Passive data collection and use in healthcare: A systematic review of ethical issues

INTRODUCTION Passive data refers to data generated without the active participation of the subject. This includes data from global positioning systems and accelerometers or metadata on phone call and text activity. Although the potential healthcare applications are far-reaching, passive data raises numerous ethical challenges. MATERIALS AND METHODS We performed a systematic review to identify all ethical concerns, normative standpoints, and underlying arguments related to the use of passive data in healthcare. RESULTS Among the various challenges discussed in the ethical literature, informational privacy, informed consent, and data security were the primary focus of the current debate. Other topics of discussion were the evaluation and regulation of products, equity in access, vulnerable patient groups, ownership, and secondary use. CONCLUSION No clear ethical framework has been established that stimulates passive data-driven innovation while protecting patient integrity. The consensus in the ethical literature, as well as the parallels with similar concerns and solutions in other fields, can lay a foundation for the construction of an ethical framework. The future debate should focus on conflicts between two or more ethical, technical, or clinical values to ensure a safe and effective implementation of passive data in healthcare.

[1]  J. Ioannidis,et al.  The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate healthcare interventions: explanation and elaboration , 2009, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[2]  M. Doerr,et al.  Consent Processes for Mobile App Mediated Research: Systematic Review , 2017, JMIR mHealth and uHealth.

[3]  F. Lapointe,et al.  Self-tracking the microbiome: where do we go from here? , 2015, Microbiome.

[4]  Raina M. Merchant,et al.  Transforming Scientific Inquiry: Tapping Into Digital Data by Building a Culture of Transparency and Consent , 2016, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[5]  L. Lipsitz,et al.  In Situ Monitoring of Health in Older Adults: Technologies and Issues , 2010, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[6]  R. Sade,et al.  Wearable Technologies in Collegiate Sports: The Ethics of Collecting Biometric Data From Student-Athletes , 2017, The American journal of bioethics : AJOB.

[7]  Bonnie Kaplan,et al.  How Should Health Data Be Used? , 2016, Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics.

[8]  Heather Draper,et al.  Telecare, Remote Monitoring and Care , 2013, Bioethics.

[9]  Bernd Blobel,et al.  Security, Safety, and Related Technology - The Triangle of eHealth Service Provision , 2008, MIE.

[10]  Wayne Hall,et al.  Realising the technological promise of smartphones in addiction research and treatment: An ethical review. , 2016, The International journal on drug policy.

[11]  Daniel Strech,et al.  How to write a systematic review of reasons , 2011, Journal of Medical Ethics.

[12]  Kenrick D Cato,et al.  Did I Tell You That? Ethical Issues Related to Using Computational Methods to Discover Non-Disclosed Patient Characteristics , 2016, Journal of empirical research on human research ethics : JERHRE.

[13]  Annette Devito Dabbs,et al.  Data safety and monitoring for research involving remote health monitoring. , 2011, Telemedicine journal and e-health : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association.

[14]  Bernd Blobel,et al.  Mobile Health Requires Mobile Security: Challenges, Solutions, and Standardization , 2008, MIE.

[15]  Predrag V. Klasnja,et al.  Exploring Privacy Concerns about Personal Sensing , 2009, Pervasive.

[16]  Anna Essén,et al.  The two facets of electronic care surveillance: an exploration of the views of older people who live with monitoring devices. , 2008, Social science & medicine.

[17]  G. Demiris,et al.  Ethical considerations regarding the use of technology for older adults. The case of telehealth. , 2009, Research in gerontological nursing.

[18]  Ricardo Neisse,et al.  Ethical Design in the Internet of Things , 2016, Science and Engineering Ethics.

[19]  Kevin G. Stanley,et al.  Ethical implications of location and accelerometer measurement in health research studies with mobile sensing devices. , 2017, Social science & medicine.

[20]  Donald M Hilty,et al.  Review of Use and Integration of Mobile Apps Into Psychiatric Treatments , 2017, Current Psychiatry Reports.

[21]  Lisa M. Lee,et al.  Ethical justification for conducting public health surveillance without patient consent. , 2012, American journal of public health.

[22]  W. Burke,et al.  If you build it, they will come: unintended future uses of organised health data collections , 2016, BMC Medical Ethics.

[23]  S. Adibi.  Understanding User Privacy Preferences for mHealth Data Sharing , 2014 .

[24]  G. Miller,et al.  Science Perspectives on Psychological the Smartphone Psychology Manifesto on Behalf Of: Association for Psychological Science the Smartphone Psychology Manifesto Previous Research Using Mobile Electronic Devices What Smartphones Can Do Now and Will Be Able to Do in the near Future , 2022 .

[25]  John Torous,et al.  New Tools for New Research in Psychiatry: A Scalable and Customizable Platform to Empower Data Driven Smartphone Research , 2016, JMIR mental health.

[26]  A. Bazzi,et al.  Ethical considerations and potential threats to validity for three methods commonly used to collect geographic information in studies among people who use drugs. , 2016, Addictive behaviors.

[27]  Jane Katusiime,et al.  A review of privacy and usability issues in mobile health systems: Role of external factors , 2019, Health Informatics J..

