Shooting the messenger: outsiders critical of your group are rejected regardless of argument quality.

People are more resistant to criticisms of their group when those criticisms are made by an outgroup rather than an ingroup member, a phenomenon referred to as the intergroup sensitivity effect (ISE). The current study compared four competing models of how argument quality would moderate the ISE, with a view to establishing the complex interrelationships between source and message effects in group-directed criticism. Quality of the argument affected responses to ingroup critics, but not to outgroup critics. For outsiders who wish to promote positive change and reform in a group culture, this leads to a somewhat depressing conclusion: their message is likely to be rejected regardless of whether it is objectively 'right', well-considered, well-justified, or well-argued.

[1]  M. Hornsey.  Why being right is not enough: Predicting defensiveness in the face of group criticism , 2005 .

[2]  D. Packer,et al.  Avoiding Groupthink , 2009, Psychological science.

[3]  Matthew J. Hornsey,et al.  Sugaring the Pill: Assessing Rhetorical Strategies Designed to Minimize Defensive Reactions to Group Criticism , 2008 .

[4]  H. Wilke,et al.  Prototypicality of arguments and conformity to ingroup norms. , 1992 .

[5]  Joohn C. Reinard.  The Empirical Study of the Persuasive Effects of Evidence The Status After Fifty Years of Research , 1988 .

[6]  T. Morton,et al.  Who Says We Are Bad People? The Impact of Criticism Source and Attributional Content on Responses to Group-Based Criticism , 2010, Personality & social psychology bulletin.

[7]  J. Jetten,et al.  Group-Directed Criticisms and Recommendations for Change: Why Newcomers Arouse More Resistance Than Old-Timers , 2007, Personality & social psychology bulletin.

[8]  J. Cacioppo,et al.  The Elaboration Likelihood Model of Persuasion , 1986 .

[9]  R. Perloff.  The Dynamics of Persuasion: Communication and Attitudes in the 21st Century , 1993 .

[10]  M. Hornsey,et al.  Does time reduce resistance to out-group critics? An investigation of the persistence of the intergroup sensitivity effect over time. , 2010, The British journal of social psychology.

[11]  S. Chaiken,et al.  Heuristic processing can bias systematic processing: effects of source credibility, argument ambiguity, and task importance on attitude judgment. , 1994, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[12]  Dominic J. Packer,et al.  On Being Both With Us and Against Us: A Normative Conflict Model of Dissent in Social Groups , 2008, Personality and social psychology review : an official journal of the Society for Personality and Social Psychology, Inc.

[13]  Leila T. Worth,et al.  Processing of persuasive in-group messages. , 1990, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[14]  M. Hornsey,et al.  Strategic defensiveness: public and private responses to group criticism. , 2007, The British journal of social psychology.

[15]  M. Edwards.  Evidence , 2004, The Lancet.

[16]  Alice H. Eagly,et al.  Heuristic and systematic information processing within and beyond the persuasion context. , 1989 .

[17]  Diane M. Mackie,et al.  Knowledge of the Advocated Position and the Processing of In-Group and Out-Group Persuasive Messages , 1992 .

[18]  S. Chaiken,et al.  Causal inferences about communicators and their effect on opinion change , 1978 .

[19]  Karen M. Douglas,et al.  Reactions to Internal and External Criticism of Outgroups: Social Convention in the Intergroup Sensitivity Effect , 2006, Personality & social psychology bulletin.

[20]  Matthew J. Hornsey,et al.  Criticizing Groups from the Inside and the Outside: An Identity Perspective on the Intergroup Sensitivity Effect , 2004, Personality & social psychology bulletin.

[21]  M. Hornsey,et al.  ‘You can criticize because you care’: identity attachment, constructiveness, and the intergroup sensitivity effect , 2004 .

[22]  Daan van Knippenberg,et al.  In-group prototypicality and persuasion: Determinants of heuristic and systematic message processing , 1994 .

[23]  Matthew J. Hornsey,et al.  “It's OK if we say it, but you can't”: responses to intergroup and intragroup criticism , 2002 .