Tolerance limits and methodologies for IMRT measurement‐based verification QA

PURPOSE Patient-specific IMRT QA measurements are important components of processes designed to identify discrepancies between calculated and delivered radiation doses. Discrepancy tolerance limits are neither well defined nor consistently applied across centers. The AAPM TG-218 report provides a comprehensive review aimed at improving the understanding and consistency of these processes as well as recommendations for methodologies and tolerance limits in patient-specific IMRT QA. METHODS The performance of the dose difference/distance-to-agreement (DTA) and γ dose distribution comparison metrics are investigated. Measurement methods are reviewed and followed by a discussion of the pros and cons of each. Methodologies for absolute dose verification are discussed and new IMRT QA verification tools are presented. Literature on the expected or achievable agreement between measurements and calculations for different types of planning and delivery systems are reviewed and analyzed. Tests of vendor implementations of the γ verification algorithm employing benchmark cases are presented. RESULTS Operational shortcomings that can reduce the γ tool accuracy and subsequent effectiveness for IMRT QA are described. Practical considerations including spatial resolution, normalization, dose threshold, and data interpretation are discussed. Published data on IMRT QA and the clinical experience of the group members are used to develop guidelines and recommendations on tolerance and action limits for IMRT QA. Steps to check failed IMRT QA plans are outlined. CONCLUSION Recommendations on delivery methods, data interpretation, dose normalization, the use of γ analysis routines and choice of tolerance limits for IMRT QA are made with focus on detecting differences between calculated and measured doses via the use of robust analysis methods and an in-depth understanding of IMRT verification metrics. The recommendations are intended to improve the IMRT QA process and establish consistent, and comparable IMRT QA criteria among institutions.

[1]  Francesco C Stingo,et al.  Toward optimizing patient-specific IMRT QA techniques in the accurate detection of dosimetrically acceptable and unacceptable patient plans. , 2014, Medical physics.

[2]  David S Followill,et al.  Institutional patient-specific IMRT QA does not predict unacceptable plan delivery. , 2014, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[3]  Frank Verhaegen,et al.  Time dependent pre-treatment EPID dosimetry for standard and FFF VMAT , 2014, Physics in medicine and biology.

[4]  A Agnew,et al.  Monitoring daily MLC positional errors using trajectory log files and EPID measurements for IMRT and VMAT deliveries , 2014, Physics in medicine and biology.

[5]  Maria F Chan,et al.  Using a Novel Dose QA Tool to Quantify the Impact of Systematic Errors Otherwise Undetected by Conventional QA Methods: Clinical Head and Neck Case Studies , 2014, Technology in cancer research & treatment.

[6]  David Followill,et al.  Comparison of 2D and 3D gamma analyses. , 2014, Medical physics.

[7]  Sara Bresciani,et al.  Tomotherapy treatment plan quality assurance: the impact of applied criteria on passing rate in gamma index method. , 2013, Medical physics.

[8]  Benjamin E Nelms,et al.  Evaluating IMRT and VMAT dose accuracy: practical examples of failure to detect systematic errors when applying a commonly used metric and action levels. , 2013, Medical physics.

[9]  Christina Skourou,et al.  Sensitivity of volumetric modulated arc therapy patient specific QA results to multileaf collimator errors and correlation to dose volume histogram based metrics. , 2013, Medical physics.

[10]  Todd Pawlicki,et al.  A method of setting limits for the purpose of quality assurance , 2013, Physics in medicine and biology.

[11]  Geoffrey G. Zhang,et al.  Validation of measurement‐guided 3D VMAT dose reconstruction on a heterogeneous anthropomorphic phantom , 2013, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[12]  Panayiotis Mavroidis,et al.  Characterization of a novel 2D array dosimeter for patient-specific quality assurance with volumetric arc therapy. , 2013, Medical physics.

[13]  Colin G Orton,et al.  Point/Counterpoint. Patient-specific QA for IMRT should be performed using software rather than hardware methods. , 2013, Medical physics.

