A reconstruction of development of the periodic table based on history and philosophy of science and its implications for general chemistry textbooks

The objectives of this study are: (a) elaboration of a history and philosophy of science (HPS) framework based on a reconstruction of the development of the periodic table; (b) formulation of seven criteria based on the framework; and (c) evaluation of 57 freshman college-level general chemistry textbooks with respect to the presentation of the periodic table. The historical reconstruction of the periodic table showed that the periodicity of the elements could be construed as an inductive generalization or as a function of the atomic theory. There is considerable controversy with respect to the nature of Mendeleev's contribution, and various alternatives are discussed: ordered domain; empirical law; and a theory with limited explanatory power. Accommodation of the elements according to their physicochemical properties is considered to be the major contribution of the periodic table by all textbooks, followed by contrapredictions of previously unknown elements (30 textbooks), and novel predictions (corrections of atomic mass) of known elements (10 textbooks). The relative importance of accommodation and prediction within an HPS framework is generally ignored. Few textbooks have attempted to explore the possible cause of periodicity in the table and very few textbooks have explored the nature of Mendeleev's contribution. The development of the periodic table as a sequence of heuristic principles in the form of a convincing argument has been ignored. The textbook approach of emphasizing that the development of the periodic table was an inductive generalization, and that Mendeleev had no model or theory, does not facilitate the spirit of critical inquiry that led the scientists to grapple with alternative interpretations, conflicts, and controversies. It is concluded that the development of the periodic table went through a continual critical appraisal (conflict and controversy), in which scientists presented various tentative theoretical ideas to understand the observed phenomena. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Res Sci Teach 42: 84–111, 2005

[1]  F. Akeroyd.  Prediction and the Periodic Table: a response to Scerri and Worrall , 2003 .

[2]  M. Kaji.  Mendeleev's Discovery of the Periodic Law: The Origin and the Reception , 2003 .

[3]  H. Schmidt,et al.  Changing Ideas about the Periodic Table of Elements and Students' Alternative Concepts of Isotopes and Allotropes. , 2003 .

[4]  S. S. Zumdahl,et al.  World of Chemistry , 2002 .

[5]  M. Niaz,et al.  Understanding nature of science as progressive transitions in heuristic principles , 2001 .

[6]  Eric R. Scerri,et al.  Prediction and the periodic table , 2001 .

[7]  N. J. Pienta.  Chemistry: Molecules, Matter, and Change, 4th Edition (Jones, Loretta; Atkins, Peter) , 2001 .

[8]  C. Giunta.  Argon and the Periodic System: the Piece that Would not Fit , 2001 .

[9]  H. Kragh.  Conceptual Changes in Chemistry: The Notion of a Chemical Element, ca. 1900–1925 , 2000 .

[10]  J. L. Marshall.  A Living Periodic Table , 2000 .

[11]  D. Eric Walters.  Fundamentals of Chemistry (3rd ed.) By Ralph A. Burns. Prentice-Hall: Upper Saddle River, NJ, 1999, 744 pp, ISBN 0-13-918665-4 , 2000, J. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci..

[12]  J. Robinson.  The Paradigm Changes--But Do Our Students Know That?. , 2000 .

[13]  Loretta L. Jones,et al.  Chemical Principles: The Quest for Insight , 1999 .

[14]  Ronald N. Giere,et al.  Science without laws , 1999 .

[15]  Eric R. Scerri.  How Good Is the Quantum Mechanical Explanation of the Periodic System , 1998 .

[16]  Michael P. Clough,et al.  The Nature of Science in Science Education: An Introduction , 1998 .

[17]  C. Giunta.  Using History To Teach Scientific Method: The Case of Argon , 1998 .

[18]  S. Genut,et al.  Uses and Limitations of Scientific Models: The Periodic Table as an Inductive Tool. , 1998 .

[19]  M. R. Matthews,et al.  In defense of modest goals when teaching about the nature of science , 1998 .

[20]  Philosophy of Science Association Toward a More , 1998 .

[21]  S. Brush.  The Reception of Mendeleev's Periodic Law in America and Britain , 1996, Isis.

[22]  R. H. Petrucci,et al.  General Chemistry: An Integrated Approach , 1996 .

[23]  P. Atkins.  The Periodic Kingdom: A Journey Into The Land Of The Chemical Elements , 1995 .

[24]  R. S. Treptow.  The Periodic Table of Atoms: Arranging the Elements by a Different Set of Rules , 1994 .

[25]  G. Holton.  Ernst Mach and the Fortunes of Positivism in America , 1992, Isis.

[26]  Peter Lipton,et al.  Inference to the best explanation , 1993 .

[27]  Nicholas C. Burbules,et al.  Science education and philosophy of science: congruence or contradiction? , 1991 .

[28]  George M. Bodner,et al.  Chemistry: Structure and Dynamics , 1990 .

[29]  N. K. Goh,et al.  Using the learning cycle to introduce periodicity , 1989 .

