Fine Particulate Matter and Total Mortality in Cancer Prevention Study Cohort Reanalysis

Background: In 1997 the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) established the National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS) for fine particulate matter (PM2.5), largely because of its positive relationship to total mortality in the 1982 American Cancer Society Cancer Prevention Study (CPS II) cohort. Subsequently, EPA has used this relationship as the primary justification for many costly regulations, most recently the Clean Power Plan. An independent analysis of the CPS II data was conducted in order to test the validity of this relationship. Methods: The original CPS II questionnaire data, including 1982 to 1988 mortality follow-up, were analyzed using Cox proportional hazards regression. Results were obtained for 292 277 participants in 85 counties with 1979-1983 EPA Inhalable Particulate Network PM2.5 measurements, as well as for 212 370 participants in the 50 counties used in the original 1995 analysis. Results: The 1982 to 1988 relative risk (RR) of death from all causes and 95% confidence interval adjusted for age, sex, race, education, and smoking status was 1.023 (0.997-1.049) for a 10 µg/m3 increase in PM2.5 in 85 counties and 1.025 (0.990-1.061) in the 50 original counties. The fully adjusted RR was null in the western and eastern portions of the United States, including in areas with somewhat higher PM2.5 levels, particularly 5 Ohio Valley states and California. Conclusion: No significant relationship between PM2.5 and total mortality in the CPS II cohort was found when the best available PM2.5 data were used. The original 1995 analysis found a positive relationship by selective use of CPS II and PM2.5 data. This independent analysis of underlying data raises serious doubts about the CPS II epidemiologic evidence supporting the PM2.5 NAAQS. These findings provide strong justification for further independent analysis of the CPS II data.

[1]  M. Brauer,et al.  Global Estimates of Ambient Fine Particulate Matter Concentrations from Satellite-Based Aerosol Optical Depth: Development and Application , 2010, Environmental health perspectives.

[2]  Scott L. Zeger,et al.  Mortality in the Medicare Population and Chronic Exposure to Fine Particulate Air Pollution in Urban Centers (2000–2005) , 2008, Environmental health perspectives.

[3]  M. Brauer,et al.  Risk of Nonaccidental and Cardiovascular Mortality in Relation to Long-term Exposure to Low Concentrations of Fine Particulate Matter: A Canadian National-Level Cohort Study , 2012, Environmental health perspectives.

[4]  Robert S. Leiken,et al.  A User’s Guide , 2011 .

[5]  Daniel Krewski,et al.  Public health benefits of strategies to reduce greenhouse-gas emissions: health implications of short-lived greenhouse pollutants , 2009, The Lancet.

[6]  C. Pope,et al.  Exposure to Fine Particulate Air Pollution Is Associated With Endothelial Injury and Systemic Inflammation. , 2016, Circulation research.

[7]  Richard Horton,et al.  Offline: What is medicine's 5 sigma? , 2015, The Lancet.

[8]  J F Gamble,et al.  PM2.5 and mortality in long-term prospective cohort studies: cause-effect or statistical associations? , 1998, Environmental health perspectives.

[9]  Daniel Krewski,et al.  Spatial analysis of air pollution and mortality in California. , 2013, American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine.

[10]  N. Mendell,et al.  A statistical study of the macroepidemiology of air pollution and total mortality , 1988 .

[11]  Response to “A Critique of ‘Fine Particulate Air Pollution and Total Mortality Among Elderly Californians, 1973–2002” By Bert Brunekreef, PhD, and Gerard Hoek, PhD , 2006 .

[12]  W. Mcdonnell,et al.  Relationships of mortality with the fine and coarse fractions of long-term ambient PM10 concentrations in nonsmokers , 2000, Journal of Exposure Analysis and Environmental Epidemiology.

[13]  Association Between Air Pollution and Coronary Artery Calcification Within Six Metropolitan Areas in the USA (the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis and Air Pollution): A Longitudinal Cohort Study , 2016 .

