Random knapsack in expected polynomial time

We present the first average-case analysis proving a polynomial upper bound on the expected running time of an exact algorithm for the 0/1 knapsack problem. In particular, we prove for various input distributions, that the number of Pareto-optimal knapsack fillings is polynomially bounded in the number of available items. An algorithm by Nemhauser and Ullmann can enumerate these solutions very efficiently so that a polynomial upper bound on the number of Pareto-optimal solutions implies an algorithm with expected polynomial running time.The random input model underlying our analysis is quite general and not restricted to a particular input distribution. We assume adversarial weights and randomly drawn profits (or vice versa). Our analysis covers general probability distributions with finite mean and, in its most general form, can even handle different probability distributions for the profits of different items. This feature enables us to study the effects of correlations between profits and weights. Our analysis confirms and explains practical studies showing that so-called strongly correlated instances are harder to solve than weakly correlated ones.