Risk assessment of pesticides and other stressors in bees: Principles, data gaps and perspectives from the European Food Safety Authority.

Current approaches to risk assessment in bees do not take into account co-exposures from multiple stressors. The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) is deploying resources and efforts to move towards a holistic risk assessment approach of multiple stressors in bees. This paper describes the general principles of pesticide risk assessment in bees, including recent developments at EFSA dealing with risk assessment of single and multiple pesticide residues and biological hazards. The EFSA Guidance Document on the risk assessment of plant protection products in bees highlights the need for the inclusion of an uncertainty analysis, other routes of exposures and multiple stressors such as chemical mixtures and biological agents. The EFSA risk assessment on the survival, spread and establishment of the small hive beetle, Aethina tumida, an invasive alien species, is provided with potential insights for other bee pests such as the Asian hornet, Vespa velutina. Furthermore, data gaps are identified at each step of the risk assessment, and recommendations are made for future research that could be supported under the framework of Horizon 2020. Finally, the recent work conducted at EFSA is presented, under the overarching MUST-B project ("EU efforts towards the development of a holistic approach for the risk assessment on MUltiple STressors in Bees") comprising a toolbox for harmonised data collection under field conditions and a mechanistic model to assess effects from pesticides and other stressors such as biological agents and beekeeping management practices, at the colony level and in a spatially complex landscape. Future perspectives at EFSA include the development of a data model to collate high quality data to calibrate and validate the model to be used as a regulatory tool. Finally, the evidence collected within the framework of MUST-B will support EFSA's activities on the development of a holistic approach to the risk assessment of multiple stressors in bees. In conclusion, EFSA calls for collaborative action at the EU level to establish a common and open access database to serve multiple purposes and different stakeholders.

[1]  J. Cresswell.  A meta-analysis of experiments testing the effects of a neonicotinoid insecticide (imidacloprid) on honey bees , 2011, Ecotoxicology.

[2]  H. R. Hepburn,et al.  Bee-hawking by the wasp, Vespa velutina, on the honeybees Apis cerana and A. mellifera , 2007, Naturwissenschaften.

[3]  Andrew Butterworth,et al.  Assessing the health status of managed honeybee colonies (HEALTHY-B): a toolbox to facilitate harmonised data collection , 2016 .

[4]  L. Arckens,et al.  The effects of four crop protection products on the morphology and ultrastructure of the hypopharyngeal gland of the European honeybee, Apis mellifera , 2011, Apidologie.

[5]  F. Jiguet,et al.  Climate change increases the risk of invasion by the Yellow-legged hornet , 2013 .

[6]  Andreas Focks,et al.  The use of traits‐based approaches and eco(toxico)logical models to advance the ecological risk assessment framework for chemicals , 2013, Integrated environmental assessment and management.

[7]  J. Sueur,et al.  Attack or retreat: Contrasted defensive tactics used by Cyprian honeybee colonies under attack from hornets , 2011, Behavioural Processes.

[8]  J. Brunet,et al.  Interactions between Nosema microspores and a neonicotinoid weaken honeybees (Apis mellifera) , 2010, Environmental microbiology.

[9]  E. Brockerhoff,et al.  Ecological effects and management of invasive alien Vespidae , 2011, BioControl.

[10]  B. Oldroyd,et al.  An ‘I see you’ prey–predator signal between the Asian honeybee, Apis cerana, and the hornet, Vespa velutina , 2012, Animal Behaviour.

[11]  E. Darrouzet,et al.  Rapid spread of the invasive yellow‐legged hornet in France: the role of human‐mediated dispersal and the effects of control measures , 2017 .

[12]  D. Garthwaite,et al.  Collection of pesticide application data in view of performing Environmental Risk Assessments for pesticides , 2015 .

[13]  P. Calistri,et al.  Opinion of the Scientific Committee on Survival, spread and establishment of the small hive beetle (Aethina tumida) , 2015 .

[14]  P. Tardy,et al.  Defensive behaviour of Apis mellifera against Vespa velutina in France: Testing whether European honeybees can develop an effective collective defence against a new predator , 2014, Behavioural Processes.