[14]  Alejandra Rangel,et al.  ROC analysis in patient specific quality assurance. , 2013, Medical physics.

[15]  Charles S Mayo,et al.  Comment on "Catching errors with patient-specific pretreatment machine log file analysis". , 2013, Practical radiation oncology.

[16]  Sridhar Yaddanapudi,et al.  Catching errors with patient-specific pretreatment machine log file analysis. , 2013, Practical radiation oncology.

[17]  Per Munck af Rosenschöld,et al.  Patient QA systems for rotational radiation therapy: a comparative experimental study with intentional errors. , 2013, Medical physics.

[18]  Andrea Molineu,et al.  Credentialing results from IMRT irradiations of an anthropomorphic head and neck phantom. , 2013, Medical physics.

[19]  Geoffrey S Ibbott,et al.  American College of Radiology (ACR) and American Society for Radiation Oncology (ASTRO) Practice Guideline for Intensity-modulated Radiation Therapy (IMRT) , 2012, American journal of clinical oncology.

[20]  Sara Bresciani,et al.  Pretreatment patient-specific IMRT quality assurance: a correlation study between gamma index and patient clinical dose volume histogram. , 2012, Medical physics.

[21]  Núria Jornet,et al.  3D DVH-based metric analysis versus per-beam planar analysis in IMRT pretreatment verification. , 2012, Medical physics.

[22]  J. Roselló,et al.  A two-dimensional liquid-filled ionization chamber array prototype for small-field verification: characterization and first clinical tests , 2012, Physics in medicine and biology.

[23]  Geoffrey G. Zhang,et al.  VMAT QA: Measurement-guided 4D dose reconstruction on a patient. , 2012, Medical physics.

[24]  Jonas D Fontenot,et al.  Comparison of action levels for patient-specific quality assurance of intensity modulated radiation therapy and volumetric modulated arc therapy treatments. , 2012, Medical physics.

[25]  Sharon C Dutton,et al.  On using 3D γ-analysis for IMRT and VMAT pretreatment plan QA. , 2012, Medical physics.

[26]  Pietro Mancosu,et al.  Pretreatment quality assurance of flattening filter free beams on 224 patients for intensity modulated plans: a multicentric study. , 2012, Medical physics.

[27]  Darryl G. L. Kaurin,et al.  VMAT testing for an Elekta accelerator , 2012, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[28]  Arthur J Olch,et al.  Evaluation of the accuracy of 3DVH software estimates of dose to virtual ion chamber and film in composite IMRT QA. , 2011, Medical physics.

[29]  Benjamin E Nelms,et al.  Statistical variability and confidence intervals for planar dose QA pass rates. , 2011, Medical physics.

[30]  Benjamin E Nelms,et al.  Moving from gamma passing rates to patient DVH-based QA metrics in pretreatment dose QA. , 2011, Medical physics.

[31]  Geoffrey G. Zhang,et al.  Optimizing the accuracy of a helical diode array dosimeter: a comprehensive calibration methodology coupled with a novel virtual inclinometer. , 2011, Medical physics.

[32]  J Godart,et al.  Reconstruction of high-resolution 3D dose from matrix measurements: error detection capability of the COMPASS correction kernel method , 2011, Physics in medicine and biology.

[33]  Olivier Riou,et al.  Eight years of IMRT quality assurance with ionization chambers and film dosimetry: experience of the montpellier comprehensive cancer center , 2011, Radiation oncology.

[34]  J. Galvin,et al.  Safety considerations for IMRT: Executive summary , 2011, Practical radiation oncology.

[35]  D. Georg,et al.  218 speaker GUIDELINES FOR THE VERIFICATION OF IMRT , 2011 .

[36]  Ravikumar Manickam,et al.  Comparison of four commercial devices for RapidArc and sliding window IMRT QA , 2011, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[37]  C. Baldock,et al.  Investigation of radiological properties and water equivalency of PRESAGE dosimeters. , 2011, Medical physics.

