The safeguards mess: a critique of WTO jurisprudence

The creation of the WTO revived the use of ‘safeguard’ measures to protect troubled industries against surges in import competition. Many of these measures have now been challenged in the WTO dispute resolution process, and in each case the process has found the challenged measure to be a violation of WTO law. This paper examines the WTO rules on safeguards from an economic perspective. Among other things, it argues that the textual preconditions for the use of safeguards in the treaty text are incoherent, and that the Appellate Body has compounded the problem through a series of dubious and unhelpful rulings. The result is a situation in which nations cannot use safeguards without facing a near certainty that they will be found invalid. Those who believe that safeguard measures are wasteful protectionism may welcome these developments, but it is by no means clear that the trading system will benefit in the long run.

[1]  Cass R. Sunstein,et al.  Regulating Risks after "ATA" , 2001, The Supreme Court Review.

[2]  Eric A. Posner,et al.  Law and the Emotions , 2000 .

[3]  Cass R. Sunstein,et al.  Military Tribunals and Legal Culture: What a Difference Sixty Years Makes , 2002 .

[4]  C. Sunstein,et al.  Social and Economic Rights? Lessons from South Africa , 2001 .

[5]  Saul Levmore,et al.  Puzzling Stock Options and Compensation Norms , 2000 .

[6]  C. Sunstein,et al.  The Laws of Fear , 2001 .

[7]  Cass R. Sunstein,et al.  Must Formalism Be Defended Empirically , 1999 .

[8]  E. Posner,et al.  Law and Economics of Consumer Finance , 2001 .

[9]  Randal C. Picker,et al.  Entry Policy in Local Telecommunications: Iowa Utilities and Verizon , 2002, The Supreme Court Review.

[10]  Alan Sykes,et al.  Trips, Pharmaceuticals, Developing Countries, and the Doha 'Solution' , 2002, Chicago journal of international law.

[11]  Randal C. Picker.  Security Interests, Misbehavior, and Common Pools , 1992 .

[12]  Saul Levmore,et al.  Conjunction and Aggregation , 2001 .

[13]  R. Pindyck,et al.  Are Imports to Blame? Attribution of Injury under the 1974 Trade Act , 1985, The Journal of Law and Economics.

[14]  D. Weisbach,et al.  Ten Truths About Tax Shelters , 2001 .

[15]  Cass R. Sunstein,et al.  Behavioral Law and Economics: Second-Order Decisions , 2000 .

[16]  Ilana Ritov,et al.  Predictably Incoherent Judgments , 2002 .

[17]  Richard A. Posner,et al.  Creating and Enforcing Norms, With Special Reference to Sanctions , 1999 .

[18]  Gary S. Becker,et al.  The Economic Way of Looking at Life , 1992 .

[19]  D. Baird,et al.  Revisiting Auctions in Chapter 11 , 1993, The Journal of Law and Economics.

[20]  Daniel Kahneman,et al.  Deliberating About Dollars: The Severity Shift , 2000 .

[21]  D. Lichtman,et al.  Strategic Disclosure in the Patent System , 2000 .

[22]  A. Sykes.  An Introduction to Regression Analysis , 1993 .

[23]  J. Mark Ramseyer,et al.  Explicit Reasons for Implicit Contracts: The Legal Logic to the Japanese Main Bank System , 1993 .

[24]  W Meadow,et al.  Statistics, not experts. , 2001, Duke law journal.

[25]  Kenneth W. Dam.  The Economic Underpinnings of Patent Law , 1994, The Journal of Legal Studies.

[26]  David B. Mustard,et al.  Crime, Deterrence, and Right‐to‐Carry Concealed Handguns , 1997, The Journal of Legal Studies.

[27]  D. Lichtman.  Property Rights in Emerging Platform Technologies , 1999, The Journal of Legal Studies.

[28]  D. Baird,et al.  Optimal Timing and Legal Decisionmaking: The Case of the Liquidation Decision in Bankruptcy , 1999 .