[15]  D. Biron,et al.  Exposure to Sublethal Doses of Fipronil and Thiacloprid Highly Increases Mortality of Honeybees Previously Infected by Nosema ceranae , 2011, PloS one.

[16]  Henry S. Pollock,et al.  Ecologically Appropriate Xenobiotics Induce Cytochrome P450s in Apis mellifera , 2012, PloS one.

[17]  C. Dantec,et al.  Nutrigenomics in honey bees: digital gene expression analysis of pollen's nutritive effects on healthy and varroa-parasitized bees , 2011, BMC Genomics.

[18]  David J. Hawthorne,et al.  Killing Them with Kindness? In-Hive Medications May Inhibit Xenobiotic Efflux Transporters and Endanger Honey Bees , 2011, PloS one.

[19]  M. Rundlöf,et al.  Replication, effect sizes and identifying the biological impacts of pesticides on bees under field conditions , 2016 .

[20]  N. Quignot,et al.  Data collection on Combined Toxicity of Multiple Chemicals for Animal Health and Ecological Risk Assessment , 2015 .

[21]  Karl Crailsheim,et al.  The influence of brood on the pollen consumption of worker bees (Apis mellifera L.). , 1998, Journal of insect physiology.

[22]  M. Jonker,et al.  Mixture Toxicity: Linking Approaches from Ecological and Human Toxicology , 2016 .

[23]  C. Topping,et al.  Landscape structure and management alter the outcome of a pesticide ERA: evaluating impacts of endocrine disruption using the ALMaSS European Brown Hare model , 2015, bioRxiv.

[24]  G. Burgio,et al.  Combined effect of pollen quality and thiamethoxam on hypopharyngeal gland development and protein content in Apis mellifera , 2016, Apidologie.

[25]  Elinor M. Lichtenberg,et al.  Crop Pollination Exposes Honey Bees to Pesticides Which Alters Their Susceptibility to the Gut Pathogen Nosema ceranae , 2013, PloS one.

[26]  M. Spiteller,et al.  Erratum to: Neonicotinoid insecticides translocated in guttated droplets of seed-treated maize and wheat: a threat to honey bees? , 2011, Apidologie.

[27]  P. Thorbek,et al.  Using BEEHAVE to explore pesticide protection goals for European honeybee (Apis melifera L.) worker losses at different forage qualities , 2017, Environmental toxicology and chemistry.

[28]  Reed M. Johnson.  Honey bee toxicology. , 2015, Annual review of entomology.

[29]  W. Munns,et al.  Assessing Risks to Wildlife Populations from Multiple Stressors: Overview of the Problem and Research Needs. , 2006 .

[30]  J. Boesten,et al.  EFSA Guidance Document on the risk assessment of plant protection products on bees (Apis mellifera, Bombus spp. and solitary bees) , 2013 .

[31]  F. Jiguet,et al.  Predicting the invasion risk by the alien bee-hawking Yellow-legged hornet Vespa velutina nigrithorax across Europe and other continents with niche models , 2011 .

[32]  C. Giorio,et al.  Assessment of the environmental exposure of honeybees to particulate matter containing neonicotinoid insecticides coming from corn coated seeds. , 2012, Environmental science & technology.

[33]  A. Gregorc,et al.  Heat shock proteins and cell death in situ localisation in hypopharyngeal glands of honeybee (Apis mellifera carnica) workers after imidacloprid or coumaphos treatment , 2011, Apidologie.

[34]  Daniele Milanesio,et al.  Design of an harmonic radar for the tracking of the Asian yellow‐legged hornet , 2016, Ecology and evolution.

[35]  H. Thompson,et al.  Potential impacts of synergism in honeybees (Apis mellifera) of exposure to neonicotinoids and sprayed fungicides in crops , 2014, Apidologie.

[36]  Noa Simon Delso,et al.  Scientific Opinion on the science behind the development of a risk assessment of Plant Protection Products on bees (Apis mellifera, Bombus spp. and solitary bees) , 2012 .

