Robustness and evolution: concepts, insights and challenges from a developmental model system

Robustness, the persistence of an organismal trait under perturbations, is a ubiquitous property of complex living systems. We here discuss key concepts related to robustness with examples from vulva development in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. We emphasize the need to be clear about the perturbations a trait is (or is not) robust to. We discuss two prominent mechanistic causes of robustness, namely redundancy and distributed robustness. We also discuss possible evolutionary causes of robustness, one of which does not involve natural selection. To better understand robustness is of paramount importance for understanding organismal evolution. Part of the reason is that highly robust systems can accumulate cryptic variation that can serve as a source of new adaptations and evolutionary innovations. We point to some key challenges in improving our understanding of robustness.

[1]  C. Waddington.  Canalization of Development and the Inheritance of Acquired Characters , 1942, Nature.

[2]  J. Sulston,et al.  Post-embryonic cell lineages of the nematode, Caenorhabditis elegans. , 1977, Developmental biology.

[3]  Mediterranean pollution: one man's optimism , 1978, Nature.

[4]  H. Lipkin.  Where is the ?c? , 1978 .

[5]  D. Hartl,et al.  Principles of population genetics , 1981 .

[6]  J. Sulston,et al.  Regulation and cell autonomy during postembryonic development of Caenorhabditis elegans. , 1980, Developmental biology.

[7]  H. Kacser,et al.  The molecular basis of dominance. , 1981, Genetics.

[8]  D. Hartl,et al.  Limits of adaptation: the evolution of selective neutrality. , 1985, Genetics.

[9]  H. Horvitz,et al.  Identification and characterization of 22 genes that affect the vulval cell lineages of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. , 1985, Genetics.

[10]  H. Horvitz,et al.  The multivulva phenotype of certain Caenorhabditis elegans mutants results from defects in two functionally redundant pathways. , 1989, Genetics.

[11]  H. Horvitz,et al.  The multivulva phenotype of certain C. elegans mutants results from defects in two functionally redundant pathways , 1989 .

[12]  D. Houle.  Comparing evolvability and variability of quantitative traits. , 1992, Genetics.

[13]  R. Sommer,et al.  Changes of induction and competence during the evolution of vulva development in nematodes. , 1994, Science.

[14]  P. Sternberg,et al.  Similarity of sli-1, a regulator of vulval development in C. elegans, to the mammalian proto-oncogene c-cbl , 1995, Science.

[15]  Thomas R Clandinin,et al.  Different Levels of the C. elegans growth factor LIN-3 promote distinct vulval precursor fates , 1995, Cell.

[16]  S M Stigler,et al.  Galton and identification by fingerprints. , 1995, Genetics.

[17]  C. Kenyon.  A perfect vulva every time: Gradients and signaling cascades in C. elegans , 1995, Cell.

[18]  Stuart K. Kim,et al.  Sequential signalling during Caenorhabditis elegans vulval induction , 1995 .

[19]  Y. Ohshima,et al.  Mosaic analysis of the let-23 gene function in vulval induction of Caenorhabditis elegans. , 1995, Development.

[20]  Sequential signalling during Caenorhabditis elegans vulval induction , 1995, Nature.

[21]  A. Wagner.  DOES EVOLUTIONARY PLASTICITY EVOLVE? , 1996, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[22]  D. Hogness,et al.  Effect of Polymorphism in the Drosophila Regulatory Gene Ultrabithorax on Homeotic Stability , 1996, Science.

[23]  G. Wagner,et al.  A POPULATION GENETIC THEORY OF CANALIZATION , 1997, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[24]  S. Leibler,et al.  Robustness in simple biochemical networks , 1997, Nature.

[25]  D. Riddle,et al.  Genetic and Environmental Regulation of Dauer Larva Development -- C. elegans II , 1997 .

[26]  Donald L Riddle,et al.  Genetic and Environmental Regulation of Dauer Larva Development , 1997 .

[27]  S. K. Kim,et al.  Inhibition of Caenorhabditis elegans vulval induction by gap-1 and by let-23 receptor tyrosine kinase. , 1997, Genes & development.

[28]  P. Sternberg,et al.  Two nested gonadal inductions of the vulva in nematodes. , 1997, Development.