[29]  E. Glaeser,et al.  Incentives and Social Capital: Are Homeowners Better Citizens? , 1998 .

[30]  Eric A. Posner,et al.  Implementing Cost-Benefit Analysis When Preferences are Distorted , 1999 .

[31]  C. Sunstein,et al.  Academic Fads and Fashions (with Special Reference to Law) , 2001 .

[32]  Cass R. Sunstein,et al.  Assessing Punitive Damages (with Notes on Cognition and Valuation in Law) , 1998 .

[33]  Richard A. Posner,et al.  What Do Judges and Justices Maximize? (The Same Thing Everybody Else Does) , 1993, Supreme Court Economic Review.

[34]  Richard A. Posner,et al.  Values and Consequences: An Introduction to Economic Analysis of Law , 1998 .

[35]  Richard A. Epstein,et al.  Animals as Objects, or Subjects, of Rights , 2002 .

[36]  Richard A. Posner,et al.  Status Signaling and the Law, with Particular Application to Sexual Harassment , 1999 .

[37]  Michael E. Solimine,et al.  Judicial Influence: A Citation Analysis of Federal Courts of Appeals Judges , 1998, The Journal of Legal Studies.

[38]  W. Landes,et al.  Winning the Art Lottery: The Economic Returns to the Ganz Collection , 1999, Recherches économiques de Louvain.

[39]  R. Epstein,et al.  Transaction Costs and Property Rights: Or Do Good Fences Make Good Neighbors? , 1997 .

[40]  Cass R. Sunstein,et al.  Rules and Rulelessness , 1994 .

[41]  Kenneth W. Dam,et al.  Chicago Unbound , 2018 .

[42]  Randal C. Picker,et al.  Regulating Network Industries: A Look at Intel , 1999 .

[43]  D. Baird,et al.  Bankruptcy Decision Making , 2001 .

[44]  Anup Malani,et al.  The Political Economy of Property Exemption Laws , 2001 .

[45]  Geoffrey P. Miller,et al.  Explaining Deviations from the Fifty-Percent Rule: A Multimodal Approach to the Selection of Cases for Litigation , 1996, The Journal of Legal Studies.

[46]  Cass R. Sunstein,et al.  Switching the Default Rule , 2001 .

[47]  E. Posner,et al.  Controlling Agencies with Cost-Benefit Analysis: A Positive Political Theory Perspective , 2001 .

[48]  R. Posner,et al.  Market Signaling of Personal Characteristics , 1999 .

[49]  Richard A. Epstein,et al.  Into the Frying Pan: Standing and Privity under the Telecommunications Act of 1996 and Beyond , 2002 .

[50]  Richard A. Epstein,et al.  Class Actions: Aggregation, Amplification, and Distortion , 2003 .

[51]  Randal C. Picker.  Pursuing a Remedy in Microsoft: The Declining Need for Centralized Coordination in a Networked World , 2001 .

[52]  C. Sunstein,et al.  Private Broadcasters and the Public Interest: Notes Toward a 'Third Way' , 1999 .

[53]  Anil K. Makhija,et al.  Throwing good money after bad?: Nuclear power plant investment decisions and the relevance of sunk costs☆ , 1988 .

[54]  John R. Lott,et al.  Does a Helping Hand Put Others at Risk?: Affirmative Action, Police Departments, and Crime , 2000 .

[55]  J. Goldsmith,et al.  Statutory Foreign Affairs Preemption , 2000, The Supreme Court Review.

[56]  Cass R. Sunstein,et al.  The Cost-Benefit State , 1996 .

[57]  C. Sunstein.  Social Norms and Social Roles , 1995 .

[58]  E. Posner,et al.  Transfer regulations and cost-effectiveness analysis. , 2003, Duke law journal.

[59]  Alan V. Deardorff.  No . 2 Safeguards Policy and the Conservative Social Welfare Function , 2005 .

[60]  John R. Lott,et al.  Term limits and electoral competitiveness: Evidence from California’s state legislative races , 1997 .

[61]  Richard A. Posner,et al.  Antitrust in the New Economy , 2000 .

