Aggregating Sets of Judgments: An Impossibility Result

Suppose that the members of a certain group each hold a rational set of judgments on some interconnected questions. And imagine that the group itself now has to form a collective, rational set of judgments on those questions. How should it go about dealing with this task? We argue that the question raised is subject to a difficulty that has recently been noticed in discussion of the doctrinal paradox in jurisprudence. And we show that there is a general impossibility theorem that that difficulty illustrates. Our paper describes this impossibility result and provides an exploration of its significance. The result naturally invites comparison with Kenneth Arrow's famous theorem (Arrow, 1963 and 1984; Sen, 1970) and we elaborate that comparison in a companion paper (List and Pettit, 2002).

[1]  L. A. Goodman,et al.  Social Choice and Individual Values , 1951 .

[2]  A. Sen,et al.  Collective Choice and Social Welfare , 2017 .

[3]  Kenneth J. Arrow,et al.  Social Choice and Justice , 1984 .

[4]  Lawrence G. Sager,et al.  Unpacking the Court , 1986 .

[5]  L. Kornhauser.  Modeling collegial courts I: Path-dependence , 1992 .

[6]  David Miller,et al.  Deliberative Democracy and Social Choice , 1992 .

[7]  L. Kornhauser.  Modeling Collegial Courts. II. Legal Doctrine , 1992 .

[8]  Lawrence G. Sager,et al.  The One and the Many: Adjudication in Collegial Courts , 1993 .

[9]  J. Bohman,et al.  Deliberative Democracy: Essays on Reason and Politics , 1997 .

[10]  Bruce Chapman.  Law, Incommensurability, and Conceptually Sequenced Argument , 1998 .

[11]  B. Chapman,et al.  More Easily Done than Said: Rules, Reasons, and Rational Social Choice , 1998 .

[12]  C. Sunstein.  The Law of Group Polarization , 1999, How Change Happens.

[13]  Christian Rostboll,et al.  On Deliberative Democracy , 2001 .

[14]  Philip Pettit,et al.  A Theory of Freedom: From the Psychology to the Politics of Agency , 2001 .

[15]  P. Pettit.  Deliberative Democracy and the Discursive Dilemma , 2001 .

[16]  Jürgen Habermas,et al.  Social Choice Theory and Deliberative Democracy : A Reconciliation , 2002 .

[17]  C. List,et al.  Social Choice Theory and Deliberative Democracy: A Reconciliation , 2002, British Journal of Political Science.

[18]  Christian List,et al.  Aggregating Sets of Judgments: Two Impossibility Results Compared1 , 2004, Synthese.