[37]  James T. Wilkes,et al.  The Bee Informed Partnership: Using Beekeeper's Real-World Experience to Solve Beekeepers' Real-World Problems , 2012 .

[38]  Y. Devos,et al.  Advancing environmental risk assessment of regulated products under EFSA's remit , 2016 .

[39]  S. Radloff,et al.  Cooperative wasp-killing by mixed-species colonies of honeybees, Apis cerana and Apis mellifera , 2012, Apidologie.

[40]  O. Malaspina,et al.  Effects of Nosema ceranae and thiametoxam in Apis mellifera: A comparative study in Africanized and Carniolan honey bees. , 2016, Chemosphere.

[41]  O. Campolo,et al.  A scientific note on a new pest for European honeybees: first report of small hive beetle Aethina tumida, (Coleoptera: Nitidulidae) in Italy , 2014, Apidologie.

[42]  Vincent Bretagnolle,et al.  ECOBEE: a tool for long-term honey bee colony monitoring at the landscape scale in West European intensive agroecosystems , 2014 .

[43]  E. Genersch,et al.  The German bee monitoring project: a long term study to understand periodically high winter losses of honey bee colonies , 2010, Apidologie.

[44]  F. Sgolastra,et al.  A meta-analysis comparing the sensitivity of bees to pesticides , 2014, Ecotoxicology.

[45]  P. J. Kennedy,et al.  BEEHAVE: a systems model of honeybee colony dynamics and foraging to explore multifactorial causes of colony failure , 2014, The Journal of applied ecology.

[46]  G. Arnold,et al.  Sublethal doses of imidacloprid decreased size of hypopharyngeal glands and respiratory rhythm of honeybees in vivo , 2013, Apidologie.

[47]  G. Daily,et al.  Population diversity and ecosystem services , 2003 .

[48]  Andy Hart,et al.  Development of a framework based on an ecosystem services approach for deriving specific protection goals for environmental risk assessment of pesticides. , 2012, The Science of the total environment.

[49]  G. Suter,et al.  Species Sensitivity Distributions in Ecotoxicology , 2001 .

[50]  S. More,et al.  Scientific Opinion on the risk of entry of Aethina tumida and Tropilaelaps spp. in the EU. , 2013 .

[51]  H. Hepburn,et al.  Heat-balling wasps by honeybees , 2005, Naturwissenschaften.

[52]  H. Hepburn,et al.  Wasp Hawking Induces Endothermic Heat Production in Guard Bees , 2010, Journal of insect science.

[53]  K. Wallner,et al.  Review on activities in Germany to assess the occurrence, residues and possible risk of guttation for honey bees , 2012 .

[54]  C. Topping,et al.  Statement on the suitability of the BEEHAVE model for its potential use in a regulatory context and for the risk assessment of multiple stressors in honeybees at the landscape level , 2015 .

[55]  N. Moran.  Genomics of the honey bee microbiome. , 2015, Current opinion in insect science.

[56]  D. Goulson,et al.  Neonicotinoid Residues in Wildflowers, a Potential Route of Chronic Exposure for Bees. , 2015, Environmental science & technology.

[57]  C. Ockleford.  Guidance to develop specific protection goals options for environmental risk assessment at EFSA, in relation to biodiversity and ecosystem services , 2016 .

[58]  Pernille Thorbek,et al.  REVIEW: Towards a systems approach for understanding honeybee decline: a stocktaking and synthesis of existing models , 2013, The Journal of applied ecology.

[59]  D. vanEngelsdorp,et al.  Direct effect of acaricides on pathogen loads and gene expression levels in honey bees Apis mellifera. , 2012, Journal of insect physiology.

[60]  P. Hendrikx,et al.  Bee mortality and bee surveillance in Europe. , 2009 .

[61]  J. Mbabazi,et al.  Principles and Methods for the Risk Assessment of Chemicals in Food , 2011 .

[62]  K. Crailsheim,et al.  Pollen consumption and utilization in worker honeybees (Apis mellifera carnica): Dependence on individual age and function , 1992 .