[62]  C. Sunstein.  The Law of Group Polarization , 1999, How Change Happens.

[63]  Kenneth W. Dam.  Self-Help in the Digital Jungle , 1999 .

[64]  John R. Lott,et al.  How Dramatically Did Women's Suffrage Change the Size and Scope of Government? , 1998 .

[65]  Christine Jolls,et al.  A Behavioral Approach to Law and Economics , 1998 .

[66]  Edna Ullmann-Margalit,et al.  Inequality and Indignation , 2001 .

[67]  Eric A. Posner,et al.  Moral and Legal Rhetoric in International Relations: A Rational Choice Perspective , 2002, The Journal of Legal Studies.

[68]  John R. Lott,et al.  A Simple Explanation for Why Campaign Expenditures are Increasing: The Government is Getting Bigger , 1999 .

[69]  D. Baird,et al.  Control Rights, Priority Rights, and the Conceptual Foundations of Corporate Reorganizations , 2001 .

[70]  David A. Weisbach,et al.  Ironing Out the Flat Tax , 2000 .

[71]  Richard A. Posner,et al.  The Economics of Legal Disputes Over the Ownership of Works of Art and Other Collectibles , 1996 .

[72]  David A. Weisbach,et al.  The Fifth Circuit Gets It Wrong in Compaq v. Commissioner , 2002 .

[73]  Yannis Bakos,et al.  Shared Information Goods , 1999 .

[74]  Richard A. Epstein,et al.  In and Out of Public Solution: The Hidden Perils of Property Transfer , 2001 .

[75]  Richard A. Epstein,et al.  In Defense of the 'Old' Public Health: The Legal Framework for the Regulation of Public Health , 2002 .

[76]  John R. Lott,et al.  Punitive Damages: Their Determinants, Effects on Firm Value, and the Impact of Supreme Court and Congressional Attempts to Limit Awards , 1998 .

[77]  William M. Landes,et al.  Counterclaims: An Economic Analysis , 1994 .

[78]  Lisa E. Bernstein,et al.  Private Commercial Law in the Cotton Industry: Creating Cooperation Through Rules, Norms, and Institutions , 2001 .

[79]  Daniel N. Shaviro.  Budget Deficits and the Intergenerational Distribution of Lifetime Consumption , 1995 .

[80]  Alan O. Sykes,et al.  The Economics Structure of Renegotiation and Dispute Resolution in the WTO/GATT System , 2002 .

[81]  Eric A. Posner,et al.  Covenants Not to Compete from an Incomplete Contracts Perspective , 2001 .

[82]  Randal C. Picker,et al.  Bankruptcy Rules, Managerial Entrenchment, and Firm-Specific Human Capital , 1993 .

[83]  C. Bown.  Why are safeguards under the WTO so unpopular? , 2002, World Trade Review.

[84]  Eric A. Posner,et al.  A Theory of Contract Law under Conditions of Radical Judicial Error , 1999 .

[85]  Avraham Tabbach,et al.  Criminal Behavior, Sanctions, and Income Taxation: An Economic Analysis , 2002, The Journal of Legal Studies.

[86]  John R. Lott,et al.  Environmental Violations, Legal Penalties, and Reputation Costs , 1999 .

[87]  Richard A. Posner,et al.  Orwell Versus Huxley: Economics, Technology, Privacy, and Satire , 2000 .

[88]  Richard Craswell,et al.  Freedom of Contract , 1995 .

[89]  R. Posner,et al.  The Long-Run Growth in Obesity as a Function of Technological Change , 1999, Perspectives in biology and medicine.

[90]  Douglas Lichtman,et al.  Uncertainty and the Standard for Preliminary Relief , 2002 .

[91]  D. Weisbach,et al.  Measurement and Tax Depreciation Policy: The Case of Short-Term Assets , 2003 .

[92]  Alan O. Sykes,et al.  Justice in immigration: The welfare economics of immigration law: a theoretical survey with an analysis of U.S. policy , 1992 .