[29]  J. Gerhart,et al.  Cells, Embryos and Evolution , 1997 .

[30]  Stuart K. Kim,et al.  The beta-catenin homolog BAR-1 and LET-60 Ras coordinately regulate the Hox gene lin-39 during Caenorhabditis elegans vulval development. , 1998, Development.

[31]  G. Gibson,et al.  Naturally occurring genetic variation affects Drosophila photoreceptor determination , 1998, Development Genes and Evolution.

[32]  M. Huynen,et al.  Neutral evolution of mutational robustness. , 1999, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[33]  A. Arkin,et al.  It's a noisy business! Genetic regulation at the nanomolar scale. , 1999, Trends in genetics : TIG.

[34]  M. Félix.  Evolution of developmental mechanisms in nematodes. , 1999, The Journal of experimental zoology.

[35]  M A Nowak,et al.  Evolutionary preservation of redundant duplicated genes. , 1999, Seminars in cell & developmental biology.

[36]  M. Lynch,et al.  PERSPECTIVE: SPONTANEOUS DELETERIOUS MUTATION , 1999, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[37]  R. Sommer,et al.  Evolution of nematode development. , 2000, Current opinion in genetics & development.

[38]  P. Sternberg,et al.  ARK-1 inhibits EGFR signaling in C. elegans. , 2000, Molecular cell.

[39]  M. Lynch,et al.  THE FITNESS EFFECTS OF SPONTANEOUS MUTATIONS IN CAENORHABDITIS ELEGANS , 2000, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[40]  A. Wagner,et al.  The role of population size, pleiotropy and fitness effects of mutations in the evolution of overlapping gene functions. , 2000, Genetics.

[41]  Garth A. Gibson,et al.  Canalization in evolutionary genetics: a stabilizing theory? , 2000, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.

[42]  G. Odell,et al.  The segment polarity network is a robust developmental module , 2000, Nature.

[43]  Thomas de Quincey.  [C] , 2000, The Works of Thomas De Quincey, Vol. 1: Writings, 1799–1820.

[44]  S. Rutherford,et al.  From genotype to phenotype: buffering mechanisms and the storage of genetic information , 2000, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.

[45]  V. Debat,et al.  Mapping phenotypes: canalization, plasticity and developmental stability , 2001 .

[46]  M. Félix,et al.  Polymorphism and evolution of vulval precursor cell lineages within two nematode genera, Caenorhabditis and Oscheius , 2001, Current Biology.

[47]  A. Hajnal,et al.  Notch Inhibition of RAS Signaling Through MAP Kinase Phosphatase LIP-1 During C. elegans Vulval Development , 2001, Science.

[48]  Claus O. Wilke,et al.  Adaptive evolution on neutral networks , 2001, Bulletin of mathematical biology.

[49]  A. Bergman,et al.  Waddington's canalization revisited: Developmental stability and evolution , 2002, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[50]  S. Shimeld,et al.  Evolution of developmental mechanisms , 2002, Genome Biology.

[51]  G. Odell,et al.  Robustness, Flexibility, and the Role of Lateral Inhibition in the Neurogenic Network , 2002, Current Biology.

[52]  Iva Greenwald,et al.  Endocytosis-mediated downregulation of LIN-12/Notch upon Ras activation in Caenorhabditis elegans , 2002, Nature.

[53]  D. Krakauer,et al.  Redundancy, antiredundancy, and the robustness of genomes , 2002, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[54]  Lauren Ancel Meyers,et al.  Fighting change with change: adaptive variation in an uncertain world , 2002 .

[55]  Colin D. Meiklejohn,et al.  A single mode of canalization , 2002 .

[56]  N. Barkai,et al.  Robustness of the BMP morphogen gradient in Drosophila embryonic patterning , 2022 .

[57]  T. Schedl,et al.  C. elegans ksr-1 and ksr-2 Have Both Unique and Redundant Functions and Are Required for MPK-1 ERK Phosphorylation , 2002, Current Biology.

[58]  Y. Dong,et al.  Systematic functional analysis of the Caenorhabditis elegans genome using RNAi , 2003, Nature.