[38]  Lei Dong,et al.  Dosimetry tools and techniques for IMRT. , 2011, Medical physics.

[39]  S. Krafft,et al.  Confidence limit variation for a single IMRT system following the TG119 protocol. , 2011, Medical physics.

[40]  P Francescon,et al.  Quality assurance of volumetric modulated arc therapy: evaluation and comparison of different dosimetric systems. , 2011, Medical physics.

[41]  Benjamin E Nelms,et al.  Per-beam, planar IMRT QA passing rates do not predict clinically relevant patient dose errors. , 2011, Medical physics.

[42]  Geoffrey G. Zhang,et al.  Evaluation of a new VMAT QA device, or the “X” and “O” array geometries , 2011, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[43]  Colin G Orton,et al.  Point/counterpoint. It is still necessary to validate each individual IMRT treatment plan with dosimetric measurements before delivery. , 2011, Medical physics.

[44]  Volker Steil,et al.  Experimental validation of a commercial 3D dose verification system for intensity-modulated arc therapies , 2010, Physics in medicine and biology.

[45]  Arthur J Olch,et al.  Validation of a treatment plan-based calibration method for 2D detectors used for treatment delivery quality assurance. , 2010, Medical physics.

[46]  Piotr Zygmanski,et al.  Evaluation of MatriXX for IMRT and VMAT dose verifications in peripheral dose regions. , 2010, Medical physics.

[47]  Jon J Kruse,et al.  On the insensitivity of single field planar dosimetry to IMRT inaccuracies. , 2010, Medical physics.

[48]  Geoffrey G. Zhang,et al.  Initial dosimetric evaluation of SmartArc – a novel VMAT treatment planning module implemented in a multi‐vendor delivery chain , 2010, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[49]  W. Kwa,et al.  Monte Carlo based, patient-specific RapidArc QA using Linac log files. , 2009, Medical physics.

[50]  Bo Lu,et al.  Calibration of a novel four-dimensional diode array. , 2009, Medical physics.

[51]  M. Geurts,et al.  Longitudinal study using a diode phantom for helical tomotherapy IMRT QA. , 2009, Medical physics.

[52]  J. Mechalakos,et al.  IMRT commissioning: multiple institution planning and dosimetry comparisons, a report from AAPM Task Group 119. , 2009, Medical physics.

[53]  Sasa Mutic,et al.  Enhanced efficiency in helical tomotherapy quality assurance using a custom-designed water-equivalent phantom , 2009, Physics in medicine and biology.

[54]  Vladimir Feygelman,et al.  Evaluation of a biplanar diode array dosimeter for quality assurance of step‐and‐shoot IMRT , 2009, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[55]  F. Bochud,et al.  An absolute dose determination of helical tomotherapy accelerator, TomoTherapy High-Art II. , 2009, Medical physics.

[56]  Jan-Jakob Sonke,et al.  A simple backprojection algorithm for 3D in vivo EPID dosimetry of IMRT treatments. , 2009, Medical physics.

[57]  M. Oldham,et al.  Investigation of the feasibility of relative 3D dosimetry in the Radiologic Physics Center Head and Neck IMRT phantom using presage/optical-CT. , 2009, Medical physics.

[58]  David A Jaffray,et al.  Novel dosimetric phantom for quality assurance of volumetric modulated arc therapy. , 2009, Medical physics.

[59]  Vincent Marchesi,et al.  A comprehensive analysis of the IMRT dose delivery process using statistical process control (SPC). , 2009, Medical physics.

[60]  Guanghua Yan,et al.  On the sensitivity of patient‐specific IMRT QA to MLC positioning errors , 2009, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[61]  Todd Pawlicki,et al.  Moving from IMRT QA measurements toward independent computer calculations using control charts. , 2008, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[62]  Michael B Sharpe,et al.  Statistical process control for IMRT dosimetric verification. , 2008, Medical physics.