[14]  A. Peters,et al.  Particulate Matter Air Pollution and Cardiovascular Disease: An Update to the Scientific Statement From the American Heart Association , 2010, Circulation.

[15]  Antonella Zanobetti,et al.  PM2.5 and Mortality in 207 US Cities: Modification by Temperature and City Characteristics , 2015, Epidemiology.

[16]  A. Cohen,et al.  Interactions between cigarette smoking and fine particulate matter in the Risk of Lung Cancer Mortality in Cancer Prevention Study II. , 2014, American journal of epidemiology.

[17]  Daniel Krewski,et al.  Comparing the Health Effects of Ambient Particulate Matter Estimated Using Ground-Based versus Remote Sensing Exposure Estimates , 2016, Environmental health perspectives.

[18]  Michael Lipsett,et al.  Long-Term Exposure to Constituents of Fine Particulate Air Pollution and Mortality: Results from the California Teachers Study , 2009, Environmental health perspectives.

[19]  J Kaiser,et al.  Showdown Over Clean Air Science , 1997, Science.

[20]  Joel Schwartz,et al.  Chronic Fine and Coarse Particulate Exposure, Mortality, and Coronary Heart Disease in the Nurses’ Health Study , 2008, Environmental health perspectives.

[21]  D. Dockery,et al.  An association between air pollution and mortality in six U.S. cities. , 1993, The New England journal of medicine.

[22]  J. Enstrom,et al.  Fine Particulate Air Pollution and Total Mortality Among Elderly Californians, 1973–2002 , 2005, Inhalation toxicology.

[23]  Y. Béjot,et al.  Evidence of the role of short-term exposure to ozone on ischaemic cerebral and cardiac events: the Dijon Vascular Project (DIVA) , 2010, Heart.

[24]  L. Sheppard,et al.  Long-term exposure to air pollution and incidence of cardiovascular events in women. , 2007, The New England journal of medicine.

[25]  Kazuhiko Ito,et al.  Long-term ozone exposure and mortality. , 2009, The New England journal of medicine.

[26]  D. Rojas-Rueda,et al.  The health risks and benefits of cycling in urban environments compared with car use: health impact assessment study , 2011, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[27]  Daniel Krewski,et al.  Lung Cancer and Cardiovascular Disease Mortality Associated with Ambient Air Pollution and Cigarette Smoke: Shape of the Exposure–Response Relationships , 2011, Environmental health perspectives.

[28]  Chris C. Lim,et al.  Ambient Particulate Matter Air Pollution Exposure and Mortality in the NIH-AARP Diet and Health Cohort , 2015, Environmental health perspectives.

[29]  Daniel Krewski,et al.  Long-Term Ozone Exposure and Mortality in a Large Prospective Study. , 2016, American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine.

[30]  Daniel Krewski,et al.  Relationships Between Fine Particulate Air Pollution, Cardiometabolic Disorders, and Cardiovascular Mortality , 2015, Circulation research.

[31]  R. Burnett,et al.  Extended follow-up and spatial analysis of the American Cancer Society study linking particulate air pollution and mortality. , 2009, Research report.

[32]  F. Laden,et al.  Particulate Matter Exposures, Mortality, and Cardiovascular Disease in the Health Professionals Follow-up Study , 2011, Environmental health perspectives.

[33]  R. Burnett,et al.  Ischemic Heart Disease Mortality and Long-Term Exposure to Source-Related Components of U.S. Fine Particle Air Pollution , 2015, Environmental health perspectives.

[34]  David E Newby,et al.  Expert position paper on air pollution and cardiovascular disease. , 2015, European heart journal.

[35]  R. Phalen.  The Particulate Air Pollution Controversy , 2004, Nonlinearity in biology, toxicology, medicine.

[36]  Matthew L. Thomas,et al.  Estimates and 25-year trends of the global burden of disease attributable to ambient air pollution: an analysis of data from the Global Burden of Diseases Study 2015 , 2017, The Lancet.