[93]  Cass R. Sunstein,et al.  The Rights of Animals: A Very Short Primer , 2002 .

[94]  Richard A. Epstein,et al.  Deconstructing Privacy: And Putting It Back Together Again* , 2000, Social Philosophy and Policy.

[95]  C. Sunstein.  Probability Neglect: Emotions, Worst Cases, and Law , 2001 .

[96]  Eric A. Posner,et al.  Economic Analysis of Contract Law after Three Decades: Success or Failure? , 2002 .

[97]  C. Sunstein,et al.  Cognition And Cost‐Benefit Analysis , 1999, The Journal of Legal Studies.

[98]  Richard A. Posner,et al.  The Theory and Practice of Citations Analysis, with Special Reference to Law and Economics , 1999 .

[99]  C. Sunstein,et al.  Cost-Benefit Analysis and Relative Position , 2000 .

[100]  R. Epstein,et al.  Allocation of the Commons: Parking and Stopping on the Commons , 2001 .

[101]  Richard A. Posner,et al.  Community, Wealth, and Equality , 1997 .

[102]  David A. Weisbach,et al.  Does the X-Tax Mark the Spot? , 2002 .

[103]  Richard A. Epstein,et al.  HIPAA on Privacy: Its Unintended and Intended Consequences , 2002 .

[104]  D. Weisbach,et al.  Should the Tax Law Require Current Accrual of Interest On Derivative Financial Instruments? , 1999 .

[105]  Cass R. Sunstein,et al.  DO People Want Optimal Deterrence? , 2000, The Journal of Legal Studies.

[106]  Randal C. Picker.  An Introduction to Game Theory and the Law , 1994 .

[107]  A. Roth,et al.  The Market for Federal Judicial Law Clerks , 2007 .

[108]  Lisa E. Bernstein.  ‘The Questionable Empirical Basis of Article 2’s Incorporation Strategy: A Preliminary Study , 1999 .

[109]  David A. Weisbach,et al.  Taxes and Torts in the Redistribution of Income , 2002 .

[110]  C. Sunstein,et al.  The Arithmetic of Arsenic , 2001 .

[111]  William M. Landes,et al.  Copyright, Borrowed Images, and Appropriation Art: An Economic Approach , 2000 .

[112]  W. Landes,et al.  Indirect Liability for Copyright Infringement: An Economic Perspective , 2003 .

[113]  Cass R. Sunstein,et al.  On Academic Fads and Fashions , 2001 .

[114]  David A. Weisbach,et al.  Taxation and Risk-Taking with Multiple Tax Rates , 2002, National Tax Journal.

[115]  D. Baird,et al.  Does Bogart Still Get Scale? Rights of Publicity in the Digital Age , 2001 .

[116]  Richard A. Epstein.  Contracts Small and Contract Large: Contract Law through the Lens of Laissez-Faire , 2020, The Fall and Rise of Freedom of Contract.

[117]  W. Landes,et al.  What Has the Visual Arts Rights Act of 1990 Accomplished? , 2001 .

[118]  Randal C. Picker.  Copyright as Entry Policy: The Case of Digital Distribution , 2002 .

[119]  C. Sunstein,et al.  Human Behavior and the Law of Work , 2000 .

[120]  Eric A. Posner,et al.  Courts Should Not Enforce Government Contracts , 2001 .

[121]  Cass R. Sunstein,et al.  Health-Health Tradeoffs , 1996 .

[122]  Richard A Epstein,et al.  Steady the course: property rights in genetic material. , 2003, Advances in genetics.

[123]  Randal C. Picker.  From Edison to the Broadcast Flag: Mechanisms of Consent and Refusal and the Propertization of Copyright , 2002 .

[124]  Cass R. Sunstein,et al.  Avoiding Absurdity? A New Canon in Regulatory Law , 2002 .

[125]  Geoffrey P. Miller,et al.  Das Kapital: Solvency Regulation of the American Business Enterprise , 1995 .

[126]  William M. Landes,et al.  The Art of Law and Economics: An Autobiographical Essay , 1997 .