[28]  Heather Draper,et al.  Telecare, Surveillance, and the Welfare State , 2012, The American journal of bioethics : AJOB.

[29]  Amanda L. Roy.  Innovation or Violation? Leveraging Mobile Technology to Conduct Socially Responsible Community Research , 2017, American journal of community psychology.

[30]  M. DiStefano,et al.  mHealth for Tuberculosis Treatment Adherence: A Framework to Guide Ethical Planning, Implementation, and Evaluation , 2016, Global Health: Science and Practice.

[31]  Scout Calvert,et al.  Opportunities and challenges in the use of personal health data for health research , 2016, J. Am. Medical Informatics Assoc..

[32]  John Torous,et al.  Navigating Ethics in the Digital Age: Introducing Connected and Open Research Ethics (CORE), a Tool for Researchers and Institutional Review Boards , 2017, Journal of medical Internet research.

[33]  Jacqueline Kerr,et al.  "Spatial Energetics": Integrating Data From GPS, Accelerometry, and GIS to Address Obesity and Inactivity. , 2016, American journal of preventive medicine.

[34]  Christian Montag,et al.  Psycho-informatics: Big Data shaping modern psychometrics. , 2014, Medical hypotheses.

[35]  Mike Conway,et al.  Ethical issues in using Twitter for population-level depression monitoring: a qualitative study , 2016, BMC Medical Ethics.

[36]  L. Fernández-Luque,et al.  Self-Tracking, Social Media and Personal Health Records for Patient Empowered Self-Care , 2012, Yearbook of Medical Informatics.

[37]  S. Rauch,et al.  Harnessing Smartphone-Based Digital Phenotyping to Enhance Behavioral and Mental Health , 2016, Neuropsychopharmacology.

[38]  O. Nov,et al.  Social Annotation Valence: The Impact on Online Informed Consent Beliefs and Behavior , 2016, Journal of medical Internet research.

[39]  C. Eccleston,et al.  Case study: ethical guidance for pediatric e-health research using examples from pain research with adolescents. , 2012, Journal of pediatric psychology.

[40]  Jacki Liddle,et al.  Mobile Phones in Research and Treatment: Ethical Guidelines and Future Directions , 2015, JMIR mHealth and uHealth.

[41]  Abeer Alsadoon,et al.  Ethical Implications of User Perceptions of Wearable Devices , 2018, Sci. Eng. Ethics.

[42]  Miranda Olff,et al.  Mobile mental health: a challenging research agenda , 2015, European journal of psychotraumatology.

[43]  Vincent Rialle,et al.  Environmental Cognitive Remediation in Schizophrenia: Ethical Implications of “Smart Home” Technology , 2005, Canadian journal of psychiatry. Revue canadienne de psychiatrie.

[44]  Flora Cornish,et al.  Too Much Information: Visual Research Ethics in the Age of Wearable Cameras , 2014, Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science.

[45]  S. Marshall,et al.  An ethical framework for automated, wearable cameras in health behavior research. , 2013, American journal of preventive medicine.

[46]  A. Bredenoord,et al.  Consent for governance in the ethical use of organoids , 2018, Nature Cell Biology.

[47]  M. Keshavan,et al.  New dimensions and new tools to realize the potential of RDoC: digital phenotyping via smartphones and connected devices , 2017, Translational Psychiatry.

[48]  Jörg Schmidtke,et al.  Data storage and DNA banking for biomedical research: informed consent, confidentiality, quality issues, ownership, return of benefits. A professional perspective , 2003, European Journal of Human Genetics.

[49]  George R. Milne,et al.  Internet of Things: Convenience vs. privacy and secrecy , 2015 .

[50]  Eleni Kosta,et al.  Mobile-Centric Ambient Intelligence in Health- and Homecare—Anticipating Ethical and Legal Challenges , 2010, Sci. Eng. Ethics.

[51]  Camille Nebeker,et al.  Acceptance of Mobile Health in Communities Underrepresented in Biomedical Research: Barriers and Ethical Considerations for Scientists , 2017, JMIR mHealth and uHealth.

[52]  Katie Shilton,et al.  Ethics Regulation in Social Computing Research: Examining the Role of Institutional Review Boards , 2017, Journal of empirical research on human research ethics : JERHRE.

[53]  Peter A. Flach,et al.  Smart homes, private homes? An empirical study of technology researchers’ perceptions of ethical issues in developing smart-home health technologies , 2017, BMC medical ethics.

[54]  K. Bramstedt.  When microchip implants do more than drug delivery: blending, blurring, and bundling of protected health information and patient monitoring. , 2005, Technology and health care : official journal of the European Society for Engineering and Medicine.

[55]  María Luisa Martín Ruiz,et al.  Developing a System for Processing Health Data of Children Using Digitalized Toys: Ethical and Privacy Concerns for the Internet of Things Paradigm , 2018, Sci. Eng. Ethics.

[56]  R. Landau,et al.  Ethical aspects of using GPS for tracking people with dementia: recommendations for practice , 2011, International Psychogeriatrics.

[57]  J. Geddes,et al.  Ethical perspectives on recommending digital technology for patients with mental illness , 2017, International Journal of Bipolar Disorders.