[37]  Daniel Krewski,et al.  Reanalysis of the Harvard Six Cities Study and the American Cancer Society Study of Particulate Air , 2000 .

[38]  Daniel Krewski,et al.  Interactions between cigarette smoking and ambient PM2.5 for cardiovascular mortality , 2017, Environmental research.

[39]  Derek G. Cook,et al.  Mortality associations with long-term exposure to outdoor air pollution in a national English cohort , 2013 .

[40]  Mark J van der Laan,et al.  Deletion/Substitution/Addition Algorithm in Learning with Applications in Genomics , 2004, Statistical applications in genetics and molecular biology.

[41]  F. Lipfert,et al.  Commentary on the HEI Reanalysis of the Harvard Six Cities Study and the American Cancer Society Study of Particulate Air Pollution and Mortality , 2003, Journal of toxicology and environmental health. Part A.

[42]  Bert Brunekreef,et al.  Health effects of air pollution observed in cohort studies in Europe , 2007, Journal of Exposure Science and Environmental Epidemiology.

[43]  Michael Brauer,et al.  Ambient PM2.5, O3, and NO2 Exposures and Associations with Mortality over 16 Years of Follow-Up in the Canadian Census Health and Environment Cohort (CanCHEC) , 2015, Environmental health perspectives.

[44]  A. Peters,et al.  Long-term air pollution exposure and cardio- respiratory mortality: a review , 2013, Environmental Health.

[45]  Michael Jerrett,et al.  Long-term exposure to air pollution and cardiorespiratory disease in the California teachers study cohort. , 2011, American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine.

[46]  M. Stafoggia,et al.  Long-Term Exposure to Urban Air Pollution and Mortality in a Cohort of More than a Million Adults in Rome , 2013, Environmental health perspectives.

[47]  Joel Schwartz,et al.  Chronic Exposure to Fine Particles and Mortality: An Extended Follow-up of the Harvard Six Cities Study from 1974 to 2009 , 2012, Environmental health perspectives.

[48]  L. Bernstein,et al.  Associations of Mortality with Long-Term Exposures to Fine and Ultrafine Particles, Species and Sources: Results from the California Teachers Study Cohort , 2015, Environmental health perspectives.

[49]  D. Dockery,et al.  Particulate air pollution as a predictor of mortality in a prospective study of U.S. adults. , 1995, American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine.

[50]  D. Krewski,et al.  Geographies of uncertainty in the health benefits of air quality improvements , 2007 .

[51]  D. Mirvis,et al.  Preliminary evidence for an emerging nonmetropolitan mortality penalty in the United States. , 2008, American journal of public health.

[52]  B. Brunekreef,et al.  A Critique of “Fine Particulate Air Pollution and Total Mortality Among Elderly Californians, 1973–2002” by James E. Enstrom , 2006, Inhalation toxicology.

[53]  Anu W. Turunen,et al.  Effects of long-term exposure to air pollution on natural-cause mortality: an analysis of 22 European cohorts within the multicentre ESCAPE project , 2014, The Lancet.

[54]  R. Burnett,et al.  Lung cancer, cardiopulmonary mortality, and long-term exposure to fine particulate air pollution. , 2002, JAMA.

[55]  James V. Zidek,et al.  CAUSALITY, MEASUREMENT ERROR AND MULTICOLLINEARITY IN EPIDEMIOLOGY , 1996 .

[56]  James E. Enstrom.  Particulate Matter is Not Killing Californians , 2012 .

[57]  R. Burnett,et al.  Spatial Analysis of Air Pollution and Mortality in Los Angeles , 2005, Epidemiology.

[58]  Thomas J. Smith,et al.  Long-term ambient multipollutant exposures and mortality. , 2011, American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine.

[59]  R. Burnett,et al.  Cardiovascular Mortality and Long-Term Exposure to Particulate Air Pollution: Epidemiological Evidence of General Pathophysiological Pathways of Disease , 2003, Circulation.