journal of clinical nutrition.

[89]  M. Tomlinson,et al.  Scaling up Integrated Early Childhood Development programs: lessons from four countries , 2018, Child: care, health and development.

[90]  B. Daelmans,et al.  Care for Child Development: an intervention in support of responsive caregiving and early child development , 2018, Child: care, health and development.

[91]  F. Lopez Boo,et al.  Chile Crece Contigo: Implementation, results, and scaling‐up lessons , 2018, Child: care, health and development.

[92]  A. Harden,et al.  Methods for the thematic synthesis of qualitative research in systematic reviews , 2008, BMC medical research methodology.

[93]  T. Cole,et al.  Zinc supplementation and psychosocial stimulation: effects on the development of undernourished Jamaican children. , 2005, The American journal of clinical nutrition.