[59]  G. Wagner,et al.  PERSPECTIVE:EVOLUTION AND DETECTION OF GENETIC ROBUSTNESS , 2003, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[60]  S. Rutherford,et al.  Quantitative trait symmetry independent of Hsp90 buffering: Distinct modes of genetic canalization and developmental stability , 2003, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[61]  H. F. Nijhout,et al.  A mechanistic study of evolvability using the mitogen‐activated protein kinase cascade , 2003, Evolution & development.

[62]  G. Wagner,et al.  Effects of epistasis on phenotypic robustness in metabolic pathways. , 2003, Mathematical biosciences.

[63]  Naama Barkai,et al.  Self-enhanced ligand degradation underlies robustness of morphogen gradients. , 2003, Developmental cell.

[64]  G. Gibson,et al.  Evidence that Egfr Contributes to Cryptic Genetic Variation for Photoreceptor Determination in Natural Populations of Drosophila melanogaster , 2003, Current Biology.

[65]  P. Sternberg,et al.  Modulation of EGF receptor-mediated vulva development by the heterotrimeric G-protein Gαq and excitable cells in C. elegans , 2003, Development.

[66]  Greg Gibson,et al.  Uncovering cryptic genetic variation , 2004, Nature Reviews Genetics.

[67]  Patrick C Phillips,et al.  The Opportunity for Canalization and the Evolution of Genetic Networks , 2004, The American Naturalist.

[68]  D. Baillie,et al.  C. elegans SUR-6/PR55 cooperates with LET-92/protein phosphatase 2A and promotes Raf activity independently of inhibitory Akt phosphorylation sites , 2004, Development.

[69]  Iva Greenwald,et al.  Crosstalk Between the EGFR and LIN-12/Notch Pathways in C. elegans Vulval Development , 2004, Science.

[70]  Günter P. Wagner,et al.  Genetic measurement theory of epistatic effects , 2004, Genetica.

[71]  D. Houle.  How should we explain variation in the genetic variance of traits? , 2004, Genetica.

[72]  Dee R. Denver,et al.  High mutation rate and predominance of insertions in the Caenorhabditis elegans nuclear genome , 2004, Nature.

[73]  Ning Chen,et al.  The lateral signal for LIN-12/Notch in C. elegans vulval development comprises redundant secreted and transmembrane DSL proteins. , 2004, Developmental cell.

[74]  I. Dworkin.  Canalization, Cryptic Variation, and Developmental Buffering: A Critical Examination and Analytical Perspective , 2005 .

[75]  I. Dworkin.  A STUDY OF CANALIZATION AND DEVELOPMENTAL STABILITY IN THE STERNOPLEURAL BRISTLE SYSTEM OF DROSOPHILA MELANOGASTER , 2005, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[76]  P. Sternberg.  Vulval development. , 2005, WormBook : the online review of C. elegans biology.

[77]  T. Flatt.  The Evolutionary Genetics of Canalization , 2005, The Quarterly Review of Biology.

[78]  A. Wagner.  Distributed robustness versus redundancy as causes of mutational robustness. , 2005, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.

[79]  Massimo Pigliucci,et al.  Evolution of phenotypic plasticity: where are we going now? , 2005, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[80]  A. Wagner.  Robustness, evolvability, and neutrality , 2005, FEBS letters.

[81]  Alex Hajnal,et al.  The C. elegans homolog of the mammalian tumor suppressor Dep-1/Scc1 inhibits EGFR signaling to regulate binary cell fate decisions. , 2005, Genes & development.

[82]  B. Calcott.  Fitness Landscapes and the Origin of Species , 2005 .

[83]  M. Sundaram,et al.  RTK/Ras/MAPK signaling. , 2006, WormBook : the online review of C. elegans biology.

[84]  C. Wilke,et al.  Robustness and Evolvability in Living Systems , 2006 .

[85]  R. B. Azevedo,et al.  Sexual reproduction selects for robustness and negative epistasis in artificial gene networks , 2006, Nature.

[86]  Paul W Sternberg,et al.  Intercellular coupling amplifies fate segregation during Caenorhabditis elegans vulval development , 2006, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[87]  Benedikt Hallgrímsson,et al.  Variation , 2006, Keywords and Concepts in Evolutionary Developmental Biology.