[63]  C. Ling,et al.  Commissioning and quality assurance of RapidArc radiotherapy delivery system. , 2008, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[64]  Todd Pawlicki,et al.  Process control analysis of IMRT QA: implications for clinical trials , 2008, Physics in medicine and biology.

[65]  Indra J. Das,et al.  Intensity-Modulated Radiation Therapy Dose Prescription, Recording, and Delivery: Patterns of Variability Among Institutions and Treatment Planning Systems , 2008 .

[66]  Parminder S Basran,et al.  An analysis of tolerance levels in IMRT quality assurance procedures. , 2008, Medical physics.

[67]  R. Howell,et al.  Establishing action levels for EPID‐based QA for IMRT , 2008, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[68]  David S Followill,et al.  Challenges in credentialing institutions and participants in advanced technology multi-institutional clinical trials. , 2008, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[69]  Jatinder R Palta,et al.  Quality assurance of intensity-modulated radiation therapy. , 2008, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[70]  J. Deasy,et al.  Geometric interpretation of the gamma dose distribution comparison technique: interpolation-free calculation. , 2008, Medical physics.

[71]  Riccardo Calandrino,et al.  Results of a two-year quality control program for a helical tomotherapy unit. , 2008, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[72]  P. Xia,et al.  Impact of MLC leaf position errors on simple and complex IMRT plans for head and neck cancer , 2008, Physics in medicine and biology.

[73]  Karl Otto,et al.  Volumetric modulated arc therapy: IMRT in a single gantry arc. , 2007, Medical physics.

[74]  C. Fiorino,et al.  Agreement criteria between expected and measured field fluences in IMRT of head and neck cancer: the importance and use of the gamma histograms statistical analysis. , 2007, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[75]  D. Huyskens,et al.  On-line quality assurance of rotational radiotherapy treatment delivery by means of a 2D ion chamber array and the Octavius phantom. , 2007, Medical physics.

[76]  Benjamin E. Nelms,et al.  A survey on planar IMRT QA analysis , 2007, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[77]  R. Howell,et al.  WE‐D‐AUD‐05: Clinical Implementation of Portal Dosimetry — Establishing Action Levels , 2007 .

[78]  J. Dempsey,et al.  TG-69: radiographic film for megavoltage beam dosimetry. , 2007, Medical physics.

[79]  Stefan Both,et al.  A study to establish reasonable action limits for patient‐specific quality assurance in intensity‐modulated radiation therapy , 2007, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[80]  Patrick A Kupelian,et al.  Characterization and use of EBT radiochromic film for IMRT dose verification. , 2006, Medical physics.

[81]  Maarten L P Dirkx,et al.  Dosimetric pre-treatment verification of IMRT using an EPID; clinical experience. , 2006, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[82]  M. V. van Herk,et al.  Clinical experience with EPID dosimetry for prostate IMRT pre-treatment dose verification. , 2006, Medical physics.

[83]  C. Wuu,et al.  Three-dimensional dose verification for intensity modulated radiation therapy using optical CT based polymer gel dosimetry. , 2006, Medical physics.

[84]  M. V. van Herk,et al.  Accurate two-dimensional IMRT verification using a back-projection EPID dosimetry method. , 2006, Medical physics.

[85]  Wendel Dean Renner,et al.  A method for deconvolution of integrated electronic portal images to obtain incident fluence for dose reconstruction , 2005, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[86]  Todd Pawlicki,et al.  Statistical process control for radiotherapy quality assurance. , 2005, Medical physics.

[87]  A. L. Angelini,et al.  Characterization of a 2D ion chamber array for the verification of radiotherapy treatments , 2005, Physics in medicine and biology.

[88]  C. Ma,et al.  A practical Monte Carlo MU verification tool for IMRT quality assurance , 2005, Physics in medicine and biology.

[89]  J. Moran,et al.  A dose‐gradient analysis tool for IMRT QA , 2005, Journal of applied clinical medical physics.

[90]  Lei Dong,et al.  Retrospective analysis of 2D patient-specific IMRT verifications. , 2005, Medical physics.