[30]  M. Laing.  The periodic table - A new arrangement , 1989 .

[31]  J. Campbell.  Let Us Make the Table Periodic. , 1989 .

[32]  J. Bouma.  An application-oriented periodic table of the elements , 1989 .

[33]  George M. Bodner,et al.  Chemistry: An Experimental Science , 1989 .

[34]  P. Maher,et al.  Prediction, Accommodation, and the Logic of Discovery , 1988, PSA: Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association.

[35]  Harold I. Brown,et al.  How the Laws of Physics Lie , 1988 .

[36]  Bernadette Bensaude-Vincent.  Mendeleev's periodic system of chemical elements , 1986 .

[37]  Bernice G. Segal,et al.  Chemistry: Experiment and Theory , 1985 .

[38]  Dudley Shapere,et al.  Scientific Theories and Their Domains , 1984 .

[39]  H. Stoker.  Introduction to Chemical Principles , 1983 .

[40]  J. Brady.  General Chemistry : Principles and Structure , 1982 .

[41]  Theodore L. Brown.  Chemistry: The Central Science , 1981 .

[42]  James E. Brady,et al.  Fundamentals of Chemistry , 1981 .

[43]  R. Dresdner,et al.  Chemistry: A Systematic Approach , 1980 .

[44]  Sydney B. Newell.  Chemistry: An introduction , 1980 .

[45]  D. A. Jenkins,et al.  Birefringence images of arbitrarily oriented dislocation lines in (111) silicon wafers , 1979 .

[46]  J. Ziman,et al.  Science and Its Critics@@@Reliable Knowledge: An Exploration of the Grounds for Belief in Science , 1979 .

[47]  R Schofield,et al.  Reliable Knowledge: An exploration of the grounds for belief in science , 1979 .

[48]  D. E. Goldberg,et al.  Chemistry: Reactions, Structure and Properties , 1978 .

[49]  F. H. Verhoek,et al.  Chemistry: A study of matter , 1977 .

[50]  Rod. O'Connor.  Fundamentals of chemistry , 1977 .

[51]  D. W. Ball,et al.  Chemistry: Principles and Practice , 1976 .

[52]  James E. Brady,et al.  Chemistry: Matter and Its Changes , 1975 .

[53]  J. Kennedy,et al.  Chemistry: principles and applications , 1973 .

[54]  R. H. Petrucci,et al.  General Chemistry: Principles and Modern Applications , 1972 .

[55]  I. Lakatos,et al.  Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge: Falsification and the Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes , 1970 .

[56]  Morris Hein,et al.  Foundations of College Chemistry , 1970 .

[57]  J. W. V. Spronsen,et al.  The Periodic System of Chemical Elements. A History of the First Hundred Years , 1969 .

[58]  J. W. V. Spronsen,et al.  The periodic system of chemical elements , 1969 .

[59]  T. Kuhn,et al.  The Genesis of the Bohr Atom , 1969 .

[60]  H. Gray,et al.  Basic principles of chemistry , 1967 .

[61]  J. Heilbron.  The Work of H. G. J. Moseley , 1966, Isis.

[62]  E. Board,et al.  CATHODE RAYS , 1966 .

[63]  P. Ander,et al.  Principles of chemistry : an introduction to theoretical concepts , 1965 .

[64]  J. W. V. Spronsen.  The prehistory of the periodic system of the elements , 1959 .

[65]  J. Partington,et al.  A Short History of Chemistry , 1957 .

[66]  Clara de Milt.  The Congress at Karlsruhe , 1951 .

[67]  Arthur Bishop,et al.  An Introduction to Chemistry , 2001, Nature.

[68]  H. P. Cady.  THE CHEMISTRY OF THE FUTURE. , 1927, Science.

[69]  L. Bogert.  Fundamentals of chemistry , 1924 .

[70]  Gilbert N. Lewis,et al.  Valence And The Structure Of Atoms And Molecules , 1923 .

[71]  R. Ladenburg.  Atombau und Periodisches System der Elemente , 1920 .

[72]  John William Nicholson,et al.  The Constitution of Atoms and Molecules , 1914, Nature.

[73]  H. Moseley,et al.  LXXX. The high-frequency spectra of the elements. Part II , 1914 .

[74]  H. Moseley,et al.  XCIII. The high-frequency spectra of the elements , 1913 .

[75]  F. Soddy,et al.  The Structure of the Atom , 1913, Nature.

[76]  E. RUTHERFORD,et al.  The Structure of the Atom , 1913, Nature.

[77]  E. Rutherford,et al.  The scattering of alpha and beta particles by matter and the structure of the atom , 1911 .

[78]  W. Ramsay,et al.  Argon and its Companions , 1900, Nature.

[79]  Mendeléeff.  LXIII.—The Periodic Law of the Chemical Elements , 1889 .

[80]  D. Mendeleev.  The Periodic Law of the Chemical Elements ” , 2022 .