[63]  J. Sandoz,et al.  Olfactory pathway of the hornet Vespa velutina: New insights into the evolution of the hymenopteran antennal lobe , 2016, The Journal of comparative neurology.

[64]  P. Hendrikx,et al.  Statistical analysis on the EPILOBEE dataset: explanatory variables related to honeybee colony mortality in EU during a 2 year survey , 2016 .

[65]  H. Köhler,et al.  Interactions between effects of environmental chemicals and natural stressors: a review. , 2010, The Science of the total environment.

[66]  Pernille Thorbek,et al.  Predicting Honeybee Colony Failure: Using the BEEHAVE Model to Simulate Colony Responses to Pesticides , 2015, Environmental science & technology.

[67]  K. Monceau,et al.  Vespa velutina: a new invasive predator of honeybees in Europe , 2013, Journal of Pest Science.

[68]  J. Frazier,et al.  Comparative Toxicities and Synergism of Apple Orchard Pesticides to Apis mellifera (L.) and Osmia cornifrons (Radoszkowski) , 2013, PloS one.

[69]  Colin Ockleford,et al.  Scientific Opinion on good modelling practice in the context of mechanistic effect models for risk assessment of plant protection products , 2014 .

[70]  Blair D. Siegfried,et al.  Acaricide, Fungicide and Drug Interactions in Honey Bees (Apis mellifera) , 2013, PloS one.

[71]  H. Thompson.  Interaction between pesticides and other factors in effects on bees , 2012 .

[72]  M. Berenbaum,et al.  A deficit of detoxification enzymes: pesticide sensitivity and environmental response in the honeybee , 2006, Insect molecular biology.

[73]  A. Barron,et al.  A Quantitative Model of Honey Bee Colony Population Dynamics , 2011, PloS one.

[74]  Henry S. Pollock,et al.  Synergistic Interactions Between In-Hive Miticides in Apis mellifera , 2009, Journal of economic entomology.

[75]  G. Theophilidis,et al.  Smothered to death: Hornets asphyxiated by honeybees , 2007, Current Biology.

[76]  G. Gilioli,et al.  Environmental risk assessment for plant pests: a procedure to evaluate their impacts on ecosystem services. , 2014, The Science of the total environment.

[77]  F. Mutinelli,et al.  Detection of Aethina tumida Murray (Coleoptera: Nitidulidae.) in Italy: outbreaks and early reaction measures , 2014 .

[78]  A. Klein,et al.  Importance of pollinators in changing landscapes for world crops , 2007, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[79]  E. Jablonka,et al.  Editorial: Epigenetics as a Deep Intimate Dialogue between Host and Symbionts , 2016, Front. Genet..

[80]  Joint Fao,et al.  Codex Alimentarius Commission procedural manual , 1968 .

[81]  H. Thompson.  Extrapolation of acute toxicity across bee species , 2016, Integrated environmental assessment and management.

[82]  L. Belzunces,et al.  Evidence of synergy between prochloraz and deltamethrin in apis mellifera L.: a convenient biological approach , 1992 .

[83]  K. Monceau,et al.  Vespa velutina nest distribution at a local scale: An 8‐year survey of the invasive honeybee predator , 2017, Insect science.

[84]  M. Berenbaum,et al.  CYP9Q-mediated detoxification of acaricides in the honey bee (Apis mellifera) , 2011, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[85]  B. Oldroyd,et al.  The ‘I see you’ prey–predator signal of Apis cerana is innate , 2013, Naturwissenschaften.

[86]  G. Budge,et al.  The small hive beetle Aethina tumida: a review of its biology and control measures. , 2013 .

[87]  J. Biesmeijer,et al.  Summary for policymakers of the assessment report of the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (IPBES) on pollinators, pollination and food production , 2016 .

[88]  G. Di Prisco,et al.  Honey Bees (Apis mellifera, L.) as Active Samplers of Airborne Particulate Matter , 2015, PloS one.

[89]  C. Krupke,et al.  Non-cultivated plants present a season-long route of pesticide exposure for honey bees , 2016, Nature Communications.