[91]  Lei Dong,et al.  Dosimetric accuracy of Kodak EDR2 film for IMRT verifications. , 2005, Medical physics.

[92]  R. Mackay,et al.  Quantitative analysis of patient-specific dosimetric IMRT verification , 2005, Physics in medicine and biology.

[93]  I. Rosen,et al.  Detection of IMRT delivery errors using a quantitative 2D dosimetric verification system. , 2004, Medical physics.

[94]  Geoffrey S Ibbott,et al.  Credentialing of institutions for IMRT in clinical trials. , 2004, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[95]  F. Gum,et al.  Verification of IMRT: Techniques and Problems , 2004, Strahlentherapie und Onkologie.

[96]  J. Dempsey,et al.  An extensive log-file analysis of step-and-shoot intensity modulated radiation therapy segment delivery errors. , 2004, Medical physics.

[97]  Tom Depuydt,et al.  The use of an aSi-based EPID for routine absolute dosimetric pre-treatment verification of dynamic IMRT fields. , 2004, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[98]  R. Cirio,et al.  Dosimetric characterization of a large area pixel-segmented ionization chamber. , 2004, Medical physics.

[99]  M. Oldham,et al.  Evaluation of a 2D diode array for IMRT quality assurance. , 2004, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[100]  B G Fallone,et al.  Dosimetric IMRT verification with a flat-panel EPID. , 2003, Medical physics.

[101]  M. Alber,et al.  A revision of the γ-evaluation concept for the comparison of dose distributions , 2003 .

[102]  J. Dempsey,et al.  Evaluation of the gamma dose distribution comparison method. , 2003, Medical physics.

[103]  Jun Duan,et al.  Dosimetric effect of respiration-gated beam on IMRT delivery. , 2003, Medical physics.

[104]  Cedric X. Yu,et al.  Guidance document on delivery, treatment planning, and clinical implementation of IMRT: report of the IMRT Subcommittee of the AAPM Radiation Therapy Committee. , 2003, Medical physics.

[105]  I. Rosen,et al.  The design and testing of novel clinical parameters for dose comparison. , 2003, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[106]  Lei Dong,et al.  Patient-specific point dose measurement for IMRT monitor unit verification. , 2003, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[107]  Peter B Greer,et al.  Dosimetric properties of an amorphous silicon electronic portal imaging device for verification of dynamic intensity modulated radiation therapy. , 2003, Medical physics.

[108]  Antonio Leal,et al.  Routine IMRT verification by means of an automated Monte Carlo simulation system. , 2003, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[109]  P. Jursinic,et al.  A 2-D diode array and analysis software for verification of intensity modulated radiation therapy delivery. , 2003, Medical physics.

[110]  A. Sethi,et al.  Comparison of ionization chambers of various volumes for IMRT absolute dose verification. , 2003, Medical physics.

[111]  Nesrin Dogan,et al.  Comparative evaluation of Kodak EDR2 and XV2 films for verification of intensity modulated radiation therapy. , 2002, Physics in medicine and biology.

[112]  Lei Dong,et al.  Rapid radiographic film calibration for IMRT verification using automated MLC fields. , 2002, Medical physics.

[113]  A. Olch.  Dosimetric performance of an enhanced dose range radiographic film for intensity-modulated radiation therapy quality assurance. , 2002, Medical physics.

[114]  J. Rownd,et al.  Evaluation of Kodak EDR2 film for dose verification of intensity modulated radiation therapy delivered by a static multileaf collimator. , 2002, Medical physics.

[115]  Ping Xia,et al.  Investigation of the use of MOSFET for clinical IMRT dosimetric verification. , 2002, Medical physics.

[116]  M. Bock,et al.  Preliminary study on the use of an inhomogeneous anthropomorphic Fricke gel phantom and 3D magnetic resonance dosimetry for verification of IMRT treatment plans , 2002, Physics in medicine and biology.