[127]  J. Mark Ramseyer,et al.  Judicial Independence in Civil Law Regimes: Econometrics from Japan , 1996 .

[128]  M. Adler,et al.  Rethinking Cost-Benefit Analysis , 1999 .

[129]  John R. Lott,et al.  Multiple Victim Public Shootings, Bombings, and Right-to-Carry Concealed Handgun Laws: Contrasting Private and Public Law Enforcement , 1999 .

[130]  Eric A. Posner,et al.  Probability Errors: Some Positive and Normative Implications for Tort and Contract Law , 2004, Supreme Court Economic Review.

[131]  Alan O. Sykes,et al.  The Economics of WTO Rules on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures , 2003 .

[132]  Julie Roin,et al.  Truth in Government: Beyond the Tax Expenditure Budget , 2002 .

[133]  Eric A. Posner,et al.  A Theory of the Laws of War , 2002 .

[134]  Richard A. Epstein,et al.  The Ubiquity of the Benefit Principle , 1994 .

[135]  Randal C. Picker.  Simple Games in a Complex World: A Generative Approach to the Adoption of Norms , 1997 .

[136]  Richard A. Epstein,et al.  The Assault on Managed Care: Vicarious Liability, Class Actions and the Patient's Bill of Rights , 2000 .

[137]  Alan Sykes,et al.  Terrorism and Insurance Markets: A Role for the Government as Insurer? , 2002 .

[138]  IN DOUGLASA.IRW.  Causing problems? The WTO review of causation and injury attribution in US Section 201 cases , 2004 .

[139]  William M. Landes,et al.  Copyright Protection of Letters, Diaries, and Other Unpublished Works: An Economic Approach , 1992, The Journal of Legal Studies.

[140]  R. Hahn,et al.  A New Executive Order for Improving Federal Regulation? Deeper and Wider Cost-Benefit Analysis , 2002 .

[141]  Cass R. Sunstein,et al.  Behavioral Analysis of Law , 1997 .

[142]  Richard A. Posner,et al.  An Economic Approach to the Law of Evidence , 1999 .

[143]  Randal C. Picker.  Understanding Statutory Bundles: Does the Sherman Act Come with the 1996 Telecommunications Act? , 2003 .

[144]  Alan O. Sykes,et al.  The Dormant Commerce Clause and the Internet , 2000 .

[145]  D. Baird,et al.  The Law and Economics of Contract Damages , 1995 .

[146]  J. Mark Ramseyer,et al.  The Market for Children: Evidence from Early Modern Japan , 1995 .

[147]  David A. Weisbach,et al.  An Economic Analysis of Anti-Tax Avoidance Laws , 2000 .

[148]  Douglas Lichtman,et al.  Copyright as a Rule of Evidence , 2001 .

[149]  David A. Weisbach,et al.  Thinking Outside the Little Boxes: A Response to Professor Schlunk , 2002 .

[150]  J. Mark Ramseyer,et al.  Credibly Committing to Efficiency Wages: Cotton Spinning Cartels in Imperial Japan , 1993 .

[151]  A. Sykes.  Protectionism As a Safeguard: A Positive Analysis of the GATT Escape Clause with Normative Speculations , 1991 .

[152]  Kenneth H. Kelly.  The Analysis of Causality in Escape Clause Cases , 1988 .

[153]  D. Baird,et al.  The Hidden Virtues of Chapter 11: An Overview of the Law and Economics of Financially Distressed Firms , 1997 .

[154]  Lior Strahilevitz,et al.  Charismatic Code, Social Norms, and the Emergence of Cooperation on the File-Swapping Networks , 2003 .

[155]  Kenneth W. Dam.  Some Economic Considerations in the Intellectual Property Protection of Software , 1995, The Journal of Legal Studies.

[156]  R. Posner,et al.  Indefinitely Renewable Copyright , 2002 .

[157]  William M. Landes,et al.  Sequential versus Unitary Trials: An Economic Analysis , 1993, The Journal of Legal Studies.