[117]  T LoSasso,et al.  Comprehensive quality assurance for the delivery of intensity modulated radiotherapy with a multileaf collimator used in the dynamic mode. , 2001, Medical physics.

[118]  D Yan,et al.  Monitor unit settings for intensity modulated beams delivered using a step-and-shoot approach. , 2000, Medical physics.

[119]  S Webb,et al.  Radiation dosimetry using polymer gels: methods and applications. , 2000, The British journal of radiology.

[120]  Y Chen,et al.  Monitor unit calculation for an intensity modulated photon field by a simple scatter-summation algorithm. , 2000, Physics in medicine and biology.

[121]  J. Galvin,et al.  Radiochromic film dosimetry: recommendations of AAPM Radiation Therapy Committee Task Group 55. American Association of Physicists in Medicine. , 1998, Medical physics.

[122]  D A Low,et al.  A software tool for the quantitative evaluation of 3D dose calculation algorithms. , 1998, Medical physics.

[123]  D. Low,et al.  Quality assurance of serial tomotherapy for head and neck patient treatments. , 1998, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[124]  G. Starkschall,et al.  American Association of Physicists in Medicine Radiation Therapy Committee Task Group 53: quality assurance for clinical radiotherapy treatment planning. , 1998, Medical physics.

[125]  D. Low,et al.  A technique for the quantitative evaluation of dose distributions. , 1998, Medical physics.

[126]  A. Haus,et al.  Processor quality control in laser imaging systems. , 1997, Medical physics.

[127]  M. Carol,et al.  Initial clinical experience with the Peacock intensity modulation of a 3-D conformal radiation therapy system. , 1996, Stereotactic and functional neurosurgery.

[128]  R Mohan,et al.  Conformal radiation treatment of prostate cancer using inversely-planned intensity-modulated photon beams produced with dynamic multileaf collimation. , 1996, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[129]  T LoSasso,et al.  Testing of dynamic multileaf collimation. , 1996, Medical physics.

[130]  T LoSasso,et al.  Dosimetric verification of intensity-modulated fields. , 1996, Medical physics.

[131]  W Schlegel,et al.  Dynamic X-ray compensation for conformal radiotherapy by means of multi-leaf collimation. , 1994, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[132]  J O Deasy,et al.  Tomotherapy: a new concept for the delivery of dynamic conformal radiotherapy. , 1993, Medical physics.

[133]  J. Cygler,et al.  Commissioning and quality assurance of treatment planning computers. , 1993, International journal of radiation oncology, biology, physics.

[134]  S. Webb.  Optimization by simulated annealing of three-dimensional conformal treatment planning for radiation fields defined by a multileaf collimator. , 1991, Physics in medicine and biology.

[135]  T. Bortfeld,et al.  Methods of image reconstruction from projections applied to conformation radiotherapy. , 1990, Physics in medicine and biology.

[136]  A. Brahme,et al.  Optimization of stationary and moving beam radiation therapy techniques. , 1988, Radiotherapy and oncology : journal of the European Society for Therapeutic Radiology and Oncology.

[137]  Y. Nakaguchi,et al.  Dose verification of IMRT by use of a COMPASS transmission detector , 2011, Radiological Physics and Technology.

[138]  P. Jursinic,et al.  MapCHECK used for rotational IMRT measurements: step-and-shoot, TomoTherapy, RapidArc. , 2010, Medical physics.

[139]  W. Grant,et al.  QA for helical tomotherapy: report of the AAPM Task Group 148. , 2010, Medical physics.

[140]  M. Stock,et al.  Interpretation and evaluation of the gamma index and the gamma index angle for the verification of IMRT hybrid plans. , 2005, Physics in medicine and biology.

[141]  M. Oldham,et al.  3D verification of a prostate IMRT treatment by polymer gel-dosimetry and optical-CT scanning , 2004 .

[142]  M. Alber,et al.  A revision of the gamma-evaluation concept for the comparison of dose distributions. , 2003, Physics in medicine and biology.